13 ms·
Beware of the perfect gentleman
- imwillofficial 4y agoI know it’s sad and scary to get death threats. But having a gay guy have a wide following of women in love with him is hilarious
- ChrisMarshallNY 4y ago> But having a gay guy have a wide following of women in love with him is hilarious Women loved Rock Hudson. I think there are a number of gay women stars that are quite popular with men. Social media is very weird. People can have entire friendships, romances, and work relationships, without meeting the other person. I had a friend whose wife left him for an online relationship. She got to the other state, met the guy (it was not a scam), and then things didn't work out. By then, however, it was too late. Best thing that could have happened to him. He's been happily married to another person for many years.
- lelanthran 4y ago> Best thing that could have happened to him. Yup. IME, the best way for a spouse to leave you is for someone else. When they have someone that they're in a hurry to settle down with, they're unlikely to argue over splitting of assets, or custody of pets, or access to children, because they want the process over as soon as possible. When they are leaving you because they are unhappy with you, then they'll argue over every single petty and trivial thing, and drag out the process for two years. Sure, it may hurt more when you find out that they've been cheating, but that will still be less painful when they take out their frustration with you using the kids visitation schedule.
- achenet 4y agono, my Dad and Mom split because Mom found out Dad had been having an affair, had gotten HIV and made a baby with another woman, and they're still fighting over small stuff, literally 19 years later. Just don't get married, ever.
- not2b 4y agoIt doesn't surprise me. Especially among men over 40, on average gay men pay much more attention to their appearance, grooming, etc. than straight men, because men whether gay or straight tend to be more visually oriented than women and looks matter to the people they want to attract. Of course like any generalization there are many exceptions to this.
- logicallee 4y agoI agree there are many exceptions and we have to be careful about generalizing. It's an interesting explanation. (That gay men pay more attention to their appearance than straight men because they want to be attractive to men rather than women, and men both gay and straight are more visually oriented than women.) This theory would predict that gay women would pay much less attention to their own appearance than straight women do (since the women they want to attract care less about looks than men do). Do you think that's the case?
- achenet 4y agommm... from what I've seen gay women (i.e. lesbians) tend to have rather noticable appearances - either rather butch/masculine, or somewhat 'freaky'. There are exceptions, where they just go for "comfy", however.
- MikePlacid 4y ago>among men over 40, on average gay men pay much more attention to their appearance, grooming, etc. than straight men Men over 40 do not need to pay any attention to their appearance, grooming etc. They just need to not wear a wedding ring. (Ask me how I know...)
- hoseja 4y agoWomen may take interest in pictures of a well-groomed gay man. But they would absolutely NOT tolerate their partner actually spend more time fussing about his appearance than them. Instant ick. Feminine behaviour.
- 4y ago
- RcouF1uZ4gsC 4y agoThings I didn't realize I should be thankful for #2,500,231: My face will never ever be used for a romance scam.
- Waterluvian 4y agoDon’t sell yourself short. Perhaps your face, like mine, can be used kind of like the intentionally implausible stories of Nigerian scams.
- autotune 4y agoMy face looks too much like Jack Black to be taken seriously enough by a potential romance scam victim.
- swivelmaster 4y agoThis is not the greatest romance scam in the world. No, this is just a tribute.
- bavell 4y agoJust a matter of opinion!
- zimpenfish 4y agoYou'd be surprised how much thirst there is for Jack Black in certain corners of the internet. Admittedly a lot to do with his apparently genial nature and general goodness but still.
- verdenti 4y ago
- pcthrowaway 4y agoSoon enough, DALL-E may be able to tweak any face to make it scam-worthy, and GPT will be able to complement it to pluck the heartstrings just so
- deleted 4y ago[deleted]
- timrice 4y agoUpsetting that in an article all about photos being used to scam people, there's not a single sample of an offending image! I mean, I think I get why. But still, it's the first thing I want to see when I read a story like this.
