6 ms·
Standardized testing is the reason why India – despite its billion strong population and heavy cultural emphasis on science and engineering – is unable to produ
by paxys 4y ago
Standardized testing is the reason why India – despite its billion strong population and heavy cultural emphasis on science and engineering – is unable to produce a single ounce of innovation. Students are only taught rote memorization from primary school onwards. They spend their formative years in before-school and after-school coaching doing more of the same, all to crack that single test which will determine their future (and a large number are driven to suicide because of it). No curiosity, no outside interests, no social skills, no independent thought. All of these are discouraged in favor of memorizing equations.
Institutions like Harvard, Yale, MIT, Stanford produce leaders and entrepreneurs. India's top engineering colleges (IITs) are meanwhile ranked nowhere globally, and its top graduates dream of getting a cushy job at Google, nothing more.
There are a lot of problems with American universities, but the lack of entrance exams is a feature, not a bug.
- gautamdivgi 4y agoI would differ on this. It’s access to capital and connections. For the longest time access to capital in India has been limited and children are expected to support parents in their old age. Hence, the heavy move towards the cushy job at google. To be fair a large cohort of IIT & IISc grads come to top American universities. I actually think standardized tests create more equality than other methods. The whole recommendation letter/essay/interview is an eyewash.
- idontpost 4y ago
- geodel 4y ago> To be fair a large cohort of IIT & IISc grads come to top American universities. Why are they coming to American universities when IITs and IISC have GATE exam for post graduate courses and none of the ridiculous process for admission?
- oefrha 4y agoMust be because they love ridiculous admission processes, not because American income is higher.
- gautamdivgi 4y agoConnections and access to capital. Isn’t that why people move or get a job, etc.? And the fact that they can tolerate the ridiculously low PHD stipends.
- paxys 4y ago> I actually think standardized tests create more equality than other methods If that was actually the case then India wouldn't have a quota system where >50% of seats are reserved for certain castes and religions.
- selimthegrim 4y agoWhich religions?
- gautamdivgi 4y agoThose are mostly political freebies. If you have someone using the reservation to gain admission there is no way they will be able to go through with recommendation letters/writing essays/interviews, etc. Edit: In a way, the standardized testing made that inequality apparent and harder to wave your with a very ambiguous policy on inclusion.
- eklavya 4y agoTo uphold equality I need to be punished for the sins of my fathers at least 2 generations before me. I have stopped complaining and my children and grandchildren will learn as well.
- mensetmanusman 4y agoConnections is key and related to EQ. You can memorize all the works of physics and be horrible at making connections to get stuff done in the real world.
- scifibestfi 4y agoThey produce MBAs, but some of the most successful founder entrepreneurs drop out from those institutions. What does that tell you?
- vecter 4y agoThe trope about successful dropout founders just isn't really true. Most successful founders finished college. That's not to say that college is the end-all and be-all of life (it's barely just beginning), but let's not pretend that a small handful of famous dropouts makes the trend.
- deleted 4y ago[deleted]
- mrguyorama 4y agoOr much more importantly, most of those business founder dropouts had strong support systems in upper class families.
- paxys 4y agoIt tells me that these universities have an environment that supports students setting up and running companies while still enrolled. Students being successful enough to drop out before graduating is a badge of honor for these universities. Flexibility with schedules, reduced work load, taking semesters off – none of these are allowed by Indian colleges (believe me, I went through it myself). You can't even pick your own subjects or class schedule. Tell me, what was the last success story to come out of the IIT entrepreneurs' club?
- Khelavaster 4y agoA less insulting version of this might be accurate..
- eklavya 4y agoYou should research a bit before you say there isn’t an ounce of innovation from India. Very mainstream and simple example is UPI (google it). Tell me any system in the whole world which comes close in scale, ease of use and security. You are discounting Indian institutions, take a look at the Fortune 500 c suite list and tell me how many of them studied at IIT/IIM. Investment is a key requirement for enterprise. You will be surprised to see the startup ecosystem now since the investment is flowing in. I 100% agree with the asinine focus on cracking the exam and not anything else. But then the ROI is too good.
- geodel 4y ago> You will be surprised to see the startup ecosystem now since the investment is flowing in. Do you mean copycat chumps getting bloated on Softbank money as example of startup innovation?
- eklavya 4y agoDepends on which parts you choose to look at. If you are insinuating that Indian startup ecosystem is more inflated than everywhere else and you strongly believe that Indian startup ecosystem is devoid of innovation, then I don't know what to say to you.
- baandam 4y agoIt is an embarrassing mindset as an American. We will just ignore all the Indians working on letting us "google it". Just like there is a little niche in information theory that I keep up on current research and I pretty much ignore research outside of China at this point. So many Americans just have their head up their ass they literally have no idea what is going on in the outside world.
- elgar1212 4y ago> Students are only taught rote memorization from primary school onwards. They spend their formative years in before-school and after-school coaching doing more of the same, all to crack that single test which will determine their future (and a large number are driven to suicide because of it). No curiosity, no outside interests, no social skills, no independent thought. All of these are discouraged in favor of memorizing equations. You do realize that this is the same language that universities like Harvard use to discriminate against Asian Americans (and historically against Jewish people)? Reading this and knowing that you're talking about South Asians in particular, this comment just comes off as stereotypical and racist
- bombcar 4y agoSchools like Stanford et al produce things like Sam Bankman-Fried who I cannot deny is an innovator of something. I'm not sure it's a good thing, mind you.
- gautamdivgi 4y agoYou missed the Theranos founder :)
- eli_gottlieb 4y ago>Standardized testing is the reason why India – despite its billion strong population and heavy cultural emphasis on science and engineering – is unable to produce a single ounce of innovation. Says someone whose country brain-drains Indian innovators to do the actual work for which nepotistic grifters from Harvard take the credit!
- tester756 4y agoI'd argue that this is money btw. did you have an opportunity to study using those two "approaches"?
- baandam 4y agoThe irony to me is this view of the world that has nothing to do with the real world is the bug. As if the innovation from silicon value has nothing to do with people born in India. What planet are we on again?