7 ms·
German police arrest 25 suspects in plot to overthrow state
- raxxorraxor 4y ago> Heinrich XIII The pensioned monarchs strike back. This reads like satire.
- tartoran 4y agoImagine living all his life deprived, depressed and impotent of his divine right to rule and suddenly break free from that depression at 77 after browsing Qanon memes. Inner voice goes “yes you can” or “now it’s the right time” or “now or never”. Old man can plead senility but he has offspring, this can randomly erupt between now and next century.
- idontwantthis 4y agoThey sound like sovereign citizens plus nazis plus Qanon. They have almost no room for any kind of reality left in their minds.
- jagermo 4y agoplus a dash of aging royalty. Seems like some old fart "prince" wanted to be head of state.
- qikInNdOutReply 4y agoIt worked in the french revolution.
- 41tor 4y agoMost of these people would have been guillotined during the French revolution.
- tobilg 4y agoPlus members of the AfD party, which is currently in the Bundestag, and under scrutinity for far-right / Nazi connection.
- lzaaz 4y ago
- timonoko 4y agoDetails of the plot little vague. Maybe they are using the Plot of 1923. "First get arrested and then let the media do the dirty work".
- churchill 4y agoSounds like Beer Hall putsch 2.0 Context: https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Beer_Hall_Putsch https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Beer_Hall_Putsch
- tinus_hn 4y agoThe article sadly is rather thin on details of what they were trying to replace the state with.
- rsfern 4y agoI’m guessing the group is more familiar to Germans (I’m in the US) but I find wiki helpful. It’s not a monolithic movement but they basically want to go back to the German Reich circa 1918, and they have some kind of provisional government that’s supposed to be a continuation of this https://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/Reichsbürger_movement https://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/Reichsbürger_movement
- freilanzer 4y agoThis group is about the German Empire in 1971, apparently.
- rsfern 4y agoDo you mean 1871? Wiki says 1871-1918 German Empire and that the first sort of shadow government from this group was founded in 1985
- 082349872349872 4y agoshould be familiar to USians as well (imagine SovCits mit Lederhosen): https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=33893138 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=33893138 PS: my current favourite Los Angeles/Münich mashup is https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=wbsEZzgCwmI https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=wbsEZzgCwmI Edit: as far as I know (not being in either country) Reichsbürger and SovCits are a fringe in both, but far more of an obvious fringe in Deutschland than in the US.
- deleted 4y ago[deleted]
- kbrkbr 4y agoThis had zero chance of succeeding. Germany is a federal state with strong separation of power between federal government and local governments with local police forces. Society is split like elsewhere, but the fringe parties like AFD are at 15% in general election weekly question [1]. This is Don Quixotery. It can also be seen in the layout of German newspapers: spiegel.de and bild.de have the main article behind a paywall. They don’t do this for important news. [1] https://www.wahlrecht.de/umfragen/ https://www.wahlrecht.de/umfragen/ Edit: updated link
- 41tor 4y ago>Society is split like elsewhere, but the fringe parties like AFD are at 15% in general election weekly question [1]. This is Don Quixotery. When you factor in most reporting about the American election (I'm American) only give percents in terms of voters (small portion of population), Trump also had ~15%. This was a very serious incident, and the people who try these things should possibly be executed in a humane manner if this pattern of misbehavior continues.
- maxbond 4y agoI'd suggest that a humane manner of execution does not exist because murder is fundamentally inhumane.
- uninformed 4y agoWhoa, executing them might make them bigger heros in the eyes of their supporters aswell as make the government look like a bigger oppressor. Just ignore the shit out of them like a toddler throwing a tantrum while making sure that they don't hurt themselves or those near them.
- TheLoafOfBread 4y agoExactly last thing you want are monarchist martyrs.
- 41tor 4y agoThat's how you ended up needing to arrest a bunch of morons who post all day about wanting to do exactly what they ended up attempting to do. Instead what needs to happen is if execution is off the table, you very purposefully remind them, repeatedly, that there is nowhere to defect to -- you will not have quiet enjoyment of your Nazi coffeehouse, your Nazi bar, your Nazi... whatever... because the antifascists will not tolerate your behavior and invoke stand your ground the second you even hint at acting on your antisocial urges.
- 41tor 4y ago[flagged]
- LarsDu88 4y agoI'm really starting to think these fringe "activist" groups are driven by the FSB doing "active measures". Putin cut his teeth as a field agent in Germany supporting fringe groups to destabilize governments. In 2014, it was these types of groups that stormed the Luhansk and Donetsk governments. In 2021, right wing groups attempted to do the same in Washington. Now we see the German version of this in 2022.
- 082349872349872 4y agoThe argument against that is that groups of this memetic profile have been documented in the US since the 1960's, and in Deutschland since the 1980's, both of which predate the FSB as such (1995). On the "for" hand, they could all plausibly be Полезные идиоты (NB loan word from english!) and so it'll be interesting to see whether TFA's "one suspected supporter [who] is from Russia" winds up connected during the prosecution.
- zozbot234 4y agoThe predecessor was certainly highly active in 1960s U.S. though. We know of this from the Mitrokhin revelations.