- toomim 4y agoYeah, I had to do a google to guess what the images might look like. https://www.google.com/search?q=James+Scott+Geras&tbm=isch https://www.google.com/search?q=James+Scott+Geras&tbm=isch
- rurp 4y agoHaha, yeah my thought process reading the article was basically: - Why aren't there any photo examples? - OK, I get why not - But still. Couldn't they find a way to add some photos?
- Balgair 4y agohttps://thispersondoesnotexist.com/ https://thispersondoesnotexist.com/ Pick a few from there?
- jxdxbx 4y agoHonestly it might be helpful for these guys to have a story about their situation in a relatively large publication. Just send it to people each time it happens. Works without pictures I guess
- maerF0x0 4y agoThe woman calling the guy her fiance is pretty sad and a total failure on her parents' behalf. You dont get engaged with or attempt to marry someone you've never met in person.
- caseyohara 4y agoThere's a good Netflix documentary about Manti Te'o, the football player who famously got catfished while he was playing at Notre Dame. It made national news when his "girlfriend" passed away. He seemed to have a good upbringing, it's wild what gullible or desperate people can get sucked into. https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Manti_Te'o#Catfishing_incident https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Manti_Te'o#Catfishing_incident Untold: The Girlfriend Who Didn't Exist https://www.netflix.com/title/81580141 https://www.netflix.com/title/81580141
- swivelmaster 4y agoI watched bits and pieces of this because my wife was into it, and it was absolutely infuriating. The catfisher went to increasingly ludicrous lengths to hide the sham, including getting their cousin to take a photo holding a piece of paper with their name or the current date or something like that. And the whole time, they KNEW they were in too deep but they couldn't help themselves. It wasn't a scam for money, it was just a multi-year cry for help.
- bryanlarsen 4y agoAccording the article Geras' profile was used to attract older divorced & widowed women, so I doubt the parents had much input.
- etchalon 4y agoHope and love make people do wacky things.
- markus_zhang 4y agoI have been constantly harrased by accounts with pretty girl pictures on LinkedIn, wish they could do something. Why did I know they are fake? One, I'm not handsome, neither do I work in those high status companies, why did they reach out to me? Two, they look more like models than software engineers. Completely bullshit.
- mbg721 4y agoThose are just the auditors; the audit firms send charismatic and attractive people around so that the people whose work they're checking will let their guard down.
- maerF0x0 4y agoAlso pen test teams will use halo effect when it's an option.
- markus_zhang 4y agoNot really, the title is usually something like a tech consultant with completely BS educational and career experience. But I do agree it could be red team but they are annoying as hell. Actually lemme show you one: https://www.linkedin.com/mwlite/in/ellie-fang-411900257 https://www.linkedin.com/mwlite/in/ellie-fang-411900257
- papercrane 4y agoThat headshot is of a Taiwanese actress. You'd think they'd at least use a more believable headshot. https://ent.ltn.com.tw/news/breakingnews/2357875 https://ent.ltn.com.tw/news/breakingnews/2357875
- 998244353 4y agoOne common explanation to such things is that it is a filter: if a person doesn't notice something like that, there's a good chance they won't become suspicious later either.
- diego_moita 4y agoFor me, the most fascinating part is about women refusing to accept they've been scammed or wanting a relationship with the men whose pictures were stolen, even though some of them are gay. It is quite similar to cult followers like QAnon. They want to believe desperately on what is comforting discarding what is reasonable. My Brazilian family of Bolsonaro supporters camping in front of barracks demanding a coup-d'etat is an example of it, similar to Republicans that believe in the Big Lie. Most people love comforting and convenient lies and don't like uncomfortable truths.
- MarcoZavala 4y ago
- rahimnathwani 4y ago"wanting a relationship with the men whose pictures were stolen" This is the plot of 'Love Hard' with Jimmy O. Yang.
