10 ms·
How a dangerous stew of air pollution is choking the United States
- therein 4y agoMade me think of this. https://www.geoengineeringwatch.org/documents/GeoengineeringWatch%20-%20Vietnam%20War%20Forest%20Fire%20As%20A%20Military%20Weapon.pdf https://www.geoengineeringwatch.org/documents/Geoengineering...
- sparrish 4y agohttps://www.epa.gov/air-trends/air-quality-national-summary https://www.epa.gov/air-trends/air-quality-national-summary > EPA creates air quality trends using measurements from monitors located across the country. The table below show that air quality based on concentrations of the common pollutants has improved nationally since 1980. > emissions of the common air pollutants and their precursors have been reduced substantially since 1980. > from 1990 to 2017 emissions of air toxics declined by 74 percent
- idiotsecant 4y agoWhile this is true on average it's apparent to me that you are not a resident of the American PNW, or you'd understand that the national average of air toxins is not what this article is discussing. For the last decade the yearly forest fires in the american northwest have been getting worse and worse and the levels of pm2.5 particulates in the air air are not only unhealthy, but dangerous for all groups (not just the old or young or sick) for weeks or months at a time depending on your exact location. It's a huge problem.
- rmah 4y agoSeems to me that when you have a lot of forests, you eventually get forest fires. I don't see much way around this except regularly cutting down the trees. Too many people think that nature always finds an equilibrium (the "balance of nature" idea) when left alone. That's often not true. It often cycles between extremes.
- culi 4y agoOr... we could just let indigenous people do their cultural burns. Cultural burns were banned in California before California was even technically a state. It's moronic. These practices have been in place for thousands of years and much of the flora of at least California shows many signs of adaptation to these frequent, low-frequency burns. These types of burn practices reduce the amount of fuel for wildfires, help fight invasive species while promoting native species, produce charcoal that purify the waterways, protect the soils from the higher intensity fires that can often turn soil infertile, and increase the production of certain native foodcrops like acorns and blueberries. Indigenous people throughout the west coast are fighting for their rights to reclaim their stewardship role. Frankly, we should be paying them, not challenging them https://www.nps.gov/subjects/fire/indigenous-fire-practices-shape-our-land.htm https://www.nps.gov/subjects/fire/indigenous-fire-practices-... https://www.vox.com/22518592/indigenous-people-conserve-nature-icca https://www.vox.com/22518592/indigenous-people-conserve-natu...
- hombre_fatal 4y agoIs controlled burning some lost technology that only a modern druid can bring back? Or is it something states already do, and when they don't, it's for political reasons and various other concerns and even failings, not because there's nobody who knows how to steward the burn? I could even imagine that, for political reasons, some indigenous entity is the right hand for the job. But surely not because they possess some secret hereditary epistemology in 2022.
- culi 4y agoControlled burns are something firefighters are something many states are finally starting to recognize the importance of and providing funding for. However, given how critically understaffed firefighters are (e.g. California has ~3.5k fighterfighters total, down from 5k a few years ago) and how undertrained they are for a technique that has only recently been recognized for its importance, it's hard to imagine us having any success without the help of the indigenous communities that are fighting for the RIGHT to practice their cultural burns Besides that, prescribed burns and cultural burns often have different goals. Firefighters sole goal is to use up residual fuel sources to prevent larger fires. Cultural burning practices are often done with the aim of supporting the health of forests and other ecosystems. They're often much more narrowly scoped and frequent and require much more intimate knowledge of specific ecosystems and landscapes. Given that so many tribes have been displaced from their homeland, a lot of this knowledge is lost. But the goals of these communities are to revitalize landscapes with the intent of returning to them and make use of them. I think it's that fundamental difference in goals that tends to cultivate much more thorough ecological knowledge about specific landscapes often shown in cultural burning practices Hazard-reduction burns also simply use different techniques. They tend to rely on drip-torches to burn through control lines. These types of fires are controlled but still very hot and damaging to the soil. Compare that to indigenous experts that use a wide range of techniques to ensure the fires are as slow moving and cool as possible
- wizofaus 4y agoWhich is mentioned in the article, but notes that's been recently overwhelmed by particulates from wildfires etc.
- culi 4y agoYou should read the OP > Researchers say that laws intended to combat air pollution don’t address increasingly important sources, such as wildfires and dust. In fact, the EPA created an exemption for the increased air pollution that occurs during wildfires, dust storms and similar events considered to be ‘natural’. The agency’s ‘exceptional events rule’, adopted in 2007, excludes days when such events happen from consideration by regulators. > By pruning outliers deemed ‘natural exceptions’, the regulatory data set is skewed, says Katie Clifford, author of a paper this year that called the practice into question.
