3 ms·
I strongly disagree. Most of these guidance were not set on scientific grounds to begin with, but based on political grounds. The science was always in the oth
by s1artibartfast 4y ago
I strongly disagree.
Most of these guidance were not set on scientific grounds to begin with, but based on political grounds. The science was always in the other direction for an unbiased reviewer.
It is good that science ultimately won out, but I think it will be a long time before institutional credibility is restored.
- vehemenz 4y agoGuidance is normative, not descriptive. Science itself cannot tell anyone what to do. No amount of "science" can tell you how to prioritize your messaging, mask production/distribution, and hospital usage. Why is it inherently bad that the early pandemic guidance had a political valence? Obviously, no one likes to be misled, but the CDC and WHO were making decisions that would affect billions of people in the absence of any US leadership.
- s1artibartfast 4y agoI wholeheartedly agree that there is science and public policy. The two are different. Many choices are political and should be. For example, The tradeoff of how many deaths is it worth to keep open schools has no scientific answer. The problem is when lies are used to misrepresent the science to achieve a desirable policy outcome. The ultimate reason not to lie is that it undermines social trust and democracy.
- quest88 4y agoWhat was political? Convince me that people weren't doing the best they could with the information they had.
- s1artibartfast 4y agoRefusal to accept prior infection immunity. All the high quality data suggested it was good as or nearly as good as vaccines. This also matched the experience with similar viruses, yet policy makers claimed it was not "based on the science"
- LorenPechtel 4y agoInfection immunity is as good as or better than vaccine immunity *against that variant*. Unfortunately, there is variant after variant after variant. The vaccine fares better than infection against new variants but at this point neither works well.