8 ms·
What are executive off-sites good for?
- throwaway2729 4y agoI feel that executive off-sites will be better discussing cultural/operational shifts the company should make in the coming year and perhaps broad themes for success rather than going deep because most people will just doze through it.
- triyambakam 4y agoAll hands off sites in "remote" companies are so often a way to make up for the ways the company has failed to implement a stable async remote culture. "Let's get together every quarter (!) to talk about all the things we can't figure out how to talk about remotely"
- ageitgey 4y agoI'm a cofounder of a start-up that is all remote but does quarterly get togethers (though attendance isn't required). I think that the software development team in general is ambivalent about them and happy to just work from home. But the other areas of the company seem to really enjoy getting together to socialize and interact with their co-workers once in a while. A lot of people want some level of human connection with the thing they spend the majority of their waking hours doing and really hate being isolated and never meeting their team in person. Preferences of course vary by personality, age/living situation, type of work, etc. So I think it's a little unfair to say that the only reason people have off-sites is because they can't figure out how to effectively work remotely. Different people like different things and need different things to get satisfaction from their job.
- drewcoo 4y agoYour paragraph about what people "seem to really enjoy" is just a restatement of the grandparent's "make up for the ways the company has failed to implement a stable async remote culture." Same substance; different spin.
- oblio 4y agoLet's be real here. People are different and software developers are notoriously asocial if not antisocial.[1] Their desires shouldn't be extrapolated to the general population, since even the most tech heavy company will at point need to have HR, sales folks, marketing folks, recruiters, program managers, project managers, on site consultants, technical writers, etc, etc, etc. [1] On average, this is based on anecdata from my personal experience and tons of discussions with folks, reading books, blog posts, etc.
- bin_bash 4y agoI've been working remote for nearly a decade and find quarterly offsites super helpful. Things like brainstorming about loosely defined problems and just getting to know your colleagues happen at a rapid pace vs remote. They don't need to be "all-hands" though, the way I've seen it done that I like is 2 offsites with my direct team and potentially 1 more to team up with, 1 offsite with cousin teams, then 1 offsite with a much larger group—maybe the entire company. In fact this is something I ask about in interviews: I find quarterly to be the ideal balance between being productive at work and not being away from my family too much. I used to want to meet more (before I had a family) but I learned to make a list of the people I want to talk to and the conversations I want to have ahead of time which really helps me make the most of our short time together.
- kevstev 4y agoTbh, in a remote company, I would call this an "on-site" even if you don't have a home office to go to. My previous company, we did the fully remote thing pre-pandemic and had a good culture, but I found meeting up once a quarter was really effective. Reasons why: 1- No one has solved the remote whiteboarding problem. There is nothing quite like a few people sitting around a whiteboard, drawing pictures, looking in the whites of each others eyes to see if they really understand, and debating the tradeoffs. You can simulate this remotely, but its just not nearly as effective in my experience. In general, I found that about once every 3 months we would have a pile of problems and things we are seeing as potential problems on the horizon that we want to brainstorm on how to fix in a way that chat did not facilitate well. In fact, I would send out a list of these items ahead of time so we could deliberate on them and then present ideas. Things like: "We seem to be generating a lot of metrics that cost a lot of money to store and we only use them when debugging thorny problems- how do we try to make these smaller/more useful?" 2- Text communication is great to a point, but sometimes perceived slights can build up, or maybe someone's communication style is just off putting to you, and you start to build up animosity or perceive there to be animosity that just isn't there. Breaking the ice by just talking to the person in person almost always makes that friction go away. 2a- Often you work with someone and may think they are not performing, or not very smart, or an **hole or whatever, and sitting next to them for a day or two makes you empathetic to their situation as you see how many times they are getting pinged by other teams/people. Sometimes sitting next to them makes you realize they really are a problem and you can start focusing on your efforts on routing around that. 3- It lets you get to know people socially. I find that as we move into an ever more surveilled environment, just talking over slack becomes an ever more fraught endeavor. Discussions about the difficulties your kids may be giving you or the fact that you had a little too much fun last weekend are now archived and mineable for more or less forever. It just puts a real damper on making a connection with your team mates. I have a real example of this at the end of this post. 4- Its fun? Getting away roughly once every three months and spending time face to face, in a new city, is generally pretty enjoyable. We would try to do a different region each time so that no one was stuck traveling a far distance all the time- and in the cold winter months, we would try to go to a warmer location, and vice versa. The ability to socialize with coworkers outside of coworkers was always enjoyable for me. Real example of socializing on work channels gone bad: At a fairly brutal place I worked at during the pandemic, which reluctantly allowed remote work, I was chit chatting with a coworker I was friendly with, and mentioned how I had had to work the previous three weekends, which was really grating on me, and I had pushed back on checking out another change the upcoming weekend because I needed a "Mental health weekend." This got flagged by some system, next thing you know I am getting a call from my boss asking if everything is ok, and he wouldn't admit at the time, but they were actively surveilling our messages and looking for stuff like this amongst other things mostly related to IP theft, insider trading, etc.
