8 ms·
Mastodon: Servers, Good and Bad
- dossy 4y agoNed's spot on. The single thing that's kept me from joining/participating in Mastodon is the lack of clarity around which server I "should" join, whether I should start my own server, or if I join someone else's server, how portable is my content/profile - can I export it all/import it all into my account on another server easily, or is that a lot of work, or even not possible at all?
- zimpenfish 4y ago> which server I "should" join Any you want as long as you're happy with their rules. > whether I should start my own server It's currently faff (but potentially getting better.) > how portable is my content/profile - can I export it all/import it all into my account on another server easily You can move your account with followers easily (but not posts). Can take a while for everything to filter through on busy servers though.
- dossy 4y ago> You can move your account with followers easily (but not posts). That's what I thought based on what I've read so far, thanks for confirming. Unless and until that's fixed, if I finally see enough value in joining Mastodon, I will have to do so using my own server where I have full access to all my content.
- vidarh 4y agoYou can export all your content, including posts, but Mastodon doesn't support directly importing posts, so you need either a (very) friendly admin or your own server if you want to import it somewhere new.
- pbronez 4y agoYeah this is probably a needed feature. There are some good philosophical objections to post imports, but they’re overwhelmed by practical arguments for it. it’s a solvable problem.
- vidarh 4y agoAbsolutely agree. I think solutions will come, but they may well come as an extension or fork first until it's pointless for the core developers to resist. It's particularly idiotic because the Activities in the export are all signed, so an importing server just need to do a webfinger and profile lookup, and can then validate all of the posts. Of course you can still fake them, but if you show a "moved from <origin instance>" on them, that's really all you need to do - moves from, say, mastodon.social would be trustworthy, moves from some small instance would not. But even that can be fixed with tamper proof timestamps and signing the whole archive, and in any case you can validate this against the public API because it remains accessible on the origin server (at least for some time after the initial move, I don't know how long).
- hombre_fatal 4y agoThat last point is a doozy. Mastodon servers can be as bad as subreddits with power tripping mods, and you don’t necessarily know that until the day you cross a line that you didn’t know existed, just like on reddit. And then your account gets nuked and you can’t migrate your posts. Going from one server (Twitter) to multiple smaller servers doesn’t seem to go far enough on the axis to address major issues that Twitter has. e.g. you still don’t “own” your content.
- zimpenfish 4y ago> e.g. you still don’t “own” your content. If you're not running your own server, true.
- dossy 4y ago> [...] until the day you cross a line that you didn’t know existed, [...] And then your account gets nuked and you can’t migrate your posts. Exactly. This is the critical flaw in Mastodon's design. It does not solve the single biggest flaw in Twitter (or any other typical platform) design, where the platform operator owns the network, and not the author/user. This is why I won't bother investing my own personal time and effort in joining anyone else's server, given how the current design is implemented. It's sad that BitTorrent has now existed for 21 years, and still no one has built a social media content distribution network on top of it. I would have done it but I don't have the motivation to do it alone, as it would tilt control away from the platform operators who require that control in order to monetize the platform to make it worth the investment. :sigh:
- zimpenfish 4y ago> And then your account gets nuked and you can’t migrate your posts. Well, you pretty much can't migrate your posts anyway even if you're moving without being nuked. But if you get nuked, you probably can't move your followers either which would suck.
- toofy 4y agodoes twitter have this problem solved?
- CharlesW 4y ago> Ned's spot on. Definitely. This is a great post that helps explain to technical folks why Mastodon is not (and will never be) a replacement for Twitter, which I say as a Mastodon user and fan. If something has a chance to displace Twitter, it'll need to be as dead-simple to use (like Hive¹). > The single thing that's kept me from joining/participating in Mastodon is the lack of clarity around which server I "should" join… If you're looking for an opinionated answer to this question by someone who's just gone through this, for HN readers I can also recommend the instance mentioned in the article: hachyderm.io. There are a lot of tech and otherwise-interesting people there, and it's run by Kris Nóva². Her most recent articles on Medium talk about running an instance as a serious endeavor. > …if I join someone else's server, how portable is my content/profile - can I export it all/import it all into my account on another server easily, or is that a lot of work, or even not possible at all? Kris's most recent post, "Experimenting with Federation and Migrating Accounts"³, goes into detail on how this works in practice. ¹ https://techcrunch.com/2022/11/21/twitter-alternative-hive-jumps-to-top-20-on-the-u-s-app-store-after-surge-of-sign-ups/ https://techcrunch.com/2022/11/21/twitter-alternative-hive-j... ² SME in Linux kernel security, distributed systems and infrastructure management, and open-source software engineering. https://medium.com/@kris-nova https://medium.com/@kris-nova ³ https://medium.com/@kris-nova/experimenting-with-federation-and-migrating-accounts-eae61a688c3c https://medium.com/@kris-nova/experimenting-with-federation-...
