4 ms·
I think she knew what was going to happen, but I don't think she could've prevented it without lies (which would be found out quite quickly). I've seen people t
by jeroenhd 4y ago
I think she knew what was going to happen, but I don't think she could've prevented it without lies (which would be found out quite quickly). I've seen people talk around difficult questions, but this is something else.
Writing small novels in response to simple questions ("who owns the company", "in what countries are you a legal entity") was never going to work with the CA forum. It might work in corporate contexts where nobody has the time to read emails, but it only seems to have raised suspicions more in this mailing list.
When Serge Egelman came up with a plausible defence for why both the allegations and the responses to them could be true at the same time (the representative and the current employees actually being victims of a company set up in bad faith and left behind by government/bad actors) she becomes extremely defensive. The thinly veiled accusation of sexism definitely doesn't help their case at the very least.
I find this a very strange response by a CA representative, or a CA in general. If the company is actually the victim of something bad, it can definitely learn a thing or two about clear communication. I do like the way the paragraphs of her email was structured (in response to, prior context, actual answer), though.
- landswipe 4y agoThe response reads to me, like one big long white line.
- flir 4y agoIt's quite a funny example of corporate culture running headlong into geek culture, because in this case geek culture has the upper hand. I feel that in other circumstances, the geeks trying to get a straight answer would be labelled "difficult" and routed around.
- ethbr0 4y agoIt's not very amusing to me that geek culture can't handle objectively reading writing from a discipline other than their own. Imho, Matthew Hardeman makes the best point in the entire thread: "Something that yet again concerns me in this discussion is an issue that I touched on previously in the discussions related to Dark Matter: that unless the program is requiring transparency as to corporate governance and management/operations authority, and establishing a basis for trust and accountability at the level of those individuals empowered by participation in the program, I believe we will continue to see these subjective trust decisions again and again. [...] I once again humbly submit that I believe the executive and operational management teams of the CAs in the programs should be required to submit to the root program personal attestations as to their position and authority along with a commitment to inform the program promptly if anything has altered or replaced their authority. I believe there should be an explicit understanding that failures by such person(s) would be held against such person(s) individually and would bar their involvement at other trusted CAs for an indefinite period. I yet again advocate for a measurable standard for holding CAs accountable at the executive management / operations level with costs taxed upon those persons who have made commitments to the program and failed to honor them. It seems likely to me that one or more presently included CA could be reasonably described as owned by Blackrock or Vanguard. [...]"
- salawat 4y agoThis is why the CA "Web of Trust" model was dead on arrival, and we really should be doubling down on trying to render cryptography, and building personal trust networks approachable for the layman. That would upset far to many balances/be way too hard however.
- puffoflogic 4y agoI interpreted TrustCor's replies as sending up increasingly frantic "please route around!" signals and shock that this wasn't happening.
- flir 4y agoCan you expand on this take? I'm not sure I get it, and I'd like to.
- ikiris 4y agoEven now you can see in this thread some people going waaayyyy out of their way to try to pretend like this CA is an embattled party on an island and companies that aren't the CA don't matter even when they share entire officer structures, dev teams, etc. It's wild.
- chrisjc 4y ago> When Serge Egelman came up with a plausible defence I honestly feel like his explanation is likely, but she was in complete denial knowing how she's effectively left holding the bag. Is she and the company now in a better place having everything revoked but still standing by her assertions? or would it have been better accepting the possibility of what happened and instead tried to work with everyone involved? Serge was giving her rope to pull herself out of this hole and she just seemed to want to wrap it around her own neck instead...
- treis 4y ago>Writing small novels in response to simple questions ("who owns the company", "in what countries are you a legal entity") was never going to work with the CA forum >Unknown until recently by any employee officers of TrustCor we and Measurement Systems S de RL had in common a group of investors who represented funds (groups of companies and other funds), not individuals. Even though we shared a common group of investment funds, we have always operated our business independently of any other company and have exclusion provisions in place to protect the CA business from having access-to or being controlled by or influenced from any third-party, investors, equity-holders, or anyone other than TrustCor’s CA Approving Officials and employees. To the best of our knowledge (and our focused investigation) there is not and has never been shared ownership with any defense company or any USA company. This common group of investors with Measurement Systems S de RL. had already dissolved mid 2021, before these recent claims were publicized, meaning as a natural course of business and not as a reaction to any claims or adverse events. In 2021 TrustCor ownership was transferred from the initial investors/founders to the employees of TrustCor. The legal process has been very step-by-step and very slow, especially due to the protracted treatment and recent death of one key founder, Ian Abramowitz. Nonetheless, it is underway and irreversible, and the common investment vehicle was dissolved over a year ago. I'm not sure how that isn't a straightforward answer to a somewhat complicated situation in transition.
- ethbr0 4y agoYeah... I feel like a lot of people on HN are seeing a wall of text, not reading it, and jumping on the bandwagon. Don't fault a person for giving a comprehensive answer when you ask an important but complicated question. If people knee-jerk from that, that's a listener problem, not an answerer problem.
- zchrykng 4y agoThe thing is that it wasn't a comprehensive answer. It was a wall of text that attempted to appear like it was giving an answer while not actually clarifying anything. As a CA, even a hint of malfeasance should require in depth transparent answers. Not this legal BS peddling.