8 ms·
‘It's all bullshit’: Democrats unload on the crypto industry while hearings loom
- deleted 4y ago[deleted]
- sharemywin 4y agoThe only thing crypto had a shot at was bypassing regulations to get investment money. once that became illegal it pretty much lost it's legal use cases.
- sharemywin 4y agoand the problem from an investment vehicle is too much money flowed in too quickly so there's not much incentive to actually make the products work.
- quickthrowman 4y agoThere’s an easy solution, make it illegal to exchange cryptocurrency for dollars (and vise-versa) and the problem will solve itself. Crypto has no use case if you can’t convert to and from dollars.
- affgrff2 4y agoCan't you use it as a stand alone currency for the exchange of goods?
- bitxbitxbitcoin 4y agoYes. Even if every country in the world “banned” it. It would still be used as such.
- chitowneats 4y agoSo let me get this straight. I can't be paid in it, and I can't pay rent with it or buy groceries with it. Sure, there would be hobbyists who conduct trivial transactions with their monopoly money. But no, this would not even be a small fraction of overall economic activity in such a scenario.
- jjk166 4y agoNo, you can still be paid in it and still pay rent with it or buy groceries with it. You can't exchange a bitcoin for cash, but you can exchange bitcoin for something that has cash value.
- chitowneats 4y agoPlease let me know when the first ever major employer offers a paycheck in BTC, and when the first ever landlord offers rent payment in BTC. Oh, and most importantly. When the U.S. government will allow me to pay my taxes in BTC. Until then, this is a thought experiment. I'm not holding my breath.
- bitxbitxbitcoin 4y agoEmployers offering paycheck in BTC: https://www.coindesk.com/markets/2014/11/04/bitwage-now-lets-any-employee-get-paid-in-bitcoin/ https://www.coindesk.com/markets/2014/11/04/bitwage-now-lets... https://www.nyc.gov/office-of-the-mayor/news/041-22/mayor-adams-receive-first-paycheck-cryptocurrency https://www.nyc.gov/office-of-the-mayor/news/041-22/mayor-ad... Landlords offering payment in BTC: https://www.american-apartment-owners-association.org/property-management/marketing-vacant-units/apartment-listing-service-accepting-bitcoin-landlords/ https://www.american-apartment-owners-association.org/proper... U.S. government allowing you to pay taxes in BTC: you can take your btc and turn it into usd and pay taxes that way - and would need to on your capital gains. Lots of reading for you to do!
- chitowneats 4y agoSo do you considering that you missed that the entire premise of this thread was, "what happens if the U.S. government bans the exchange of BTC and dollars?". In that instance, bitcoin would lose nearly ~100% of its current market value due to anyone with a brain dumping it.
- infecto 4y agoOver the past N years since bitcoin came into being, I have yet to see a real use for exchange of goods that is running at scale. The cost to move coins/token has always been too high or the use was never at real scale.
- acdha 4y agoTheoretically but it’s a weak fiat currency with high overhead and no intrinsic value, and it’s risky for anyone to use if they are not complying with local law. There are very few cases where someone’s best option is to pay more to use bitcoin despite the drawbacks.
- BirAdam 4y agoNothing has intrinsic value as value is subjective. Things may have inherent human utility, but in the case of cryptocurrency, there is certainly utility. The true utility of a cryptocurrency is the blockchain itself as way to perform escrow, saving, spending, and transaction auditing without a human intermediary. Despite all of this, I will grant that so far it would seem that the financial and material costs of crypto are higher than the benefits lowering overall utility.
- acdha 4y ago> Nothing has intrinsic value as value is subjective. Yeah, yeah, and reality has no meaning because everything is subjective. That's great as a dorm-room topic at 4am but it's not a useful distinction here because there's a huge practical difference. Bitcoin uses random hashes which nobody cares about except to the extent that someone else will give them some tangible value in exchange for them. That's different from almost any other fiat currency because most of them are linked to a functioning economy and have some built-in demand where a government requires use for taxes, procurements, salaries, etc. Quality varies, of course, which is why some currencies are stronger than others but Bitcoin is an extreme outlier in the sense that almost nobody has any need to use it except when they think it's financially advantageous. This is why it's so volatile: someone who has purchased a lot of Bitcoin has an incentive to get other people to buy into the system so they can make money off of it but nobody else shares that reason. Using Bitcoin could make sense if it was cheaper but there are many alternatives and unless you have an ideological commitment you're most likely to pick whatever fits your preferred balance of easiness, cost, and safety. That could some day be Bitcoin but it hasn't been for the last decade and a half except in a few cases involving unusual circumstances.
- cjglo 4y agoIn fairness, all the businesses that currently accept it (at least in America) as a method of payment would likely stop accepting it if they couldn’t exchange it for dollars.
