22 ms·
Asian faiths try to save swastika symbol corrupted by Hitler
- vanniv 4y ago
- clownworldclown 4y ago
- Tao3300 4y agoDo you boycott Unicode because they deemed 卐 and 卍 to be worth including?
- vanniv 4y ago[flagged]
- nemo 4y agoThe Great Seal of the US has fasces on it, the House Rostrum, and many other older decorations relating to Congress do too. That's a symbol the fascists used, and they aligned very closely to the Nazis. It hasn't been abandoned since it was a traditional part of those things well before the fascists, as it was Roman iconography. So too, the swastika has been a part of various cultures that long preceded its use by the Nazis. While we should be sensitive about its use, it's clear many are generally happier to police other cultures than their own.
- Tao3300 4y agoThere's also a story of Genghis Khan trying to impress the strength of unity on his sons by showing them how a single arrow can be snapped, but that a bundle of them is strong. I don't think it worked, but that's a sort of fasces as a literary symbol.
- Tao3300 4y ago> Why is this the only hate symbol you love so much? Who said I loved it? I'm only asking questions to examine your position. > Should we start flying confederate flags now everywhere What prior meaning does the "stars and bars" have?
- _-david-_ 4y ago
- vanniv 4y agoThe Confederate flag may not have anything to do with racism. Should we fly it everywhere then? Are black people hateful for feeling uncomfortable going places that proudly wave it?
- deleted 4y ago[deleted]
- ram4jesus 4y agoThis attitude is borderline parody. Don’t be so stringent and assume malintent. Most people aren’t sneaking Nazi beliefs into everyday interactions.
- lehi 4y agoIt's not borderline, they're trolling. Check the poster's comment history.
- TulliusCicero 4y agoI, too, hate the peaceful symbols of other cultures. Seriously, should we stop using Z everywhere because of Russia's invasion? This isn't a super obscure symbol, it's been in use for much longer than the Nazis were around, with far more people than the Nazis.
- YurgenJurgensen 4y agoSo your position is "asians have to change their behaviour to atone for what an unrelated group of white people did"? Seems like the real racist here is you.
- deleted 4y ago[deleted]
- t-3 4y agoAs usual, cultural diversity is abhorrent to the symbol-minded. A shape which has been drawn by humans around the world since prehistory is effectively banned because a small group of people decided to use it while they did a bunch of nasty stuff. I don't see anyone trying to ban crosses or raise a fuss about them, and Christians have historically used it as a symbol while perpetrating many horrifying acts. Nobody is trying to ban the flags of any of the other countries which engaged in slavery, genocide, and colonial oppression, and those are at least reasonably unique. Why should this ancient religious symbol be forever tainted?
- hulitu 4y ago> Why should this ancient religious symbol be forever tainted? Vae victis. This symbol has become a non symbol because the history was rewritten.
- rocknor 4y ago> history was rewritten Hundreds of millions of people still use it regularly in India, it's everywhere. It's pretty innocuous. Unless you stop them from doing so somehow, history is not rewritten. Attempts to colonize ancient symbols will not succeed.
- deleted 4y ago[deleted]
- HebericNewt 4y ago
- beezlewax 4y ago...the Nazis were hardly a "small group of people".
- wongarsu 4y ago1939 Germany had about 80 million inhabitants. By far not all Germans were Nazis, but then not all Nazis were Germans, so let's just use that as a first approximation. At the same time, India had about 320 million inhabitants, or four times as many. Maybe calling Nazis a small group is a bit far, but they were definitely a minority of swastika users even at the time.
- pxc 4y agoRenaming Nazi uses of the symbol to 'hakenkreuz' seems like a good idea to me. But we should expect changes in connotation to happen slowly, and in a way that's not entirely controllable. At the very least, I hope we can avoid getting the state involved in censoring or punishing genuine religious displays, as happened in one case described in the article.
- dhruval 4y agoThe word swastika itself is culturally appropriated from Sanskrit (India) by the British who had colonized the country during WW2. Hakenkreuz (hooked cross) is the German term.
