10 ms·
Users seamlessly buy crypto with USD and spend it. Merchants seamlessly convert crypto back to USD and cash it out. So what is the point of crypto again other
by paxys 4y ago
Users seamlessly buy crypto with USD and spend it.
Merchants seamlessly convert crypto back to USD and cash it out.
So what is the point of crypto again other than giving Stripe (and similar centralized providers) a needless cut?
- m00dy 4y agousd for cross border payments is a problem and speaking frankly it is a hugeeeee problem. Crypto fixes this.
- newaccount74 4y agoIsn't something like wise.com a much better option for that? You have to trust only a single company instead of multiple potentially sketchy exchanges, and you are not exposed to crypto currency fluctuations.
- m00dy 4y agook, usd is terrible for cross border micropayments
- valcron1000 4y agoAs someone who uses Wise out of necesity: no, it's not better. Wise can freeze my account whenever they want. They can go out of business any day. Fees can change over time. Transfers can take a long time (ex. wire transfers can take several working days). Crypto is a far better solution in my experience.
- newaccount74 4y agoAll those problems also apply to the exchanges you use for crypto. Unless you are thinking about a hypothetical future where you can directly use cryptocurrencies to pay your rent and buy your groceries.
- logicchains 4y ago>All those problems also apply to the exchanges you use for crypto. Yes but they don't apply to using crypto for cross border payments, which is what the poster was referring to.
- newaccount74 4y agoTransferring crypto across borders without exchanging to/from local currencies or USD is of course trivial. But it's also useless, since most people can't pay their rent with crypto.
- djur 4y agoWhy is it a problem?
- m00dy 4y agoSWIFT system is taking too much time...(slow) It is costly...(expensive) It is not for micro-transactions... You can get kicked out like Russia... (So, as a government, you cannot rely on it) As a government, you don't have a right to vote in decision making or government in SWIFT system. (not inclusive)
- djur 4y agoThanks for the info! Those mostly seem like problems that can be resolved without cryptocurrency.
- dashdot 4y agoOh yes sure. The current system could also work without all the current issues... But who of the parties that control or profit from it now would want a change? Why give up control? Why renounce fees? To change it, at least one competing system is required to put the pressure the current system. It will not change from the inside.
- imtringued 4y agoThat is the best argument so far. The money system is a monopoly and competition fosters innovation. The problem is that cryptocurrencies are bad competitors.
- mnahkies 4y agoTo elaborate on the sibling comment, my understanding of Wise's mechanism from having used it is something along the lines of: - they establish local accounts everywhere - a transfer is you send money locally to their account, and then they send money from another local account to your destination - they take some (small) mark-up over the actual rates - they aggregate the many smallish transactions to exchange with optimal rates and fees for themselves, and probably do a bunch of stuff around mitigating risk of having too much float in a particular currency It's a model that impressed me when I used it, relatively simple conceptually but solved a big pain point. Not sure that crypto adds much other than offloading risk (of exchange rate fluctuations) onto the person doing the transfer - I quite like that wise essentially bears that risk
- rvz 4y agoThere you go. For near instant, low fee, global cross-border payments the technology works for people in countries like Argentina, Nigeria, etc, and especially with stablecoins like USDC and that works worldwide. All the recipient needs is an internet connection and a wallet address or resolved wallet name like abcxyz.eth, or testing123.sol, for example. So yes, it does indeed fix it.
- itake 4y agoPeople bought or earned crypto 5+ years ago and want to spend it.
- paxys 4y agoWe are talking about a product that lets users buy crypto. Why would they people you mention need it?
- SparkyMcUnicorn 4y agoIn addition to cross-border, fees can end up being much lower. Especially when there's multiple transactions or change of hands happening on the chain side.
- mrtksn 4y agoIt works in the US only and not all of it, Hawaii is excluded. You need to be not only US resident but be physically in the US[0]. [0] https://support.link.co/questions/where-can-i-purchase-crypto-with-link https://support.link.co/questions/where-can-i-purchase-crypt...
- SparkyMcUnicorn 4y agoFor now. Only the on-ramp side needs to be in the US. The off-ramp user can just use their exchange.
- Nursie 4y agoJust use your exchange! Which ones of those aren't collapsing this week? Sorry "experiencing a temporary liquidity problem in the wake of FTX"? Or "suspending withdrawals temporarily"? Even in the good times there's been no shortage of horror stories about exchanges not honouring withdrawals and ghosting customers, but now the exchange might not even be there next week. Your deposit might be considered part of bankruptcy proceedings and get rolled into general creditor compensation as part of a multi-year wind-up...
- SparkyMcUnicorn 4y agoCoinbase, Kraken, and Binance have (so far) stood the test of time and proven that they either hold assets 1:1 and/or are working towards a system to display their proof of reserves. Personally, I think the risk is low enough for them to hold onto my assets for a few days/minutes (depending on method/direction) while transfers are completed.
