3 ms·
Austerity doesn't work: it leads to criminal levels of capital waste: high unemployment, low standards of living, poor liquidity, and so on. No, austerity + no
by yummyfajitas 15y ago
Austerity doesn't work: it leads to criminal levels of capital waste: high unemployment, low standards of living, poor liquidity, and so on.
No, austerity + nominal wage stickiness is claimed to do this. Since austerity seems more or less a given, why not try to increase wage flexibility?
I think that "Greeks/Italians need a cut in their real wages" would be a very easy sell to Germany right now.
- gizmo 15y agoWage stickiness is definitely[1] a problem: when you have 20% unemployment (40%+ youth unemployment) wages simply have to drop. Otherwise wages only go up in good times and stay stagnant in bad times. Austerity may be a given politically, but economically speaking it doesn't make much sense, and it's definitely not in the best interest of the EU (or the world) as a whole. [1] Not definitely, as some people pointed out below.
- justincormack 15y agoAs the other posters here were saying, wages for the young are already very low. The problems are more structural, as technological change is changing what skills are needed, and some countries like Spain just had a huge property boom so everyone was trained for the construction business, which was a complete waste of resources. Existing businesses may never hire these people, so a lot of new businesses are needed, which takes time and capital, and a startup culture that much of southern europe does not have much of. Emigration is the current solution for many people instead.
- yummyfajitas 15y agoAgain, economically speaking, the problem is austerity and wage stickiness put together. Austerity with nominal wage flexibility is fine - real wages will drop, employers will hire cheap employees, and there will be no unemployment or recession. Since austerity seems unavoidable, why aren't you and other people who buy into Keynesian theory pushing for wage flexibility?
- roc 15y agoBecause the US shows that wage flexibility by itself isn't particularly effective? US wages are just about as sticky as Europe's, despite a far lower (and dropping) section of the market under collective bargaining. So why tinker with that ball of wax and hope for the best when you can just set a moderate inflation target and achieve the same end result? Everyone knows what moderate inflation does. It's well studied and understood. People who work or put their money to work have little to fear from it (as rates of return reflect and include expected inflation). Naturally, you don't want high inflation or runaway inflation, but it's clearly possible to hit and maintain something like a 4% inflation target.
- yummyfajitas 15y agoBecause the US shows that wage flexibility by itself isn't particularly effective? In that case [1], Keynesian economics is wrong and we must discard it's conclusions. Absent Keynesian economics, we have no reason to believe austerity will cause "criminal levels of capital waste" (to borrow gizmo's language). So therefore, there are no drawbacks and we should pursue austerity. Right? [1] I don't actually believe this, I'm going along with it for the sake of argument. My actual view: the US did not cut the wages of government workers during the recession, nor did it reduce real wages (on the employer side) by cutting benefits (e.g., SS contributions, subsidies for health insurance, etc). In fact, during the current recession, the US increased wage stickiness by raising the minimum wage.
- roc 15y ago1. I don't think noting that flexibility doesn't overcome the stickiness of wages is enough to sink all of Keynesian economics. 2. There is no economic theory that has ever stood entirely on its original principles and made good predictions of how the economy works. Modifying and refining cases in response to real data is how all science progresses -- if I may be so bold as to suggest that economics could stand to borrow more habits from real science than the philosophy and morality that seems to have driven it for the last few decades. To your actual view: I'm not sure how much a small bump in the minimum wage increases wage stickiness over the economy. Very few workers actually earn the minimum wage, and the difference between the minimum wage and average wage is still quite large.
- andreadallera 15y agoJust to give you some perspective - in Italy ,unemployment among the young part of the population is around 35% and the ones who managed to find a work are usually underpaid to a point that it's basically impossible to afford a rent, even less buy a house. We're talking 700/900 eur a month here, for highly skilled people (engineers and such). I honestly have no idea how things will be fixed (hint: they will not be fixed) but certainly lower wages and higher unemployment are not an option unless you want the population to literally starve. Young people in Italy have been living off their parents for more than a decade now, if it weren't for them the vast majority of the population under 30 in Italy would be really really poor by now.
- yummyfajitas 15y agoBryan Caplan has a solution for the American poor, which would probably also work for Italians. He discusses it in his essay, "Let them get roommates". http://econlog.econlib.org/archives/2005/03/let_them_get_ro.html http://econlog.econlib.org/archives/2005/03/let_them_get_ro.... If wages were flexible, Italy would not have 35% youth unemployment. It would have 5% unemployment at considerably lower wages. Italy has a GDP per capita of $30k/year (PPP adjusted). That's very far from starvation. Even if wages drop to $10k/year, no one will "literally starve."
- andreadallera 15y agoWages are very flexible around here - most of young people don't have regular contracts, and already earn less than 10k/year. With no benefits, no insurance, no 401k.
- yummyfajitas 15y agoIn that case, according to Keynesian economics, Italy should have no unemployment. Wages should already have fallen so far that it is now profitable to hire workers. If Italy does have unemployment with flexible wages, then Keynesian economics must be wrong. In that case, you must agree that gizmo was wrong when he claimed "austerity...leads to...high unemployment...[etc]". Take it up with gizmo, not me - I'm not a Keynesian. I'm just asking why Keynesians don't follow their theories to their logical conclusions.