- frugalmail 4y agoA colossal time and money waste.
- _8j50 4y agoYes, I would like to see the budget items they deny lol
- simonebrunozzi 4y agoIn my experience, they shouldn't be about work at all. It should be a bonding experience. Better if there is a non-work task to be solved, or to work for, together. Alternatively, make it leisure. Everything else is mostly BS.
- _8j50 4y agoAs a technical person, I bond by working with someone and talking about technical stuff during the course of our work. Forced social activity has always alienated me from coworkers because I can't relate with people that want to talk about their personal lives or sports or whatever and I suck at pretending. I would take a pay cut for a company that promises to not force this shit on me.
- cannonpr 4y agoI would try saying not engaging in the forced social activity, find a quiet corner with people you like and do what works for you. I used to think I couldn’t get away with it. Years later I appreciated as long as you don’t flaunt it, people are very accommodating.
- drewcoo 4y agoSame here. And you know what? I usually know the names of coworkers' significant others, children, and pets. And what their favorite foods are. And some hobbies and interests. Because those just come up in the course of work even when it's not forced. Especially if meeting with people is through a videoconference window into their homes.
- ryanbrunner 4y agoI think what works really well for these sorts of offsites is to make leisure activities really flexible and let people self-select. We went to one where you could absolutely go to a bar if you wanted, or go hiking with some other folks, or play boardgames with another, etc. There was probably a soft expectation that you were doing something to socialize, but it wasn't a dictated activity, and frankly if some people wanted to code something with a group that wasn't 100% part of a regular days work that would have probably been fine too.
- totetsu 4y ago> "Ensuring that senior leaders feel like they are" important successful people. Why not cut things like this and give better compensation to regular employees..
- _8j50 4y agoI will settle for just cutting this stuff out.
- passwordoops 4y agoClearly you've never taken a big-brained leadership course for big-brained business leaders
- achenet 4y agoum, because the people making that decision are executives?
- specialist 4y agoOne gig, we'd be punished for a job well done with regular trips to Las Vegas. New hire me skipped my first such event. Big political faux pas. I hate company parties. I especially hate Las Vegas (The Strip, gambling, drinking, etc). Just give me cash.
- iamflimflam1 4y agoThey are a good way for companies to indicate to employees who the are the nobles and who are the peasants...
- hef19898 4y agoAdded benefit, off site execs have less opportunity to get in the way and mess up things as long as they are occupied with leisure and playing politics.
- _8j50 4y agoI hate this shit so much. It's like the kids that enjoyed homework all became executives and are imposing their will.
- quickthrower2 4y agoI am suspect of any strategic planning whose timing is based on the position of the earth relative to the sun. It should be continuous. However focused offsite to solve a specific business issue can be very useful. They might be managers only or everyone depending on the need.
- nieksand 4y agoI think periodic off-sites (or on-sites in the era of remote) are incredibly valuable even without a specific business issue to address. It's easy to say that strategic thinking and planning should be continuous, but in reality there's always a storm of immediate tactical tasks sucking up your attention. That's true for both software engineers (living in Jira tickets, sprints, and one-to-two quarter projects) and the c-suite. These sessions can force you to make time, put aside the tactical noise, and think.
