3 ms·
Distributions of human skill that we can measure tend to be on long-tailed power scale distributions. Chess is one of the most obvious examples of this. Chess w
by somenameforme 4y ago
Distributions of human skill that we can measure tend to be on long-tailed power scale distributions. Chess is one of the most obvious examples of this. Chess world champions tend to be just dramatically better than the 2nd best players in the world. One early 20th century world champion (Emanuel Lasker) retained (and actively defended) his title for 27 years! And he was also a research mathematician (who made some significant discoveries) and more 'on the side'.
And while that exact stretch remains unbroken, similar levels of dominance in the game are typical. Kasparov was world champion for 15 years. And in current times Magnus Carlsen has been world champion for about a decade, and #1 in the world (by a wide margin) for years beyond that.
On things we can't measure, one can observe facts like the open problem that Einstein would go on to solve (in his twenties, while working at a patent office) was being dug into by countless brilliant minds, to no avail, since Einstein was 8 years old! And his work after that point makes it clear it wasn't just a freak coincidence.
---
I definitely do think there are plenty who are "that much" smarter than average, but I don't think they need to be paid to succeed. Nor do I think one having an official affirmation that he is a "genius" is conducive to clear-headedness. It naturally drives a sense of entitlement, and can be detrimental to actually putting in the work necessary to make things happen. All the potential in the world is irrelevant without a corresponding work ethic.
- denton-scratch 4y agoChess is an interesting example. I learned to play chess as a kid. I never got even slightly good; people that were dimmer than me could beat me easily. But how many chess grandmasters are also fabulously wealthy CEOs? They tend to stay chess-players. I'm curious about what skill in chess consists of. It seems to correspond to general cognitive capacity; but that's certainly not all of it.
- somenameforme 4y agoPeople aspire to different things. It's difficult to explain if you've never really gotten seriously into chess, but the game is, by far, one of the most satisfying and rewarding activities in existence. You can put infinite mental energy into the game and continue to get ever more out of it. It is extremely addictive, especially once one reaches a certain level in the game. If I had the choice of retiring to a life endless beaches and scantily clad ladies delivering me all the drinks and pleasures of life one could imagine, or retiring to a [safe] ghetto full of nothing but old highly skilled chess players - I would pick #2 in a heart beat. There are plenty of chess player anecdotes along the lines of Gata Kamsky. He became frustrated with his progress in chess at some point (as one of the best in the world, but not the best in the world) and just casually decided to become a lawyer. So he did that and breezed through law school and set himself to a traditional path of money and even power. But, as is always the end of these stories, the game called him back. Today he streams himself playing chess for hours a day (on Twitch) to an audience of tens and is clearly more content and satisfied than ever.
- denton-scratch 4y ago> long-tailed power scale Yeah, but a power scale implies that there are outliers at any distance from the median. That can't be true, so the model is defective.
- somenameforme 4y agoExcept it is true! That is precisely what I was getting at with chess. Right now the #1 player in the world is rated 48 points higher than the #2 player, and this difference is typical and often even more extreme. And the #2 is rated almost 20 points higher than the #3 player! I could try to explain what those numbers mean mathematically, but I think there's an even easier way to get the gist of it. There are hundreds of of thousands of FIDE rated players. That #1 player's rating is 2859. For him to be 50 points higher than the #2 player is insane in terms of any notion of broad-level approximate human equality, but perfectly normal in the not-even-remotely-equal reality of what we see in chess. And this is mirrored everywhere, even in sports where the physical limitations on the body are presumably more limiting than the cognitive ones. Running is nice because it's a field where we are going to miss close to 0 outliers, and you can fairly compare generations regardless of time. Imagine we take Usain Bolt at his peak, and have him run a 200m race against the 200th fastest human to have ever lived at his peak. People might expect this to be a pretty close race. In reality? He'd finish about 9.8 meters, more than 32 feet ahead of the other guy. It would look like 'fast' guy vs 'meh, more or less average' guy. When in reality that 'more or less average' guy is one of the fastest humans to have ever lived!
- denton-scratch 4y agoA true power law would say that there's a diminishing number of chess-players the further out you go along the long tail. But in practice, there are zero chess-players better than the world champion. It may look like a power law within some window, but power laws don't have a cutoff point. That is what I'm saying about smart people; I don't accept that there are people arbitrarily smarter than the average. My guess is that the cutoff is somewhere around double the average (modulo your method for measuring smartness).
- lordnacho 4y agoBut none of those examples gives a reason why it had to be that particular person. Someone is gonna be the first person to solve an unsolved problem, or the new best chess player. It might well be that longevity comes from reaching the top?
- somenameforme 4y agoThe point with chess is to illustrate that relative ability follows a power law. If humanity was relatively normally distributed then of course there'd still be a top, but people in this top would all be roughly equal. And so, like you're implicitly stating, any sort of achievement would largely come down to throwing darts and seeing who, largely by chance, ends up being the first to hit the bullseye. But in reality the top is not approximately equal. In chess there are hundreds of thousands of rated players. The #1 player is rated 50 points higher than the #2 player. The #1 player is rated 2859. Think about the implications of those three facts! And this is likely precisely the case with Einstein, and also the reason for his success. Back to current times/domain I'd also argue this is why having exponentially more scientists than ever before has not really led to what somebody who assumed a normal distribution would expect to see.
- lordnacho 4y agoThe examples illustrate that relative outcomes seem to follow that kind of law. How do we know that the outcomes are strongly tied to some sort of potential, and not just self-perpetuating? You get picked for the team because you're a little bit better than number 2, you feel motivated, you get more training... down the road you are a lot better. Sports especially is filled with these kinds of stories.
- somenameforme 4y agoIn general it's pretty difficult to prove a negative. How do you know you don't have a friendly little goblin named Rakinichu, made of dark matter, floating just above your shoulder? You can't really prove that you don't, so the onus is on me to prove that you do. That said, in this specific case, I think there's even reasonably strong evidence against your hypothesis. For instance Einstein's "miracle year" would come while he was working as a low level inspector at a patent office. And he was working there because he applied to numerous universities, but none were interested in taking him on board! Even in the chess world, "prodigies" are a dime a dozen and Magnus was a relatively late bloomer among his peers. Magnus received his International Master title (the second highest title in chess, prior to Grandmaster) at a later age than Sergey Karjakin, a fellow prodigy, received his Grandmaster title. He also achieved victory coming from a country that had relatively little chess culture. Grandmasters coming from countries with greater chess culture would have had access to greater resources, minds, coaching, and opportunities.