- thephyber 4y agoI think you are conflating System 1 and System 2 thinking (from Kahneman's _Thinking Fast and Slow_ [1]). Frauds typically work by triggering our System 1 ("lizard brain", containing our emotions and our innate mate selection/attraction) which selectively / temporarily disables our System 2 (cognitive / rational faculties). We have words to describe the abstractions in the mind ("ego", "defense mechanism") which form filters that prevent information from passing System 1 into System 2 unless our mind is open to accepting it. The entire point of these frauds is to trigger System 1 of the victim. This article[2] was eye-opening for me in helping me understand how the brain filters information before it can reach System 2. You probably notice it when you talk to people and they reject / deflect facts that disconfirm their priors. While I agree with you about the {QAnon, The Big Lie, Bolsonaro protesters} examples, I think people (including myself) severely overestimate _our own_ ability to withstand something untrue that tickles our confirmation bias. We all have these features, only some people have better control over their System 1 filters. I'm fascinated by these topics because (1) I work in cybersecurity and (2) I have family members that fell into QAnon + The Big Lie. Learning about _Street Epistemology_[3] has been really interesting to help me better understand not only many of these belief systems, but how discussing them in selective ways can avoid the filters/defenses of System 1. [1] https://suebehaviouraldesign.com/kahneman-fast-slow-thinking/ https://suebehaviouraldesign.com/kahneman-fast-slow-thinking... [2] https://eriktorenberg.substack.com/p/truth-status-and-tribes https://eriktorenberg.substack.com/p/truth-status-and-tribes [3] https://en.wikiversity.org/wiki/Street_Epistemology https://en.wikiversity.org/wiki/Street_Epistemology
- deleted 4y ago[deleted]
- andrewflnr 4y agoSo are the scammers already using deepfakes for this, or is that still to come? A video chat is already a pretty obvious thing to do in a long distance relationship, so it will be weird if they can't do it (building an orphanage in Africa is a pretty good excuse, but it won't last forever). If it's possible, they'll definitely want to be able to deepfake video chats.
- Hnrobert42 4y agoI think it is hard to generate multiple deepfake images of the same “person”.
- m4x 4y agoNot any more - check out dreambooth. You can train a stable diffusion model to generate images of a specific person or object quite easily now. It's well within the realm of AI art enthusiasts, even those with no technical experience. https://dreambooth.github.io/ https://dreambooth.github.io/
- thephyber 4y agoYou are thinking about it all wrong. Any effort to create deep fakes would be a waste of effort for the con artists. They already know that (1) they want to avoid any type of verification attempts by the victim and (2) the relationship with each victim has a timer. The attractive picture is just a lure (like in fishing). It only matters for the initial hook. All effort after the initial contact is directed towards building a story/narrative of the profile and latching onto the victim's emotions. Deepfakes aren't needed. Until the con saturates the supply of victims, these cons don't need to evolve.
- layman51 4y agoI think about what I would do if I were in the situation of these men. If possible, I wouldn't engage with scam victims at all. This sounds impossible though because there are those situations where your workplace security team or relatives get involved. The scary thing is how this scam can happen anywhere there is a chat function, such as Words With Friends.
- prawn 4y agoOne argument for engaging with them is that you are more likely to get some warning of a threat or head off a threat if someone sounded serious about showing up at your door.
- deleted 4y ago[deleted]
- deleted 4y ago[deleted]
- rkagerer 4y agoWhen I was growing up you never posted your photo online where strangers could see it. Earlier than that, it was also considered proper etiquette to ask before taking someone's photo. There's been a huge culture shift and some of the outcomes are disheartening but quite predictable. ...little recourse other than to continuously report fake profiles across social media platforms If they don't take down your fraudulent likeness or their efforts toward that end are a joke, hire a lawyer and put them in touch with the owners of the site.
- jack_pp 4y agoConsidering how good face recognition is these days it would be nice to have legislation in place that you have to give explicit consent to any website in order to use your image. Govt can crawl the web and block websites from the countries ISP that don't comply. Hard to see another automated solution for this problem
- iLoveOncall 4y agoIndeed, that would surely stop Nigerian thiefs from using your photos. Impervious strategy.
- jack_pp 4y agoUse them for what?
- iLoveOncall 4y agoExactly what the article is about?
