13 ms·
TSMC founder Morris Chang says globalization and free trade 'almost dead'
- baxtr 4y agoI think it’s like with many of these kind of developments: they come in waves. Thus, I rather think that globalization is not dead per se, but in a downturn. 10, 20, 30 years from now things might be very different again.
- ggm 4y agoI could believe the first statement (almost) but the second (unlikely to come back) has to be a paraphrase. He's old: it's unlikely to see significant return in his lifetime, in his field, which is highly subject to national-strategic interest. I don't see any end to globalisation in the information economy up top: kids worldwide do tiktok, don't want to use the Licenced disney version in hypothesis...
- chitowneats 4y agoWe are in the early phases of decoupling. Teenagers are not an appropriate barometer for what is about to come.
- ilyt 4y agoNeither are some old people...
- ekianjo 4y agoOld people in power are the ones moving the needle, not the teenagers
- kidme5 4y agoNot for long
- tru3_power 4y agoWhy’s that
- slater 4y agoterminal decrepitude
- bobkazamakis 4y agothey haven't moved shit and there's no incentive for them to.
- vachina 4y ago> We are in the early phases of decoupling In other words, slave moved up the value chain and no longer wants to slave for their masters.
- Vt71fcAqt7 4y agoCan you explain what you mean by this? Japan, Taiwan and SK all moved up the value chain and are still US trade partners. I'm pretty sure it's the US that has "broken up" with china, not the other way around. Lastly, using the word slave to describe something other than slavery diminishes the value of the word. The US does not force China to make products for them.
- rbetts 4y agoOr future generations will look at ours as we look at the British who exploited India, or the Europeans who exploited the Americas, or the merchants of the triangular trade, or any of the other thousands of episodes of mass exploitation for profit. Fingers crossed for that and not a fascist uprising.
- creato 4y agoThis is laughably absurd. The last few decades have seen a massive reduction in poverty in China. China has had a huge trade surplus with the US for decades, and probably the rest of the world too. How on earth is that exploitation?
- chitowneats 4y agoIt is laughably absurd. Despite this, someone in the future will write their dissertation on this topic in the affirmative. They will be considered one of the great visionaries of their time in certain circles, despite being totally wrong.
- kelipso 4y agoThey'd be totally wrong if you are an entrepreneur and they'd be totally right if you're a lower class worker. Doubt you'd find a synthesis there.
- fragmede 4y agoHow so? Teenagers, with some maturation, are literally "what is about to come". They're future adults.
- splistud 4y ago
- chitowneats 4y agoYes. In a few decades they will have power. Over the next one, they have very little.
- athrowaway12 4y agoI agree. TikTok going down wouldn't be the end of the world. But there is so much other reliance on Chinese manufacturing in the West: electronics, furniture, machinery, etc. https://ustr.gov/countries-regions/china-mongolia-taiwan/peoples-republic-china https://ustr.gov/countries-regions/china-mongolia-taiwan/peo... The transition to a bipolar world with a U.S. sphere and a Chinese sphere would be a huge shock to both sides. I don't know if it would be a fairer world or not; regardless, we all seem intent on doing this. This article is another in a long line of very scary news about the U.S.-China tensions. I hope diplomacy and peace will prevail eventually.
- tablespoon 4y ago> This article is another in a long line of very scary news about the U.S.-China tensions. I hope diplomacy and peace will prevail eventually. Write your representatives and ask them to bend the knee!
- athrowaway12 4y agoI disagree with your suggestion that diplomacy is necessarily a form of submission. Peace can still be made while maintaining a position of strength. For example, U.S.-Soviet relations.
- athrowaway12 4y agoAlso wanted to add the famous quote attributed to Goering at Nuremberg. https://www.mit.edu/people/fuller/peace/war_goering.html https://www.mit.edu/people/fuller/peace/war_goering.html "Of course the people don't want war. But after all, it's the leaders of the country who determine the policy, and it's always a simple matter to drag the people along whether it's a democracy, a fascist dictatorship, or a parliament, or a communist dictatorship. Voice or no voice, the people can always be brought to the bidding of the leaders. That is easy. All you have to do is tell them they are being attacked, and denounce the pacifists for lack of patriotism, and exposing the country to greater danger."
- tenebrisalietum 4y agoI wonder if the statement was limited to semiconductor manufacturing.
- cellis 4y agotiktok ( for one example ), is already highly segmented and containerized by country. The tiktok Russians see isn't the one Ukranians see.