- noworld 4y agoWhen did loan words become cultural appropriation?
- version_five 4y agoShortly after the end of the cold war, when we no longer had a common enemy to focus on and started fighting each other
- tom_ 4y agoWhen the British do it.
- dhruval 4y agoGood point, I meant it is a loan word. In the era of socially sensitive language, I would like to see the Nazi swastika referred to with the German term, to rehabilitate the term swastika. If you are against socially engineering language to make it more culturally sensitive via things like gender pronouns, removing certain slurs etc. Then ok at least that is a consistent ethical position, and understandable. But if you support the use of more inclusive language, then this would be my request.
- gumby 4y agoWartime Enid Blyton books called it the “Crooked Cross” (which was vaguely mystifying to 8 yo me, 30 years after the end of the war and in the pacific).
- benj111 4y agoSo when 'the west' ignore things from other nations we're sidelining them and destroying their heritage. But if we take an interest in their culture and take it on board, it's cultural appropriation? What are we supposed to do. Say how great X is without ever doing X? What parts of my own culture am I even allowed to partake in because most of it comes from elsewhere. Can't you just be happy that cultures can take things from other cultures and make it their own and gain a bit of understanding about the former in the process, rather than make it into a culture war.
- zoklet-enjoyer 4y ago"Holocaust survivors in particular could be re-traumatized when they see the symbol, said Shelley Rood Wernick, managing director of the Jewish Federations of North America’s Center on Holocaust Survivor Care." How many Holocaust survivors are even left?
- ThrowawayTestr 4y agoWhen you include second and third generation survivors? Potentially millions.
- TulliusCicero 4y ago...I don't think that's usually what people mean by "Holocaust survivor".
- ThrowawayTestr 4y agoJust because they're not thought about doesn't mean they don't exist. https://www.theguardian.com/lifeandstyle/2014/mar/15/trauma-second-generation-holocaust-survivors https://www.theguardian.com/lifeandstyle/2014/mar/15/trauma-...
- TulliusCicero 4y agoOf course they exist by this definition, but by default when someone describes an "X survivor" they obviously mean a person who actually went through that thing. Nobody says, "I was a cancer survivor" to mean "my grandma survived cancer".
- zoklet-enjoyer 4y agoI don't
- Tao3300 4y agoPresumably < 100,000 https://time.com/4392413/elie-wiesel-holocaust-survivors-remaining/ https://time.com/4392413/elie-wiesel-holocaust-survivors-rem... That was 2016.
- silisili 4y agoWhen I moved to East TN temporarily years ago, I opened the door to the rental to see a swastika on the doorstep. My first thought was 'oh come on, really', as if every stereotype was right. It was small and in red, maybe lipstick? So I googled, and realized it was backwards. And that was the apparently the symbol of the article. I called the owner just to let him know I didn't do it. Really old 'grumpy' white guy. He said 'oh, some sweet Indian family lived here before you, they asked if they could do that and I told them it's theirs to do what they want. You can leave it or clean it off.' Learned a lot that day, and busted a few common stereotypes in the process. Ended up being an area with a lot of really good people. FWIW, I ended up leaving it after reading about it. As mentioned, it wasn't big nor offensive looking. I wonder if the next family went through the same thing.
- monetus 4y agoI'm in east Tennessee now, and have seen a few mandalas in front of businesses in the past month or so. It is pretty diverse here really - a lot of the Asian diaspora in particular. Thanks for sharing.
- RickJWagner 4y agoHa, thanks for sharing this. I'm glad you saw past the stereotypes and got to really 'know' some people.
- SanjayMehta 4y agoNot lipstick, vermilion.
- ivanhoe 4y agoNot relevant just to Asian faiths, as it was a symbol widely used in many Indo-European cultures, particularly Slavic and Roman(and Germanic, but that perhaps hits too close to the problem). You still can see it as ornament carved into wooden beams under a roof and above doors on many old houses in rural areas of Serbia and Romania. Not sure though if it had any real superstitious meaning after the Christianity came, or it was just a traditional ornament that continued to be used purely as a decoration.
