6 ms·
Eric Schmidt: We Don't Talk About Occupy Wall Street In The Valley
- timjahn 15y agoA prime example of the bubble the Valley is and how disconnected that can cause people living there to get from the reality of those that don't. Writing a post on this idea soon coincidentally.
- sigzero 15y agoOr they realize that "Occupy" is ineffective and has lost their "focus". Nobody where I work talks about it either.
- _delirium 15y agoSchmidt's comment doesn't seem to be attacking their effectiveness, though; he seems to instead be arguing that there's no problem in the first place, because the economy is doing great, everyone is hiring, etc. Which, as the article notes, is only true in a very specific segment of the economy. Schmidt presumably just doesn't talk to anyone outside of that bubble.
- marshallp 15y agoThere's a also a hidden message - why don't the legions of unemployed/underpaid go into tech? Or why don't occupy wall street people join the 1 percent, ie. get trained in finance/tech and compete in that sphere, take some of the rich folks money from them.
- _delirium 15y agoI don't think people are equally good at all things. I mean, I'm good at tech, but I'm not that good at music. If suddenly violinists were the hot commodity, I'm not sure I could transition. I'd probably just keep doing tech for lower pay. Similarly, if writing well became a big thing in 10 years, I'm not sure what percentage of Google engineers could successfully transition. Not sure why we'd expect the other direction to be more doable. Google in particular I think goes out of their way to only hire people who are really techies through-and-through. As for the latter point, I think the perception is that the 1% overall is about old-boys' networks, scamming, crony capitalism, corporate/government entanglement, and general under-the-table sort of business. Nobody wants to go into that; they want it gone.
- marshallp 15y agoI keep hearing that - most people won't have the intelligence to do tech/finance etc. However, a recent datapoint, the stanford ai class had over 1000 brilliant students, but only a handful in class at stanford itself. Watch the recent video chat sebastian thrun, peter norvig, and salman khan had on this topic. Also, you could go back in history and say the same thing. 200 years ago most be people were "unintelligent" illiterate farmers, and yet today there descendents are literate, many doing highly intelligent work. The implied "genetic potential" arguments on intelligence are all wrong i believe, though i have no data to back it up. Relative differences matter of course - there can only be one chess world champion - but most of tech or even finance is not in that winner-take-all space yet.
- xiaoma 15y ago200 years ago most be people were "unintelligent" illiterate farmers, and yet today there descendents are literate, many doing highly intelligent work. The parent commenter was speaking about making a transition in one's own career. Like him, I have doubts about my ability to become a top-notch violinist, especially since you have to find the tone centers by ear for that instrument. I don't know of anybody ever developing perfect pitch as an adult. Similarly, I doubt my grandmother, who even now is an extremely talented cellist with perfect pitch, could ever become a good programmer. However, her son did become an excellent programmer, I am confident that my own children could become excellent programmers, musicians, visual artists or speakers of any language... if they start as children or adolescents. Yes people can change an learn... but drastic changes rarely happen after a certain age.
- andrewflnr 15y agoIt's not about intelligence as much as the kind of intelligence you have. I don't really consider myself a stupid person, but I don't know if I could go into, say, finance, even finance-related programming. I particularly doubt I could do a decent job and stay sane.
- kls 15y agoRight, we actually had that problem in the .com boom where a guy with a month of Flash training was commanding 100k, the problem was when it popped those guys did not just flush out of the industry in a few months and managers are notoriously bad at spotting talent. It lead to some tough times for many developers while the market corrected. Eventually those 1 month Flash in the pans got their real estate licenses and moved on, but not until it dealt some real damage to the industry. One of which was it gutted the CS programs which has created some of the supply deficiencies we see now.
- sriramk 15y agoI don't think Schmidt is saying that. I think he's saying there's a specific section of tech where there are different economic conditions at play - he seems perfectly well aware of how the rest of the world is. And I agree with him. Talk to any startup about how hard it is to hire people and the insane sign-on bonuses/perks/referral bonuses some folks are having to resort to. Or look at the number of LinkedIn messages most people on HN probably get. It's a very small part of the 'big picture' but it definitely exists here in the SF Bay Area.
- matwood 15y agohe seems to instead be arguing that there's no problem in the first place, because the economy is doing great, everyone is hiring, etc He doesn't seem to say that at all. In the article he recognizes that he and SV are in a bubble. He points out that the OWS reality is not his reality. In fact anyone who is good in tech has a completely different reality than OWS. It's not just SV where finding good people is hard.