- drew-y 4y agoIn this case, I don't think segmentation is the inverse of globalization. They're both using a service that originates outside their country.
- torben-friis 4y agoIs it? I use tiktok and the app routinely tries to throw content outside my bubble at the wall to see what sticks, even in languages I don’t speak. It is currently showing a lot of Argentinian videos on my feed even though I’m European. I’m sure that the Chinese version is different and censored, but other than that my experience is that it’s tailored to your personal engagement patterns much more than to the groups you belong to.
- btkthrowaway1 4y agoI think they're referring to this article: https://www.nrk.no/osloogviken/xl/tiktok-doesn_t-show-the-war-in-ukraine-to-russian-users-1.15921522 https://www.nrk.no/osloogviken/xl/tiktok-doesn_t-show-the-wa... It came up on HN a few months back
- eloisius 4y agoNot sure how they partition it, because you can obviously still see users you follow while you move around, but I noticed my fyp was completely different when I went back home. It could just be that IP geolocation is more important a signal than your taste profile.
- asadlionpk 4y agoIt is. Leaving China aside. Once tiktok 'segments' you to a region, the experience is totally different and unchangeable even if you move around.
- thinkingkong 4y agoWhat is the globalization information economy exactly? The broad suggestion and standard interpretation of globalization is that the movement of physical goods is coming to and end.
- ggm 4y agoThats also bogus: there is no end to extraction of goods, raw materials from overseas, the players are just shifting around. You think lithium won't continue to be bought from Australia and Chile for use in Europe? You think manufacturing in India and China and Vietnam and Pakistan and Bangladesh is all coming home to fruit-of-the-loom unionised labour in the USA? You think EV will be Tesla, Rivian and never VAG, Volvo, or BYD? There is no end to movements of goods, (and services) worldwide. The borders and boundaries on what moves to whose profit is shifting. "Globalisation" isn't ending. "We trade with anyone, irrespective of geopolitical blocs" isn't ending. Whats happening is re-balancing. The global information economy is the profit being made from trading in electronic services. Rent on transactions in payments, funds transfer, arbitrage, the dutch-irish sandwich...
- steve76 4y ago[dead]
- remarkEon 4y agoI think what Globalization skeptics like me are saying is actually really simple: you shouldn't outsource your critical shit to hostile countries. Not really more complicated than that. If we're talking about the US, other countries can sell their EVs here, no problem, but you have to be in the club. Since the 1990s, we've sort of skirted our moral responsibility on who we trade with because it made a bunch of people rich, and then those rich people gave money to politicians who helped make other people rich, who then ran for office and so on. This responsibility isn't limited to "don't trade with countries that have concentration camps", it also extends to "be smart about how you trade and who you trade with such that you don't destroy your own industry and middle class". Really not that complicated. >The global information economy is the profit being made from trading in electronic services. Rent on transactions in payments, funds transfer, arbitrage, the dutch-irish sandwich... This is a goofy way of saying "the global information economy" makes money on spying on human behavior and then selling ads based on that behavior. Yuck.
- narrator 4y agoGlobalization is dead if we hit peak world energy. Then it's every country for themselves. Most products contain energy, so why export energy in the form of finished goods? As energy gets more scarce, countries will get more stingy with exports and tend toward autarky.
- alwayslikethis 4y agoEnergy isn't all that limited though, especially with ever improving generation technology in wind and solar and in storage such as grid scale battery facilities.
- willnonya 4y agoWind, solar and grid scale batteries fall somewhere between pipedreams and nightmares. The resources needed to build much less maintain these at scale is a disaster, one that's largely inflicted on 'not us' but that requires massive economic transfers through globalization. You're not building these at this scale without globalization.
- pizza 4y agoOut of curiosity, I looked up the breakdown of 2021 US new energy capacity added: - 41% wind - 36% solar - 19% gas - 4% other I was actually kind of pleasantly surprised. 28 GW capacity added, 8.5 GW capacity retired. Total capacity 1115.68 GW generated summer 2020 Total breakdown 2021 is more like this: - 36% Petroleum - 32% Natural gas - 11% Coal - 8% Nuclear - 12% Renewable energy https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Energy_in_the_United_States https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Energy_in_the_United_States https://www.spglobal.com/marketintelligence/en/news-insights/latest-news-headlines/nearly-28-gw-of-new-us-generating-capacity-added-in-2021-led-by-wind-68435915 https://www.spglobal.com/marketintelligence/en/news-insights...