- cuteboy19 4y agoIt's the only symbol of goodwill recognized from Ireland to Japan (before WW2 that is)
- Anthony-G 4y agoOnly just reading this now and wondering if you've any reference regarding its usage in Ireland. The only non-Nazi usage that I'm aware of is the Swastika Laundry (I used to work nearby and unforunately, the swastika is now gone from its chimney stack). When I researched it, it turns out that the founder was inspired by an ornament he saw at the 1910 Great Industrial Exhibition in London: https://www.nationalarchives.ie/article/behind-scenes-swastika-laundry/ https://www.nationalarchives.ie/article/behind-scenes-swasti... With a layman's interest in history, religion, iconography (and a multitude of other areas that I don't have enough time for), I'd be interested in learning about other or older examples of swastika usage in Ireland. So far, I've found this wonderful blog post: https://rmchapple.blogspot.com/2017/10/always-remember-to-draw-swastika.html https://rmchapple.blogspot.com/2017/10/always-remember-to-dr...
- eternalban 4y agoLike heaping earth to build which leaves only so many possible forms (like pyramids) there are only so geometric patterns before things start getting massively complex. Just like the Swastika, the hex-star (seal of solomon, star of david), the cross, & the pentagram (which are all very ubiquitous), these are things you would discover yourself looking for interesting geometric figures, likely quite early in your search for designs. It seems to come down to angles that were easily measurable, like (in degrees) 30, 45, 60, 90.
- pengaru 4y agoSomewhat related; another symbol Nazis used is the Fasces[0] has managed to continue widespread use to this day. Despite its obvious etymological roots in common with Fascism. You'll even find it in the currently used Seal of the United States Senate[1]! It's also often seen displayed prominently on stone buildings across the US. I was recently walking around downtown St. Charles, IL and there were Fasces overhanging the entrances of an old stone apartment building. [0] https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Fasces https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Fasces [1] https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Seal_of_the_United_States_Senate https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Seal_of_the_United_States_Sena... edit: correction s/Nazi symbol/symbol Nazis used/ thanks to commenter.
- sph 4y agoFasces are not a Nazi symbol. They were very common in Fascist Italy—due to its association with Ancient Rome Mussolini was a big fan of—and the Fascists were culturally and ideologically allied with Nazi Germany. But AFAIK it was not a Nazi symbol. But they're not a Fascist icon either, despite what your comment suggests. The fact that it appears on the Senate building probably refers to the Roman meaning. The point of TFA is pointing out that these symbols are NOT owned by the Fascists or Nazis but should instead be returned to their cultural origins.
- throwaway294566 4y ago> The fact that it appears on the Senate building probably refers to the Roman meaning. The roman meaning is very much fascist, if phrased in modern terms. Fasces were carried by lictors accompanying a roman official, symbolizing the "imperium", or absolute, king-like power, held by that official over his domain. While for a time, the imperium of lower officials was somewhat curtailed during the republic, military commanders with imperium still held the absolute and immediate power over life and death of their subordinates (other officials still had power over life and death, there just was an opportunity for citizens for appeals and vetoes by equal-ranked officials) . Lictors with their fasces were not only bodyguards but also a small police force at the discretion of the commander, who would seize an offender, hold him for a drumhead trial by the commander and then punish (e.g. execute) him if so decided. Under the later roman dictatorships the dictator (imperator, emperor or caesar) of course also held those powers, with the same symbolism of imperium represented by the fasces. Fasces always have been a symbol of capital punishment, justice by drumhead or thumbs down, and absolute power.
- mjklin 4y agoWhen I was teaching in China I went with a student to a paint-your-own pottery shop. She painted a little cat and finished it off by drawing two 卍 on the ears. I wonder if this is part of the Chinese inheritance from India? Chinese families also commonly paint bindi dots on the foreheads of toddlers.
