12 ms·
Beyond/Incredible meat is awful. There's no other description for it. This highly processed fake meat is not healthy. Just eat meat, or don't if you don't want
by SoftTalker 4y ago
Beyond/Incredible meat is awful. There's no other description for it. This highly processed fake meat is not healthy. Just eat meat, or don't if you don't want to. There's no need for this fake garbage.
- tptacek 4y agoThe idea that processing determines the healthfulness of a foodstuff is fallacious.
- RupertEisenhart 4y agoThis source says differently [0], at least for meat. Do you have any evidence or reasoning? [0] https://pubmed.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/18444144/ https://pubmed.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/18444144/
- xapata 4y agoEvidence for processing meat doesn't transfer well as evidence for processing beans.
- tpm 4y agoThat's mostly related to the curing salts and their reaction with heme iron. Curing salts are not used when processing vegetables; heme iron is not added either (I hope), so this should not apply in this case.
- noduerme 4y agoImpossible patties have heme iron added. https://www.thrillist.com/eat/nation/impossible-burger-vs-beyond-meat https://www.thrillist.com/eat/nation/impossible-burger-vs-be...
- RupertEisenhart 4y agoFor some reason there is no reply button on the other replies. Maybe the evidence for meat doesn't generalise, but the idea that fresh vegetables would retain some sort-lived structures that start to break down once processed seems plausible. I was just pointing out that GPs claim could do with some backup.
- diroussel 4y agoI think GP didn’t provide citations as it’s a fairly well known and un-controversial opinion. If this idea was new to you then maybe have a look at these sources, or do some other searches https://www.health.harvard.edu/staying-healthy/red-and-processed-meats-raise-colorectal-cancer-risk https://www.health.harvard.edu/staying-healthy/red-and-proce... https://www.hsph.harvard.edu/nutritionsource/processed-foods/ https://www.hsph.harvard.edu/nutritionsource/processed-foods...
- RupertEisenhart 4y agoYour references seem to back me up, and not the person I was replying to? Eg: "There is evidence showing an association with certain types of food processing and poor health outcomes (especially highly- or ultra-processed foods). This association applies mainly to ultra-processed foods that contain added sugars, excess sodium, and unhealthful fats." From the second one. Maybe you confused my position?
- oifjsidjf 4y ago
- tptacek 4y agoCooking reduces availability of some nutrients and increases others.
- JoyfulTurkey 4y agoYes and can be beneficial sometimes. For example, in the case of something like kale or spinach cooking reduces goitrogens IIRC.
- arrrg 4y agoYou mentioned a ton of things that change (which, sure, they do, after all it would be weird if, after processing when things taste differently, nothing would have changed), you did not make the causal link to things changing in a way that is detrimental to health. Just because it changes doesn’t mean it‘s bad. Even your only point where one could argue that there is a potential obvious negative health effect (the vitamins) is only an issue if there are actual vitamin deficiencies that matter.
- ivanhoe 4y ago> is only an issue if there are actual vitamin deficiencies that matter. It's an issue because it's wasteful, you're loosing the good stuff in the process. Throwing half of your meal into garbage every time is only an issue if you're still hungry afterwards, but it's not economically and ecologically sane thing to do. This is a similar thing, one should try to maximize the use of food that they pay for.
- deleted 4y ago[deleted]
- ben_w 4y agoIIRC, cooking vegetables is generally necessary to make many of the calories available to human digestion. You waste much more by not cooking them.
- bryansum 4y agoNot exclusively, of course, but the degree of processing of food greatly influences our body’s insulin response, which can over time have huge impacts on health (leading to fatty liver disease / metabolic syndrome / obesity / diabetes). This is why, for instance, fruit juice is so much worse for us than the whole fruit — most of the fiber is removed which would otherwise slow down digestion and temper insulin response. For more info I’d highly recommend Jason Fung’s Obesity Code book — he’s a nephrologist specializing in diabetes treatment.
- tptacek 4y agoSome kinds of processing increase insulin impact, others don't. If your goal is controlling sugars, a diet premised solely on minimizing processing isn't a great strategy; "processing" isn't the high-order bit of that problem.
- auggierose 4y agoTheoretically, you are right, of course. In practice though, to apply this, you would need to know how the processing exactly works, and how the body responds to that processing. Given that you can not really determine this easily, it is in practice just simpler to stick to unprocessed foods as much as possible, and just apply the sugar limit to those.