- redthrowaway 15y agoExactly. I'm broadly supportive of Occupy, but couldn't bring myself to support the Vancouver branch. The only people hurting here are the perennial hurters; the only ones protesting are the rent-a-crowds who show up at every protest. We never had a housing crunch, or an employment crunch. It's still a great place to live and work, so the rank and file simply don't think about the issues that concern OWS. I recognize the serious issues they are fighting against globally, but locally they just don't exist. Note that I'm saying "exactly" to the problems being localized, not that they don't exist.
- throwaway88 15y agoIt never had focus. Poor people whining about how life isn't fair.
- SwellJoe 15y agoI left the valley two years ago specifically because I was losing my sense of perspective; there is a culture and mindset that is found nowhere else in the world. Overall, it's probably a good thing; and I'd go back there if I needed to start a tech company from scratch again. But, it also leads to a very limited worldview, and I think it's risky even for startup founders to buy too heavily into the reality distortion one finds in the valley. The number of people who are making clones (with slight differences) of companies no one outside of the valley has ever heard of just blows my mind. Sometimes I'd meet two or three people at one party working on the same stupid idea in different startups. It's too easy to lose connection with your customers when you spend so much time in an echo chamber.
- redwood 15y agoAs a native, I couldn't agree more. I've witnessed a transition from heavy hardware-based long-haul investment thinking to short-term low risk internet investment. Sure this is totally logical, but the hive mind of VCs who follow every buzz word (social -> big data, etc) is pathetic. These VCs should be the most creative, ahead of the curve investers in the world. Instead they're more often followers excited to be on the cutting edge, but too risk-averse to invest in anything meaningful. It's like another iteration of the quarterly-oriented corporate mindset. Sad. All the hardware is moving to East Asia...
- deleted 15y ago[deleted]
- amcintyre 15y agoI recently talked to an IT engineer at a mid-size financial services company downtown, and he complained that his budget is being slashed every year, as he's expected to do more with less. He's over 40 and sees no chance of getting hired at one of these sexy startups run by 20-somethings and funded by VCs who are younger than him. That seems like an odd "complaint," since, if you go work for one of those startups, you're going to be expected to do even more with even less. And that will probably be the case whether it's a sexy or boring startup, run by 20-somethings or 40-somethings.
- Jach 15y agoBesides the weird age comment, I also thought it odd how an "IT engineer" (is that what guys in the IT support business are calling themselves these days?) is trotted out as a member of the "tech industry" whose life isn't joy and might identify with the OWS people. (Personally I consider the "tech industry" to be tech companies and their most important employees, aka smart CEOs, programmers, good designers, engineers, and inventors (sure I'm leaving some out). (Sometimes all being one person.)) The startup I'm at doesn't need "IT engineers", it needs "designgineers" just like almost everyone else. Cisco laid off some thousands of people, but who were those people? Turns out mostly management. And according to the linked article about a third of them still got an early retirement. So in general I agree with the article's main point that it's a profession bubble, not a geographical bubble, but I thought the attempts at saying "but you don't even really have a bubble from these complaints, because of layoff counts and this guy I talked to!" pretty weak.
- oelewapperke 15y agoThe point they allude to is that the bubble is only accessible for a narrow subculture even inside IT. Specifically, it's not accessible to the biggest cohort of the IT workforce : the people who keep things running at huge companies call center employees/admins/weak programmers. There's a huge lot of those. I agree in the valley they've become kind of rare, most of them moved out. But that did not happen voluntarily.
- alabut 15y agoWalt Disney had the same attitude during the 30's. I'm reading his bio (it's crazy how similar he was to Steve Jobs) and he's been quoted as saying the Depression was the best thing that ever happened to their studio because not only did the revenues of their cartoons keep going up (unlike the rest of the industry) but also they were able to scoop up tons of talent that hit rough times at other studios. Disney's studio did great work during this time and even made a hit song that became an anthem for the Depression, "Who's Afraid Of The Big Bad Wolf".
- gcb 15y agoSo we should see lots of brains from goldsachs going to google?
- redthrowaway 15y agoOnly if goldsachs were hurt by the damage they caused.
- forensic 15y agoGS is doing better than ever.
- Shenglong 15y agoThat's a bit of an overstatement. Their stock price, at least, has taken a big hit.