- anigbrowl 4y agoThe EPA is arguably subject to both regulatory capture and legislative/judicial boundaries that limit the scope of its mission. This is not to say your source article isn't valuable, but that it probably can't tell the whole story.
- latchkey 4y agoThis last summer, I drove through most of the California national forests on the eastern side of the state. After seeing all the devastation from the previous fires, I'm not sure that there is that much left to burn at this point. I feel like between PG&E fixing their shit (saw lots of trucks doing repair work) and all the existing damage, that we're going to get to some sort of equilibrium where we won't have as bad of fires every year.
- baggy_trough 4y agoThere is much, much more left to burn.
- scifibestfi 4y agoIt's more about forest management, which they largely stopped doing in past decades and were supposed to start back up. They are far, far behind. Until they catch up the wildfires will continue burning massive amounts of fuel unimpeded.
- olivermarks 4y agoIn California Newsom actually lied about this with zero media pushback. https://www.capradio.org/articles/2021/06/23/newsom-misled-the-public-about-wildfire-prevention-efforts-ahead-of-worst-fire-season-on-record/ https://www.capradio.org/articles/2021/06/23/newsom-misled-t... 'Newsom overstated, by an astounding 690%, the number of acres treated with fuel breaks and prescribed burns in the very forestry projects he said needed to be prioritized to protect the state’s most vulnerable communities. Newsom has claimed that 35 “priority projects” carried out as a result of his executive order resulted in fire prevention work on 90,000 acres. But the state’s own data show the actual number is 11,399.' This is outrageous on so many levels, but the media is far more interested in the relentless drum beat around climate anxiety than they are in pushing for any practical measures. Meanwhile the Sierra club are heavily invested in burning wood to make electricity. What a mess! Look up 'biomass' here: https://planetofthehumans.com/fact-check-bible/ https://planetofthehumans.com/fact-check-bible/
- 4y ago
- vdnkh 4y agoThe Trump admin and Republicans rolled back a ton of clean air regulations: https://www.nytimes.com/interactive/2020/climate/trump-environment-rollbacks-list.html https://www.nytimes.com/interactive/2020/climate/trump-envir... "The bulk of the rollbacks identified by the Times were carried out by the Environmental Protection Agency, which weakened Obama-era limits on planet-warming carbon dioxide emissions from power plants and from cars and trucks; removed protections from more than half the nation’s wetlands; and withdrew the legal justification for restricting mercury emissions from power plants."
- jefftk 4y agoThis is smoke from forest fires. The EPA changes were in other areas.
- daVe23hu 4y agoI used to work in China 2005-2017 off and on.... Air quality index in winter could hit ~800 in Changzhou - That experience was unreal.
- DeBraid 4y agoFriend who spent time there 2008-10 has a great line: "the air is a prison".
- latchkey 4y agoSimilar experience in Vietnam. It is a totally different type of pollution than California burning fires too... a lot of it is burning trash (plastic), industrial and/or automotive (motorbikes and diesel trucks). I got used to changing clothes and taking a shower every time I came back to the house because I smelled so awful from the exhaust and pollution. I left right before covid and this is definitely one of the things that is keeping me from going back after covid. It isn't healthy at all.
- MetaverseClub 4y agoWorth to mention that Changzhou is a city on the south side of Yangtze River, where no heat provided to public, meaning that cities on the north side could be way worse due to coal burning for heat supply.
- deleted 4y ago[deleted]
- daVe23hu 4y agoI had so many positive experiences in China, Zhong Shan, Ningbo and many other places.... People/food experiences so wonderful, fun and unique. I keep in touch with many of the folks I worked with in China. But pollution was the common denominator in my supply chain management aspects that shocked me. I have so many sad stories in that category. Just my observations ........
- clsec 4y agoI've lived in SF since 1972 and have pretty much always known about Asian smog. And while it's rarely talked about, 29% of San Francisco's pollution comes from Asia [1]. I don't know about ships, but I assume they contribute significantly as well. I did notice a massive increase in smog during the height of the pandemic from all the ships anchored in the bay, so there is that. [1] https://pubs.acs.org/doi/abs/10.1021/es101450t#afn2 https://pubs.acs.org/doi/abs/10.1021/es101450t#afn2
- kderbyma 4y agowell Canada is much better than it was 25 years ago....so I guess up north we are good
- kompatible 4y agoConsidering air doesn't typically follow national borders I think that's a bit shortsighted to say. "Much better" might not mean "better than the US" but just "better than before for Canada", which may or may not say too much at all.