- mytailorisrich 4y agoIt's a Buddhist symbol and also indeed a symbol that has been incorporated in Chinese culture and is a Chinese character pronounced wàn in mandarin. If you open Google Maps over Japan you'll see it used to mark the location of Buddhist temples.
- jlengrand 4y agoAlso seen in GitHub in the wild at times. Always brings interesting discussions... https://github.com/pdoc3/pdoc/issues/64 https://github.com/pdoc3/pdoc/issues/64 https://github.com/pdoc3/pdoc/issues/87 https://github.com/pdoc3/pdoc/issues/87 I've learnt a lot about cultures through those PRs
- ThrowawayTestr 4y agoThe thumbs down on the measured response to a reactionary request makes me sad.
- netsharc 4y ago> ... makes me sad. Sad face emoji? Geez, the use of emojis, in this serious context, makes me think I'm reading a 6 year old's response.
- ThrowawayTestr 4y agoI'm sorry expressing my feelings makes my comment sound childish. I look forward to reading your well reasoned, fact-based response.
- baryphonic 4y agoIt's sort of weird this is a huge issue, considering the official Python logo looks slightly swastikaesque.
- tgv 4y agoI'm not going to say you can't use a swastika in India, but the people the article opens with are extremely naive, and should recognize that, or they're just trolling. You can't live in the US (Queens is in NY, right?) and think you can simply display a swastika, mirrored or not.
- markdown 4y agoWhy not? You don't get to impose your beliefs on your neighbour. This silliness of taking things out of context and then attacking them has got to stop. Hindus were using the symbol long before the existence of the German state. Nazis using the swastika as an expression of hate, not OK. Hindus using their symbol, OK.
- compiskey 4y agoBecause humans are far more intolerant than the high minded philosophy they memorized makes them believe they are.
- deleted 4y ago[deleted]
- signatoremo 4y ago> Why not? You don't get to impose your beliefs on your neighbour. It’s nothing to do with belief, more with common sense and respect. Tourists are advised to cover their heads when visiting Middle East countries; or not wear shorts when visiting Buddhism temples. It’s the same here for visitors to Western countries, where Nazis have left a deep deep scar in the society.
- markdown 4y agoI mean, I most certainly would never use a crooked cross for the reason you point out, but it's a bit much to demand that an ancient culture change their behaviour because of your lack of discernment with regard to usage and intent. It's also worth pointing out that the Nazi's barely did anything in the US. They inflicted their horrors on millions of people in Europe. The horror of genocide against native Americans in the US wasn't perpetuated by Nazis. If you want to fight back against such evils in the present day, rather than making a fuss about symbols, the world would be be better served if you helped fight back against those who inherited the hate of the nazis and now perpetuate it on Palestinians in Palestine. In fact many who carry that torch come from USA to squat on and steal Palestinian lands. https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=kbPnF8Hvj0I https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=kbPnF8Hvj0I
- ram4jesus 4y agoOne of the biggest shames in the West is the taboo around Nazi symbology when it was plainly coopted into that political movement. These symbols will be reclaimed. We just have to wait. The Nazi rampage will be a footnote in history like most tragic events before.
- deleted 4y ago[deleted]
- Emma_Goldman 4y agoWW2 was the deadliest conflict in human history, and involved both the Holocaust and the first - and so far only - military use of nuclear weapons. To say nothing of the fact that it completely reshaped the international order and led directly to the Cold War. Even if you zoom out and view it, like Eric Hobsbawm, as belonging to a century of warring ideologies much like the wars of religion, it will remain one of the foremost events in world history for a long time. It would take many thousands of years for it to become a 'footnote', assuming the species even lasts that long.
- etc-hosts 4y agoI hate being That Guy, but it is possible more people died in the 1850 Taiping Rebellion.
