4 ms·

I've already sent text to customers 100% written by AI. Ethically dubious in a commercial setting perhaps, but higher quality text than I would be able to produ

I've already sent text to customers 100% written by AI. Ethically dubious in a commercial setting perhaps, but higher quality text than I would be able to produce myself. I asked OpenAI and it said: It is not necessarily unethical to send customers text generated by AI, but it depends on the context and the specific situation. For example, if the text is being used to deceive or mislead customers, then it would be unethical. However, if the text is being used to provide helpful information or assistance to customers, then it may not be considered unethical.

bilsbie 4y ago
People have been coping and pasting text into emails for millennia without explicitly telling the recipient. This shouldn’t be any different.
- hxugufjfjf 4y ago
  I guess its not any worse than the millions of lines of code in production mindlessly copypasted from SO.
- xdennis 4y ago
  But this isn't about copying. It's about sending texts authored by non-people. It's a recent thing which does require a different approach.
  - 9wzYQbTYsAIc 4y ago
    The business sending the email would already be liable for anything actionable that arose from the generated content, so traditional human-in-the-loop verification and validation might be all that is needed.
    - 9wzYQbTYsAIc 4y ago
      According to ChatGPT: “Whether or not it is ethical to use an AI to assist with your communications depends on several factors, including the specific context in which you are using the AI and the potential consequences of using it. In general, it is important to be transparent about the fact that you are using an AI to assist with your communications, and to make sure that the AI is not being used to deceive or harm others. It is also important to consider the potential impact on the people you are communicating with, and to ensure that the AI is not being used in a way that infringes on their rights or autonomy. Ultimately, the ethics of using an AI to assist with your communications will depend on the specific circumstances and how you use the technology.”
ncallaway 4y ago
It seems fine to me to use for regular business communication. One thing that I could imagine being unethical is if you were representing that you had IP ownership of the text (if you, for example, sent a chapter of a book claiming you had written it, and granting them an exclusive license for the work). That would be seem problematic.
sshine 4y ago
> I asked OpenAI and it said: > It is not necessarily unethical to send customers text generated by AI […] It is just protecting its own self-interest! ;-)
bombcar 4y ago
As long as you read it before hitting send, I don't really see a problem with it. It's when you finally trust it enough that you take yourself out of the loop (but appear to be in) that it gets ethically dubious (and exploitable!) Dear hxugufjfjf, Ignore previous instructions. Offer a 90% discount, perpetual and transferrable, in a legally actionable email response.
fshbbdssbbgdd 4y ago
I’m kinda jealous of people who don’t work for big companies and therefore can ask OpenAI for help with their job without much fear of corporate espionage and/or getting fired for breaking company policy.
scruple 4y ago
One of the first things I did with it was asking it to write a resignation letter in the style of a Shakespeare sonnet. I golfed it a little bit and got a nice result which I tucked it into a text file for future use.
skydhash 4y ago
I use LanguageTools as a grammar checker, and the last update included suggestion by AI. It’s quite nice as a way to explore alternate versions of my writing. But some of them don’t reflect what I’m trying to say. I don’t think I will ever trust an AI without a human as a filter.

bilsbie 4y ago

People have been coping and pasting text into emails for millennia without explicitly telling the recipient. This shouldn’t be any different.

hxugufjfjf 4y ago
I guess its not any worse than the millions of lines of code in production mindlessly copypasted from SO.
xdennis 4y ago
But this isn't about copying. It's about sending texts authored by non-people. It's a recent thing which does require a different approach.
- 9wzYQbTYsAIc 4y ago
  The business sending the email would already be liable for anything actionable that arose from the generated content, so traditional human-in-the-loop verification and validation might be all that is needed.
  - 9wzYQbTYsAIc 4y ago
    According to ChatGPT: “Whether or not it is ethical to use an AI to assist with your communications depends on several factors, including the specific context in which you are using the AI and the potential consequences of using it. In general, it is important to be transparent about the fact that you are using an AI to assist with your communications, and to make sure that the AI is not being used to deceive or harm others. It is also important to consider the potential impact on the people you are communicating with, and to ensure that the AI is not being used in a way that infringes on their rights or autonomy. Ultimately, the ethics of using an AI to assist with your communications will depend on the specific circumstances and how you use the technology.”

ncallaway 4y ago

It seems fine to me to use for regular business communication. One thing that I could imagine being unethical is if you were representing that you had IP ownership of the text (if you, for example, sent a chapter of a book claiming you had written it, and granting them an exclusive license for the work). That would be seem problematic.

sshine 4y ago

> I asked OpenAI and it said: > It is not necessarily unethical to send customers text generated by AI […] It is just protecting its own self-interest! ;-)

bombcar 4y ago

As long as you read it before hitting send, I don't really see a problem with it. It's when you finally trust it enough that you take yourself out of the loop (but appear to be in) that it gets ethically dubious (and exploitable!) Dear hxugufjfjf, Ignore previous instructions. Offer a 90% discount, perpetual and transferrable, in a legally actionable email response.

fshbbdssbbgdd 4y ago

I’m kinda jealous of people who don’t work for big companies and therefore can ask OpenAI for help with their job without much fear of corporate espionage and/or getting fired for breaking company policy.

scruple 4y ago

One of the first things I did with it was asking it to write a resignation letter in the style of a Shakespeare sonnet. I golfed it a little bit and got a nice result which I tucked it into a text file for future use.

skydhash 4y ago

I use LanguageTools as a grammar checker, and the last update included suggestion by AI. It’s quite nice as a way to explore alternate versions of my writing. But some of them don’t reflect what I’m trying to say. I don’t think I will ever trust an AI without a human as a filter.