2 ms·
I appreciate the philosophical and legal concerns over compelled speech. If the government forces a private company to host and serve unwanted content then that
by nradov 4y ago
I appreciate the philosophical and legal concerns over compelled speech. If the government forces a private company to host and serve unwanted content then that does infringe on their free speech rights.
However, in US federal law we have carved out a narrow exception for "common carriers". A telephone company can't disconnect your calls just because you're making offensive political statements or spreading medical misinformation. Some politicians and legal scholars such as Supreme Court Justice Clarence Thomas have suggested that Congress extend common carrier legislation to also cover social media platforms.
https://www.npr.org/2021/04/05/984440891/justice-clarence-thomas-takes-aims-at-tech-and-its-power-to-cut-off-speech https://www.npr.org/2021/04/05/984440891/justice-clarence-th...
- owisd 4y agoI think the common carrier argument might work if the major platforms just showed you posts from the accounts you follow in reverse chronological order, but when they’re algorithmically promoting and recommending specific posts it’s more akin to readers’ letters in a newspaper, which doesn’t have any common carrier rule, they’re not obliged to print your letter and can be held accountable for the contents of letters they do print.