- filoleg 4y agoYeah, I am disheartened by some comments in this thread as well. Sure, let's implement these laws that essentially will be used for stiffening art, at least all these scammers (who already do illegal things) will start following the law, and these romance scams will stop /s. This is like the gun control debate, but much worse. At least with gun control, it has strong ties to geographic boundaries, given that guns are physical objects, so I can see some decent arguments for why it (at least hypothetically) could work (e.g., Australia). But with photos posted online, the locale is global internet, where everything is instantly reachable and replicable with pretty much zero marginal cost, from anywhere in the world. These proposals are imo peak idealism without much pragmatic thought applied at all. Mind you, I am not saying "let's do nothing, things are all good." But some of the proposed "fixes" to this I've seen here are truly useless at best and harmful at worst.
- DoreenMichele 4y agoMy mind is blown. Even when the ruse is revealed, many victims are unwilling to let go. The truth triggers an emotional whiplash—the promise of a soulmate, a new, fulfilling life, and mutual trust is suddenly lost, leaving the intense feelings of love behind. Once found, the real man in the photos becomes a surrogate for the fantasy. “Some of them would reach out to me and [say], ‘Now that I know what the real person is like, are you still single?’” Victor said. “‘Can I meet you? Can I FaceTime you?’” SMH. Time to retire Cinderella and similar stories.
- MikePlacid 4y ago>“‘Can I meet you? Can I FaceTime you?’” also >even after he convinced them that they had been scammed, they sometimes wanted to strike up a friendship with him. “I can’t even tell you. I would spend an hour on the phone sometimes talking to these women So: "Sure. Here's my 900 number".
- quickthrower2 4y agoIn a similar vein to how it is now normal to give personal pronouns, even if you are he/she, we should normalise opsec when online dating, even if you feel it is not needed: if everyone mentions “can I check you are not a scammer and goes through a verification call”, and it is normal it wont be seen as rude or breaking the romance”. Same should be done for a lot of interactions, such as hiring, employee to employee requests involving money, bank accounts or authorisation, and so on. With deep fakes and AI scamming will get more and more sophisticated and at scale.
- MikePlacid 4y ago> it is now normal to give personal pronouns, even if you are he/she Eagerly waiting for this “new normal” to come to Russia. You see, we have 6 forms of each pronoun. Mine’s are: “он / его / ему / его / им / нём”. Please, remember and use each one correctly. Like: You blame его. But: you are speaking about нём. Not a single mistake, please.
- robocat 4y agoAs a tech guy, I would write some web pages with my image and textual explanations of the scam, then SEO optimise them for reverse image search. Hypothetically, of course, since I will never need to do it for myself as I am definitely not handsome enough. I wonder why the guys didn't want their faces in the article? That way any reverse image lookup could find the story, the victims would know without getting in touch with the guys, and the scammers would move on to other guys' faces. That would solve the problem for those guys at least!
- koonsolo 4y agoMost people don't even know that reverse image search exists.
- kuhewa 4y agoPresumably all the women contacting the photo guys in the article are aware of it. The real issue is that the women aren't going to believe it if it doesn't link to a social media profile or similar, or if they don't talk to the person, and the scammer would easily explain the website away if they were aware of it.
- thephyber 4y ago> Presumably all the women contacting the photo guys in the article are aware of it. Point of clarification: in most instances, it's not the victim that does the reverse image search, but some friend/family member who is trying to assist the victim after the fraud has already happened.
- saagarjha 4y agoThe article explains that the women often have a hard time letting go after realizing they’ve been scammed.
- thephyber 4y ago> I wonder why the guys didn't want their faces in the article? These guys get frequent death threats. It's reliving trauma. > That would solve the problem for those guys at least! That's how therapy is supposed to work. You just asked "why don't people just face their fears in therapy RIGHT NOW and get it over with?" The answer is "because people have emotions". Sadly, emotions are also the reason these fraud schemes work.