- yanw 15y ago"We don't talk about OWS in the valley " != "OWS isn't really something that comes up in daily discussion (in the valley)" Spare yourselves SF Gate's pontifications and read the source: http://www.businessweek.com/magazine/its-always-sunny-in-silicon-valley-12222011.html http://www.businessweek.com/magazine/its-always-sunny-in-sil... Quoted in 3rd paragraph: In Silicon Valley, all the Sturm und Drang of 2011 seemed as relevant as the Cricket World Cup. High unemployment? Crippling debt? Not in Silicon Valley, where the fog burns off by noon and it’s an article of faith that talented, hard-working techies can change the world and reap unimaginable wealth in the process. “We live in a bubble, and I don’t mean a tech bubble or a valuation bubble. I mean a bubble as in our own little world,” says Google Chairman Eric Schmidt. “And what a world it is: Companies can’t hire people fast enough. Young people can work hard and make a fortune. Homes hold their value. Occupy Wall Street isn’t really something that comes up in daily discussion, because their issues are not our daily reality.”
- zem 15y agoI do not see how the extended source quote in any way contradicts the point sfgate was making, which is that the valley schmidt is talking about has no connection with the valley they see around them.
- maaku 15y agoWhich, I might add, is a very true point. The tech startup scene is very small and incestuous subculture of the SF bay area--and I say this as a 3rd generation resident (my grandparents settled here after WW2 when the land between Cupertino and Santa Clara was mostly orchards). Growing up in Santa Clara Valley, back when it had that name, my friends parents all worked for the government, in manufacturing, education, (non-tech) sales, etc. There were a few engineers of course, but they mostly worked for large firms founded a generation prior. Tech startups are back in fashion and the business is good--but only for a small, tiny little segment of this valley's population. He's right to call it a (reality-distorting) bubble, but he's wrong to generalize it to the greater geographic region.
- jdthomas 15y ago> You can get a five bedroom, three-bathroom house in the southernmost part of San Jose for less than $500,000 -- about one-third the price it would cost in Mountain View. Seems like by considering a 500k house inexpensive reinforces the point that we are in a 'bubble' in Silicon Valley.
- taskstrike 15y agoJesus, they don't even build houses that big in a lot of neighborhoods.
- geogra4 15y agoYou can get a 5/3 for 1/10 of that price (literally just saw one listed for 65k) in Pittsburgh. And Pittsburgh was one of the few places not hit that hard by the real estate downturn.
- count 15y agoIn the same 'quality' of neighborhood? You can get a 5/3 for $39k in Charleston, SC in the middle of the ghetto.
- geogra4 15y agoNot the ghetto, just a normal neighborhood. A bit dicier than your typical picket-fenced suburb but that really just comes with living in the midst of the great recession.
- paganel 15y agoAs a guy who lives in a 7x5m studio somewhere in Eastern Europ, in a building like this one http://farm4.staticflickr.com/3152/3082829290_9653703b1e_b.jpg http://farm4.staticflickr.com/3152/3082829290_9653703b1e_b.j..., I try and try again to find out why would you need three bathrooms and five bedrooms, but I really cannot think of any reasons.
- xyzzyz 15y ago
- justin_vanw 15y agoI find this comment to be more or less true. Where I work we cannot find enough qualified people to hire, and we are hiring as fast as we can. These are very highly paying jobs. Also, to hell with occupy wall-street. Banks may not be looking out for 'the little guy', but since when are we surprised by that? What do these protestors want exactly? For bigwigs to go to jail for causing all their personal problems? I can't help but think that these same people weren't exactly great success stories before the financial meltdown, and would be barely scraping by if things were great. To be supplied with an income to reward them for years spent putting no effort into gaining useful skills? Bah, I say let them eat cake. If they can't be bothered to learn how to do anything that is worth paying them to do (despite years of free educational opportunities, heavily subsidized community colleges, etc), and they can't be bothered to take their future into their own hands and start a business, then I simply cannot be bothered with them.