- aebtebeten 4y agoFrom https://www.rbth.com/history/334691-inside-mitrokhin-archive-spy-ussr-kgb https://www.rbth.com/history/334691-inside-mitrokhin-archive...: > Stashes of arms were maintained in various parts of the [US], ready to be used in the case of an armed conflict. It would be ironic if pred(FSB) [in line with techniques used by the Tsar's Охрана, pred(pred(FSB))] had been using anti-communist groups to gather and stash arms for their ultimate use! (almost as ironic as a farmer fattening hogs, ultimately for schnitzel?) Putting on my tinfoil hat, a grand conspiracy theory along these lines would involve the pred(FSB) first cancelling both Kennedy and Хрущёв to prevent rapproachment, then electing Reagan in 1984 to shatter detente and turn the US away from western european democracy, in the hopes he would bring down the state and party (which had a distressing tendency to promote Gorby types?) for which they worked, enabling them, at long last, to install one of their own as leader of the FSU... Nah, that's crazy talk! </tinfoil> (between the FBI and the KГБ, I almost start to wonder how many truly organic nutjob groups existed in the 1960s US! "Please, no russian — I'm spying!" https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=3PHLmv4Zzu0 https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=3PHLmv4Zzu0 )
- justusw 4y agoYep, they come with the whole shebang of self-issuing passports for their empire, and hoarding weapons for the next insurrection. Their fervor for the German Reich is absolutely comedic to Germans, especially the insistence on it having never ceased to exist. On the other hand their readiness to commit violent crimes (including readily assaulting city officials and law enforcement officers) is justifiably causing concern. These people behave as though grandpa woke up after a 60 year sleep and he doesn’t know yet that Germany lost the war or that the wall has fallen (like that Germany movie Good Bye Lenin https://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/Good_Bye,_Lenin https://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/Good_Bye,_Lenin! ) It’s the old trope of a family dinner where the eldest suddenly starts reminiscing how great things in the “3rd Reich” were. If I may draw comparisons then I hear that over in the US the Americans then I hear that similar situations are experienced during a thanksgiving dinner, when a certain relative shows up. Relics from the past that refuse to disappear.
- nonameiguess 4y agoIn the US, it used to be Senators casually getting nostalgic about the good old days when segregation was still legal and active. They've mostly all died by now.
- deleted 4y ago[deleted]
- 082349872349872 4y agoThe Kongo-Müller (1920-1983) interview (Der lachende Mann, DDR, 1966) is worth a watch —— but only at a time when one is otherwise well-disposed towards the innate good-nature of humanity.
- Tomte 4y ago> Their fervor for the German Reich is absolutely comedic to Germans, especially the insistence on it having never ceased to exist. There are several such groups, but one of the biggest ones has an absolutely comedic rationalisation why the German Reich still exists and "I'm the one in charge, not those other two dozen clowns who have founded their own Reich governments": They sent a letter to the American embassy. "If you want me to govern Germany on your behalf, don't object". And the American embassy even sent back a signed confirmation! Well, they did not. The Reichsbürger sent his letter as registered mail, the embassy's mail department signed its reception, the German post sent back the "we have delivered your registered mail" stub. Obviously, this news today is grave and doesn't lend itself easily towards comedy, but parts of the movement are really funny in their denial of reality.
- pyuser583 4y ago> The movement argues that the German constitution prior to World War II was never properly nullified … Prior to WWII - I assume they’re not talking about the Nazi regime, especially since they’re monarchists. Which constitution are they looking to restore? The Weimar constitution? The Pre-WWI constitution? Probably a dumb question. Folks like this aren’t known for clarity of thought. Might be the Holy Roman Empire.
- detaro 4y ago> The Weimar constitution usually that one, the leading "theory" is that it's the last legitimate (and thus still valid) one
- KoftaBob 4y agoPrimary source direct from Germany’s Minister of Justice: https://twitter.com/marcobuschmann/status/1600468138218299393?s=46&t=KdMTucYPCs3dGTelHcyESg https://twitter.com/marcobuschmann/status/160046813821829939...
- aebtebeten 4y agoAs an anglophone, I guess I should be proud that "der/das Whataboutism" is perfectly cromulent Denglish: https://www.duden.de/rechtschreibung/Whataboutism https://www.duden.de/rechtschreibung/Whataboutism What's the context for Crazy Glue, though? Is there now a political sibboleth even in the Bau und Hobby milieu?
- detaro 4y agoClimate protesters gluing themselves to things. (Who are the true terrorism menace in todays Germany according to some)
- 082349872349872 4y agoAha, I guess twitter threads follow a predictable pattern in every language.
- amai 4y ago
- itsoktocry 4y ago>death penalty by Guillotine? I find it strange when people so callously talk about ending other people's lives.
- vt85 4y ago[dead]
- whydoibother 4y ago
- archontes 4y agoWhy? What's unusual about considering applying a permanent, definite solution to a problem that one wants to both eliminate and disincentivize? I suppose I'll venture a guess: considering ending a life as a solution to a problem places a certain measurable value on the life and compares it to the value of solving the problem. Perhaps you find other peoples' valuations strange. For my part, I think that there are a few things that are valuable including people's ability to generally live their lives, but also the ability to live in a society that isn't likely to kill you on a whim. But, imo, it's pretty easy to weigh the cost of things that are threats to those very things, e.g. a murderer.
- RedditKon 4y agoIt's partially because we should always act with a degree of caution and skepticism when the government can sentence people to die for betraying the government. With a country like modern day Germany it seems easier to determine who the "good" vs "bad" guys are. But take the current situation in Iran as a counter example - there I think we'd all agree that it's decidedly less obvious that the government should have the ability to kill people who disagree.
- nautilius 4y ago