- quickthrower2 4y agoThat is true! And I get it that calendar years are easier to get your head around (2023 plan rather than specific dates). By continuous I mean end of year shouldn’t be to special, you could have a rolling plan and amend it every month with offsite when it is felt that brainpower is needed and especially more grassroots input is needed.
- beckingz 4y agoThere is some utility to having fixed length formal"Plan - Execute - Review" cycles. Usually these don't match the day to day near continuous work enough to be useful, but so it goes.
- smarri 4y agoI prefer the idea of a solo offsite better. Well, something between an offsite and a holiday. A time to think deeply about your business / market / customers / future, whatever it is.
- passwordoops 4y agoMy funniest experience as a pleb on the other end of an executive off-site working in product was being handed a detailed roadmap for the following year, which I had no input on and was politely told to shut up when I raised concerns about it. Specifically why wasn't "Big Feature X" that's been a point of emphasis for the past 4 months and that you made a big deal about being a top priority when I was hired missing from the roadmap? Nope, my job was to "deliver" not to ask questions. Three (3!) weeks later, after adjusting the teams workload to focus on the new roadmap in conjunction with the Head of Engineering and getting approval on the new plan from the CTO, CFO and VP Sales I get called into a meeting with the CTO, CFO, CEO,, COO, VP Sales, and Head of Engineering, aka the group of Big Brained Leaders who came up with the roadmap that I was responsible for delivering but not allowed to comment on. They then began to attack me over "Big Feature X" - why is it not there, when can we deliver it, how it's my job to define the roadmap and it's unacceptable that we don't have "Big Feature X"...
- deleted 4y ago[deleted]
- hnrodey 4y agoRecently, I've been breaking into upper management and now that I've seen just how messy it is/was this is a completely believable story. Crazy stuff. As I continue in my career will be interested to see if different organizations handle that better at upper management or is it just the proverbial shit show everywhere you go.
- passwordoops 4y agoYeah I flirted but after that experience I moved on to a couple of other places and started to pay closer attention. Trying to be a competent higher-up is not worth the headaches. I'm happy to find my niche at a place that pays well, delivering just enough to whatever higher up is asking for it so people stay happy with my performance to say "he's a good guy!". Side projects are where I get my personal sense of accomplishment these days
- garciasn 4y ago
- MrPatan 4y agoSpending money that would be wasted on the shareholders anyway
- thenerdhead 4y agoThey're good for teaching a McKinsey 3 horizons model and realizing you're stuck on horizon 1 for 5+ years because you never cared to get input from the line who actually does the work and has something to say. A team off-site is infinitely more valuable at the same cost including more people and less BS consultant frameworks. What really should happen is after these off-sites, a cross-comparison is made and executives can get reality checks that work aligns or it doesn't. That way there's no surprises when people start leaving or nothing gets done because too much is expected in a just do it fashion.
- passwordoops 4y agoTotally makes sense and is exactly what I would want from an off-site. Unfortunately a good chunk of today's leadership class is anathema to taking responsibility, which is required for this to work.
- cephaslr 4y agoWhen I was at Google in the bay area almost a decade ago and, unless my memory is heavily exaggerating, the executives of our org were in an offsite every three weeks for at least a year working on 'strategy'. It became a meme at the time among us lower ranks and I was amazed at the excess. There was no noticeable output from all those offsites and as an org we failed to execute on anything successful. I have had a low opinion of offsites ever since and have wondered if other people thought so as well or it was just me being cynical.
- theGnuMe 4y agoGoogle a decade ago would have been chrome, chrome os, chromebooks, android? Or maybe those happened earlier?
- codexjourneys 4y agoIt would be interesting to see long-term results of off-sites in which a company's executives and an equal number of long-tenured average-performing and high-performing employees gather to share and learn from each other, with follow-up on-site meetings to experiment and execute afterward. I have never encountered an off-site like this, but if you have, how did it go?
