6 ms·
We tend to object to people considering it normal to track us. Regardless of means.
by nottorp 4y ago
We tend to object to people considering it normal to track us. Regardless of means.
- dahfizz 4y agoThis is not tracking. Could you explain why you think it is?
- fanso99 4y agoStoring a cookie with a counter still requires consent afaik. If I am right, then this technique is not sufficiently different and also requires consent.
- robertlagrant 4y agoWhy would that require consent?
- chriswarbo 4y agoConsent is always required; even if you just give people a random UUID, with no associated session/etc., that always requires consent. There is a separate question, of whether consent is implied. If the identifying information is required to provide the user with a service they requested (e.g. a cookie for their online shopping cart), then consent is implied; no need to ask.
- Hnrobert42 4y agoGiving a random UUID and giving someone a counter is significantly different. This is not identifying and thus does not require consent.
- Hnrobert42 4y agoI don’t think this would require consent. It is not, as described in the post, uniquely identifying. It is not even pseudononymous. Thus, it is not personal data and does not require consent.
- nottorp 4y agoCould you explain why i should care, considering the current climate online? When you try to cram a list of 500 "legitimate interests" down my throat, I will consider no interest as legitimate. No matter what your goals are, you're in an industry that has zero trust these days.
- dahfizz 4y agoWithout viable alternatives, sites will continue to use Google Analytics. If people like you fear-monger every alternative, sites will continue to use Google Analytics. The method described in the article collects no personal data, collects no identifiable data, and is objectively more user-respecting than Google Analytics. But the behavior by people like you will help make sure that these alternatives don't gain traction and Google maintains their monopoly.
- EGreg 4y agoNot only that. The ability to track your own visitors is BUILT INTO how the web operates. All a site has to do is include analytics in its server-side library. And that’s it. Doesnt even need CNAME cloaking. It can send the analytics anywhere. The thing ITP and others try to stop is tracking users ACROSS sites. But if you use single-sign-on with FB or any other service, they can get your public photo, name and just find you on faceboon thru some search engine that spidered all profiles. So if you really want to be anonymous, stop using the single sign on and reusing passwords etc.
- ohbtvz 4y agoBut google analytics isn't viable. It's illegal to use in the EU. Here's an explanation by, well, a viable alternative to google analytics: https://matomo.org/blog/2022/05/google-analytics-4-gdpr/ https://matomo.org/blog/2022/05/google-analytics-4-gdpr/ (I don't have a horse in this battle - my personal website doesn't have analytics at all.)
- stalfosknight 4y agoHow about we just stop tracking users and hoovering up private data?
- xapata 4y agoWho's "we"? I don't mind it. I want advertisers to give me more relevant advertising.
- dspillett 4y agoDepends how you define relevant. Since actively trying to block stalky advertising behaviours I've had more interesting adverts (by “interesting” I mean new-to-me, not the “do you want another one of the thing you've already bought all you need of for a while” types). Things are relevant enough if, for instance, I get running related adverts while reading an article about other runners or browsing shoes. In my experience the stalky behaviour doesn't improve the advertising relevance from my PoV, so the fact it means that all that derived information, some of it definitely PII, is out there so should anyone be able to hack into it they could use it for fraudulent purposes (identity theft, spear-fishing my contacts, …), makes the situation lose-lose for me. It is worse for other people, as they have information that advertisers like to derive that might be extra sensitive. Being white, male, cis, middle-class, ete, with a life not interesting enough for there to be much to convincingly blackmail or threaten me about, living in western Europe, I'm pretty safe, but this can't be said for others especially in certain parts of the world (scarily religious ruled countries with bad records on individual rights, like Qatar and America to give two examples).
- xapata 4y agoI think you're conflating two different kinds of surveillance. The article is incrementing a counter to track the number of unique visitors. If one is worried about blackmail or violence, especially from a government, then one should take precautions beyond complaining about the prevalence of browser cookies. Modern life, carrying a mobile internet device with GPS service, using a credit card, and going to places with security cameras, presents a variety of surveillance methods.
- dspillett 4y agoI was replying to the, well, the comment I replied to, rather than the counter method that started the thread. That post was anecdata about not minding being tracked, mine was anecdata regarding why I prefer we would not be. > especially from a government Where I to live in a regime like I mentioned above, I'd be as worried about vigilantism as much as government action. > presents a variety of surveillance methods. Fair point, but I see a difference between choosing to take a risk and companies trying to follow me around whether I want them to it not. Maybe it is my monkey brain that grew up noticeably before such tech was ubiquitous, said brain having been taught that being followed was at best a bit creepy!
- lolinder 4y agoCounting is not the same as tracking. The technique proposed would in most cases be useless for trying to distinguish individuals, much less identify them. It's the computer equivalent of the person standing out in front of Costco with a clicker counter.
- bawolff 4y agoWhy would it be useless? Just pick a random date for each user.
- lolinder 4y agoI'm not talking about what you could theoretically do with cache headers, I'm talking about what the author of the article is actually doing.
- bawolff 4y agoIts not like that is a far walk though. Its the exact same technique, just storing different data. Respectfully i feel like this would be like seeing an example of css turning a page blue and claiming the technique is useless for turning the page red because that is not the specific example used.
- lolinder 4y agoIf a bunch of people got up in arms and started complaining because the author of said CSS example hadn't considered that their code could be changed slightly to produce a hate symbol, I'd definitely still jump in and say "but that's not what they were doing!"
- bawolff 4y agoThe original claim was "technique proposed would in most cases be useless" Technique does not mean precisely what the person was doing just their method. Their technique has very obvious applications to user tracking.