8 ms·
US reps urge DOJ to investigate anticompetitive conduct affecting apartment rent
- chatmasta 4y agoI was disappointed to see this was not about Blackrock and other private equity groups.
- cyanydeez 4y agoBuying out houses is a different issue than large scale price fixing
- obnauticus 4y agoThese anti-competitive pricing models seem to be the primary motivation for a large scale landlord wanting to invest in the first place. So it sort-of is?
- colechristensen 4y agoI’m quite happy to see this having lived in apartments driven by automated pricing which is obviously a new kind of cartel.
- loeg 4y agoThe innovation here isn't the automated pricing, but convincing all the landlords in an area to collude by sharing pricing and demand data with a central organizer. Humans could do the pricing and it would still be illegal collusion.
- Aunche 4y agoIf they are really facilitating collusion, then they would be selling a broken product. For example, for simplicity's sake, let's say that a city has a lot of landlords, but all their units are identical and they all follow the RealPage algorithm for price suggestions. Realpage suggests that they charge an exorbitant $10000 per unit, which leads to only 50% of all units being occupied, so your expected value of $5000 per unit. However, if you're a landlord, you'd be better off renting your units at $9000, leading to 90% occupancy. Your expected profit per unit is $8100, so you're actually much better off without the algorithm.
- loeg 4y agoYour arbitrary figure of $9,000 -> $10,000 causing a 40% drop in occupancy is wholly invented. You could instead imagine a (still completely fictitious) figure that makes your argument look bad -- e.g., that the raise in rates causes a 0% drop in occupancy. Then the landlords/algorithm win by raising prices. One reason occupancy rates might remain relatively stable even in the face of rising prices is if consumers have relatively few better options, because e.g. all of your competitors collude to also raise their rates similarly.
- Aunche 4y ago> that the raise in rates causes a 0% drop in occupancy. Housing demand isn't really that inelastic. People will move to less crowded cities if they become too expensive. Americans tend to have much more living space per capita than most of the world, so there is a lot of room to move in with roommates or family. > all of your competitors collude to also raise their rates similarly. Realpage doesn't control the prices for the majority of housing in the US, the majority of rental units in the US, or even the majority of multifamily rental units in the US. If they tried to facilitate collusion, their customers would simply lose money.
- tptacek 4y agoPE firms own only an infinitesimal fraction of all available housing.
- Forgeties79 4y agoYou’re not wrong but it’s a little more complicated than that. https://www.marketplace.org/2022/03/02/how-private-equity-is-changing-the-rental-market/amp/ https://www.marketplace.org/2022/03/02/how-private-equity-is...
- tptacek 4y agoIs it any more than just a little more complicated? None of this establishes how PE firms would gain any sort of pricing power.
- treeman79 4y agoA Black rock house company (invintation homes)lied repeatedly about weird smells in my house. whole family has permanent injuries from it.
- turtleyacht 4y agoPlease tell us more.
- treeman79 4y agoNatural gas + carbon monoxide, oddly didn’t have the rotten egg smell. When we previewed home all the windows were open. After signing paperwork we closed up windows. Hour later we noticed smell. 3 month of being told it was carpet. Floor, paint. They inspecting and saying everything is fine. Our deductive reasoning skills where nil fairly quick into this. Finally called gas company even. They started screaming for us to run From the road. Didn’t even get to the house before alarms went off. Kids went from gifted to special needs. I went from top programmer to taking hours to figure out laundry. Doctors wouldn’t say gas caused injuries. So lawyers didn’t care. About 70% Back to normal 4 years later.
- turtleyacht 4y agoThank-you. Glad to hear you got better. After reading this, a recent combo monitor helped ease my doubts.
- radicaldreamer 4y agoWhat were the smells and what are the injuries?
- bmorton 4y agoIt's only smellz. It's ok.
- joenot443 4y ago> “As recently reported, software offered by RealPage uses pricing algorithms to adjust prices on vacant apartments in real time… The program may also induce landlords to charge the rents recommended by the algorithm, putting upward pressure on prices and decreasing the availability of affordable apartments” That’s the meat of it, really. Someone more knowledgeable can speak more confidently, but I’d be pretty surprised if we see anything materializing here.
- loeg 4y ago> I’d be pretty surprised if we see anything materializing here. Note that the link is from Nov 17, a couple weeks ago. Just last week it was reported that the DOJ is already investigating (discussed here): https://www.propublica.org/article/yieldstar-realpage-rent-doj-investigation-antitrust https://www.propublica.org/article/yieldstar-realpage-rent-d... ( https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=33744136 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=33744136 ) https://www.theverge.com/2022/11/26/23479034/doj-investigating-rent-setting-software-company-realpage https://www.theverge.com/2022/11/26/23479034/doj-investigati... There is also a lawsuit: https://www.seattletimes.com/business/real-estate/seattle-landlords-accused-of-conspiring-to-raise-apartment-rents/ https://www.seattletimes.com/business/real-estate/seattle-la...
