3 ms·

What has this got to do with TFA?

by rajup 4y ago

matkoniecz 4y ago
Both are weird and suspicious and complex financial operations done by Indian government on their citizens.
- rajup 4y ago
  What is “weird” or “suspicious “ about these? Please be specific, not just parroting something off a news article you’ve read. I’m interested to hear how much you’ve actually understood the motivations for these actions (the ultimate results notwithstanding).
  - matkoniecz 4y ago
    > What is “weird” or “suspicious “ about these? Lets go with simpler one. Giving people 17 days to exchange all their cash under penalty of losing all of it is weird, suspicious and stupid. And evil or incompetent or both. People responsible for that are responsible for massive amount of human tragedy without a good justification (no, good intentions do not count as one). > Please be specific, not just parroting something off a news article you’ve read Can you explain how/why this demonetisation would NOT be “weird” or “suspicious“?
    - rajup 4y ago
      Incompetent? Most likely. Again I don’t see any convincing argument for why it’s “weird” or “suspicious” in the usual meaning of those words in the English dictionary. It’s fine to throw out a word salad if that’s your communication style, but don’t be surprised if people ask for specific reasoning for those words. > Can you explain how/why this demonetisation would NOT be “weird” or “suspicious“? No that’s not how this debate thing works :)
      - matkoniecz 4y ago
        > No that’s not how this debate thing works :) If you demand from me to spend time on more detailed explanation and you are unwilling to do the same, then I prefer to spend time on something else.
        rajup 4y ago
        > If you demand from me to spend time on more detailed explanation and you are unwilling to do the same, then I prefer to spend time on something else. So you got nothing. I suspected as much, thanks for confirming.

What has this got to do with TFA?

by rajup 4y ago

What has this got to do with TFA?

matkoniecz 4y ago

Both are weird and suspicious and complex financial operations done by Indian government on their citizens.

rajup 4y ago
What is “weird” or “suspicious “ about these? Please be specific, not just parroting something off a news article you’ve read. I’m interested to hear how much you’ve actually understood the motivations for these actions (the ultimate results notwithstanding).
- matkoniecz 4y ago
  > What is “weird” or “suspicious “ about these? Lets go with simpler one. Giving people 17 days to exchange all their cash under penalty of losing all of it is weird, suspicious and stupid. And evil or incompetent or both. People responsible for that are responsible for massive amount of human tragedy without a good justification (no, good intentions do not count as one). > Please be specific, not just parroting something off a news article you’ve read Can you explain how/why this demonetisation would NOT be “weird” or “suspicious“?
  - rajup 4y ago
    Incompetent? Most likely. Again I don’t see any convincing argument for why it’s “weird” or “suspicious” in the usual meaning of those words in the English dictionary. It’s fine to throw out a word salad if that’s your communication style, but don’t be surprised if people ask for specific reasoning for those words. > Can you explain how/why this demonetisation would NOT be “weird” or “suspicious“? No that’s not how this debate thing works :)
    - matkoniecz 4y ago
      > No that’s not how this debate thing works :) If you demand from me to spend time on more detailed explanation and you are unwilling to do the same, then I prefer to spend time on something else.
      - rajup 4y ago
        > If you demand from me to spend time on more detailed explanation and you are unwilling to do the same, then I prefer to spend time on something else. So you got nothing. I suspected as much, thanks for confirming.