- dossy 4y agoThanks, @CharlesW. I'm familiar with Kris and follow her on Twitter, and see a lot of people have opted to join her Mastodon server, which is great, but her explanation of what happened when she tried to migrate her account from one server to another, where she even controlled both, points to the weakness in the fundamental Mastodon design that makes it a non-starter for me. Being able to export all of your data (posts, followers, following, blocks/mutes, etc.) and to import it into another server MUST be table stakes at this point. Otherwise, you're just trading one Twitter for another, which is foolish, because it means you wrongly believe that history doesn't repeat itself. I'll keep watching from the sidelines and see if the fundamental issues get resolved. It certainly will be interesting to see how things play out, that's for sure!
- jillesvangurp 4y agoI used this website a few days ago to find a suitable server: https://instances.social/ https://instances.social/ And then https://movetodon.org/ https://movetodon.org/ to find some of my twitter contacts on mastodon. As for importing/exporting accounts, they have some documentation for that: https://docs.joinmastodon.org/user/moving/ https://docs.joinmastodon.org/user/moving/
- qudat 4y agoThe primary UX between servers is the "local feed." This is a feed dedicated to all posts within the server. You can't really access that feed from outside of a server. That's pretty much it. You can follow people on other servers, at-metnion, etc. Starting your own server is a waste of time, imo.
- proactivesvcs 4y agoMany servers allow their Local Timeline to be browsed by anyone. From the server's home page, click the "Local" button to the top-right. If you find a person or post you want to interact with, simply copy and paste its URL into the search bar of your app or home server.
- toofy 4y agonot sure why they’re downvoting you, what you said is absolutely accurate.
- proactivesvcs 4y agoI guess my month-long moratorium on bothering to contribute to any Fediverse-related conversation on HN needs to be maintained for a bit longer. Change is painful for many, particularly when they didn't think of it, or can't profit from it.
- tedunangst 4y agoAnd yet, you somehow managed to pick HN over reddit over TikTok or slack or discord or 100 other options. Or maybe all of the above. I'll never get the hand wringing over missing out on posts on some other server. There's tweets and reddits and tiktoks all over the place you'll never see. The lesson should be to make peace with that, not try to find them all.
- rakoo 4y ago> whether I should start my own server This is the right answer. All the questions about moderation, resources, choice and whatever will disappear and you'll be part of the Fediverse like anyone else.
- zeeZ 4y agoI wonder how easy it is for a small instance to get overwhelmed quickly, though. One of my responses to Nova got boosted by her, and my media storage and database size immediately spiked (600MiB to 1.3GiB and 20MiB to 42MiB). Requests went from none to 20/sec, just by that triggering more people to favorite and boost. I imagine if I ever manage to post something profound that someone with even greater influence happens to like, my server will be doomed.
- rakoo 4y ago20 requests/sec is absolutely nothing for a server in 2022. Even if you have many relationships, any individual server will handle the load without any fuss. Worth that can happen is a few minutes in the propagation of messages, which is not exactly a big problem. Seriously, there is no technical reasons we don't self-host; only "cultural" ones (it's hard, it's work, it's painful, and such)
- cbeach 4y agoAuthor describes Elon Musk as “a deranged over-leveraged misanthropic moron” I stopped reading there. Too much silly, hateful hyperbole about Elon Musk at the moment. Yes, I get it - he’s seen as a Republican, and you’re a Democrat supporter. You don’t like the fact Twitter used to be owned by the Blue tribe and now it’s owned by a member of the Red tribe. But for goodness sake, just give it a rest. If you don’t like Musk, just don’t use Twitter. There’s no need to broadcast this.