- tptacek 4y agoI don't think this makes a lot of sense. Cheese is cooked, fermented, emulsified, and aged. It has a lower glycemic impact than milk, its primary unprocessed input. Mostly, I think the "processed" vs. "unprocessed" debate is an appeal to tradition, not science; if it's a kind of processing we were doing 200 years ago, it's OK; otherwise, it's unhealthful.
- auggierose 4y agoI would say that Cheese, at least its classic variants, fall exactly under the category where you have fairly good knowledge of the nature of its processing and its effects on the body. I'd say your example supports my argument.
- kybernetyk 4y ago
- simulation_ 4y agoDepends on fruit/vegetable. Some have nutrients that are easily destroyed by heat, but some have nutrients that are easier absorbed after light heating, or problematic compounds removed during cooking.
- jasamer 4y agoAnd raw potato vs cooked potato?
- theodric 4y agoDefine "healthy." Clarify what you become deficient in by consuming a cooked apple. This frankly reeks of naturalistic fallacy.
- whateveracct 4y agoHN is full of bizarro techbro eating disorder talk I didn't quite realize until I met one of those "carbs are worse energy sources" guys at a job
- kybernetyk 4y agoyeah, bizzaro tech world where vitamins get destroyed by heat :)
- whateveracct 4y agoIt's not the facts - it's the mindset and focus.
- Broken_Hippo 4y agoTell me that raw, uncooked wheat is just as healthy as processed and cooked wheat. I'll wait. Cooking makes some things edible that weren't before. Just because it doesn't work on an apple in the way you are imagining doesn't mean much. I'll also note that many folks think of baked apples as sugar-laden desserts and fresh apples as eaten plain. Nevermind that folks add apples to savory rice dishes and nevermind that folks dip fresh apples in caramel sauce. You need more than the descriptions of "baked" and "raw" to denote health.
- usrusr 4y agoI agree in so far that I believe that the observation of "more processing > less health" is not caused directly by the amount of processing, but by the way those highly processed products are designed to match as many "appetites" as possible. I use the term "appetites" in the sense of a low intensity craving, the feedback signal the body sends to fill some nutrient deficit. But our taste buds can't really identify most of the nutrients in question, we just have is a set of complicated heuristics taking an educated guess. And many of those highly processed foods, in their quest to maximise desire, will fool those heuristics, matching the "appetite" without fulfilling the deficit. Perhaps not by deliberate design, but by market selection. On one hand, the faux meats sound quite risky, but in the other hand they are under extreme scrutiny like no highly processed food before them, so they might not actually be bad at all.
- LinXitoW 4y agoCategorically? Absolutely! But as humans we can't read every study for every ingredient. We have to use heuristics to guesstimate a healthy diet. Reducing (not eliminating) processed foods is a decent one. Same goes for including protein, increasing fiber (so whole wheat instead of the cake americans call "bread"), including veggies.
- literalAardvark 4y agoYou are technically correct. However... The complexity of digestion rivals that of cryptography. And the same caveats apply. Ultraprocessed foods, let's say a [plant] burger, are the food equivalent of "roll your own crypto". Less processing = fewer things we break without knowing we broke them. I'm in no way actually arguing against cooking. This would take a fair bit of time and space to explain in general, but if you have specific questions I'll do my best to address them.
- ryanbrunner 4y agoSaying there's necessarily a causal relationship is probably not well supported, but there's absolutely a correlation, and as a rule of thumb, if you choose whole foods over processed foods it will tend to net out as more healthy. Nutrition pretty much by definition requires a lot of simplification to allow people to make quick decisions on food choices, and so broad rules that are mostly right are pretty useful (and pretty much the basis of how most diets work).
- patrec 4y agoWhat makes you think so? Do you have any examples of particularly healthful highly processed foodstuff in mind? Or is this more some "there are no slow programming languages, only slow implementations" type of argument about the absence of strict logical necessity? Healthy food is basically a lemon market, so what would a plausible mechanism to economically incentivize high processing for healthfulness look like? Conversely there is a clear economic incentive to highly process food in order to decrease unit cost at fixed palatability. By increasing yield (pink slime) or shelf-life (trans-fats) or taste and looks (flavor enhancer etc). None of these are necessarily bad in all cases, and in some cases might even correspond to increases in healthfulness (e.g. by killing harmful micro-organisms). But on average, in the absence of some additional economic incentive to keep or increase healthfulness, I'd expect optimization for these criteria to decrease it. For example, a lot of nutrients have short shelf-lives, so if there is an incentive to increase shelf-life but not an equal incentive to preserve nutritiousness (and I don't think there is), you'd expect healthfulness to go down, no?