- np- 4y agoBanning is the "easy solution"--just as easy as banning alcohol, drugs, and gambling has been in the past. What banning money exchanges will do is 1) drive it underground to money exchanges being done by unsavory characters who have no issues committing crimes up to and including physical violence, 2) Drive up enforcement costs and create an entire police enterprise whose mandate and funding depend on hunting these unsavory characters, 3) Deprive Uncle Sam of any and all tax revenue from capital gains, etc, etc... I mean, all of this literally happened with alcohol, with cannabis, etc etc. Are we just going to keep repeating this cycle forever.
- TigeriusKirk 4y ago> Drive up enforcement costs and create an entire police enterprise This is a feature if you're the government.
- Nursie 4y agoThose other things are desirable in themselves. Cryptocurrency seems unlikely to fit the same mould.
- SlickNixon 4y agoWait until you find out what people buy with cryptocurrency.
- Nursie 4y agoSure, but at that point the cryptocurrency is a means to an end, not the end itself.
- SlickNixon 4y agoA buyer's intentions after the purchase of an illicit item have zero relevance to the evasion of law enforcement during the purchase itself.
- 4y ago
- bena 4y agoThat is an easy solution. But it's neither a feasible solution nor a good one. There are plenty of things that you currently can't legally exchange for dollars. But it happens.
- x86x87 4y agoIt always amazes me how trigger happy people are when it comes to banning things they don't like/don't agree with. Think about something that you like/strongly support getting banned. How would that make you feel? Did the gov try banning stuff in the past? How did that work out?
- starkd 4y agoWhatever people choose to place value in with their transactions cannot be easily regulated by banning it.
- deleted 4y ago[deleted]
- jjk166 4y agoThe whole point of cryptocurrencies is that they're not supposed to be converted to and from dollars - their use case is to bypass fiat currencies such as the dollar and more specifically the centralized institutions necessary to process transactions in fiat currency. If you sell goods or services for a bitcoin, you can buy a bitcoin worth of stuff. If bitcoin happens to be worth $15k, that means you can buy $15k worth of stuff, but the important thing is at no point in time do you need to convert your bitcoin into $15k.
- salawat 4y agoIf you are measuring the value of your BTC in USD, you already kinda lost there. Furthermore, you just handily stated cryptocurrency's true purpose, which is avoiding the modern world's curbs on the more destructive habits of unregulated finance. You are not painting yourself into a good corner with a lot of more normal people here.
- jjk166 4y agoI'm not measuring the value of BTC in USD, I clearly stated 1 bitcoin for 1 bitcoin worth of stuff. That stuff will invariably also have a USD value, and similarly a EUR value, and a Yen value, because that's how currencies work. And just as you can say a EUR is worth 1.05 USD, you can say a BTC is worth 15k USD. Yes, I stated bitcoin's purpose, but I said nothing about avoiding financial regulations. What I was referring to was ledger keeping. I am quite happy with the corner I'm in. May I ask why you are opposed to and seek to vilify something you don't use, understand, or are in any other way affected by?
- deleted 4y ago[deleted]
- Invictus0 4y agoCrypto has a use case, and that use case is money laundering. Go ahead and regulate that.
- dontbenebby 4y agoIt’s a PayPal killer :-)
- acdha 4y agoThe sad thing is that there’s a lot of interest in something like that. If people were building a better PayPal, however, it’d look less like a political manifesto and more like something with _better_ safety, performance, and pricing (rather than worse, as it currently is).
- syrrim 4y agoThey made that. It's called xmr.
- salawat 4y agoWhich as far as crypto goes, was unambiguously written out of the legal financial world since it's inception.
- dontbenebby 4y agoXMR is really interesting from a technical perspective, but I worry it’s not as anonymous as folks think.
- acdha 4y agoIf I need to pay a neighbor $10 for some random kid's stuff I'm buying from them, how much am I looking at net? Using PayPal that appears to be $0.78 cents. With Apple Cash, it's $0.15. I'm not saying there's no interesting technology going on but most normal people are going to go with the option which is cheapest unless it's a LOT harder to use.
- 4y ago
- jtode 4y agoI am Canadian and I don't follow the lower-level goings on with US politics habitually, but is Katie Porter still around? Cause I remember some fantastic video clips of her interrogating CEOs awhile back, and I would really like to see her turned loose on the bankman-fried while it's under oath. I'm cackling just thinking about it. I wanna see Katie Porter draw some blood on this one. Sorry if this is too opinionated to pass civility muster and I'm not usually much of a fanboy for political theatre, but if there's a place to buy tickets for the Katie Porter Crypto Show, I'm just sayin', I have money.
- mikeyouse 4y agoYep - she narrowly won reelection in November so she'll still be around, although since the Republicans won more seats in the House, she'll be in the minority now so she'll have less time and influence during hearings.