- watwut 4y agoIt is not. Significantly more people died in WWII. Taiping rebellion is third if ordered mu causalities, WWII first. https://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/List_of_wars_by_death_toll https://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/List_of_wars_by_death_toll
- noworriesnate 4y agoIn the Jewish Roman wars, the Jews murdered 250k men, women and children on the island of Cypress, skinning them and boiling their flesh, and they also completely depopulated Lybia and did similar things in Alexandria. The result? The Romans renamed Judea to Palestine, cypress passed a law that activated instant death penalty on any Jews who landed on the island. Maybe that was the origin of modern day antisemitism? Maybe we don’t move on from stuff like this, instead it becomes racism. Maybe we can be different this time and not say that all these ancient religions (including ancient Germanic paganism) are evil.
- amriksohata 4y agoNowhere in the mein kampf by Hitler does he call it a swastika, in the original German publication He called it haken Cruz which literally means hooked cross, it being a hooked Christian cross. t was a Christian bishop who translated it to English and translated hakencruz to swastika. Effectively taking the blame off Christianity and pushing it onto eastern religions
- beardyw 4y agoI have a set of Rudyard Kipling books with swastikas on them. Printed 1927 they obviously predate Naziism and reflect Kipling's association with the symbol. Not aware of Disney having used it.
- watwut 4y agoNazism existed in 1927. It started right after WWI. Beer Hall Putsch was in 1923. 1927 is when Hitler got the right to speak in public back. The movement was considerably large at that time and publicly very much known about. Hitler gained complete control over Germany in 1933.
- beardyw 4y agoYes, I realised my mistake. I meant its common association with Naziism.
- Anthony-G 4y agoIn fairness, most readers in the 1920s of Kipling's books would have been much more familiar with the swastika as a widely-used symobol in India than the logo of a small extreme right-wing party in Germany. Relevant quote from https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Rudyard_Kipling https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Rudyard_Kipling > Many older editions of Rudyard Kipling's books have a swastika printed on the cover, associated with a picture of an elephant carrying a lotus flower, reflecting the influence of Indian culture. Kipling's use of the swastika was based on the Indian sun symbol conferring good luck and the Sanskrit word meaning "fortunate" or "well-being". He used the swastika symbol in both right and left-facing forms, and it was in general use by others at the time
- deleted 4y ago[deleted]
- krupan 4y agoHumans are really good at interpreting the same word/symbol differently when used in different contexts, as long as we know the context.
- emptybits 4y agoI'm neither Jewish nor Asian, but I do always have a large tin of this delicious Chinese vegetarian barbecue sauce in the fridge with a prominent 卍 on it.[1] It's a fantastic marinade, among other things. Anyways, it resembles a Nazi swastika enough for the uninitiated to look twice when opening the fridge. It causes me some cringe when I think about it but my Chinese friends and family assure me it's common, has nothing to do with hateful values, and long predates the Nazi use, and ... shrug? [1] https://www.kuohua.ca/shop/p0540023/ https://www.kuohua.ca/shop/p0540023/
- mytailorisrich 4y agoIt's pronounced wàn in mandarin. Indeed, it predates the Nazis by centuries if not millenia and has nothing to do with the Nazis. So why should Chinese (and East Asians in general) change their ways because a crazy foreigner in a small country on the other side of the world used a similar symbol?
- amanaplanacanal 4y agoVegetarian barbecue sounds like an oxymoron.
- emptybits 4y agoCooking food over fire. Vegetables or meat. Traditional everywhere and all kinds of delicious! :-)
- shrubble 4y agoI have a late 1920s or early 1930s "Better Homes and Gardens" type magazine, that has a single panel humor cartoon in it of the "you always want us to keep up with the Joneses" variety. The Native American teepee in the cartoon is depicted with a swastika on it; apparently it was a symbol of good luck with some tribes? City of Albuquerque web site on its use: https://www.cabq.gov/artsculture/kimo/history-of-the-kimo/kimo-history/swastikas https://www.cabq.gov/artsculture/kimo/history-of-the-kimo/ki...
- watwut 4y agoEarly 1930 is when Hitler got to full power.
- shrubble 4y agoThe magazine is in storage, many miles away; from memory, 1927-1932 is the date of printing.
- watwut 4y agoYeah, that is when the movement was already rather large and growing. Also, the previous Beer hall putch was know about internationally - it was big news. Those dates don't predate nazism nor the symbol usage by Hitler.
