7 ms·
FTX founder Sam Bankman-Fried says he can’t account for billions sent to Alameda
- wcunning 4y agohttps://archive.ph/DVizJ https://archive.ph/DVizJ
- dmix 4y ago> who were told their money was theirs was in fact lent to Alameda. Even if we assume for a second that this wasn’t some sort of overt theft scheme and not only just an accounting failure with double counted deposits, what was the least bad scenario here? That SBF et al were so obsessed with their altruistic charity stuff that they thought they could gamble their billions and turn it into 100 billion and become neo-Bill Gates? Some kids who had no rules making crazy high risk bets on other crypto stuff, blindly believing in their ability and leveraging their parent company’s name to over extend themselves… Then FTX came to the rescue with customer deposits and hoping growth would cover the downside, while not telling anyone or changing controls as far back as April 2021?
- nullc 4y agoMost charitable, and I think likely true, is that most of the funds never existed in the first place. FTX took in 2-3 billion from investors and retail, told customers had big winnings on large leverage bets. 1 billion was squandered, 2 billion was withdrawn by customers. And poof they couldn't process withdraws anymore even though their accounts say they're still 8 billion in the hole. In that theory the real story is that they were just running a casino offering extremely leveraged side-bets on the prices of all manner of nonsense (they've even been sued for manipulating the underlying prices to benefit themselves by triggering liquidations). But to make this all appear legitimate they claimed these bets were fully collateralized, but the secret being that they'd accept illiquid magic beans as the collateral (and not just their own, but other random trash too). Now they're stuck because it's hard to explain what happened without explaining that the collateral was just a pretext and the real business they were in was a bucketshop. So they're stuck feigning surprise that the obviously worthless stuff they took as collateral turned out to be worthless.
- richbell 4y ago> But to make this all appear legitimate they claimed these bets were fully collateralized, but the secret being that they'd accept illiquid magic beans as the collateral (and not just their own, but other random trash too). This is a key lie that SBF has been allowed to peddle in these interviews. He claims that, had he not panicked and announced bankruptcy, FTX would have been fine; however, the lawyers and suits that took over have decided to burn it to the ground instead. He handily omits that the liquidity he's claiming would have saved the day is the now worthless magic beans. It reminds me of how people dishonesty reference "market cap" for NFTs and cryptocurrencies with incredibly high valuations extrapolated from a handful of sales.
- nullc 4y agoYeah, it's not clear to me why people keep allowing him to attribute significant value to those assets in these interviews particularly since the public disclosure that Alameda's balance sheet was mostly that stuff is what initially triggered the collapse. It's like a bank-of-lore collapsing after people heard that their gold vaults were full of tungsten bars ... and then none of the interviews go into talking about the tungsten bars.
- andirk 4y agoValuations often have non-liquid portions of their estimates. Market caps of regular stonks are fairly incorrect, too, since if a large holder sold all of their shares, that price per share would drop. But yeah making ones own super magic bean FTT in an already magical bean world should have been a VERY obvious red flag to anyone who knew that. I'm more shocked that he was able to get any investors with his abysmal accounting practices.
- vba616 4y agoI love this: “Here’s a list of stuff, will you give us a few billion dollars for this list of stuff? Look! The top thing on the list is this nice clean Robinhood stake. Okay that’s enough looking.” You take a wad of crumpled $1 bills and $3 bills and dry cleaning receipts and chewing-gum wrappers, you wrap some crisp $20s around the outside, you hold the wad up in front of people and see what they’ll give you for it.
- vba616 4y agoThe "least bad scenario" I read is that if we assume the money was lost through "well-intentioned but incompetent bumbling" then nevertheless the company "lied, constantly, about how carefully it was keeping track of risk and customer money". They were supposed to have automated systems to instantly liquidate margin positions like Alameda's so FTX wouldn't lose money. Without favoritism or human judgement. Now SBF is going around apparently saying "aw shucks, I made an error in judgement and also in arithmetic". Ok, noted, but that shouldn't have mattered?
- dmix 4y ago> "aw shucks, I made an error in judgement and also in arithmetic" Fascinating isn't it. A CEO playing the dumb young dude who didn't know better.