- forensic 15y agoDoes your opinion apply to children born into poverty? Kids whose parents can't afford healthy food for them so their brains don't develop? Kids who are unable to get educated because their schools are corrupt and 90% of the high school students graduate illiterate? People who were abused as kids and so have mental illnesses and live on the street because they can't hold a job? People who had their health insurance scam them and had to go $100,000 into debt to pay doctors? Kids who were brainwashed from birth by parents, teachers, media that they no matter what the expense they must go to university, and now find themselves 22 years old and $100,000 in debt with nothing to show for it? You live in an extremely exploitative society where the powerful coast while the vulnerable drown. The majority of the sufferers are people who were born into their situation. They are chronically ill from lack of access to healthcare and quality food. They are mentally ill from being abused and discarded and having nowhere to turn. They are in financial ruin by following the mainstream, standard advice regarding mortgages, investing, and education. If you were King of America, what would you do with all the destitute? You're right - there were already tons of miserable pre-2008. I just want to know what your plan for the unwashed, stupid, suffering masses is. Because it sounds like you're saying we should just let them wallow in their misery and watch as more cities crumble like Detroit. When you tell mentally ill homeless addicts to "use their bootstraps" you're really just advocating for the growth of the vast American ghettos that are already the shame of the nation.
- sathishmanohar 15y agoBecause he is one in 1%
- qdog 15y agoWhen he says they live in a 'bubble', he literally means they(or we) live in a bubble isolated from issues. I'm sympathetic to OWS, but on the other hand, I come here and worry if my salary (which is X% greater than the average American's) is too low, because people on HN are making Y% more than me(or at least claiming to). However, I'm not in the 1%. It's a little hard to fathom, but there are a handful of people at GOOG in the 1%, but we tend to act more like we(tech people, I don't work at GOOG) are the 1% than the 99%. I don't know if Schmidt is point out the divide, or oblivious. I'm hoping for the former.
- Jach 15y agoEven if some of us aren't in the 1%, there's nevertheless this desire to get there and instead of just wishing for millions of dollars people here are actively working on earning those millions. Some of us aren't in the 1%, but a lot of us are soon-to-be or trying-to-be there. As Schmidt put it, "Young people can work hard and make a fortune." (And the 1% cutoff point is only around $300k per year; the critical issues affecting the 99% are mostly affecting the 85% below $100k.)
- SeoxyS 15y agoThe rate is even higher in Contra Costa County, where Oakland is. So Oakland is in Contra Costa County now? I expected better better from SFGate. It's Alameda County, fwiw. And speaking of Oakland -- what about those Occupy riots in Oakland anyway? Those were a mere 45 minutes from Google's Mountain View campus. Even on the freeway with no traffic, it takes at least 90min to do Oakland–Silicon Valley. This article is a prime example of really bad reporting.
- bentlegen 15y agoGoogle Maps disagrees (with the travel time): http://bit.ly/ud1nZpz http://bit.ly/ud1nZpz
- rdl 15y agoI do downtown Oakland to Mountain View in 45-70 minutes, depending on traffic. It's bad, especially at rush hour (or during any unpredictable traffic delay), and moving to MV is one of my goals for 2012. However, if you don't have to go to the office every day, and if you sometimes go to SF instead, it's possible to buy a 1BR/1BA condo in downtown Oakland for about $100k. Just don't count on using any city services (schools, Oakland PD, hospitals), or going anywhere worthwhile (other than whole foods) without driving to SF or Mountain View, or maybe Berkeley or Emeryville.
- jedberg 15y agoYou're right that Oakland is in Alameda County, but you're totally wrong about the highway. Even in morning rush hour it's only 60 minutes from Oakland to SV. I used to commute from Berkeley to San Jose every day. With no traffic you can totally get from Oakland to the Googleplex in 45 minutes.
- majorgreys 15y agoDoes Silicon Valley not have janitors, cooks, maids, postal workers, garbage collectors, fire fighters, teachers, or any number of other jobs which are either already low wage or increasingly insecure during an economic recession? My guess is that the only bubble is the one inside Eric Schmidt's head that makes it impossible for him to acknowledge those who share common cause with Occupy Wall Street: jobs that don't pay poverty wages, housing as a right, protection from a banking system that tax payers (yes, even those making poverty wages) had to bail out while their schools get sold out, and a government that is actually responsible to the majority rather than the minority which increasingly controls the wealth of this world. The growth of Silicon Valley, or any city for that matter, should not be taken as meaning that we have escaped poverty or unemployment. Far more likely is that the cities that boom have been attractive to business specifically because they have a surplus of low wage workers (again it takes more than engineers to make Silicon Valley run), government subsidized land, adequate transportation built with tax payer money, etc. The high unemployment rate in Santa Clara quoted in the article should give Eric pause but he'd likely just consider that of minor concern because of the fraction of residents that are not hurting (who he wants to continue attracting to the area).