3 ms·
Self driving is limited by the only real testing requiring real hours of driving with real cars, where getting the last 10% of the way requires getting real-lif
by vidarh 4y ago
Self driving is limited by the only real testing requiring real hours of driving with real cars, where getting the last 10% of the way requires getting real-life testing in increasingly rare conditions.
- arcturus17 4y agoBut can you ascertain that similar dynamics won't also come into play for software? Yes, software is easier to deploy and test at scale - there are barely any physical constraints compared to driving. But on the other hand it's also a more complex domain than driving. Taking Advent of Code as an example, GPT seems to be making mince meat of some problems, but it struggles with others. Is it not conceivable that in software there will be a "last 10%" where AI will trip up, either because the inputs (prompts/requirements) are hard to express or parse, or the output (code) is hard to generate?
- vidarh 4y ago"Similar dynamics" requires situations where training the AI becomes bottlenecked on training opportunities. There will certainly be areas where such bottlenecks exist, and so we can assume that there will be types of problems we can't expect exponential improvement to continue once it hits those bottlenecks. But the point is that self-driving is a poor example to use to judge what we can expect to see in fields that are less constrained by turnaround times and safety. Not least because "anyone" - though certainly constrained by costs - can try to do novel things with large language models. Very few can try to do novel things with self-driving because they have nothing realistic to test it on at scale.
- phkahler 4y agoNo. Full self driving requires development of full AGI. General intelligence is needed to navigate construction zones with a flag man directing traffic someplace it normally doesn't go. As but one example. Stopping to ask said flagman a question for clarification is also preferable to just guessing the answer.