- paulpauper 4y agowow...the ftx.com domain redirects to some weird legal page https://restructuring.ra.kroll.com/FTX/ https://restructuring.ra.kroll.com/FTX/
- toomuchtodo 4y agoThis is standard fair for firms put into receivership.
- richbell 4y ago> “They were wired to Alameda, and…I can only speculate about what happened after that,” Mr. Bankman-Fried told the Journal. In a sane world, this would be an obvious confession to criminal negligence and violating his fiduciary duty. SBF paints this as one big stupid mistake, yet reporting from other sources paints a compelling argument that the chaotic structure and lack of oversight was a deliberate construction. It's highly suspect for a company, let alone a finance company, to not have a CFO. Are we really supposed to believe that he was so busy he wasn't apprised of what was going on with both of his companies, even though he had plenty of time to funnel hundreds of millions into political donations and luxury properties?
- breput 4y agoHis uh...(ex) intimate partner[0][1]...was running Alameda. This guy is dumber than a bag of hammers, but he might be smart or vengeful enough to try to shift some blame upon Caroline Ellison. [0] https://beincrypto.com/bizarre-fairy-tale-story-sam-bankman-fried-caroline-ellison/ https://beincrypto.com/bizarre-fairy-tale-story-sam-bankman-... [1] https://nymag.com/intelligencer/2022/12/sam-bankman-fried-may-regret-his-comment-on-caroline-ellison.html https://nymag.com/intelligencer/2022/12/sam-bankman-fried-ma...
- SanjayMehta 4y agoThere's an absolutely fascinating short clip off reddit featuring this lady: https://www.reddit.com/r/Wallstreetsilver/comments/ysakai/caroline_ellison_28_year_old_ceo_alameda_research/ https://www.reddit.com/r/Wallstreetsilver/comments/ysakai/ca... The way she says "stop losses" makes me think she really has no idea what she was doing.
- andirk 4y agoI've been thinking the blame handoff to her is his only way out. And as far as we currently know, she may have been heavily involved or even in charge of these shenanigans. Since their beginnings were down the street from my house, I also keep wondering if I've met them. But then I remember that they're squares who can barely down a beer in favour of pharma pills.
- dvt 4y agoGiving narcissistic sociopaths like SBF an audience is absolutely disgusting—from "citizen journalists" like Tiffany Fong that are engagement farming this tragedy for clout, to Mario Nawfal's cringe-inducing Twitter spaces, to Kim Dotcom's insufferable attempt to regain any kind of relevance, to Bitboy Crypto trying to convince his followers that he saw through SBF the whole time (even though he shilled FTT just last year)—in typical crypto fashion, everyone is trying to take advantage of this situation for their own gain. Oh yeah, there's also Kevin O'Leary who said SBF ain't that bad of a guy. But then again, a16z just gave Adam Newmann $350M, so maybe it's just par for the course. And who can forget about the NYT, writing several puff pieces about SBF, with gems like: > Critics of Mr. Bankman-Fried in the crypto community have questioned the idea that someone with his intelligence could have blundered into losing billions of dollars, suggesting that he took the money knowingly. Gross. Anyone with their wits about them knows SBF literally gambled with other people's money. Full stop. Maybe he's not indictable by the US government and will never see a day in jail, but that doesn't mean everyone needs to give him a platform.
- dmix 4y agoWhat does “giving a platform” even mean? Asking him to explain himself while the slow moving process of banks, regulators, courts, and criminal investigators take apart his company? Do you think this will somehow stop any of that from happening? That he can talk his way out of losing $5 billion?
- stephc_int13 4y agoThere is this growing belief, especially among genZ kids, that what happens online, what is seen by an audience, is the prevalent reality. And this is not entirely false, in practice.
- dmix 4y agoAll I see on social media is that SBF engaged in a black and white pump and dump scheme or is a straight up Bernie Madoff. That’s also probably not reality either, it’s far more complicated and nuanced. Would you prefer that is how the narrative stays? He becomes a Disney villain? That it’s as bad as possible to punish him? As some sort of deterrence? GenZ won’t be watching raw WSJ interviews, it will be chopped up in TikTok videos with the usual “world is going to shit” spin the media always uses.