- enqk 4y agoare those percentage in peak theoretical capacity or base load
- tootie 4y agoNah. They're both ludicrous. China is no longer a free-for-all labor bonanza for a number of reasons but global trade is all-time highs after the pandemic dip. His statements are purely calculated propaganda to influence US policy.
- pizza 4y agoThis is how I interpret it: more countries will - invest in domestic technologies development + reinvest the proceeds into whatever it takes to keep the profit pump pumping (e.g. engineering education/training/"re-skilling" programs) - de-incentivize equivalent foreign technologies as insurance against getting squeezed by international geopolitics (see e.g. Russia getting blackballed by global financial system essentially overnight, US restricting Nvidia from selling top GPUs to China, COVID->global shipping supply chain meltdown etc.) - occasionally dip into low-cost free trade as a short-term growth strategy (as ruling political parties play musical chairs and swap leadership/opposition roles) - exert dominance in intellectual property disputes as ruthlessly as possible (my fave example: fallout of the huawei/qualcomm 5G dispute - every country's communications authority has to ratify a device according to the 5G standard -> whoever owns the patent to the algorithm for the standard collects money for each device -> nasty wide-ranging political dispute that appears to have nothing to do w/ the original patent issue)
- throwaway290 4y agoNothing is as addictive as 'short-term' growth strategies and staying in power.
- pizza 4y agoWhich is both why free trade and free trade are respectively the future and not the future
- throwaway290 4y agoNot the future because governments have so much self control? OK. It's either global trade or dark times. Global trade is the only thing maintaining peace. Thankfully it's too useful to all involved to go away
- emodendroket 4y ago> I don't see any end to globalisation in the information economy up top Maybe that's a later stage but it's definitely on the agenda... I mean they openly flirted with banning it just a few years ago. I think it'd be silly to assume the hawks pushing that (or their allies of convenience who are just running US social media companies) just shrugged their shoulders and gave up.
- mlindner 4y agoFor context, here's the full quote: > "Twenty-seven years have passed and [the semiconductor industry] witnessed a big change in the world, a big geopolitical situation change in the world," Chang said. "Globalization is almost dead and free trade is almost dead. A lot of people still wish they would come back, but I don't think they will be back."
- verdenti 4y agoI’ll believe it when 95% of the things I buy don’t come from Asia
- koolba 4y ago95% of what? Disposable income spent on clothing and trinkets? Assuming you’re living in the west somewhere, you housing and food expenses would be local. Ditto for the majority of your energy consumption.
- pengaru 4y ago> and food expenses would be local Do you purchase food stuffs in the USA? It's absolutely not a safe assumption that food purchased here is locally grown/produced. That hasn't been the case for a long time, decade+ I'd estimate just based on experience.
- WoodenChair 4y agoOnly 15% of the US food supply is imported. [0] 0: https://www.fda.gov/food/importing-food-products-united-states/fda-strategy-safety-imported-food https://www.fda.gov/food/importing-food-products-united-stat...
- shepherdjerred 4y agoI wonder how they measure that. Is it by calories, weight, cost?
- pengaru 4y agoIf it's calories that's a pretty easy game for corn syrup to win...
- deleted 4y ago[deleted]
- pengaru 4y ago
- eddiewithzato 4y agoGood, almost there and we will finally eliminate modern day slavery. Because paying someone $1 a day at the other side of the world is no different than giving them only food for the days work.
- coffeebeqn 4y agoHow much were they making before and for what work? How much will they be making and for what work after?
- twblalock 4y agoThey take those jobs because their other options are worse. It is a way out of poverty for many. No poor country is going to get rich without passing through a phase of low-wage semi-poverty (unless they find a ton of oil under their ground).
- noduerme 4y ago>> unless they find a ton of oil under their ground And even then... https://press.princeton.edu/books/paperback/9780691159638/the-oil-curse https://press.princeton.edu/books/paperback/9780691159638/th... [edit] better link: https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Resource_curse#Enclave_effects https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Resource_curse#Enclave_effects
- eddiewithzato 4y agoThose jobs are only causing more inequality by propping up a wealthy slave owner class in their country. Only winners are the CEOs who do sell this service to the west. Without them that country can happily live within their means.