- addajones 4y agoI felt the same reading the article. So much hate towards a single human. There are many ways to express dislike or disagreement with someone or their ideas and management styles without being so explicit and rude about it. It seems like its a badge of honor and prerequisite to say "I hate Elon, ok moving on about Mastodon..." I believe it's possible to dislike someones views and still have common ground and dialog, but I guess I'm in the minority (online) now.
- emkoemko 4y agobecause he told everyone that Tesla cars would be robotaxis that make you $30,000 a year and you would be dumb not to buy a Tesla...i know a few people who fell for this scam. I stay away from anything he is involved in after this. There are lots of reasons for people hating him and for good reasons.
- cbeach 4y agoSo he’s slow on delivering a very difficult and ground breaking technology (he has, however, delivered FSD to North America). Is that really a reason to hate the man? “Hate” is a strong and emotionally loaded word.
- nedbat 4y agoThis is nothing personal against Musk. When you look at what he has done since taking over Twitter, it's nothing but chaos. He doesn't seem to have a clue how to run that company. I have liked Twitter, and I hate what he is doing to it.
- hprotagonist 4y agoI am coming around more and more to the metaphor that "mastodon is email and activitypub is SMTP". At which point for good or ill verification becomes a server-level problem: see http://blog.archive.org/2022/11/13/we-have-added-a-mastodon-server/ http://blog.archive.org/2022/11/13/we-have-added-a-mastodon-... ; archive.org has a staff-only server, and we'll know if interesting things are afoot if potus@whitehouse.pub or mayor@yourtown.gov or whatever start to exist.
- CharlesW 4y ago"Mastodon is WordPress + a feed reader, posts are posts, and ActivityPub is RSS" is also a near-perfect metaphor.
- hprotagonist 4y ago“blogrolls that work!”
- Kye 4y agoActivityStreams are RSS. ActivityPub is Yahoo Pipes.
- rsynnott 4y agoThe EU already has one: https://social.network.europa.eu/about https://social.network.europa.eu/about
- autotune 4y agoMy primary reason for not setting up Mastodon myself is I don't want to be a content moderator. I am seeing more and more links to content in various Mastodon Servers in one of the more forward thinking Slack groups I remain apart of and think that is a great thing.
- zimpenfish 4y ago> I don't want to be a content moderator. If you're the only user on your server, there's no much moderating to do, I find. Might have to block an instance or remote user now and then but that'd be the same on any instance.
- autotune 4y agoThat too. I also don't want to have to deal with marketing lol. There is a reason I am not interested in becoming an entrepreneur of anything.
- ancientworldnow 4y agoWhy would you need to market? You just follow users on other servers and post your thoughts. It's no more marketing than any social space has to be.
- autotune 4y agoOh it's that connected? For some reason I thought it was more involved. Maybe I will look into hosting it on the personal EKS cluster and get some real use out of it looks like it would be as simple as installing the https://artifacthub.io/packages/helm/si-gitops/mastodon https://artifacthub.io/packages/helm/si-gitops/mastodon helm chart and setting up a domain. Thanks for convincing me ha.
- zimpenfish 4y agoUnless you want 100% Mastodon API / quirks compatibility, I'd skip the original Mastodon source and go for something like Akkoma[1] (it's a fork of Pleroma) - easier to install and much lighter in resource use. If you're only ever going to be single-user, Ktistec[2] might be worth a look Or if you want to go ultra-minimal, there's Honk[3]. (GoToSocial is an up-and-comer but I'm having weird issues with it talking to other instances. But they're working on these things.) [1] https://akkoma.dev/AkkomaGang/akkoma/ https://akkoma.dev/AkkomaGang/akkoma/ [2] https://github.com/toddsundsted/ktistec https://github.com/toddsundsted/ktistec [3] https://humungus.tedunangst.com/r/honk https://humungus.tedunangst.com/r/honk
- aquova 4y agoI agree with some of the complaints mentioned here. The biggest hurdle to joining Mastodon is deciding which server you actually want to join, which has a big impact on your experience and isn't (and probably can't be) clear to a new user. I'm not sure what they can really do for a better onboarding experience. Perhaps one of those "pick which topic most interests you" wizards, which then will give a user a list of servers that have identified themselves as catering towards those types of users. Even then, I don't think this will really help things, and will probably just drive traffic to the biggest servers. As for some of his other issues, I've been pleased to see that de-centralization hasn't happened largely, as there's been a large number of new servers popping up. I thought as well that Twitter exiles would likely congregate to a few large servers, but I've seen a pretty diverse listing of servers in my own feeds. > Your handle on Mastodon is more complicated than on Twitter, because you need to name your server also. I actually like this, it gives a sense of what types of topics the user is interested in, and what their profile is likely to focus on.
