6 ms·
This is the exact type of question that tricks those with more nuanced knowledge but doesn't trick those that memorize textbook answers. I'm not sure we should
by godelski 4y ago
This is the exact type of question that tricks those with more nuanced knowledge but doesn't trick those that memorize textbook answers. I'm not sure we should be encouraging this type of learning, despite it being how a lot of standardized testing questions work.
- wppick 4y agoActually, that sounds like it's working as intended
- mcrad 4y ago
- throwawaysleep 4y agoI would say it is a utter failure of a question if an expert in the topic is perplexed by the answer and there is (presumably) a supposedly correct answer. Knowledge is punished? Don’t ever learn beyond the book? That’s outrageous.
- gregmac 4y agoI wonder how this type of question even gets written. Does the author purposely put in these "gotcha" questions to see if you read the textbook? Or are they literally unaware of how bad the question is written - ie: their knowledge is limited to the point they don't see the nuance or unambiguity?
- gjadi 4y agoI used to fully agree with that feeling but not anymore. IMO they are two kinds of tests: 1. Tests to help you retain information. 2. Tests to evaluate your knowledge. Assuming this question belongs to the first kind (memorization) and the answer is in a textbook being studied, then this is a good question.
- jolmg 4y agoSo, a good question for a bad kind of test? Why shouldn't all tests be type 2?
- gjadi 4y agoTests are one of the best technique to retain knowledge. It's called active learning, as opposed to passive learning. Space Time Repetition systems such as Anki or Mnemosyne or SuperMemo are based on 2 concepts: (1) knowledge fades overtime unless reactivated and (2) asking questions is very effective to activate knowledge
- jolmg 4y agoAnd type 2 tests don't achieve that? Remember, we're talking about the benefit of questions that encourage the ignoring of nuance.
- gjadi 4y agoThey can but: - it's more time-consuming to create good evaluation questions. - it's more time-consuming to provide a nuanced answer. - it's more time-consuming to evaluate nuanced answers. If the purpose of the tests is to help students retain the knowledge they've been recently exposed to, then the first kind of tests are more effective. That is, the teacher will be able to provide students with more tests, thus helping them retain more in a shorter amount of time for everyone. It's a compromise.
- jolmg 4y agoOk, you're thinking type 1 vs type 2 is multiple choice vs written answers. I'm thinking type 2 can have multiple choice, but then there's only 1 answer that can be correct. Type 1 can have multiple choice, but puts multiple correct answers and expects you to pick the one that is most directly covered in the class, marking the other correct answers incorrect. That, to me, is testing information retention without nuanced knowledge.