- twblalock 4y agoLook at what happened in China over the past several decades, after the Chinese government embraced international trade and market economics. The average person there is much better off now. Hundreds of millions of people who had been trapped in subsistence poverty for many generations have been lifted into a much higher standard of living. It's such a drastic change in standard of living that it's indisputable.
- metaphor 4y agohttps://archive.ph/VtR7k https://archive.ph/VtR7k
- diego_moita 4y agoI am reading an well argued book saying the same thing: The End of the World Is Just the Beginning - Mapping the Collapse of Globalization by Peter Zeihan. He argues that international trade competition will withdraw the U.S. from international sea trade patrolling and peace keeping military operations and will weaken the institutions created by the Breton Woods treaty. Interesting read but still not convinced. The book was written before Putin had that stupid idea. Let's see how does it play out.
- UncleOxidant 4y agoI find that Zeihan has some interesting insights, but I also often find that he seems to be a little too confident in some of his predictions. He often times comes off as being very positive about the US outlook, but very pessimistic about the rest of the world. And sure, the US has a better demographic situation than China and Russia and that's going to be bad for them, but it's not like they don't have any cards to play.
- marmetio 4y agoAnd now you know how to properly use his analysis. The service he provides is to brief US-centric companies on potential geopolitical trends, risks, and opportunities. You'd be misusing the information if you had little business with the US, or expected a crystal ball.
- spaceman_2020 4y agoHis reasoning seems rock solid to me. It is factually true that the US has built-in geographic security. It is also true that the US has a culture of immigration which makes it easier to keep demographic decline at bay, compared to, say, China.
- VancouverMan 4y agoImmigration is a double-edged sword. Bringing in educated, skilled, productive, and socially-compatible individuals can certainly help a nation and its economy. On the other hand, bringing in unskilled, unproductive, and socially-incompatible individuals can very quickly become a total disaster for a nation and its economy, too. There's not much room for error. The negative impacts of allowing in just one additional unsuitable individual can easily cancel out the positive contributions of several productive individuals.
- lvl102 4y agoGlobalization is just getting started.
- UncleOxidant 4y agoCare to expound on your thesis a bit more? Is this just a pause in the longterm path to globalization?
- avastmick 4y agoI agree with this; we’ve only been recently witnessing the awakening. My view entirely: (some) people will start to see themselves as the true commodity of value and either move to where they are valued or work remotely. This is already starting to happen. The more enlightened nation states will get on the bus and compete for people resources. Those more backward thinking will seek to lock the door and regress and live increasingly in tyranny. Just my view.
- navi0 4y agoAgree. Remote work during pandemic has shown companies they don’t need legions of mid- and low-tier white collar workers onshore. You can hire top tier college educated talent in the Philippines for $30K/yr. They work US hours and are hard working. A friend runs his entire US operations for a $5M/yr revenue company with just one other US-based employee.
- lvl102 4y agoI think it will be the other way around. Wages abroad will rise. Same with standard of living.
- navi0 4y agoYes, both can be true; one would expect that to happen over time until supply meets demand. It will do to service/clerical jobs what 90s-10s globalization did to manufacturing.
- lm28469 4y ago
- pcurve 4y agoIt sounds like he is speaking on behalf of his own industry. But for almost everything else, there is still plenty of labor arbitrage opportunities for lower cost production in developing countries in Asia and Africa.
- blueblimp 4y ago> "It was, I thought, a dream fulfilled," Chang said. "But it [the first plant] ran into cost problems. We ran into people problems, we ran into cultural problems. The dream fulfilled became a nightmare fulfilled. It took us several years to untangle ourselves from my nightmare, and I decided that I needed to postpone the dream." What makes this time different, in particular regarding people problems? Isn't the US high skill immigration system as broken as it's ever been?
- mewse-hn 4y agoI think the context is important: this was a political event where the US president made an appearance, and all the tech CEOs lined up to say the age of China is over. There's little evidence that new fabs won't run into the same problems they ran into in the mid 90s. What's different this time is there is political will all the way to the top in keeping this chip making capacity on-shore. It remains to be seen whether that political motivation translates to on-the-ground differences (cynical view: unlikely).
- navi0 4y agoYes, I wondered the same. What were the cultural and people problems encountered last time? Were Americans not educated/skilled enough to operate the fab? Did they not want to work the hours necessary to reach required yield thresholds? And how is that being managed this time?