- butz 4y agoNot sure if someone has already coined a term for "a feeling when you don't know which Mastodon server to join", but I'm currently here. I am probably wrong, but joining some themed server makes me think that I should be writing and discussing only about that theme and nothing else. Or joining a server not from your region just feels wrong. Of course, I could just spin my own instance, but how to make it attractive to other users, because one user per server ain't very optimal.
- ZeroGravitas 4y agoThey have now: Masto-daunted.
- robga 4y agoAnd: masto-debated
- ftio 4y agoYes, I believe you're referring to Mastodoubt. I have it as well. I've had an account on mastodon.social for ages, but there's nobody there talking about topics I care about.
- aliqot 4y agoWho needs a social network? HN is almost too much. How much hubris is enough to say "people should hear my smallest thoughts and acknowledge them with appreciation or by repeating them".
- lijogdfljk 4y agoI don't "need" one, but i appreciate their ability for community. Ie i'm in the mood for a semi-niche Computer Graphics community. There's something about Microblogging that i find.. interesting. Something like a Forum, say Reddit or an actual Forum is so.. purposeful. Does my WIP post warrant an actual forum post? Likely not. Something about Microblogging seems more fit for WIP posts of artwork/etc, tech thoughts, etc. Likewise i enjoy subscribing to other peoples content in the same nature. The barrier for forums seems to be large enough that the posts that get submitted are often finished works only.. at least in my experience. To me that's less interesting.
- aliqot 4y agoYou need one, but the word 'need' is too strong. If that's the case what other word would you use?
- lijogdfljk 4y agoNot sure i follow. I said i didn't need one because, well, i don't believe i do. Good evidence of this is that i have not, and do not currently, have one. Nor have i ever used Twitter, Facebook or any social platform beyond link aggregators. And even with link aggregators i've rotated accounts and/or deleted history frequently as a way to undermine "identity", which to me is vital to social networks. With that said, lately i've been in the process for searching for one because of the reasons i stated above. I'm looking for a like-minded community on Art stuffs. A forum will do, but microblogging seems to be more inlined with my desired, as i described above. I guess to reword my previous post; "social networks" can have different applications in my view. In the case of microblogging, i like the idea more as a Forum flipped on it's head to reduce friction on content posting.
- jlpom 4y agoThe absence of global search outside of #s is annoying.
- johnklos 4y agoYou know, I think there are a lot of people who completely miss one important aspect of Mastodon: while it's open source, it's EXTREMELY Linux-centric. While people have gotten it running on other platforms, it's fraught with problems and assumptions. Then add that Ruby on Rails has a history of breaking when trying to update to keep ahead of security vulnerabilities, and we may expect to see some big security issues when something is found that's exploitable and updating breaks things, and everyone is sitting around waiting for the Mastodon people and/or the Docker image makers to update things properly. Mastodon would be improved by spending more energy making fewer assumptions about the underlying OS and being less dependent on specific versions of underlying Ruby components.
- zimpenfish 4y ago> Mastodon [...] fraught with problems and assumptions Many other servers are available - Akkoma (Elixir), Honk (Go), GoToSocial (Go), Takahe (Python), Ktistec (Crystal), snac2 (C), ... I should expect by this time next month, you can probably add another 3-5 to that list.
- claudiawerner 4y agoAnd Pleroma too, which somehow missed your list despite being the second most popular AP server...