- nodesocket 4y agoDemocrats the party of hypocrites. Sure, we will happily take your millions of dollars in campaign contributions, but then pretend like there is no conflict of interest and sit on a pedestal of moral and intellectual superiority as we have hearings about crypto and the FTX meltdown.
- starkd 4y agoExactly. Once its clear there's no more donations to be had, all to ready to denounce it. On the other hand, you have to wonder if they are truly done with it, since SBF felt a little too comfortable answering questions, no real fear of prosecution.
- chollida1 4y agoIt should be noted that Sam admitted to giving equally to both Dems and Reps. This has nothign to do with one party or another. He said he gave publicly to Dems to get credit and via dark money to Reps due to reporters giving him a hard time about donations to republicans, which in of itself says alot about people these days:(
- JumpCrisscross 4y ago> Sam admitted to giving equally to both Dems and Reps Sam is a liar. What we know: he predominantly gave to Democrats, though he “also made maximum donations to many individual candidates, including Republican senators John Hoeven (R-N.D.) and John Boozman (R-Ark.)” [1]. Meanwhile, “Ryan Salame, a top Bankman-Fried lieutenant at FTX” gave “$19 million…to Republican candidates and committees, and made him the GOP's 10th-largest donor.” [1] https://www.axios.com/2022/11/15/ftz-crypto-bankman-fried-democrats-midterms-campaigns https://www.axios.com/2022/11/15/ftz-crypto-bankman-fried-de...
- gamblor956 4y agoSam originally denied giving any money to Republicans, until he discovered that political donations are publicly reported and he admitted to donating to Republicans. And that's around the time he stopped donating to Democrats and claims he started making untraceable donations to the GOP. The GOP Senate Leadership PAC admitted to receiving large dark money donations in the summer, so it's fair to say that SBF was one of these donors since the timing adds up.
- JumpCrisscross 4y agoI’m toying with advocating for a three-pronged approach: 1. An annual wealth tax on crypto holdings to fund (a) a victims’ compensation fund and (b) an enforcement agency; 2. Said enforcement agency, whose job is to manage the compensation fund and make referrals to the DoJ (no rulemaking authority); and 3. Reporting requirements for crypto transactions, crypto-fiat or DeFi, above $10k, individually or in aggregate. Civil fines for first time violators. Criminal referrals for repeat, large-scale violators. Also considering: SEC gets explicit jurisdiction over crypto and FinCEN over DeFi and mining. (I’ve toyed with extending liability to VCs, but that gets messy because it requires defining a crypto start-up, which is harder than defining crypto.)
- hackingforfun 4y agoI always appreciate reading your comments even though I don't necessarily agree with the position you take. However, I'm wondering, how would "1. An annual wealth tax on crypto holdings to fund (a) a victims’ compensation fund and (b) an enforcement agency;", make any sense? Why would someone who owns, say, Bitcoin, be required to pay a "wealth tax"? What is the rationale? Just because there are other people who use the Bitcoin system illegaly? If USD is used illegally, should everyone who holds USD pay a "wealth tax"? In terms of "3. Reporting requirements for crypto transactions, crypto-fiat or DeFi, above $10k, individually or in aggregate. Civil fines for first time violators. Criminal referrals for repeat, large-scale violators.", how do you propose reporting works for personal wallet addresses, or DeFi protocols? It seems to me like the implementation of that would be a nightmare, not to mention the concerns with privacy.
- JumpCrisscross 4y ago> If USD is used illegally, should everyone who holds USD pay a "wealth tax"? Don’t we? The FBI and Secret Service are funded out of taxes. I don’t think someone who has never touched crypto should pay for crypto crimes. One could introduce a transaction tax, but that seems messier than counting up your crypto once a year. > how do you propose reporting works for personal wallet addresses, or DeFi protocols? Same way it does with cash. Most people voluntarily comply. Criminals don’t, and occasionally get busted.
- idoubtit 4y agoIt's a strange read, because the article forgets to mention how crypto companies have influenced the politics in the USA with their money. The former FTX CEO claims he gave more than 1 b$ to Democrats, and the same amount to the Republicans (but anonymously). And that's just the legal donations, there were other activities, like invitations of influencial people to high-class event. I don't assert that some political representatives were bought, of course it can't happen in such a democracy with high moral standings, but maybe these billions of dollars had a purpose?
- JumpCrisscross 4y ago> maybe these billions of dollars had a purpose? Tens of millions, not billions [1]. Profligacy whose purpose seems to have been to convince retail investors he had an in on the Hill. Plenty of people spend tens of millions and buy nothing more than press and photo ops. Until we see evidence of policy pressure, I am concluding he was another rich numpty. [1] https://www.opensecrets.org/elections-overview/biggest-donors?cycle=2022 https://www.opensecrets.org/elections-overview/biggest-donor...