- shrubble 4y agoYou can read the link above, from the city of Albuquerque; the building built in 1927 had swastikas incorporated in its decoration at that time. quote: "Information about the swastikas at the KiMo Theater. Swastika and skulls detail at KiMo Theater The KiMo was designed and built in 1927 using the style and designs that were very common to several Native American cultures in the American southwest at that time. Now on the National Register of Historic Places, the design elements of the KiMo Theatre are preserved for their original cultural significance. Although today the swastika can evoke negative emotions, the KiMo invites visitors to remember that the original meaning of this ancient sacred symbol is one of life and prosperity. "
- rrwo 4y agoThe symbol is going to be associated with nazis so long as nazis keep using it, and people in the west (especially for places and people affected by the nazis) will find it offensive.
- jquery 4y agoYeah. Any talk of “reclamation” isn’t going to work very well as long as actual nazis are around and using the symbol. People are welcome to try, of course, but to act like victims when they’re politely asked to hide the symbols is hypocritical.
- mckern 4y agoSuch symbols have been used way before the Nazis and are still present in Asian societies today. What’s hypocritical is being woke about issues like this then denying the culture and heritage of others. These people shouldn’t have to modify their cultures to accommodate the inability of westerners to distinguish the semantics of this symbol. To describe these people as “acting the victim” is seriously bordering on racism. The world does not revolve around the west.
- jquery 4y agoSo foreigners don’t need to respect the local cultures at all? They can fly the most offensive symbols and say “well in my home country it’s fine” and then play victim when everyone around them is like “hey, take it down a notch”? Give me a break. Pure hypocrisy. It’s not racism to have basic decency.
- mckern 4y agoI do not disagree that when in rome, act as romans do. However, your original comment did not specify a context like the one you're stating now. If so, my point still holds, generally speaking. And again, they are not hypocrites or playing the victim; people have cultures of their own and are able to semantically distinguish what these symbols ought to mean in different context. I live in an Asian country that has been involved in the second world war, stories about the atrocities of the nazis and the imperial japanese army still survive through our grandparents and educational curriculums. We also have schools that bear the symbol of the swastika. Yet all of us are able to discern the difference in semantics when it comes to that symbol. The case here being that we can respect the culture of others by not intentionally conflating two completely different things together, the only reason for which is because you think your culture is the only one that matters, which is what I meant by "bordering on racism". Your reply, as with your original comment, willingly conflates two completely different meanings of the swastika symbol. In fact, the symbols are not even identical (one is a rotation of the other). With that, the only hypocrisy I'm observing here is your view that your culture is the only one that matters. Once again, the world does not revolve around the west.
- TulliusCicero 4y ago> They supported a new California law that criminalizes the public display of the hakenkreuz — making an exception for the sacred swastika. There is zero chance such a law is found to be constitutional in the US.
- Waterluvian 4y agoImagine if we decided the letter Z needed to be removed from our language because of Russia’s atrocities. But I think there’s plenty of room for understanding and nuance rather than just saying, “hey people who are offended by this symbol, read your history books and toughen up!” Millions were exterminated by those wearing the symbol. There is no such thing as ownership of a symbol. It has different, equally valid meanings to different audiences.
- thomassmith65 4y agoIf the Nazis had used a common letter like Z, there would not be the same stigma attached to the symbol. That this is so obvious suggests your argument has a flaw.
- Waterluvian 4y agoHow common must a symbol be before it’s immune to the stigma of murdering millions? I’m curious how one calculates that. Also: don’t mistake an observation for an argument. I’m not implying anything. I think it is an interesting thought.
