4 ms·
Besides being an amazing technical achievement, I find this very interesting legally, as it further blurs the line between passively viewing content hosted some
by lxgr 4y ago
Besides being an amazing technical achievement, I find this very interesting legally, as it further blurs the line between passively viewing content hosted somewhere and redistributing/actively sharing content.
Have there already been cases of websites making their visitors unwitting peers, similar to e.g. JavaScript cryptocurrency mining?
- mk_stjames 4y agoMy first thought was like "Oh, this is like CryptoJacking a browser window but for file storage instead". Of course, it is technically amazing, and pretty neat that this is possible at all, and could have some very interesting edge-use-cases.
- klabb3 4y agoWell spotted. In other words, WebRTC lets a site owner have their visitors distribute content directly to others without their knowledge or consent, basically making it impossible to argue that the distributor has intent to do so in the general case. That said, it was already highly questionable for legal application, since a torrent client can run on any machine connected to a home wifi, including guests and compromised machines. It may have been enough for a "hey, you're breaking our tos, please check your devices" from the ISP, but should never have been more than that (like threatening letters from rights-holders).
- _def 4y agoI totally agree, that's how it should be. In reality right now there are countries in which you get cease and desist letters and a ~800 Euro fine for even a short amount of seeding. This is a cool technology but also allows more automation in this shady industry and laws will take years and years to follow up.
- 6510 4y agoclicking a link wouldn't count, I mean, what link? oh, now you are seeding too?
- googlryas 4y agoAlong those lines, Comcast/Xfinity for example has a defaultish setting on their routers to leave an open guest network available. If I connect to my neighbors guest network and download game of thrones, will my neighbor get the nastygram, or is it smart enough to know it is a guest network? Should I connect to my own guest network (not that I have it enabled) if I want to do illegal things?
- ocdtrekkie 4y agoThe xfinitywifi network requires you log your device into a Comcast account. It's not strictly a "guest network" for arbitrary devices, it's more of a roaming access to your own account. Pretty sure they can nail you even harder for piracy on this than on your own network where it might be someone else's device.
- throwaway82028 4y agoNot only does it require login, but it is not like they are giving you full bandwidth. Good luck to anyone trying to do a lot of high-bandwidth downloads over an Xfinity guest network.
- googlryas 4y agoEvery one I've ever connected to gave you free access for a new account for some limited period of time. But that was like 5+ years ago so maybe they've changed it.
- lxgr 4y agoUsually, these CPE guest networks have their traffic routed via an IP different from the main customer one, and have their own bandwidth/QoS class as well.
- TylerE 4y agoIntent isn’t always nessesary for a conviction. Child porn comes instantly to mind.
- zuminator 4y agoIntent is a necessary element for that charge, at least on the US Federal level. But in any case, completely accidental possession is a defense, meaning, if you have something in your possession without even knowing that it's in your possession, that can be presented as a defense to charges. That would likely be the same when it comes to being an unwitting distributor of copyrighted material via a stealth torrent. Similarly we don't prosecute individuals whose computers are infected with viruses that propagate (and thus illegally access and trespass onto other systems) without the person's knowledge.
- TylerE 4y agoIn theory, sure. But I’ve read enough horror stories. The reputational damage of even being charged is immense.
- mahathu 4y agoDo countries other than Germany also have dedicated, famous [1] legal agencies sending out cease and desist letters and suing for damages (~900€) as soon as you accidentally seed a compromised torrent for even a few seconds? [1]: https://de.wikipedia.org/wiki/Frommer_Legal https://de.wikipedia.org/wiki/Frommer_Legal
- bdhcuidbebe 4y agoIn Sweden that happened for a year, then it stopped. Just refuse to pay abd deny all.