- eli_gottlieb 4y agoI do assert that political representatives can be bought, but of course they're not exactly going to stay bought when the industry goes bust and the checks stop coming in.
- nextaccountic 4y ago> anonymously How is this even possible? If political donations aren't attributed to the donor, couldn't foreign nations just donate too?
- asdajksah2123 4y agoForeign nations do donate to US politicians. I thought this was obvious. Ever since Citizens United (and more accurately, subsequent Supreme Court rulings which strengthened aspects of Citizens United), unlimited secret donations are not just possible, they're the norm.
- hodgesrm 4y agoIs the problem with crypto that it has no useful purpose or is it just riddled with fraud, like what happened at FTC? It's a useful thought experiment to consider how much faith we would have in the banking industry today if it were as poorly regulated as the crypto industry.
- JumpCrisscross 4y ago> problem with crypto that it has no useful purpose or is it just riddled with fraud It’s riddled with fraud. But so are other things. That it has no redeeming value makes the cost of crackdown palatable.
- salawat 4y agoThe "problem" with crypto is that it was specifically designed as anti-finance. Finance is a loaded term in the U.S. it's a composition of a few activities and responsibilities that you must fulfill to stay in business. You must firewall customer deposits. You must do OFAC. You must do KYC/AML. All of these responsibilities are tied to the act of money transmission. Keep in mind, money here is USD. Most "Crypto" tries to sidestep those extra responsibilities. You still do money transmission like activities and account management, but all that squicky social responsibility like maintaining transaction records, OFAC, KYC/AML, and sane institutional controls over customer assets? Naaaaaah. If you implemented constructs like Monero and Tornado.Cash in USD, and tried to operate, you would be shut down faster than you can say "FIN-wha?" The only reason crypto hasn't, is because the on-ramps to crypto-USD have largely been locked down/brought into compliance. The cryptocurrencies in play are treated more as commodities than currency, and the tooling to integrate financial surveillance of the public ledgers crawls forward as resources to handle it come into awareness at the institutional level. The old one about crypto speed running the history of finance applies. Every regulation they didn't bother implementing has proved that, yes, the regulation in trad fi is still, in a sense, justified.
- ChainOfFools 4y agoCrypto is an ideological position first, and a technology second (and only in a subordinate role as a framework for the ideological objective). So whether it is useful depends on how one feels about the tradeoff between highly efficient but potentially more oppressive centralization of public capital (the incumbent position), vs. ineluctably, stupendously inefficient but notionally less corruptable decentralization of public capital (this is the crypto-blockchain position). And notionally is pulling a heavy load here indeed, as we have seen time and again that cryptocurrency might as well be called kleptocurrency given the endless fiasco parade of rugpulls, outright fraud, concentration of the market's very thin real liquidity in a few hands (thus enabling Number Go Up chart puppetry), facilitation of rampant ransomware and extortion to the point of inflicting naked cruelty on innocent people, shutting down city services, hospitals and more.
- bubblematrix 4y agoIt's funny to watch how crazy Bitcoin drives everyone. Bitcoin was the hottest thing on IRC in 2009 because of the 2008 recession. The USD (and all other currencies) were becoming questionable in terms of stability. Bitcoin was meant to be a world-currency not tied to one government. Simple as that. Don't like Bitcoin? Don't believe in it? Don't use it or accept it at your business. I'll continue to use and accept it because I like the concept.
- deleted 4y ago[deleted]
- lern_too_spel 4y agoThat's like saying, "Don't like CFCs? Don't use them." It affects the rest of us with increased carbon emissions and increased fraud that we all have to pay for.
- deleted 4y ago[deleted]
- tdeck 4y agoWhen you accept it, do you price dynamically based on the value in fiat currency? I'm curious if there's anyone left not doing that these days.
- bubblematrix 4y agoYep, it grabs the latest price of Bitcoin for each invoice. A flat, non-dynamic price was cool when Bitcoin was under $100 (so "Starting at 0.1₿/mo")
- asdajksah2123 4y ago> Bitcoin was meant to be a world-currency not tied to one government. And yet the dumbest thing you could have done in 2009 is make a Bitcoin transaction. People who used their bitcoins for buying pizza ended up paying a mansion's worth of money for extra pepperoni. If the goal of Bitcoin was to be a currency it's a terrible one at that.
- kodyo 4y agoDemocrats are the least skeptical about fiat, so hey, why not denounce it.
- asdajksah2123 4y agoI do think crypto is all bullshit. And that's precisely why I think it should be completely unregulated. Stop trying to legitimize it. Stop spending FBI resources trying to recover money stolen from crypto accounts. If you want to spend law enforcement resources spend it on people who are running obvious scams like most of the exchange operators.