- shawn-butler 4y agoFrom a technical perspective why isn't this a solved problem? Identity will always be a difficult problem, but being able to own your own face / likeness by demonstrating it should be technically possible right? Forced visual "captchas" something like "please take a photo standing on one foot and your finger pointed at your nose" Then once you own your likeness with "faceID" likeness similarity isn't it then easy to monitor the images uploaded to the profile or am I completely missing something?
- pugworthy 4y agoI think there are some privacy issues here you're not addressing. Like exactly who gets to be the authority on face ID? What if it gets leaked or hacked? Not to mention the near future triviality of image generating AI being able to just recreate what you're asking it for a "capchat". I mean once it figures out hands that is.
- superhuzza 4y agoBecause this isn't inherently a technological problem, it's a loneliness and emotional vulnerability problem. I guarantee you that scammers will find ways to convince their victims regardless of photos being verified or not.
- acdha 4y agoIt’s a question of cost. Facebook has a billion users, if they can save $0.10 per user someone just got a promotion. Here’s a related question: every day, people lose access to their Google or Facebook accounts. This could easily be solved with some process where they could get a third party (librarian, notary, police or DMV, etc.) to do an ID check. Nobody does this because the cost would be greater than zero.
- ryandrake 4y ago> “‘You shouldn’t have anything on social media. People are using your pictures.’ And I’m like, ‘Excuse me. I’m not gonna move to a deserted island or live my life as a monk. That’s just not gonna happen.’” Not posting pictures of yourself online seems to be a pretty reasonable, sensible preventative measure for anyone. I don’t (to my knowledge) have pictures of myself floating around social media, and I don’t consider myself to be “living my life as a monk.”
- quickthrower2 4y agoNot really since anyone else can post a picture of you. Work dos, nights out, even incidental picture of you in someone elses tourist photo. Maybe you wont be mentioned by name in the photo but maybe you will.
- kuhewa 4y agoI don't reckon the intended meaning is that it is literally impossible, but that it is an unfair and likely ineffective way to prevent romance scamming. His visage is used because they have already farmed the pictures, probably because there were quite a few available so enough to titrate them out over several weeks. So it doesn't really make sense that he now has the duty to remove his online presence, which is important to many people's expression of themselves. In fact, the ability to find him online probably has ended a number of these scams and prevented the women from losing even more money.
- nonameiguess 4y agoOther than for a new driver's license and a passport, I haven't even taken a picture of myself since 2014. I do some fantasy cosplay, though, so have had pictures taken of me from that, though I'm not sure many would recognize me.
- jxdxbx 4y agoI find it so much more sad when people fall in love and get their hearts broken, than some dude who is scammed just looking for sex.
- tasuki 4y agoI find it curious that people fall in love with a person they'd never met.
- rendall 4y agoI've always got scammers trying to get to me on Twitter. Once, I went down the road a bit to see what would happen. So, so boring. No conversational skill, no chemistry, just whoever happened to be working the shift at the time. I did wonder if the girl in the pictures was associated with the gang somehow, or just a random victim, as in the article.
- RickJWagner 4y agoOf interest: "The male voice, tinged with a Southern-sounding accent, stopped him cold: I’m going to slit your throat." What would you think if Vice had written: "The male voice, tinged with a Black-sounding accent...." "The male voice, tinged with an Asian-sounding accent...." "The male voice, tinged with an Italian-sounding accent...." Why of course you'd think "That publication is hate mongering! They're trying to subtly guide the reader to bad thoughts about their target!" Which is exactly true.
- BlargMcLarg 4y ago"Remember kids, discrimination is wrong, unless X" ~ practically every society in history believing they can determine X and would scoff at both their ancestors and predecessors. Vice just having a little slip of the tongue and showing what's really up.
- NackerHughes 4y agoInteresting and telling indeed. A southern US accent is acceptable to portray as threatening (or unintelligent or otherwise villainous). I would say the Russian accent is similarly A-OK to use for such prejudice. Racial stereotyping is exempt from being considered hate speech, it seems, when the target is the Bad People™.
- coorski 4y agobeware of vices