- philippejara 4y agoThis is a question without a general answer, because stigma changes on a person by person basis and there isn't a single thing that will end up immune to it, there is no better example of this taken to the extreme as some fringe groups holding the stigma of white supremacy over an "ok" symbol or a bowl cut[0]. The swastika is a bit more complicated because the western world's exposure to it isn't all that big, but I don't see how a symbol that is used by probably over 10% of the world population today and has been used for over 5000 years should be shunned, especially when you consider that it's not even the same symbol most of the time! At the end of the day most of this stigma wouldn't be an issue if people would just stop assuming malice from others by default. [0]: https://www.cbsnews.com/news/ok-symbol-hand-gesture-anti-defamation-league-bowl-cut-racism-hatred/ https://www.cbsnews.com/news/ok-symbol-hand-gesture-anti-def...
- 4y ago
- slavboj 4y ago
- bsaul 4y agoI don’t think any jews advocate for suppressing nazi symbols on asian soil, but maybe i misread the article. So, i don’t see what imperialism you’re talking about. Fight against nazi is a traumatic experience for every european, american and westerner in general, because every person in that part of the world has some kind of family history related to this fight.
- slavboj 4y agoOf course it's "asian soil", it's land where asians live and wish to continue their cultural traditions. But a very small faction of people is demanding that those cultural traditions be discarded in order to promote their comfort as fifth generation holocaust survivors (read who is quoted in the actual article - everyone complaining is speaking on behalf of a Jewish organization). It's no different than dynamiting Indian temples because erotic engravings offend their sense of propriety.
- emmelaich 4y agoSee also https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Fylfot https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Fylfot If you consider the angles as feet, then similar icons are the three-legged Isle of Man one and the many legged Easter European symbol. Customs house in central Sydney has Fylfots on its floor.
- bsaul 4y agoAmerica never ceases to amaze me. So it’s not ok to use « whitelist » or « blacklist » in your *source code* in xcode when coding in swift in case someone may actually be offended just reading those words, but displaying the symbol of nazis is fine, because hey, you shouldn’t impose your own cultural taboos over people with other backgrounds. I think US will have to admit that they, too, just like every country in the world, have their own culture, with their own taboos and peculiarities, norms and habits, and accept for this culture to have some kind of special status over the other ones. Much like you find it absolutely normal and respectful to take into account the specificities of a country you’re visiting as a tourist.
- userbinator 4y agoI think far fewer people care about "whitelist" and "blacklist" (and likewise, "master") in the general population than they do about swastikas. The former is largely isolated to one faction of the tech bubble.
- marcellus23 4y ago> So it’s not ok to use « whitelist » or « blacklist » in your source code in xcode when coding in swift Can you explain what you mean by this? This seems to suggest there's some kind of compiler error or warning in Xcode when using those terms, but I just tried it and there's no such thing. No one is preventing you from using those terms, as far as I can see — some people have chosen to stop using them, but they're not forcing their decision on you.
- amiga386 4y agoI have an example of Apple _forcing_ you to change terminology. Apple decided to rename the function IOMasterPort() to IOMainPort() and marked IOMasterPort() as deprecated, for what would appear to be non-technical reasons. You can see that they did it hastily and poorly; e.g. in the documentation of most functions that take a port, the type definition has been renamed "mainPort" but the parameter is still labeled "masterPort" https://developer.apple.com/documentation/iokit/1514494-ioservicegetmatchingservices https://developer.apple.com/documentation/iokit/1514494-iose... If you use IOMasterPort(), Apple nags you to use their new wording instead. If you follow their advice, your program immediately stops working on macOS < 12.0, those OSes don't have an _IOMainPort symbol. If you reject their advice, your program stops working on macOS 13.0, that OS doesn't have an _IOMasterPort symbol
- userbinator 4y agoI remember when people would sell various bits of plumbing such as valves and pipe fittings with swastikas on them, claiming them to be WW2 German artifacts, when in fact they were prewar products of the American Crane company: https://mechanical-hub.com/did-you-know/ https://mechanical-hub.com/did-you-know/ https://www.reddit.com/r/mildlyinteresting/comments/60edsv/all_of_the_gas_valves_in_my_parents_house_are/ https://www.reddit.com/r/mildlyinteresting/comments/60edsv/a...