- ignoramous 4y ago> So what is the point of crypto again other than giving Stripe (and similar centralized providers) a needless cut? Access to BUSD, USDC, (shudder) USDT, DAI, CUSD for folks across the globe is a good enough reason [0] (right now, the Stripe on-ramp is US-only, but that needn't be the case)? Stripe did bootstrap an alt global payments network in Stellar.org, but that hasn't worked as expected, it'd seem? Stripe is wise to participate in the stable-coin business, which is a way better bet. MobileCoin, which is embed in every Signal installation, also has Stellar-like features but it isn't mainstream, just yet. Meta's Diem / Libre had similar grandoise visions for an alt payments network given its very global, commerce-hungry Instagram and WhatsApp userbases, but for some reason, they never got the legal side of things over the line. [0] Ex: https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=28770875 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=28770875
- beckingz 4y agoKnow Your Customer means that it won't work at scale because the government will shut it down.
- ignoramous 4y agoI don't see any reason why global payments with stable coins and KYC are at odds. This is a long game. I can see why the governments may resist this, but I suspect not all countries would disallow stable coin payouts and payments.
- mrtksn 4y agoThe point of crypto is that trading parties don't have to trust each other and have no recourse to fix issues post payment. The problem with that is, only illegal transactions happen between parties that don't trust each other. Therefore, this having a KYC probably narrows its use cases quite a bit. You won't be able to sell drugs, you won't be be able to collect ransomware payments. It work only in the US, which means its not good for international payments. Unbanked people either don't have money or keep their funds outside of the governments reach for tax or legal reasons, therefore not good for them too. What you can do? Maybe if you are so much and crypto and what to do transactions in crypto as an ideological performance, then this could be for you.
- rt4mn 4y ago> The problem with that is, only illegal transactions happen between parties that don't trust each other. This is patently untrue. When I buy something with cryptocurrency, its not because I don't trust the merchant or am doing something illegal, its because I care about my privacy and dont want a huge list of my financial transactions available to visa/mastercard/paypal/the government, and I don't want to schlep to the gas station to buy a prepaid debit card with cash, which is the only other way to maintain a semblance of financial privacy if you want to buy things online.
- mrtksn 4y agoWhat did you bought?
- rt4mn 4y agoFood, Electronics, web hosting, gifts, etc. you know. stuff. I'm normally a cash in person guy but sometimes I'm feeling lazy and just want to order a big box of candy and be pleasantly surprised and mildly guilty when it arrives.
- mrtksn 4y agoWhat was the benefit of using crypto instead of a card or direct deposit etc?
- r_hoods_ghost 4y agoEnabling fraud and embezzlement by the next generation of Sam Bankman-Fried's and ensuring that the pool of greater idiots and potential victims continues to expand?
- andirk 4y agoSend fiat overseas and let me know how that goes. Crypto has plenty of issues but calling people who use a decentralized form of currency as "idiots" doesn't paint you as the sharpest tool in the shed.
- r_hoods_ghost 4y agoI live in the UK. I can send money instantly anywhere in the EU for nothing via SEPA and frequently do. That covers 28 countries. If I do want to send money to someone in another country I can use paypal, or for larger sums, one of the myriad international wire services that are regulated by the FCA and where I have recourse if something goes wrong.
- gburdell3 4y agoI hate crypto as much as the next guy, but try sending some money to Iran and see how well that goes. There's a legitimate use there for people with families in tumultuous countries.
- clpm4j 4y agoA legitimate, small use case.
- logicchains 4y agoMore legitimate than pretty much the entirety of web advertising.
- yosame 4y agoReally the only use case for crypto is breaking/avoiding the law in some way.
- gnarbarian 4y agopost operation choke point Visa, and MasterCard have been increasingly making moral and political judgments on who is allowed to transact. Even when the transactions are perfectly legal. https://reclaimthenet.org/dick-masterson-new-project-2-mastercard/ https://reclaimthenet.org/dick-masterson-new-project-2-maste... This is a potential way around these behaviors. but I assume it will eventually be blocked by visa and MasterCard simply by threatening to blacklist stripe as a payment processor.
- seydor 4y agoHow does Stripe sidestep this? Can people use VISA to pay pornhub through this portal? I dont think so , that would break Visa rules
- gnarbarian 4y agoI'm thinking through a potential pessimistic scenario here so take this with a grain of salt. let's say a verboten but legal business embeds this widget on their website. a user then uses their visa credit card to exchange for cryptocurrency and make a purchase. I believe Visa would argue that stripe is laundering money through cryptocurrencies to get around high risk payment processing. Visa could demand all cryptocurrency addresses associated with stripes embedded widget and compare that against known blacklisted destination addresses. It would do so under the guise of preventing terrorism, child exploitation, and money laundering. stripe is huge so rather than immediately cutting them off as is what happened to new project 2, I believe they would give stripe an ultimatum of sorts to remove the functionality, or demand stripe prevent transactions to any of the vague/subjective categories of businesses deemed high risk. The latter would likely be impossible because a high risk business could generate a new address easily which would only later be blacklisted and associated with the business landing stripe in breach of the agreement.
