3 ms·
> Mortgage bankers and real-estate agents say the new limits are needed to reflect higher home prices. Before we do this, how about we outlaw non-resident owne
by neilv 4y ago
> Mortgage bankers and real-estate agents say the new limits are needed to reflect higher home prices.
Before we do this, how about we outlaw non-resident ownership of 1-3-family homes? Won't that mean prices will go/slow down, and more people will be able to afford to be homeowners? Without the government stuffing more taxpayer money into the pockets of bankers and Realtors.
- bigyikes 4y agoHow would this work in practice? Could renters afford to buy the homes they live in when their landlords are no longer legally allowed to own them?
- thebradbain 4y agoI mean, if corporate landlords legally were not allowed to own them, then supply would absolutely skyrocket as homes flood the market. Potentially to the point where they worth pennies on the dollar, as otherwise wealthy individuals would also be reaching the 2-3 home cap (with home prices so low, why not!) Of course, this would also decimate the entire sector as a store of wealth, which, while some may consider that good (and I am partial to the view that a home is first a place to live than an investment), in the short term it would definitely have the effect of wiping out most middle class wealth, which is tied up in the primary/only home. Then there’s also the problem you would likely see absolutely no units built in high demand areas, since the math wouldn’t pencil out until some sort of equilibrium was found.
- neilv 4y agoIt could be phased in over time. Start by halting new acquisitions, then gradually undo the very recent boost due to institutional and foreign investors. But don't drag it out so long that billion-dollar conspirators have more chances to buy a reversal of legislation.
- replygirl 4y agoa clause for immediate reclamation of non-resident-owned properties through eminent domain would all but guarantee a ruling that the legislation is unconstitutional. current landlords would certainly be grandfathered in and, if we're lucky, maybe new leases would be banned and existing tenants would be guaranteed right to purchase units at appraisal. it'd be a similar story for non-resident investors without tenants, except in their case they'd be entitled to hold indefinitely.
- maxerickson 4y agoJust tax em, no need to seize anything. People aren't going to stay invested in things that are clearly going to lose them money on an ongoing basis. You can even phase it in over time. That said, I think working on creating more housing is a better idea than making a bunch of rules about who can own existing housing.
- thebradbain 4y agoI agree building is the only way out, I just think it’s a fun (but absurd) thought experiment
- orangecat 4y agoPotentially to the point where they worth pennies on the dollar People have to live somewhere. If you're renting and this insane policy gets enacted, you now need to buy something or you'll be out on the street. So supply increases, but demand increases by the same amount.
- thebradbain 4y agoNo one is arguing the policy isn’t insane, I’ll be the first to admit it is. It has a million other problems to it, but it would absolutely cause dramatic price reductions: if everyone was limited to 1-2 units nationally (let’s say 1 home/unit in high demand cities), then there would absolutely be more supply than demand. A 400 unit apartment building where the landlord legally must sell 399 units (or all 400 assuming they have other properties), repeated en masse throughout the city, would truly see there being more units on the market than buyers, because a) investors and high net-worth individuals would not be able to buy, as they would be having to sell off to get under the legal cap b) the only available buyers would thus be those who are under the limit of the housing cap, i.e. renters, which are mostly those who could not afford a home at the previous prices in the area Considering the legal onus would be on the previous owners to sell per this insane law, sellers would rather make $100k>$10k>$1k than $0 and so there would be a rush to sell, exherting immediate downward prices on homes. In San Francisco, which is a city where >66% rent where they live (and thus <33% of the city owns the whole housing stock), you would see a giant flood of homes hit the market that the existing landed gentry would be unable to snap up, equalizing around a 100% live-own rate (because, again, once you buy one unit you can’t buy another, no matter how cheap it is)
- replygirl 4y agobetter yet, we could free housing from market dynamics (nearly) altogether by outlawing non-resident ownership of any residential property to force widespread adoption of cooperatively-tenant-owned CLTs, and requiring that residential construction be done by unionized co-ops. neither of us are suggesting realistic goals for legislation though
- JumpCrisscross 4y ago> how about we outlaw non-resident ownership of 1-3-family homes? In countries that do this, you wind up with every daughter, cousin and nephew of the wealthy owning title to property. As this shifts the "true" ownership level to a customary, versus legal, plane, extrajudicial dispute resolution becomes commonplace.
- willio58 4y agoThis is still better. The house is not in one persons name. Of course if someone puts their house in your name they’re hoping they have full control over it, but they do not and it’s up to the owner to do with it what they want.
- imtringued 4y agoWe must end this travesty. All wealth belongs to the first born son.
- ZoomerCretin 4y agoThere are too few houses available. You can't redistribute your way out of a supply shortage. The solution is to build more homes, not change who can own them.
- BurningFrog 4y agoHousing prices are fundamentally set by the relationship between supply and demand. Changing the ownership status of some of the supply doesn't change those numbers. Any price effect will be very marginal.
- kelnos 4y agoI don't think we can safely assume that everyone who is renting a single-family home can afford to buy one, even if prices were to crash somewhat due to a policy like this being enacted. You might say "oh well, that's a shame, but they can move into an apartment", and, well, yes, that is indeed strictly true, but I don't think that's particularly fair. Now, if we can solve the problem where anyone who can afford to rent the home they live in could also afford to buy it, then sure, let's do this. Not sure that's a tractable problem at this time, though.