- Leary 4y agoWhen Nancy Pelosi visited Taiwan, Morris Chang also told her the US efforts at manufacturing chips were "doomed to fail" [1] [1] https://www.taiwannews.com.tw/en/news/4697368 https://www.taiwannews.com.tw/en/news/4697368
- csomar 4y agoGlobalization is inevitable. Whether it'll eventually happen in our lifetime or not is up to our current elite and general population. I think Morris Chang is a bit upset by the current situation but he is wrong in generalizing the time in "never coming back".
- fnordpiglet 4y agoI agree. The efficiencies are too stark. Globalization is equivalent to specialization and division of labor. You can’t hope it away.
- sremani 4y agoSecurity is not free. who is under-writing global maritime security and what do they get in return.. that is the bigger question.
- remarkEon 4y ago>who is under-writing global maritime security and what do they get in return The United States. The conventional wisdom is that what the US gets in return is outsized influence in the internal politics of basically every country within that protection sphere, plus the petro-dollar. I don't totally agree with the second part, but that's what you'd find in an "explainer" from Vox or the pages of The Economist.
- 4y ago
- vlovich123 4y agoI’m curious what Apple, Nvidia, and AMD are using this plant to build. AFAIK none of these have assembly lines in America. I doubt they’re going to be shipping those chips from the US to China/India/Vietnam for assembly (from a supply chain delay and cost perspective alone). Is this just for taping out initial designs? Are they planning on onshoring assembly lines? What customer markets would those onshored assembly lines even service in a way that would compete with 3p resellers from abroad (assuming assembly cost would meaningfully differ).
- pwarner 4y agoMy bet is they shift to Mexico, at least for some products. Also, if anything is cheap to fly across the world, I'd say it's a chip?
- vlovich123 4y agoThis shit isn’t flown anywhere. You ship it by boat / rail using the absolute cheapest mechanism you can because you’re building tens of millions of these. The first batch of assembled products might be drop shipped if you’ve fucked up your dev schedule and you need to meet some sales deadline but that’s a totally different thing.
- macshome 4y agoApple ships components from all over the world to China for assembly already. This would just be one more.
- vlovich123 4y agoCan you give an example of which ones? AFAIK every single component comes from Asia.
- philliphaydon 4y ago100% of the FaceID component in iPhone comes from Texas. According to Apple. Edit: Oh and I think the accelerometer comes from Germany, but I would need to look it up, it might be a German company.
- blagie 4y agoI'd like to see globalization for everything non-essential. I'd like food, medicine, weapons, and everything needed to keep those industry running at a basic level as close as possible.
- WatchDog 4y agoSerious question, what's left after that? The technology involved in food production, medicine, and weapons are very diverse and complex, if you need to keep all the supporting industries, whats left to globalize?
- blagie 4y agoYou don't need to keep all the supporting industries. If global supply chains collapse tomorrow, farms will continue to operate even if they can't buy new robotic combines, so long as the old ones haven't broken down. We need enough parts to maintain those for long enough to adapt (probably by going back to simpler technologies). If, tomorrow, the US depended on manually picking crops, the US wouldn't collapse if Silicon Valley suddenly switched from building software to harvesting crops by hand. Same thing for most services -- lawyers, therapists, professors, teachers, etc. Some of those would be *painful*, and the economy might be set back by a half-century, but we'd be alive, and we'd eventually recover. To globalize: * Pre-SaaS software. If the US had disappeared in a nuclear war with Russia, Windows 95 wouldn't get any upgrades, but it would keep working for the installed base worldwide. * Entertainment and education. * Luxury goods. * Cars, building materials, and similar, so long as we maintain the basic capacity to keep supply chains going and provide basic shelter. * Digital cameras, trash cans, furniture, kitchen appliances, and 90% of the other stuff we buy
- midoridensha 4y agoMost countries don't have the technical capability needed to manufacture advanced medicines and weapons; that's why they buy them from elsewhere. US allies buy US-made weapons because they're the most advanced (e.g., F-35), not because they're the cheapest, and also it helps integrate their capabilities with the US's in case there's a conflict. Food is already made locally, but many things just don't grow in many places. You're not going to get coconuts or bananas to grow in Norway.
- eloff 4y agoOnce again Africa draws the short straw.
- dgreensp 4y agoJust because the US might be able to manufacture something high-tech again doesn’t mean the death of anything… like maybe globalization will get 5% less extreme, before turning around or doing whatever it does next? I don’t see how the existence of some small trend or force going against some huge dominant trend amounts to it being almost dead. Globalization is like capitalism. Calling it fragile is just mock victimhood or whining. Proponents push it forward regardless of the human cost. Democracy and human rights are fragile.