- seydor 4y agoat best, visa requires people who participate to upload their government ID for such stuff. Stripe is not that big for them to care
- mattdesl 4y agoExample: a centralized game distributor builds an in-game marketplace for certain assets and user-generated content—think skins, plugins, and game mods that might cost $1 each. The owner of the platform collects a small fee on each sale in crypto, allowing them to have funds that are outside the control of Stripe or even a bank (useful to avoid the regular "Stripe killed my business" posts[1]). The rest of the amount goes automatically to the content creator, unlike Apple's 45 day settlement time for in-app purchases. Through on-chain contracts, these could even be split collaboratively, such as if a team builds a plugin and each member wants an equal % cut without pooling it into a single user's account. The owner and users benefit from the lack of payment processing fees (2-5% or up to 30% in app store models). All of this is interesting, but the system also needs an easy way to get "into" and "out of" the system for those that don't want to hold crypto (or for those that are just coming to the game without any crypto). Instead of forcing them through a shady CEX like FTX, they can just buy tokens through this Stripe embed. [1] https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=32854528 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=32854528
- gnarbarian 4y ago>All of this is interesting, but the system also needs an easy way to get "into" and "out of" the system for those that don't want to hold crypto (or for those that are just coming to the game without any crypto). Instead of forcing them through a shady CEX like FTX, they can just buy tokens through this Stripe embed. and unfortunately, we still have to rely on a company who can choose to deny you business for any reason they want (perhaps stripe doesn't like the addresses you are sending crypto to, for example). This could be an actual use case for central bank digital currencies though I expect the result will be more fine-grained control and micromanagement rather than less.
- mattdesl 4y agoThis is only for the on-ramp and off-ramp on that site. If a user is censored by Stripe, and very determined to get into the digital game economy, they could probably find a local crypto exchange that would handle on and off ramps. Once they are in the crypto system, which may already be the case for many users if we imagine these embeds are in more parts of the web than just niche game marketplaces, that censorship becomes very difficult.
- halpmeh 4y agoIn the long-term, I can see a very real benefit to this. Credit card transaction fees are insanely expensive as they're typically charged at a percentage of the purchase. For instance, if I pay my rent online with a credit card, I am changed a $100 fee. If there was an easy way I could pay my rent with Eth, the transaction fee would be a lot lower. So I can see this working in the following way: 1) Stripe builds out the current functionality as a beta for accepting crypto payments. 2) Stripe lowers fees and expands the merchant base. 3) Stripe begins offering stable-coins on credit. Stripe is now Visa, but with way lower fees.
- pmalynin 4y agoDepends on the gas fees though....that fee could easily be $150.
- halpmeh 4y agoTransaction fees are currently $0.50. I doubt we’ll see such high gas fees after switching to proof-of-stake.
- LegionMammal978 4y agoWhich blockchain are you talking about? Ethereum switched to proof-of-stake almost 3 months ago now, and gas fees were pretty much unaffected from what I can tell.
- halpmeh 4y agoI was judging the tx cost from this: https://ycharts.com/indicators/ethereum_average_transaction_fee https://ycharts.com/indicators/ethereum_average_transaction_...
- simpsond 4y agoPoS hasn’t had much impact. The leveling out there is more like related to fewer transactions. Proto dank sharding, which may ship in 2023, should have a bigger impact on gas fees.
- EGreg 4y agoThe point of Web3 is smart contracts. Voting that you can trust Governance and managing Roles publicly Currencies with own monetary policy Contests and fair judging Fundraising Escrow https://community.qbix.com/t/why-do-we-need-web3-and-web5 https://community.qbix.com/t/why-do-we-need-web3-and-web5
- jiggawatts 4y agoYou just listed a bunch of things with well-established standard solutions that do not need crypto in any shape, way, or form. Voting is already trustworthy in most countries and organisations. Governance has been a thing for literally millennia without crypto. Currencies... I mean sheesh, do I need to list every real-world, huge-scale, widely used example of how all of this is already happening and has been since like the dawn of history!?
- EGreg 4y agoWhy can’t this argument be used against any new technology? They said exactly this about the Internet… why do you need it? See all the well established solutions at the time: https://m.youtube.com/watch?v=tgODUgHeT5Y https://m.youtube.com/watch?v=tgODUgHeT5Y
- throwup 4y agoI don't think this is targeted at traditional merchants who would want to convert anything to fiat. It is targeted at crypto companies that want to streamline user onboarding. The blog post lists 3 partners and they are all crypto companies.
- woah 4y agoDid you read the article?
- imtringued 4y agoSomeone needs to build an inflation adjusted RAI equivalent. Yeah, let me tell you, that is the tiny amount of potential that is left in cryptocurrencies and I would require abandoning everything that cryptocurrencies stand for. All the post rationalizations would have to be ejected from your mind. On the other hand, it would be immediately visible why a cryptocurrency with both low volatility and no inflation would be very popular and you wouldn't even need to shill it to a greater fool.