5 ms·
What's more cynical is that these hackers are helping Apple to eliminate the competition, and when that happens they'll put another layer of crypto on everythin
by amelius 4y ago
What's more cynical is that these hackers are helping Apple to eliminate the competition, and when that happens they'll put another layer of crypto on everything and the hackers and other developers have no platform left to work on without paying 90% Apple taxes.
- gigatexal 4y agoWhat are you on about? Apple locking down their platform is their prerogative. If it comes to that and the Asahi team cannot continue their reverse-engineering efforts then they'll stop. Consider why they began in the first place. The M1 and their subsequent M2 and future chips are amazing. The M1 was such a huge leap in performance per watt that it wow'd everyone. In fact it's a huge testament to the hardware team at Apple for creating such an amazing bit of kit that a team of Linux hackers wanted to work on porting Linux to it. This rebellious striving for freedom is refreshing and amazing. They're going to get Linux working on the M1/2... hardware working under Linux and it'll be even more performant than under MacOS. That's huge. But now folks are saying why Apple? Because nobody has a chip that rivals the M1. Why would you settle for worse performance? Why would you settle for build quality from a lesser hardware manufacturer? Qualcomm and others don't have chips that are as performant. They might in the future but by then the M3 or M4 will likely be out. Why are we punishing hackers -- in teh purest sense of the word -- for opening up a platform that is superior (hardware wise) to any of the other offerings from all the other deep pocketed ARM laptop/desktop manufacturers? Oh, right, because of tribal hate of Apple. Smh. If the other manufacturers get off their butts and pour billions into chip design and process and can get laptops out with similar or better performance characteristics then perhaps other teams will attempt what Asahi is doing, and if these same manufacturers wanted to release the specs or work with the upstream Linux community and release drivers themselves that'd be even better. Until then I will continue to support the Asahi team and champion their efforts in every ear that will hear me because I am just so astounded by what they've accomplished so far. I say all of this as a former Apple-stan. I had macbooks every year since college until now. That's some 15 years. I've since gone full time on Fedora and Thinkpads (currently a P14s but maybe an X1 Carbon in the future). Edit: I don't think there will be a huge wave of sales because of this for Apple but it will mean that i can get a used M1 and run my favorite distro of Linux because the Asahi team is working with upstream to get their changes up-streamed -- they're amazing like that. It really is how open source work thrives.
- amelius 4y agoApple produces consumer hardware. You can't build anything hardware-wise using the M1 or M2 processors. There are hackers and startups who love to build new hardware. They now see Apple buying entire supply chains and dominating the market. If this continues, then after a while these hackers will not be able to fully depend on technological progress because it will all be locked up.
- gigatexal 4y agoWhat? None of that makes any sense. There’s been no chatter about Apple buying up or hogging wafers. Nobody is preventing others from building ARM based machines. The M1 and M2 chips are proprietary to Apple and so be it; the Asahi folks are allowing us to run Linux on them at full acceleration. What’s not to love?
- smoldesu 4y ago> There’s been no chatter about Apple buying up or hogging wafers. https://www.extremetech.com/computing/315186-apple-books-tsmcs-entire-5nm-production-capability https://www.extremetech.com/computing/315186-apple-books-tsm... It already happened for TSMC's first-gen 5nm node. > Nobody is preventing others from building ARM based machines. There is somebody, namely the ARM corporation that Apple owns a controlling stake in. So yes, Apple does prevent people from doing what they please with the ISA. > What’s not to love? You sound like the people preaching the Nouveau drivers right now. "we reverse-engineered this proprietary GPU and got it working at 50% speed and 3x power consumption, what's not to love?" Nvidia's first-party drivers are far-and-away the more popular (and faster, more power-efficent, more well-supported, etc.) option. What's "not to love" is the fact that we're cheering for someone doing thankless and redundant work that wouldn't exist if the multi-billion dollar corporation dedicated a couple engineers to Linux support. You can't even consistently control the brightness on these machines more than a year after they've launched, it's obvious that there are significant problems WRT reverse-engineering the hardware.
- gigatexal 4y ago
- tpush 4y ago> What's more cynical is that these hackers are helping Apple to eliminate the competition [...] Nonsense premise. > [...] they'll put another layer of crypto on everything [...] That's just unsubstantiated FUD.
- amelius 4y ago> That's just unsubstantiated FUD. It's hypothetical. The problem is that the reverse argument is also unsubstantiated.
- Steltek 4y ago> > What's more cynical is that these hackers are helping Apple to eliminate the competition [...] > Nonsense premise. Take Brew and any container runtime away from all developer's laptops. See how useful they are for development when compared to the more open competition.
- dihrbtk 4y agoThis is completely nonsensical. Take away your linux package manager and compiler and you'll get no work done either!
- Steltek 4y agoErr, the premise is that Linux tech and effort is improving the appeal of Apple products, which hurts the more open, Linux-friendly competition. Look at the rest of this thread comparing MacBooks to other options. My point is that a MacBook without the free work by these hackers/tech would be a paperweight for development and the Linux-friendly options would get more business. Your retort of "take Linux tech away from Linux" doesn't make any sense. Apple is entirely comfortable with using crypto to lock down its platforms when the competition is dead and users are left with no other choice.
- smoldesu 4y agoMy package manager and compiler are part of my OS. Brew and container runtimes are not part of MacOS.