4 ms·
Even most ardently pro-gun people do not recommend killing to protect property; only to protect human life. It does occur and it isn’t usually terribly newswor
by bombcar 4y ago
Even most ardently pro-gun people do not recommend killing to protect property; only to protect human life.
It does occur and it isn’t usually terribly newsworthy (here’s a recent one: https://www.cbsnews.com/chicago/news/calumet-heights-shooting-attempted-carjacking/ https://www.cbsnews.com/chicago/news/calumet-heights-shootin... ) unless there is something else around it.
- dtech 4y agoIf the robber has a gun - like here - isn't it usually easy to argue shooting back was to preserve life? Your comment is also directly contradicted by the numerous Stand-your-ground laws [1], quoting Wikipedia: "Under such a law, people have no duty to retreat before using deadly force in self-defense" [1] https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Stand-your-ground_law https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Stand-your-ground_law
- bombcar 4y agoIn that case it can be - assuming the victim has a gun, and legally. Stand your ground laws exist but even then the training literature is quite clear - you run the risk of ruining your life at least financially by pulling the trigger so you better have that as the better option compared to death or serious bodily harm.
- matwood 4y ago> isn't it usually easy to argue shooting back was to preserve life? Depends on the particular laws of where you are. The reality is that even if the laws favor shooting back, if the criminal ends up injured or killed it means years of legal issues for the shooter. This is true for any physical altercation regardless of if weapons are used.
- deleted 4y ago[deleted]
- kkielhofner 4y agoI don’t think OP was referring to the letter of the law. My understanding is that “Stand your ground” /can/ at a minimum be applied to any situation where “a reasonable person would be in fear for their life” - which likely (technically) would cover almost any scenario where any kind of violence or even “crime” is targeted towards you. That said, as OP was saying the overwhelming take (from what I’ve seen) in the gun/conceal carry community has a pretty high standard for deadly force. In reality the standard for “fear for your life” is actually really high for most people. As you say “shooting back” - which implies you were shot at first. I think in that case “fear for your life” is very reasonable and push come to shove anyone with a gun would use it. This take even stretches into robberies like this. If someone comes up to you on the street and demands your camera (even with a weapon) it’s best just to cooperate and hand it over. All but the most fervent gun people at their core realize that real life isn’t Hollywood. The vast majority of people who say otherwise are keyboard warriors/wanna be tough guys that have never been in such a situation and have some delusional fantasy of themselves channeling John Wick when/if it happens to them. Obviously that’s not reality. Clearly the US has a ton of guns and there are many millions of people who are armed at all times. Stories in the news of people using a gun to defend themselves are few and far between because 1) violent crime is actually exceedingly rare statistically and 2) even most gun people realize it’s not OK to kill someone over a camera/wallet/etc even though you may have the means to and the law is technically on your side.
- lbayes 4y agoI lived (and loved!) in Northern California for nearly 20 years and left in 2017 for personal reasons. Without a concealed carry permit, any law-abiding citizen who travels with firearms in California must keep them unloaded and in a locked container [0]. It used to be incredibly difficult (nearly impossible [1]) for regular citizens to obtain a concealed carry permit in San Francisco because they had a "Good Cause Requirement" which essentially meant that your cause was not good enough. Apparently, that changed in June of 2022 with a recent Supreme Court Ruling [2]. There are also [3] many stories of victims who shoot their attackers either being prosecuted criminally or sued for civil damages. Lastly, while the views on concealed carry vary widely throughout the US, most social environments that I ever encountered in Northern California would find it repugnant. [0] https://oag.ca.gov/firearms/travel https://oag.ca.gov/firearms/travel [1] https://www.desertsun.com/story/news/nation/california/2022/06/29/california-leaks-gun-owners-california-to-limit-concealed-carry-ccw-access-restrict-firearms-law/7767652001/ https://www.desertsun.com/story/news/nation/california/2022/... [2] https://www.sanfranciscopolice.org/get-service/carrying-concealed-weapon-ccw-information-and-application https://www.sanfranciscopolice.org/get-service/carrying-conc... [3] Oregon, not CA https://www.gilmanbedigian.com/man-who-shot-intruder-in-his-home-sued-for-wrongful-death/ https://www.gilmanbedigian.com/man-who-shot-intruder-in-his-...
- MengerSponge 4y agoThere are plenty of pro-gun people who advocate killing to protect their property! Texas is not the only state with castle doctrine, but it's the least surprising one where it's legal to kill intruders to protect your land. https://www.dougmurphylaw.com/defense-of-property https://www.dougmurphylaw.com/defense-of-property
- yonaguska 4y agoThere's a big difference in protecting property in your domicile vs protecting your property while you're out and about. Most serious gun self defense legal advocates will advocate not protecting your property while out in public, unless your life is truly in danger, simply because you are going to incur immediate legal issues and at least 20k in debt. Whatever you were protecting is not likely going to be worth the legal, or emotional costs of self defense. When it comes to protecting your property, as in your domicile- you are having your safest place violated. Your life is more likely in danger, and laws are also more likely to favor you, lessening the legal risk. If I'm carjacked, I have insurance, if someone breaks into my house, where I have several guns and my family- I have much less to lose by killing the intruder.
- pcl 4y agoNot in Texas — the Texas castle doctrine extends to your vehicles and workplace. See section 9.31 here. https://statutes.capitol.texas.gov/Docs/PE/htm/PE.9.htm https://statutes.capitol.texas.gov/Docs/PE/htm/PE.9.htm
- MengerSponge 4y agoAgain, depends on the state. If you're a white person in Texas? It's vanishingly unlikely that your interaction with the state legal apparatus will extend beyond a hat tip and a thank you sir/ma'am. Think of it as a "barbarians at the gate" type situation. You're defending civilization from lawlessness. Whether or not your life is in danger doesn't matter in many places. You similarly only have an obligation to deescalate in some states.
- arcbyte 4y ago