- kevin_thibedeau 4y agoOne of the perks of living on the northern US border is the clean Canadian air.
- jasone 4y agoReally? As someone who lives 100 miles south of British Columbia, my smoke season experience suggests that Canadian forests have been managed similarly to US forests, which is to say "very poorly".
- moistly 4y agoYah, no. I live in Interior BC. It has become rare to have a summer where, for several weeks, our valleys are choked with smoke. Twice in recent years I have literally been unable to see the house across the street because the smoke was so thick. My entire city was on bloody evacuation notice! Some small towns burned to the ground, not a building left standing. The fires get so big they develop their own weather systems. If you live outside a town, chances are you can no longer obtain home fire insurance. We are not good, not by any metric.
- Syonyk 4y ago> Researchers say that laws intended to combat air pollution don’t address increasingly important sources, such as wildfires and dust. Yes, because wildfires are so good at obeying laws passed to regulate them... We talk about "fire season" out here now (Treasure Valley, southwest Idaho) as a distinct season - often overlapping with summer and fall, but sometimes doing other things. It's the time when the air ranges from "a bit gross" to "quite human-toxic." It sucks, and really wasn't a thing before about 7-8 years ago. You'd have the occasional "smoke day," but it wasn't a distinct season. Some years, it's not bad - 2022 wasn't bad, we had some days that were bad, a couple weeks of "Eh, this isn't great to be in..." - but that was about it. Last year, from June to somewhere in October was just vile to be out in. I've started trying to more deliberately manage indoor and personal air quality (which, yes, is slightly at odds with my winter kerosene lantern habits, but different things for different seasons). We have a "box filter" sort of arrangement on a fan in one of the rooms in the house that's gone from being a seasonal thing to "always on, fan speed varies based on how bad the air is." Indoor PM in the winter is quite low, and even when it's vile outside in the summer, I can usually keep indoor air quality more or less acceptable. Though CO2 levels climb due to the lack of venting... pick your poisons, literally. My social circle has largely settled on 3M half face painter's masks with P100 filters for outdoor work during smoke season (and they're handy the rest of the year too if you're mowing or trimming - it keeps the pollen and dust out of your lungs too). The newer "white with pink stripes" filters breathe better than the old pink ones, and while I wouldn't really want to go running in them, you certainly could. A few of us are looking at how to do something more PAPR-like with a face mask, for less than the cost of the "certified" solutions. Tired of my eyes burning when outside... My office has a HEPA filter I run basically all day in the summer, which helps with PM levels in my shoffice (shed office). Again, you can kind of trade CO2 and PM and a few other things, though I'm seriously considering an algae based absorber... There's no great solution, unfortunately. The jokes about "being out of forest to burn" run squarely into the reality of "Most of the western US forest hasn't burned yet," and we're far from out of areas that can burn given incentive. The last 80 years of forest management of "not letting it burn" has caught up to us, and until it's all burned back down to a sustainable level, this is likely to be the future. Unfortunately, decades of debris buildup means that when a forest (not if, when) lights, you get incredibly destructive crowning fires that just sterilize an area, not the lower burns that leave stronger pines intact (consider that many pines require fire for their cones to open - that requires a pine cone left behind after the fire has gone through). But a couple years on a set of furnace filters for indoor air cleaning, wrapped around a box fan, is well worth doing at this point. As is a P100 mask of some variety for outdoor use in these conditions. Neil Stephenson's "Earthsuits" are a concept whose time, unfortunately, seems to be coming.
- wizeman 4y ago
- Tade0 4y agoI've experienced US AQI levels of 200+. I didn't know how to set my car vents because with only inside air it would fog up and in outside mode the air had a disgusting aftertaste, despite filtering. What baffled me the most was how locals reacted to it. They called it "fog" and didn't complain. And that wasn't the only instance of such behaviour. Apparently there's some kind of taboo surrounding smog and places where it is a result of heating with questionable fuels.
- selimthegrim 4y agoWhere was this?
- Tade0 4y agoZabrze, Poland. But I see the same attitude here, less than 200km west.
- badpun 4y agoI live in the area. It's 150 AQI right now. In one extreme Winter evening, I measured 1200 PM2.5.... I don't know how it would translate to AQI, but I imagine it would be a lot.