- gregjor 4y agoWas't "blockchain technology" supposed to prevent this exact thing -- no record of money transfers? Instead it just enables obfuscation and fraud. I really hope the IRS/FBI have more success tracking down where that money went. No one can spend that much on Adderall.
- smsm42 4y agoNo, blockchain technology was never intended to prevent this kind of fraud. How could it? If $N bln is missing, how any blockchain could tell you where it went if those dollars have never been represented on that blockchain? The blockchain can only record operations made within the chain, blaming it for fraud that happened outside the chain is like blaming differential equations that they don't prevent robbery. It's not something that is possible for this technology, and it was never intended to solve it. If all the transactions everywhere happened on the blockchain, then you could make claims that it should be traceable (even then it doesn't mean it actually is, though) - but it's clearly not the case.
- gregjor 4y agoI think you missed the sarcasm in my comment even though I tried to make it obvious. Fraud is fraud, technology can’t stop it. In the popular mind, away from the “crypto community,” regular people equate crypto with claims for the revolutionary blockchain. That enables scammers and predators. Technology cannot bear fault or blame because it has no will or action.
- smsm42 4y agoI'm not sure what would be the reason to think blockchain will change anything in the fraud department. It's like expecting electric cars will cure cancer. I mean, maybe some people have weird expectations, but I work in a crypto-adjacent company and it is true that a lot of people misunderstand crypto and blockchains, but I haven't encountered many that would expect it to magically stop fraud.
- 4y ago
- dragonwriter 4y ago> Mr. Bankman-Fried’s remarks suggest that FTX customer funds flowing into Alameda bank accounts could have been recorded in two places—both as FTX customer funds and as part of Alameda’s trading positions. But we know that they weren’t recorded in the first place, since the balance sheets maintained by FTX when SBF was in charge, as reported in the bankruptcy filing, had $0 (both as assets and liabilities) for customer fiat deposits, and no recording of customer crypto deposits. (pp. 13-14 of the bankruptcy filing) [0] [0] https://pacer-documents.s3.amazonaws.com/33/188450/042020648197.pdf https://pacer-documents.s3.amazonaws.com/33/188450/042020648...
- user_named 4y agoWouldn't that mean that he basically embezzled all customer deposits, by design?
- dragonwriter 4y agoAt a minimum, failed to account for them in a way which very much enabled embezzlement, but, yes, the massive set of accounting and other record keeping irregularities at the FTX family of companies would look like a deliberate setup to enable fraud and embezzlement even if you just looked at what wasn’t recorded, and not at SBFs explicit instruction to others to use self-destructing messages for company business to avoid a permanent record. Everything was set up in a way which complicates being able to prove exactly who involved stole what (lack of records of assets and debts, particularly customer accounts, lack of records of bank accounts controlled by the various corporations, lack of records of who the employees of the various corporations were, and what their terms of employment were, unprotected group email account with keys for corporate crypto wallets–which coincidentally a large sum was transferred out of right around the time of the bankruptcy, etc.), but in a way which makes it very hard to imagine that it was anything but deliberately structured for exactly that purpose.
- rhaway84773 4y agoWhat I don’t understand is that SBF’s own explanation is fraud. His argument against it being fraud is that he was too dumb to know that he was committing fraud. I don’t think that’s believable at all, and even if that’s the case, I don’t think it makes his fraud any less criminal.
- newguynewphone 4y agothe son of 2 tax experts that have helped draft tax legislation, is insinuating that he doesn't know the basics of what makes his actions fraud, and how he wants to distance himself from Alameda, even though he is a 90% owner, just sounds fishy
- pdntspa 4y agoTo say nothing of the fact that he was fucking its CEO. Imagine the pillow talk...
- kryogen1c 4y ago> the son of 2 tax experts I'm no SBF apologist, but this is about the silliest argument you could make. What does what his parents did have anything to do with anything? I don't know anything about my parents' field of expertise.