- refurb 4y agoAgree. To say it’s “dead” when Apple is shifting their manufacturing from China to India says the exact opposite. I think the author has blinders on and seems to think “China” = “world”.
- LarsDu88 4y agoCapitalism will ensure that globalization will bounce back if only for that fact that resources (both human and natural) are not evenly distributed across the world. AI is not going to change that. It's people's attitude towards the resulting cultural shifts that's causing a local snapback
- robocat 4y ago"Twenty-seven years have passed and [the semiconductor industry] witnessed a big change in the world, a big geopolitical situation change in the world," Chang said. "Globalization is almost dead and free trade is almost dead. A lot of people still wish they would come back, but I don't think they will be back." > Globalization Without the context of a video or transcript, this is almost meaningless. Presumably he is talking about TSMC only, which is politically all-in on globalisation and is motivated to undermine US hegemony in IC production. Could the US onshore the European supply chain for chip-making? There is doubt that China can do the same, so surely the same doubt holds for the US. Occasional supply-chain shocks show how interconnected the modern world is. The absolute simplest world commodities require years to replace - Neon is not a complicated substance. New Zealand (my country) is a small country near the edge of the world, so we have no choice but globalisation. Most countries have no choice either. A lot of US power comes from globalisation — witness the politics of denying China and Russia access to goods and services. Should the US become more disconnected, it would have less influence. > free trade I think the USA is becoming more protectionist, but that doesn’t mean that free trade agreements amongst the rest of the world stop. In 2008 New Zealand signed a free trade agreement with China. One problem seems to be that the USA asks a lot and gives a little (see AUSFTA), so NZ is unlikely to be better off by “negotiating” with the USA. After the USA withdrew from the TPP[1] in 2017, the remaining 11 countries (edit Australia, Brunei, Canada, Chile, Japan, Malaysia, Mexico, New Zealand, Peru, Singapore, and Vietnam) ratified a new agreement called the CPTPP[2] in 2018. In the CPTPP: “22 measures favoured by the U.S. but contested by other signatories were suspended”. In New Zealand we care a lot about free trade: we wide-opened our market early and we still have one of the most open markets in the world. [1] https://wikipedia.org/wiki/Trans-Pacific_Partnership https://wikipedia.org/wiki/Trans-Pacific_Partnership [2] https://wikipedia.org/wiki/Comprehensive_and_Progressive_Agreement_for_Trans-Pacific_Partnership https://wikipedia.org/wiki/Comprehensive_and_Progressive_Agr...
- mc32 4y agoPeople on the left and the right ware against the TPP and so were those concerned with aspects of IP. The main ones who were big fans were captains of industry and not the man or woman on the street, by and large.
- Waterluvian 4y agoWe will hear a lot of this from various incumbents as a ton of production, especially in semiconductors, develops in the US. It’s incredibly healthy and about darn time.
- wskish 4y agoisn't it more about "bifurcated globalization" versus "singleton globalization"?
- ineedasername 4y agoI think that’s a little premature. Logistical problems caused by the pandemic and geopolitics have revealed significant weaknesses that may be inevitable in globalization past a certain point but that just means the pendulum will shift a bit in the other direction, not kill it. Also most medium & smaller countries won’t be able to onshore all goods and services and will therefore be required to continue relying significantly on globalized industry.
- mcrad 4y ago
- gwbas1c 4y agoGlobalization is as old as written history. Trade routes were around at least 1000 years ago. Colonization of the Americas was driven by Europe's search for easier access to Asia. Modern Globalization will return once the political climate improves.
- spaceman_2020 4y agoThat form of “globalization” was for esoteric commodities usually consumed by the wealthy. You could only ship products that were a) small enough, and b) could survive a year long voyage. You were trading expensive spices and luxury fabrics, not furniture and household utensils. The average person had maybe a couple of items in his home that were imported from global shipping routes. The rest of it was made locally. Compare that to now when its the opposite - your house is filled with imported goods and locally made products might be rare (and often, expensive). Which is to say, globalization of previous eras was a demographically isolated phenomenon - for the wealthy few.