- SteveSmith16384 4y agoI've googled it for at least 2 minutes and I'm still trying to work out what an "executive off-site" actually is. A big meeting? An away-day?
- passwordoops 4y agoThe C-suite and VPs go to a resort or someone's cabin for a few days to talk about business strategy
- nprateem 4y agoI think you mean they put the idea cows out to pasture and drive some virtual infomediaries
- passwordoops 4y agoSo you've been to several, I see. Did you successfully subvert the paradigm shift to deliver transformative innovation in a black-box containerized interface?
- marcus0x62 4y agoI think you and nprateem need to circle back and have a quick sidebar to collaborate on strategic initiatives to inspect his/her ability to move the needle in terms of the paradigm shift to ensure the organization can gain leverage from efficiencies across the various stakeholders. Be sure to keep me looped in, but I’ll be OOO this week and won‘t have the bandwidth to discuss until our next touchpoint. —— Sent from my iPad
- matwood 4y agoPeople typically think of them as extravagant trips, but not always the case. When we did them we would go to one of the members houses nearby for the day twice/year after the prior 2Qs financials settled. We would deep dive into how the business was doing and make sure big picture strategy was still on point. For us anyway, it was the only time to get us all in a room without interruption for a day.
- hgsgm 4y ago
- ryanbrunner 4y agoThe last executive offsite I went to was with a company that had a severe problem with focus - we were always chasing 10 trends at once and never really accomplishing any of them. The main output of the offsite is that we came up with a list of around 30 different things that were essential to nail in the next year. The 30th? "Relentless prioritization"
- kneebonian 4y agoThe Dilbert comics write themeselves
- mandelbrotwurst 4y agoInteresting, any idea why? Did the executives struggle to focus individually or only as a collective?
- ren_engineer 4y agonobody gets praised for shooting down other people's ideas or saying "lets do less". Everybody has their own pet idea that will surely bring in a bunch of money so more and more stuff just gets added to the list
- goopthink 4y agoAt my last company, this was so common and painful that towards the end of my tenure we started using a “No” roadmap, which was a list of things we would explicitly not do. Shooting down an idea is hard but sometimes people would go around and try to get a team working on it anyway as hidden work.
- goopthink 4y ago“When Everything Is Important and Nothing Is Getting Done” -> https://sharedphysics.com/everything-is-important/ https://sharedphysics.com/everything-is-important/ Traditional prioritization is a broken process for most people.
- nickstinemates 4y ago
- kneebonian 4y agoExecutive Off-Sites are good for paying for a luxury all expense paid trip for the executives where they can go ahead and have affairs without their wives being around.
- nickstinemates 4y agoevery exec offsite i have been to has been the exact opposite of what you describe here.
- stevecalifornia 4y agoThis site is basically Reddit now. Really stupid comments from people with no insight.
- d_e_solomon 4y agoSo there is lots of grouchiness in this thread. Maybe I'll try and give some comments on how these can be productive. I'm in a remote working firm that provides IT services. We get together as a leadership team once a quarter to review what was and wasn't completed the previous quarter; review operations metrics, discuss changes in the business environment; and build the plan for the next quarter. On a yearly basis, we do a bigger strategy session to really think about our marketing position, our offerings, our competitors and so on. The fancy strategy so to speak. It's good for the group to be in person as the conversations can get difficult at times and it's easier to have them without having to mediate through Zoom. We also use it as a chance to do relationship building and to handle some tactical issues that need a hand. We don't do go anywhere fancy - we usually rent a conference room offsite as our office doesn't have a lot of conference space. Implementing these sessions has led to much better execution overall against our plans.
- smcg 4y agoyou're small enough that you can't get away with wasting money on lavish expenses and executives retaining their power.
- d_e_solomon 4y agoYes, we're about 100 people in total with a leadership team of sevenish. Adding the regular offsites has actually increased accountability and ferreted out who is effective and who is not; and ended tolerance for those who are not.
- ElfinTrousers 4y agoMy off-the-cuff answer would be something like "they give people who work for a living a valuable chance to do so without interference while the management are off somewhere else".