- deleted 4y ago[deleted]
- bovinejoni 4y agoHis parents are the beneficial owners of Bahamas real estate purchased with FTX funds, allegedly for “employee purposes”. This all looks really bad
- thedudeabides5 4y agoHis parents were both employed by the company and (imho) obviously still providing legal services in a world where all his lawyers dropped him. He's not dumb, everyone is just taking the bait.
- iampivot 4y agoIs this guy going to jail for a long time?
- HPMOR 4y agoYeah, probably
- diogenescynic 4y agoI bet it’s less than 7 years total and probably serves less than 5. Our justice system is weak on white collar crime and SBF is politically connected.
- tptacek 4y agoThat's a dumb bet. The crimes he'd be on the hook for all have sentences that mostly hinge on 2B1.1(b), which scales sentences by the dollar amount of the crime. He'll easily be into double digit years just based on the dollar amounts involved here, if he's convicted. He'll also be charged federally. There is no federal parole.
- diogenescynic 4y agoSBF is the largest donor to the Democratic Party this year and his mom runs an org that raises hundreds of millions for political bribes each year. I'm sure that won't be forgotten. Elizabeth Holmes committed worse crimes and got a slap on the wrist--mostly because the was stealing from the elite. People are going to forget all about SBF and he'll get charged in a few years and get forgotten until he times some meager sentence and then re-emerges a few years later as the new Jordan Belfort, probably selling some new get rich quick scheme.
- tptacek 4y agoOK. Want to bet?
- bovinejoni 4y agoIt wasn’t weak on madoff or holmes, both politically connected
- mlindner 4y agoIt's nice that he keeps talking to the press giving more and more self-incriminating and contradictory information to prosecutors. I assume of course that all these press people will recant their praise for him once that happens. /s
- Cameri 4y agoWhy isn't he and his girlfriend behind bars already?
- water8 4y agoHe’s the second largest contributor to the democratic party this year
- timmytokyo 4y agoHe was smarter than that. He claims he gave just as much money to Republicans. He just used dark money for Republicans because he thought it would look better. [0] https://www.msn.com/en-us/money/companies/sam-bankman-fried-says-hes-the-republicans-third-biggest-donor-but-used-dark-money-to-avoid-media-criticism/ar-AA14JR5M https://www.msn.com/en-us/money/companies/sam-bankman-fried-...
- water8 4y ago[dead]
- pharrington 4y agoThe Feds don't arrest you until they have a case fully prepared that they're 99.99% sure will get a conviction.
- balderdash 4y agoIf you’re prosecuting this guy, all these interviews he’s doing are PURE GOLD, why would you want him to stop?!
- deleted 4y ago[deleted]
- andirk 4y ago1) Smart guy gets good at arbitrage trading, gets a taste for it 2) Starts a trading desk company 3) Loses some bets when he has never lost before, so he bets the farm (keep in mind the farm in this case is every piece of currency that he can conceivably reach regardless of laws, ethics, morality) 4) Loses his hail mary bets. Game over. Dude needs to be a man/woman and spend the rest of his life working to repay everyone he hurt all while justice crushes his freedom forever.
- baandam 4y agoDude needs to go to jail. This is EXACTLY the story of Nick Leeson blowing up Barons Bank. Hopefully this asshole gets more than 4 years though but I doubt it. Leeson didn't have the political connections to get all this fluff swirling about him. He just had to go on the lam.
- sschueller 4y agoWhat about all the enablers that knew he was incompetent but still invested millions? Likepeople providing bomb making materials to terrorists.
- chitowneats 4y agoKind of like Germany gutting its energy infrastructure, making itself wholly dependent on nat gas from a revanchist, authoritarian regime? Hope you're doing well, Herr Scheuller.
- kwertyoowiyop 4y agoWhy is everyone giving him such a hard time? I mean, who among us hasn’t misplaced a few billion dollars at some point in our lives? At a company we ran?
- 1B05H1N 4y agoThe fact that he hasn't opted to speak through a lawyer speaks to his incompetence.
- germandiago 4y agoThis guy should go to prison. He violated the contract with users and ruined them.