- throwaway290 4y ago> That form of “globalization” was for esoteric commodities usually consumed by the wealthy. What a rich guy in another country bought, a poor guy in this country sold for profit. The beauty of capitalism, I guess:) > You could only ship products that were a) small enough, and b) could survive a year long voyage. International routes were used for grain and construction materials since the beginning of AD. They did not connect the entire planet since the tech was not there but they worked across countries around Mediterranean sea and Indian ocean. But now that tech is here and it is not going away
- spaceman_2020 4y ago> What a rich guy in another country bought, a poor guy in this country sold for profit. The dominant political order for much of recent human history was feudalism. The poor guy didn't sell his wares in a free market. The poor guy's wares were the property of his feudal Lord who was the primary beneficiary of this trade. The poor guy remained just that - poor.
- tw1984 4y agoI am not sure whether globalization is almost dead or not, but it clear to me that it is not sustainable. Look at the trade figures for China, e.g. $675 billion surplus[1] was recorded for 2021. US should unionize its labor forces and start doing all kinds of manufacturings. Countries like China and India should be build more high tech & high value added stuff to climb up the value chain. [1] https://asia.nikkei.com/Economy/China-trade-surplus-reached-record-in-2021-despite-trade-war https://asia.nikkei.com/Economy/China-trade-surplus-reached-...
- ashwagary 4y ago>US should unionize its labor forces and start doing all kinds of manufacturings. The economics of this suggestion doesnt work. Either the US issues the global reserve currency and stays a major importer or gives up that status and becomes a larger exporter. Can't have it both ways.
- throwaway4good 4y agoLet's not forget that the primary beneficiary of globalization is the American capitalist class. And even with current populist/protectionist winds those guys likely win out in the long run.
- mikewarot 4y agoThe coming collapse of the German industrial system as it is starved of cheap natural gas that formed the basis of its chemical and energy inputs means that the current big Semiconductor Fab installs in the US are likely to be the last round of machines sent by AMSL before they're forced to relocate to the US. It remains to be seen if we can build up enough specialty gas industry before existing stocks run out, and force decisions as to which chips will/won't get made. (I.E. if we run out of Neon) Global trade is winding down, it was the bribe the US gave to the rest of the world to keep them on our side against the Soviet Union. We're backing out of our role as the world's guarantee of security on the high seas. Piracy is about to make a big comeback against anyone not flying a US or Ally's flag. Manufacturing in the US will have to double its installed base to keep up with demand. Capital is fleeing the rest of the world, and we in the US enjoy having our currency as the Global Reserve, so for us, it'll still be a rough ride, but better that most.
- selimthegrim 4y agoI am pretty sure a grateful Ukraine is gonna hook us up with neon
- DocTomoe 4y agoEither Russia takes over, and then there's going to be a price hike for having been anti-Russian. Or Ukraine somehow survives, and then they have to rebuild ... leading to a price hike. They may be grateful, but they will also make us pay through the nose.
- michaelmrose 4y agoIt might be opening a can of worms but how do you see Russia pulling off a victory after the abject failure so far. They are burning through assets trained and built over years. There is absolutely no reason to believe that their position or resources should improve over time. As it stands their logistics are a laughingstock incapable of effectively bringing a few few hundred thousand people effectively to bear on Ukraine. There is absolutely no reason to believe its up to bringing a larger force to bear. How do you see them possibly winning? I was hoping part of the rebuilding would be simply seizing every penny of Russian assets currently frozen and giving them to Ukraine.
- bigcat12345678 4y agoNote that Morris is not really the founder perse, as he was recruited by Taiwan government officials for developing indigenous semiconductor industry. Same thing as many Chinese Americans were recruited by Chinese government.
- b20000 4y agoso how are we going to make and sell ARM cpus for under $10 retail a piece at a few K qty? digikey, mouser, arrow will still want ridiculous markups and there is a cartel that controls pricing. cost of labour is much higher in the US than asia and the skilled labour is missing. how is all this going to work? by 2024, we will be paying 4K for a TV and 20K for a laptop.
- refurb 4y agoIsn’t most chip manufacturing automated? And US wages are ~2.5x that of Taiwan. It’s not like they are get $0.50/hr.
- b20000 4y agothat might be true. i don’t know. however the question is what the executives might decide to do or what the expectations of shareholders are. i bet someone will have the idea to double or triple cost of parts at retail because chips are now made in the US which would be a terrible mistake. it could make it impossible to start a small hardware company.
- Havoc 4y agoIn chips maybe. All the stuff on Amazon is still made in China though so I'd say reports of globalization's death are greatly exaggerated