- bobthepanda 4y agoThe question I think is interesting. If you replaced an algorithm with a group of people, would a centralized entity recommending rents be price-fixing, just outsourced?
- HWR_14 4y agoI'm pretty sure that group of people would be guilty of price fixing.
- themagician 4y agoI can speak about how it actually works, because I live in a building that uses this and has used it since I moved about 2-3 years ago… although it seems like they just recently paused using it (I got my renewal a few days ago). Every day (or every week or month, up to the property) the rent gets recomputed for every unit for whatever terms you want to offer. My building offers 7, 8, 9, 11, 13 and 14 month terms at the moment (yes, 12-months is surprisingly absent). You get a wide range of rents based on the terms that seemingly don't make sense. That's because it calculates both current market factors as well as what it thinks is in store for the future. So a 9-month term can be either less or more than an 13-month term, because it heavily depends on WHEN that term will end in terms of how hard it anticipates it will be to find a new tenant. When I first when to move in I was told that the rate quoted would only be good for a week and next week ALL the terms would be different—and they were. It feels like a little bit of a lottery. Wait another week and the rent may go up or down for any of the terms. I did wait an extra week, and then the rent went UP for the 12-month by DOWN for the 13. The rent spread between both terms and time was around $400/mo IIRC, so it was not trivial. I just got my renewal for this year and my building is no longer using this feature. I can tell because all the terms now have the same (albeit it ridiculous) rate. I'm not sure why my building stopped using it. It may be because of the backlash happening right now, but I actually think it may be because tenant turnover is simply through the roof with this system. Our building is a rotating door. People would move in with a great intro rate, but when it comes around for renewal the rates were VASTLY different, as well as the terms they were mapped to—and you knew that. Why pick a 14-month term when you can pick a 7-month term… and maybe stand to get a lower rent in 7-months? I was always wondering what my options would be on renewal. Sometimes I would check my unit, which despite being rented, I could still see what the "new rate" would be if my renewal was that day. The numbers were always just all over the place. Sometimes the 7 or 8 month lease was the cheapest. Other times it was by far the most expensive. It honestly just felt like there were a bunch of dice rolls every day that determined rent within some range.
- notch656a 4y ago
- fdgsdfogijq 4y agoMonetary policy turned housing into an asset class and ruined it for regular americans
- nullc 4y ago> turned housing into an asset class comparatively attractive asset class. It was always an asset class, but not a particularly attractive one.
- KboPAacDA3 4y agoThey are US Senators, not US Representatives.
- jmyeet 4y agoPrice controls are ineffective long term but can be a useful stopgap measure in the short term. The only solution to this is dealing with supplyside issues, notably the artificial constraints on housing supply. This is longer term.So the pricing algorithms are a natural reaction to market forces. Here are some more important things you can do in the short term to increase supply: 1. Outlaw (at the local and state level) and punitively tax (at the Federal level) short-term rentals (eg AirBnB/VRBO). The evidence that these reduce the supply of rental units is undeniable. It's not even capital intensive as people will rent units where the lease allows them to sublet short-term; 2. Start punitively taxing second homes; 3. Punitively tax ultra-luxury housing supply. In the longer term the government should temper these market forces by creating an alternative source for housing by buying and building housing units that are rented to people on reasonable terms.
- UncleOxidant 4y ago> 2. Start punitively taxing second homes; I'm assuming you mean punitively tax 2nd homes that aren't being rented out?
- jmyeet 4y agoI distinguish between "investment property" and "second homes". An investment property is a working asset that's specifically there to generate income (eg by renting it out). "Second homes" here are really non-working assets (eg the family lake house).
- calvinmorrison 4y agobut lake houses and beach houses are seasonal and have little demand year round
- nullc 4y agoAnd usually in locations where the housing market isn't congested and where building additional units (especially if you don't care if they have a view) would be no big deal.
- ramesh31 4y agoIt really was something to see. Over the course of about 5 years, somehow magically the rent for a two bedroom corporate apartment in every city in the US converged on ~$1800.
- alar44 4y agoNah. Where I live, $1800 will rent you a really nice 3br duplex or house.
- cheriot 4y ago> pricing algorithms to adjust prices on vacant apartments in real time… The program may also induce landlords to charge the rents recommended by the algorithm, putting upward pressure on prices and decreasing the availability of affordable apartments. Wait until she hears about hotels and flights. > The software analyzes non-public data that RealPage gathers from its property management clients, including confidential information on the rents charged by competing property managers, data it also makes available to its subscribers in aggregated, anonymized form. The program may also induce landlords to charge the rents recommended by the algorithm, putting upward pressure on prices This is identical to how employers share salary information. Either this is nonsense grandstanding (most likely) or the beginning of a sea change in consumer protection. I won't hold my breath.