- ajmurmann 4y agoTo each their own. I greatly enjoy the flavor of meat, but feel like a serial killer when I think about the animal suffering and to a lesser extend carbon emissions. While I also get a slightly odd feeling in my stomach from Impossible beef (doesn't happen with their cyber chicken), it's a tradeoff I'm excited to make 1-2 a month to get the flavor of a burger without feeling like I just tortured a puppy.
- goda90 4y agoIf you have the money, buy meat directly from a regenerative ag farm you can go visit personally. You'll see animals with plenty of space, given healthcare and protection from predators, and contributing to soil growth and biodiversity.
- agentgumshoe 4y agoYou'd be surprised how many animals die in the process of scaled agriculture and displacement that occurs to create these replacement goods. But they're not the big fluffy animals we anthropomorphise, so it's easy to accept.
- JoyfulTurkey 4y agoI have always wondered just how many accidental casualties occur with harvesting equipment. I guess home garden is the best bet if it’s a concern?
- iforgotpassword 4y agoLook up how olives are harvested. There are big machines that go over rhe tree and vacuum off all the olives. Too bad theres a lot of birds living in there that get sucked in and die. Why don't they fly away? The noise must be a fair warning ahead of time! Well, the harvest is at night because of lower temperatures. The birds freeze in shock when the noise and bright lights get turned on and don't move.
- ajmurmann 4y agoI don't think I'd be surprised. I don't know how to solve that though short of starving myself to death.
- froggychairs 4y agoWe know red meat isn’t healthy. Most (not all) fake meats try to replicate red meat. What proof do you have them being unhealthy? Impossible for example has fairly simple list of ingredients. Better macros than burger ground. Anecdotally. My father in law has had to stop eating red meat due to health concerns. He enjoys impossible products just fine with no negative concerns in blood biomarkers or examines (several years running now). We are controlling for exercise patterns too. He’s just replaced his frequent burgers with an impossible patty instead. This comment is just a wild claim with no evidence and falsely equates “processed” with “unhealthy”
- VSerge 4y agoFor one thing, the high level of saturated fats in beyond meat patties (25% of max daily recommended intake) could be considered unhealthy. On some other aspects it seems pretty decent, with good protein content and some added vitamins as well.
- sph 4y ago> We know red meat isn’t healthy. I think you mean we have studies of dubious quality blaming red meat. And scores of people repeating the same trite arguments. It's the same people that brought to you salt causes high blood pressure and saturated fat causes atherosclerosis, pushing the low fat craze and the obesity epidemic. Sure, meat is bad, go eat hyper processed fake meat.
- johnnymorgan 4y agoThank you! Those studies were all ideological driven and would never pass replication. Mongols vs China, diet was a defining factor in the Mongols victories. Meat and dairy, the dairy gave them tons go vitamin D as well.
- oblio 4y ago> Mongols vs China, diet was a defining factor in the Mongols victories. Source?
- unethical_ban 4y agoI disagree. Depending on the prep, I could have been fooled into thinking it was a real patty at Hopdoddys. Saying it is unhealthy sounds ideological. The point of making this imitation meat is to over time, get better and better until it is truly indistinguishable. It is premised on the idea that many people don't want to give up their meat foods, and that mass meat production is unethical and environmentally negative. There is a need.
- HDThoreaun 4y agoBeyond/impossible aren't trying to be healthy. They're trying to be meat replacements and have similar healthiness to red meat, which they do. I prefer them to previous generation meat substitutes. They work great as ground beef replacement, much better than any vegetables.
- ilyt 4y agoThat's really anything highly processed. Soo much easier to control eating habits once I limited the highly processed, fast metabolizing stuff.
- int_19h 4y agoI'm a heavy meat eater, and I actually kinda liked the impossible whopper. More importantly, while I like the taste of meat too much to give up on it, I would also very much prefer that it could be had without killing animals. I don't think plant-based meat is going to be the ultimate solution to this - more likely, it'll be the lab-grown stuff. But, either way, it requires investments from the food industry to reach maturity, and those won't happen unless there's a real customer interest. Buying fake-meat burger is a way to express that interest.