- Tade0 4y agoDo people generally see it as a problem or is it sort of an "it is what it is" type of situation? I'm asking because I moved to this region of the country just a few years ago and I'm genuinely confused. I had a very weird conversation with a daycare worker about the air filters I found in the building. I thought they were there due to outside air, but apparently they bought them to filter the air inside and she saw the level of pollution as something "typical for a large city".
- badpun 4y agoThe awareness of the fact that extreme smog is not cool is growing, but still a large group of people (perhaps even a majority) accept it as a fact of life. In the eighties, it was so much worse here (there were heavy industrial plants - steel mills etc., without any pollution filtering, running at full steam in city centers of Zabrze, Katowice, Bytom etc.), that those who rememeber it perhaps still see current situation as a massive improvement.
- godshatter 4y agoWe need to do a better job caring for our forests. We need to put more resources into thinning them out, clearing debris and undergrowth, and clearing areas closest to developed areas. Preventative maintenance designed to reduce the impact of fires. Unfortunately we can't, because Trump brought it up one day in his patented ham-handed way. Now people just talk about "raking forests" and laugh it off.
- cowmoo728 4y agoThe US Forest Service, CalFire, National Park Service, aren't doing better forest management because Trump talked about raking the forests? That's a pretty reductive take. It's because of the immense manpower cost that they don't have funding for, how quickly human settlements are expanding into and encroaching on forest areas, the incredible risk of doing prescribed burns that could get out of control, and myriad other bureaucratic messes between native rights, federal land and agencies, and state agencies and air quality regulations. https://arstechnica.com/science/2020/01/why-isnt-california-using-more-prescribed-burns-to-reduce-fire-risk/ https://arstechnica.com/science/2020/01/why-isnt-california-...
- godshatter 4y agoI shouldn't have added the bit about Trump (I'm not an R or a D, btw), I just find it annoying that the idea gets shut down so quickly. Funding is an inherently political subject, and we've never been great as a country about working together and thinking ahead. I acknowledge all the problems mentioned and I realize the cost is huge to address them. But I live in the PNW and have seen the air quality get so bad due to locally close fires that I couldn't see the house across the street from my doorstep due to the smoke. For whatever reasons, movement politically on this subject has been a non-starter. I just hope we decide somewhere along the line that some preventative maintenance might go a long way to helping mitigate this.
- Lochleg 4y agoSo, forests won't be worked on to prove a point or what? The idea is decades old from at least when railroad companies were dealing with Canadian forests, so it seems like apathy or complacency won and still rules the day. It must have been a pretty good joke if people are still laughing about it though.
- ars 4y agoWith this graph: https://media.nature.com/lw767/magazine-assets/d41586-022-04333-9/d41586-022-04333-9_23789324.png?as=webp https://media.nature.com/lw767/magazine-assets/d41586-022-04... they attempt to claim that wildfires are getting worse due to climate change. But the graph actually shows the opposite: Notice how there is no change until year 2000, and only after that do wildfires get larger. And they get larger - and then stay at a larger size, they don't keep getting larger. Their trendline is so inaccurate it's basically false info. Climate change did not start in year 2000, what did change then is wildfire policy: "The Fish and Wildlife Service, Bureau of Land Management, and Bureau of Indian Affairs joined the other two agencies by implementing fire use programs in the late 1990s and early 2000s." https://fireecology.springeropen.com/articles/10.4996/fireecology.0302003 https://fireecology.springeropen.com/articles/10.4996/fireec... It's good that they are bringing awareness to the problem, but when their entire article is predicated on the wrong cause, I'm not sure how valuable it is.
- nightfly 4y agoThe increased heatwaves, extended drought periods, lack of snowfall are climate-change caused and definitely contributing to fire issues.
- Fricken 4y agoThe majority of increases in wildfires over the last 2 decades has happened in boreal forests, largely in Canada and Siberia, and a bit in Alaska. There was never much fire management going on in these places.
- rootusrootus 4y agoFor sure the wildfires in 2020 were awful. We actually got a level 2 evac warning in the city just outside of Portland. The smoke was so bad that I was replacing filters daily in the furnace running it 24x7 to try and keep the indoor air clean. We normally have such clean air here. This year we had another wildfire event where it got kinda gross outside, but not at all on the same scale. In 2020 the smoke was so bad that the AQI numbers were literally off the scale, above the claimed maximum value.
