5 ms·
Do other commenting websites (like Reddit, Disqus, ...) allow the user to delete an account and all the associated comments? I think Reddit only shows [deleted]
by amelius 4y ago
Do other commenting websites (like Reddit, Disqus, ...) allow the user to delete an account and all the associated comments? I think Reddit only shows [deleted] next to a comment, with the comment still there.
Are they obliged to delete the comments according to laws like GDPR?
- joshuamorton 4y agoIt's possible to go back and delete individual posts, which hn doesn't allow.
- deleted 4y ago[deleted]
- deleted 4y ago[deleted]
- 13of40 4y agoOne thing to be aware of for Reddit (and perhaps HN) is there are multiple scrapers archiving it in real time, so even if you delete a post from the main site it's still going to be available to anyone who takes the time to look. I would assume that government agencies archive and index all of that low hanging fruit as well.
- fasthands9 4y agoI would think this is true though admittedly I think 95% of people just want their comments deleted so co-workers/friends can't stumble upon a semi-political hot take from a few years ago. Not because there is anything illegal or even career ruining.
- generalizations 4y agoI don’t think hn is subject to GDPR, since hn is based in the us, and GDPR doesn’t have jurisdiction.
- frereubu 4y agoMy understanding of GDPR is that, theoretically, any service which is used by European citizens is subject to GDPR. It's the citizenship of the user, not the location of the hosting or service.
- kube-system 4y agoTechnically true, but in practice, jurisdictional limitations mean that this is often ignored without consequence by those who do not have a financial presence in the EU.
- VanTheBrand 4y agoY combinator is invested in quite a few EU companies fwiw
- counttheforks 4y agoDang has confirmed via email he doesn't care about GDPR and has no intention to conform to it.
- AlchemistCamp 4y agoUnder the same kind of reasoning, Hong Kong’s security law of a couple of years ago has global reach and European citizens in Europe can be held responsible for violating it if they say the wrong things.
- generalizations 4y agoThe EU can claim whatever they want - ownership of the moon, taxes from Chinese villagers, or that US companies in the US have to follow their little rules. Doesn't mean they have the right, jurisdiction, or authority.
- samus 4y agoAt least one US state has a data protection law that gives a similar basis for deletion requests. HN already has to honor these, even though they might or might not be useless for EU citizens.
- ForTheWin98 4y agoEven if GDPR does not apply, California's CCPA mandates a right to delete. I don't see any way around that.
- lelandfe 4y agohttps://leginfo.legislature.ca.gov/faces/codes_displaySection.xhtml?sectionNum=1798.105.&nodeTreePath=8.4.47&lawCode=CIV https://leginfo.legislature.ca.gov/faces/codes_displaySectio... > A business that receives a verifiable consumer request from a consumer to delete the consumer’s personal information pursuant to subdivision (a) of this section shall delete the consumer’s personal information from its records Is a comment personal information?
- ForTheWin98 4y agoArguably, and in my own view, yes! The stylometry website linked comment texts to persons. The courts or legislature are the ones to decide this. I believe they could side with my view.
- shagie 4y agohttps://calawyers.org/antitrust-unfair-competition-law/what-is-personal-information-under-the-california-consumer-privacy-act/ https://calawyers.org/antitrust-unfair-competition-law/what-... > The CCPA definition of personal information can be best understood by analyzing separately each of the four closely intertwined building blocks embedded in it: (i) “information”; (ii) “that identifies, relates to, describes, is reasonably capable of being associated with, or could reasonably be linked”; (iii) “directly or indirectly”; (iv) “with a particular consumer or household”. A comment would likely not meet those tests. A user login maybe - though that is already covered in the faqs - https://news.ycombinator.com/newsfaq.html https://news.ycombinator.com/newsfaq.html > Can I change my username? > Yes. Email hn@ycombinator.com and we'll help. Which could then dissociate you sufficiently to pass the tests ii through iv. That might work for me (my user name is relatively unique and consistent) while throwaway123456 may have difficulty passing any of those tests.
- 4y ago
- 8organicbits 4y agoTools exist to delete comments as well, although I'd prefer if reddit supported it with the deletion request. https://old.reddit.com/r/Python/comments/6wfqsv/quick_script_to_delete_your_reddit_comments/ https://old.reddit.com/r/Python/comments/6wfqsv/quick_script...