- zimpenfish 4y agoWell, Akkoma is a fork of Pleroma with a more active and user-friendly focus on development. Pleroma seemed to have stalled and been largely dormant not long ago.
- johnklos 4y agoIndeed. I'm running Akkoma, and it was straightforward to set up and get running, unlike Mastodon.
- lonk 4y agoEvery mastodon server has its own Musk :P
- zimpenfish 4y agoAs the sole user and admin of my server, How Dare You!
- dash2 4y agoAll of this is what I expected: Mastodon is a great big set of public goods problem waiting to happen, and it will take over from Twitter on the Year of Linux on the Desktop. Public goods problems include: * Who makes it easy to onboard people? * Who is responsible for Mastodon not having a reputation - based on some servers, not all but some is enough - as a sink of depravity? * What happens if, say, anti-Rohingya activists decide to use Mastodon to spread propaganda and plan violence? * Who will fix the server when it breaks at midnight? Who will pay them? * Who will pay for hosting if this is going to scale to the whole world? What is the funding model? The solution to bad companies - if you think Twitter on Musk will be terrible - is better companies. It is not software run by a collective of Boy Scouts.
- root_axis 4y agoAll good points, but I think more important than any of them: lacking billions of dollars for growth hacking. These gigantic social media sites didn't become huge organically, they've all dumped boatloads of cash into growing the user base, something a federated social network can never do.
- rsynnott 4y ago> What happens if, say, anti-Rohingya activists decide to use Mastodon to spread propaganda and plan violence? Then everyone defederates. There's precedent for this; Gab is a Mastodon instance for Neo-Nazis, which practically no-one federates with (Truth Social is also a Mastodon instance, but I think it voluntarily doesn't attempt to federate with anyone).
- retox 4y agoMaybe it's a feature only of the soapbox frontend the instance I'm on uses but I can add a remote instance timeline and it's exactly the same as being a user there. The "which instance to choose" problem has already been solved. Another feature is that you can migrate your profile and follows to another instance very easily, your followers get a message to say you've moved and they are already set to follow you.
- dcj4 4y agoTwitter is a great Mastodon alternative.
- kurt44 4y ago> Defederation: A server can decide to never communicate with some other specific server. Your vegan community server could decide not to federate with the safari hunter community server, because of the clash of interests. That’s good, it helps focus you on what you want to see and keeps communities cohesive. It gives server admins a giant kill switch to keep their servers safe. Server admins, X have two switches for defederation another server Y: 1. X silences Y: posts from X aren't visible on X's public timelines. 2. X blocks Y: users on X are unable to follow users from Y. I see how silencing can be seen as keeping users safe. Unsuspecting users of X might not want to see messages from Y. I don't see how blocking for content moderation is reasonable: users of X have to opt in to users of Y to see their content anyway.
- dgudkov 4y agoThe more I read about Mastodon, the more I think wont' take off (unless a deep redesign will be done) and the more I think ActivityPub will succeed. The problem with Twitter and Mastodon is that they both are based on poor abstractions of how humans communicate. They just don't model it well enough. For instance, they completely ignore the basic fact that one person can have multiple interests and communicates with different groups of people depending on interests. Humans are multifaceted things, after all. Another problem is with monetization. There must be paid instances of Mastodon or whatever federated it will be replaced with. Techno-communizm won't work, we've seen it so many times. Yet, here we are again.
- denysvitali 4y agoMastodon's decentralization issues and Twitter's rogue behavior is what's pushing us to develop OpenDolphin [1]. Sadly decentralization doesn't seem to work for multiple reasons that are outlined in the post, and the scary part is that the admin of the Mastodon instance you choose has a lot of power (including reading your DMs). We are trying to build something that will give power to the people in terms of product definition and company's direction. [1]: https://about.opendolphin.social/ https://about.opendolphin.social/
- zimpenfish 4y ago> We might decide to not remove hate speech If you go that route, you'll pretty quickly become a haven for the hate speech crowd and anathema to everyone else.
- denysvitali 4y agoDe-prioritizing it is probably the way to go, but we'll see. Nothing is written in stone and we encourage people to provide their feedback in form of PRs or Slack messages