4 ms·
"Applying this pressure to your congressmen is the only real way to affect change" is followed by "I've called each of mine and have the vapid response letter
by scarmig 15y ago
"Applying this pressure to your congressmen is the only real way to affect change"
is followed by
"I've called each of mine and have the vapid response letters to prove it."
Slight disconnect there? =)
Don't mean to harp on it, because contacting your congresscritters is a genuinely productive way to enact change. (Just don't put a whole lot of effort writing a heartfelt argument informed with evidence and rigor--its value comes more from indicating to the politician the breadth and energy of opposition to SOPA.)
But focusing on GoDaddy isn't a distraction, either. One of the central rules of political organizing is this: you pick the target, freeze it, personalize it, and polarize it. Victory isn't going to come in one fell swoop: if it comes at all, it will be through a loosely connected series of small victories, looking plausible only in retrospect.
GoDaddy is an easy enemy: it has an anti-charismatic founder who has a long history of general shittiness. A victory there doesn't only screw over GoDaddy, which is in the grand scheme of things not even a secondary target--its only actual goal is to make a quick buck from the feds. But what a victory does do is this: for one, it sends an obvious message to Congress and to other companies that the Internet matters: it's providing objective information that, yes, the anti-SOPA forces have some power, and other players might re-evaluate their current strategy to accomodate that new information.
But beyond that, and more important than that, is that it builds the movement. A victory sends a signal to people who are anti-SOPA but disenchanted that there is at least the hope of victory, bringing them back into the fold. It generates a bunch of news articles providing valuable anti-SOPA publicity, which is especially valuable since broader public knowledge of SOPA is one of the things we need most now. And it develops commitment and better engagement for the movement via showing how each of us as individuals can contribute to change.
It's not an either-or choice: you can both send letters and move your domains from GoDaddy.
By the way, if you're reading this and you haven't sent a letter... close out this window immediately, write a letter, and send it.
- palish 15y agoPlease don't write a letter. It accomplishes nothing. We need to call our congressman and speak to whomever is on the line, with our voices. Not pens or keyboards. When your congressman asks his staff "What have the public been calling about?" (which he asks regularly), then there's a good chance that SOPA will be mentioned. But only if you call your congressman!
- pingswept 15y agoWhat evidence is there concerning the relative efficacy of emails, paper letters, and phone calls?
- seigenblues 15y agofrom speaking to staffers (i live in the DC area). They are generally young 20-somethings whose job it is to answer the phones, tally the e-mails & letters, and report on it to the congresscritters; they are generally unanimous on a few points: 1) that the congresspeople care and notice if an issue is getting a lot of attention from constituents 2) that this is something they usually ask about every day 3) that phone calls are generally more influential than letters, which are generally more influential than e-mails -- but it depends on how each office handles their inbounds.
- Canada 15y agoWhy not write a letter, send an email, and make a phone call?
- seigenblues 15y agoyes, doing all of the above is best :)
- espeed 15y agoIf politicians don't cooperate, a tactic lobbyists use is to threaten to throw their weight behind the politician's challengers. We could set up a site to donate to all the SOPA supporters' challengers.
- Alterlife 15y agoBesides, "On the Internet", GoDaddy is a more relevant target than the US government. If the US Government wants to censor the internet, I can do nothing - I don't live there. However, if GoDaddy wants to censor the internet, I can move my domains away.