- rtpg 4y agoHotels and flights are, granted, less essential than a place to live. Remember, you _have to live somewhere_. That is a functional difference compared to other "market-based" things (never mind that "market-based solutions" are a lot less workable when atomicity is lost. Yeah yeah, regulations making things harder to build, I think more should be built! But there are real, "wanted" things in the way of just having market magic solve everything). Employers sharing salary information is also maybe a descriptive reality but I don't believe to be necessarily smiled upon. Remember the wage fixing scandals in SV? Analogies are great because you can say A is like B, up until A is no longer like B and then they are terrible. But seriously, there are qualitative differences in things which make comparable effects be more or less of a problem (or even go from good to bad!). Thinking continuously by analogy misses the forest for the trees.
- JustSomeNobody 4y agoHow is it not competitive? One raises their rent and the others race to raise theirs as well? Sounds competitive to me.
- anonreeeeplor 4y ago
- mullingitover 4y ago> The fact Twitter was able to get away with kicking off a US President without any ramifications is frightening. Your stance is the government should be able to compel private businesses to be mouthpieces for government officials? Seems pretty authoritarian.
- themagician 4y agoHonestly, Twitter kicking off a sitting President was one of the biggest wins for free speech in a long time. I don't know how people don't see that. This kind of public rebuke of the government will _literally_ get you killed in some countries countries. In many more it will get you disappeared at the very least.
- nullc 4y agoThe thing to complain about twitter is that they didn't kick him off years before while nuking accounts that were far less abusive, but waited until he was a lame duck president. One could read that history as severely undermining your point-- that they were afraid of him until he was on his way out. But I don't think that's true: rather they kept him on because his popularity and toxicity brought a ton of revenue to them, and punted him when they finally expected him to be less profitable in the future.
- ceejayoz 4y ago> The fact Twitter was able to get away with kicking off a US President without any ramifications is frightening. It'd be pretty frightening if the President could require private businesses to publish his writings via a special just-for-him exception to their normal rules. > Murders do not get solved anymore and our cities are unsafe. Cops were reporting 100% homicide clearance rates in the 1960s; it's highly unlikely it was anything near that. Statistically - even with the 2022 uptick - we're in one of the safest societies in human history. There has been an absolutely enormous drop in crime rates, year after year, since the 1970s.
- mlindner 4y agoIf this has any contributing effect, it's a minor one, as anyone can offer up housing for rent. The real reason housing is expensive in a couple of places is because of regulations preventing the building of new housing. As extensively seen in places like San Francisco.
- reeddavid 4y agoThe recent outrage over RealPage seems misplaced, at least here in Seattle where demand for housing is so much higher than supply. There are so many restrictions on new housing. We're considered a liberal city, but plenty of our residents have really conservative views around housing and work against increasing housing supply. It seems to me that RealPage simply helps landlords assess the market price for apartments. Sort of like how "Redfin Estimate" and Zillow's "Zestimate" help homeowners assess the market value of their house. The reason houses and apartments are expensive is because the market rate is so high. My test for whether RealPage is anticompetitive would be: does RealPage induce multiple landlords to withhold apartments from the market in order to intentionally restrict supply and drive up rents? (Or, does RealPage just clue them in to how high the market rents are?)
- naijaboiler 4y agoI disagree. Realpage is essentially turning a competitive market (multiple buyers, multiple sellers) into a quasi-monopoly market (multiple buyers,one seller). Econ 101 tells you the result of that is higher prices, lower quantity, less incentive to improve or innovate. State policies may indeed be already limiting supply, realpage makes things worse.
- fsckboy 4y ago> We're considered a liberal city, but plenty of our residents have really conservative views around housing and work against increasing housing supply. you can't create a system with politically "liberal" rules ("let's have the government control the economy") and then say it's "conservatives" who are holding things up. the politically conservative position would be let owners of property do what they want with it, including developing it into more housing if they want. not saying one system is better than the other, just saying you're simply using liberal and conservative to mean good and bad.
- phendrenad2 4y agoThe only solution to housing is for the government to start building houses. The free market has failed to build affordable housing, and I don't see anything changing that.
- blkstormy 4y agoSeems like nearly the same thing as employees sharing salary data among themselves, no? What's the problem? Don't we want transparency in pricing within a market?
- exabrial 4y agoAny collusion on prices should be prosecuted, fined, with 100% refunds issued to consumers and the company conjuring crimes picks up the legal fees.