- djur 4y ago> “A rose by any other name is a rose,” he said. “In the end it’s how a symbol affects you visually and emotionally. For many, it creates a visceral impact and that’s a fact.” I'm sympathetic to both sides of this argument, but I think the "rose by any other name" allusion is inapt. The rose by any other name would smell as sweet, because the physical existence of the rose is independent of our social or cultural understanding of the rose. The swastika is a symbol and its offensiveness is due to our cultural understanding of its meaning as a symbol. The swastika is neither inherently a symbol of hatred and murder nor one of peace; it has no objective meaning or reality in itself.
- sohkamyung 4y agoThere is also a Red Swastika Society in China [1]. In Singapore, there is a Red Swastika School [2]. AFAIK, the Jewish society in Singapore has never objected to its presence. [1] https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Red_Swastika_Society https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Red_Swastika_Society [2] https://redswastika.moe.edu.sg/ https://redswastika.moe.edu.sg/
- FooBarBizBazz 4y ago1. An irony is that this symbol coexists in Hindu temples with that other symbol known in the West as the "Star of David" -- which is not, actually, a specifically Jewish symbol. 2. That this also appears in American indigenous cultures is extremely interesting, because it points either to very old origins (before people crossed the Bering Strait), or to co-evolution (almost like the "discovery" of mathematical abstractions). Related, there is some evidence that some American indigenous myths, related to the constellations, share a common structure with myths from ancient Greece and elsewhere. Again, this may point to very old origins before the human diaspora across the continents. I wonder how much culture is shared, dating back to the neolithic. 3. This then is a second irony: That symbols from closer to the root of the linguistic and phylogenetic tree -- symbols that are more in common to us -- are used to divide.
- wink 4y agoad 2) I think it's just not complex enough to not evolve organically, same as a pentagram or star of david. If you ever doodled on square paper with tetris-block shapes you're kind of bound to have some sort of accidental swastika shape in there.
- SanjayMehta 4y agoHitler used a Hakenkreuz. A hooked cross. I haven't seen it for myself but there are pictures floating around claiming it's visible in art in the Vatican. It really infuriates Hindus and Buddhists to see this ancient symbol associated with that regime and its modern debris.
- deleted 4y ago[deleted]
- benrapscallion 4y agoStrangely, the article fails to mention that the hateful and religious symbols are actually not the same: they’re mirror images.
- c0m 4y agoThe reason for that is that you are mistaken. Both right and left-facing swastikas are used within religious contexts.
- AtomicOrbital 4y agoLiving and working in Asia for many years I have enjoyed seeing this symbol on many temples ... its a beautiful energy boost obviously absolutely nothing to do with hitler influence ... long live this symbol
- deleted 4y ago[deleted]
- fellellor 4y agoTo say that Hitler was appealing to some shared aryan culture by using the hakenkreuz symbol turns out to be just absolute bullshit. Hitler was a Christian fundamentalist. And his hatred for the Jews originated from his belief in Christianity. It was certainly not because Aryans hated the Jews. Or some such ludicrous thing. >Nakagaki’s research also shows the symbol was called the hakenkreuz in U.S. newspapers until the early 1930s, when the word swastika replaced it. I think further research will show you that Hitler himself never used the word Swastika and always referred to his own symbol as the hooked cross. I’m guessing that maybe the leading Christian voices of the time were so guilt stricken by what Hitler had done in the name of their religion that they were happy to blame his pathology on him dabbling with obscure alien philosophies rather than admitting that he was just being a “true Christian”. It has taken a long time for Christian religious institutions to absolve the Jewish people of the crime of “killing Jesus Christ”. Or have they? I don’t know. For Hitler himself, the motivation to use the hooked cross was probably to symbolise a return to the roots of Christianity and for that he chose the oldest version of the cross he (or his designer) could find.
- rswskg 4y agoMany years ago, I stopped(pleaded..) a very large man from punching an indian student who was wearing a swaztika badge (one correctly orienteted). I did advise the student that London in 2004 wasn't yet ready to understand the subtle differences. Not sure it's moved any closer since then.