- autoexec 4y agoIn the US the ESA RIAA and MPA hire out several different third parties (some of which they have very close ties with) to do that kind of work on their behalf. They include companies like Rightscorp, Vobile, OpSec, or PML Process Management Mostly they just threaten people with lawsuits in order to get settlement money from folks who may even be fully innocent, but who cannot afford to fight against an international media empire in court. Lawsuits against random users are less common than they were, but still happen. The bigger issue is that the media industry has been pressuring ISPs to permanently disconnect users after nothing more than repeated unproven accusations of copyright infringement. ISPs who fail to close these accounts risk being fined billions of dollars, so anyone in the US who has been getting DMCA notices from their ISP should take steps to prevent that or else they're risking getting disconnected which is a problem for those without many options for high speed internet access. Permanently cutting people off from the internet over nothing but accusations seems very extreme, but the media industry has already taken several ISPs to court for not doing it and so far they are winning.
- BlueTemplar 4y agoThat's why for a decade already the law around here punishes you not so much for seeding, but specifically for failing to secure your Internet connection to prevent seeding (regardless of who actually seeded).
- consumer451 4y agoI am on a 200GB capped residential LTE internet connection. Upload is included in that data cap. If this was surreptitiously deployed that would cost me money and generally be not cool.
- nashashmi 4y agoSeems like the browser should warn of a webRTC connection coming from the site.
- lxgr 4y agoAs far as I know, Safari is doing something along these lines already (I believe WebRTC connections only work there after requesting camera or microphone permissions). An explicit permission would be nicer, possibly ("this site is requesting to establish direct connections" or similar).
- dzhiurgis 4y agoSounds like a job for an adblocker
- nashashmi 4y agoIs it? An adblocker blocks content. Controlling invasive technologies like camera use or file browsing cannot be realistically achieved by an adblocker.
- speedgoose 4y agoThankfully internet innovation doesn’t stop because a few people have terrible internet service providers.
- woah 4y agoWhile there are definitely some terrible ISPs out there, not every instance of someone not being able to use as much bandwidth as they want is a great injustice. Sometimes it’s just sane network management. LTE networks in particular are limited in capacity. There are a bunch of different ways to limit use with different tradeoffs, and bandwidth caps actually strike a good balance between effectiveness and predictability. I have a lot of experience thinking about and implementing bandwidth pricing models, and I don’t have time to list all the options and their tradeoffs here, but you can suggest one you think is better if you want. Bandwidth caps cause users to limit their use, while still allowing a user to use the network heavily without penalty when they need to. The real problem here is that OP doesn’t have an intuitive UX for limiting upload bandwidth to something he is comfortable with. Webtorrent then breaks his assumption that web browsing will not incur upload bandwidth.
- Findecanor 4y agoI know there has been unwitting peer-to-peer live streaming of video, but that is not exactly the same as it did not involve file storage. I think BBC, among others, have experimented with that.
- autoexec 4y ago> Have there already been cases of websites making their visitors unwitting peers, similar to e.g. JavaScript cryptocurrency mining? I haven't seen it yet in websites, but I have seen video streaming apps using torrents on the backend without informing users about it. It's caused people who thought they were legally (or at least 'safely') streaming shows and movies for free using something they found in the app store to be surprised when they got hit with DMCA notices from their ISP.
- maerF0x0 4y agoI did a PoC in college (~2008!) where I coded a distributed rainbow table generator in JS. It'd assign a block of hashes which would get sent back to the server. We showed that a single webserver distributing the work in a naive js implementation (long before webworks and wasm) could outpace a fairly decent local c impl (we were undergrads, so definitely not optimization experts). Was fun until sites actually got on board with salting.
- lantry 4y agoThere is https://arc.io/ https://arc.io/ which is a P2P CDN. Sites get paid a share of the profits based on the amount of data provided by their users. Seems like a cool alternative to ads IMO, but most people that hate ads also hate having their browser "hijacked" so idk if it'll take off.
- coolspot 4y ago> Have there already been cases of websites making their visitors unwitting peers, similar to e.g. JavaScript cryptocurrency mining? vk.com used to do that for popular videos, maybe still doing that.