4 ms·
For sheep and pigs surely you can just run a farm and do experiments on them just before they're due to be slaughtered. Then only vegetarians can complain! Sha
by IshKebab 4y ago
For sheep and pigs surely you can just run a farm and do experiments on them just before they're due to be slaughtered. Then only vegetarians can complain!
Shame about the monkeys though.
- chunkyslink 4y agoThe quality of comments on this site has gone down recently. Prime example.
- IshKebab 4y agoThat's not very nice. Your comment isn't exactly filled with original insight either is it?
- kayodelycaon 4y agoActually, you can’t do this. Negligence is one thing. Deliberately torturing animals, even if they are used for food, is illegal. Scientific animal research has guidelines to minimize suffering as much as possible. The government treats this as a necessary evil. If you’re attempting to do this in good faith, it’s only morally wrong. Many companies make illegal activity a corporate policy, but that doesn’t make them immune from prosecution if someone decides they have stepped too far over the line.
- sixQuarks 4y agoWhere in the article did it say NeuroLink was deliberately torturing the animals? In fact, the article said that the animals are killed after research in order to do post mortem examinations. This is standard across many animal testing labs.
- SketchySeaBeast 4y agoThey don't seem to be DELIBERATELY torturing them, but there seems to be a lot of easily predictable negligence going on.
- discordance 4y agoI would feel tortured if a team of people were to purposefully drill a hole in my head and install a device into my brain to see how I responded. Seems deliberate enough?
- SketchySeaBeast 4y agoThis is how we could describe any procedures in this area of medicine, so the intentions seem to meet the criteria for calling it a test and not torture, but the sloppiness is the extra cruelty on top.
- iancmceachern 4y agoIt is deliberate when they had the time, money and expertise to do better but chose not to do better.
- SketchySeaBeast 4y agoGood point.
- iancmceachern 4y agoThere are other articles describing horrific incidents: "In two separate incidents, experimenters used an unapproved adhesive called BioGlue to fill holes in the animals’ skulls, which seeped through to the monkeys’ brains. In one monkey, the use of BioGlue caused bleeding in her brain, and she vomited so much from the resulting side effects that she developed open sores in her esophagus." https://www.businesswire.com/news/home/20220926005606/en/Physicians-Committee%E2%80%99s-Lawsuit-Against-Elon-Musk-Company-Neuralink-Reveals-Existence-of-Hundreds-of-Photos-of-Monkeys-Used-in-Painful-Experiments https://www.businesswire.com/news/home/20220926005606/en/Phy...
- noptd 4y agoTwo mistakes != Torture. You're obviously not arguing in good faith here.
- iancmceachern 4y agoIt's not two mistakes. It's two cases of torture. Just because it's only two doesn't mean it wasn't torture. It's not like they discovered the mistake and then immediately euthanized the animals, they chose to continue the experiments and torture them after the mistakes were evident.
- zozbot234 4y agoYou have to put the critters to sleep with anestethic drugs in order to "experiment" on them, since the experiments involve surgery. I very much doubt that such animals can safely enter the human food supply.
- iancmceachern 4y agoCorrect, they can't enter the food supply by law.
- ckemere 4y agoNot sure why you were down voted. This is a valid question. The challenge is that anesthesia gas and analgesia drugs may contaminate the meat, and most research orgs are understandably terrified of further liability given the already intense pressure on them. (As seen by the Reuters piece, which is clearly a hit job.)
- iancmceachern 4y agoNot true. In this context there is no meat. No one sells these animals as meat, it's illegal. These animals are being sacrificed to test new medical devices, drugs and procedures. We use anesthesia gas and drugs on people when we use these devices, so we need to use it for the animal tests also. Every single animal case I've been a part of utilized human quality anesthesia, including having a real anesthesiologist present doing it. This comment is way off, shows a deep lack of understanding of the process.
- rideontime 4y agoMuch respect to you for bringing relevant knowledge and experience to this discussion
- ckemere 4y agoThe purpose of my comment was to point out that no one, AFAIK, has actually attempted to outgas the meat or evaluate whether buprenorphine survives cooking. And it is wasteful, in the sense that if they don't need to do cardiac perfusion of formaldehyde, the meat part of the pig might well still be edible once the brain has been removed. (edit) And I should point out that when I started in the field, we used to donate euthanized rodents to the zoo for snake food, but somehow that now became not-a-thing, despite the fact that there are humane/approved ways of doing euthanasia that minimize distress while still not requiring anesthesia. (This is how the reptile food industry operates!)
- iancmceachern 4y agoNot really. They really work to get the most out of each animals sacrifice. So one day it may be used for a cardiac procedure, the next day some kind of skin drug test, the next day some kind of cardiac drug, etc. So it's not like they use one tiny part of an animal then throw it away. They use the whole animal to get clinical benefit. It's the same with cadavers. They cut them up and use only the part they need to do the work. It's far less wasteful that way.