- _chu1 4y ago[flagged]
- hammock 4y agoThe US-wide heat map aligns pretty well with agricultural and industrial pollution, not necessarily wildfires. Let's not turn every last thing into a climate change debate. A US-wide view also obscures the air quality where it matters most, which is population centers. They are too small to show up on the blurry, smoothed heat map provided. In population centers (big cities), smog from personal and commercial vehicles is the primary contributor to poor air quality. I spent Thanksgiving week on Catalina Island and I personally watched the smog roll over greater Los Angeles. However on Thanksgiving Day I woke up and looked east, and the air was incredibly clear like I've never seen. On Friday morning it was still pretty good. But by Saturday the smog was back to normal. The weather was the same all week - this had to do with the number of vehicles on the road in a given day.
- ryukafalz 4y agoYeah, air pollution is a related but not identical issue to climate change. Emissions from ICE vehicles affect both air quality and atmospheric CO2. Particulates from tire wear (for example) affect primarily local air quality and not atmospheric CO2. And even setting aside climate change, we should also be worried about all the pollution we're breathing in. Lots of health issues there.
- vondur 4y agoBefore all of the emissions regulations were imposed, I remember in the 80’s growing up in LA county, a “Smog Alert” could be issued for the day, warning us to limit exercise time outdoors.
- bombcar 4y agoHeh kids these days do NOT know how bad LA used to be. Pictures don't really do it justice, you had to be there. https://www.insider.com/vintage-photos-los-angeles-smog-pollution-epa-2020-1#in-1949-smoke-from-a-trash-dump-covered-the-city-later-fearing-the-effects-of-smog-on-the-citys-inhabitants-gov-goodwin-knight-restricted-the-open-burning-of-garbage-it-was-made-illegal-in-1958-7 https://www.insider.com/vintage-photos-los-angeles-smog-poll...
- eYrKEC2 4y agoHearsay: In Washington state, a Vietnam vet pilot started working on forest fires after the Vietnam war and has been doing work in it ever since, though he's going to retire whenever he wants as he's past retirement age now. What he says has changed is: * lack of smoke jumpers -- the state thinks it costs too much to have adrenaline junkies waiting to fly out and put out a fire. * lack of will to fight forest fires as they are deemed "good" * inter-department fighting between federal and state managed land. Doesn't matter what state does if federal has land right next to it that they think is "good" to burn. -- Also, my wife's cousin is an Alaska smoke jumper. He says that smoke jumpers in the lower 48 are waaaay more safety conscious than they used to be and they're vastly more unwilling to get into the fray of the fire than previously. Whether that safety is warranted or not, I do not know, but it definitely could contribute to the problem.
- rendang 4y agoWhy would you want to put out natural forest fires when that just builds up more flammable material for next time?
- eYrKEC2 4y agoWhat if there are other solutions, like managing the forests in other ways, that does not make air quality be at unsafe levels for 1 month a year.
- mdorazio 4y agoAre any of these bad things?
- eYrKEC2 4y ago2 of the last 3 years, the outdoor air quality has been so bad due to these forest fires that it was unsafe to exercise outdoors and kids fall soccer season has been delayed by 1 month until snow fell in the mountains to put out the raging forest fires. Do you think that's bad?
- Eumenes 4y agoI recall reading a blog post years ago where someone made a air quality raspberry pi thing and they lived in a major city. When their windows were open, air quality was shit, but reduced quite a bit with them closed.
- olddustytrail 4y agoThat's really weird. Why would you expect bad air to improve if you shut it in a room?
- bombcar 4y agoBecause the air stops moving and things settle out, and the air that is in the room gets cycled through any air filters you might have.
- olddustytrail 4y agoBut the new air that's pulled in is just as dirty and the settled out air is settling in your lungs. It really doesn't make sense.
- ZeroGravitas 4y agoSomewhat related tangent: We should build Hydrogen powered fire-fighting planes that store the H20 output from the fuel cell and dump it onto the fire rather than (or in addition to) scooping up water from lakes.
- joshmarinacci 4y agoResident of Eugene Oregon here. I remember that day in September 2020 very well. It literally rained ash from the red sky for two days. This was 100% because of wildfires. The causes seem to be mixed between global climate change and the federal government not properly funding the forest management. (A huge chunk of Oregon is national forest. )
- lowbloodsugar 4y agoI feel like the forests burning is just a realignment due to climate change. The climate has changed on the west coast. Had the current climate been the stable climate of the last thousand years, the forests there would look very different. Many would not exist. Others would be made of different trees. What we are seeing is the rapid realignment of these environments to the new realities. Ironically, it might actually be better to chop them all down then replant with more appropriate trees.