10 ms·
Startup Restructuring 101
- zuhayeer 4y ago> Have you even straightly asked your users: what would you be ready to pay for? It's a bit up front, but this works. After providing some context to your customer, ask what they'd pay for. Even if they don't answer directly, they're likely to share some more information on what they're looking for or even slip a max budget they might have. Either way it's a win for you to glean some information and make the sale. You can always tailor your existing offerings to the context of your customer, and make them feel like it's specific for their needs. Rest of the article was a great write up on the mindset shift needed to turn around from default dead to default alive.
- hackernewds 4y agoSurveys are a terrible idea. Customers are prone to not being representative or not knowing their own biases - famously Ford said "if you ask a horseman what kind of vehicle you'd want, they'd say a faster horse".
- samtho 4y agoSurveys also terrible because people answer them in 3 different ways on the whole and it’s impossible to figure out which ones are genuine: - the participant answers the survey genuinely - the participant answers the survey as the person they wishes they were - the participant answers in a way they think the surveying organization wants to hear
- fakedang 4y agoIt's not about finding what they "want". It's about figuring out what's the core problem they're facing.
- heisenbit 4y agoWho said that asking users is done through surveys? You should be in a dialogue with your users or if there are many with key users.
- ido 4y agoI want to highlight this paragraph: Freeze all payments that would not result in an outage: rent, non technical vendors, professional services, etc. You’ll get back to them in a more discriminate way in a couple of weeks, once you have a clearer overall plan Is the author suggesting screwing over the companies you buy services from by not paying them?
- kingkongjaffa 4y agoMost B2B are on 30/60/90 day payment terms anyway. You should be able to get your shit together in 30days without delaying any payments. The more prudent thing would be to scrap all subscriptions/SAAS solutions you can live without, with one month notice where you are not contracted, where you are see how to activate any break-clauses etc. So this month you pay the same but maybe next month you cancelled some nine essential stuff and your burn rate is 1-10% leaner? shrug
- bjornsing 4y ago> Is the author suggesting screwing over the companies you buy services from by not paying them? In a bankruptcy or restructuring someone is going to get screwed. That’s sort of the definition of it.
- hef19898 4y agoUsually that happens undet proper bancruptcy proceeding (Chapter 11 or some variety of that depending on jurisdiction).
- simonebrunozzi 4y agoYes. As hard and unfair as it sounds, if you have finite resources and too many expenses, at some point you have to take drastic decisions. The big difference is in how you handle them "in a couple of weeks". You can totally screw them, or you can honor their credits.
- ido 4y agoHow do you know you will actually have money in a couple weeks?
- monero-xmr 4y agoIt’s shocking that a short 10 months ago the recruiters were getting recruited and tech workers were demanding 4 day work weeks. It’s always been a boom and bust industry but this last boom was surreal.
- baxtr 4y agoIn a similar vein this bust seems also to be exaggerated.
- samtho 4y agoI agree. This sort of thing becomes a self-fulfilling prophecy unfortunately, and the incentives that publicly traded companies are given do not align with going against the grain.
- walterbell 4y agoBased on the first chart in the story, this restructuring may be only getting started. If intermingled with a change in the definition of legal tender (e.g. CBDCs), there's no recent precedent. Perhaps London around 1666.
- baxtr 4y agoSo you think it’s just the start? What’s the thing with CBDCs?
- walterbell 4y ago> What's the thing with CBDCs? Potential scenarios include a digital euro/dollar/yuan that lives alongside existing paper cash, "Johnny's Cash and the Smart Money Nighmare" (search for that video which has a short half-life on YT), or something in the middle if elected legislators represent their citizens in negotiations with the BIS/IMF, https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Bank_for_International_Settlements https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Bank_for_International_Settlem.... There's an intro in this thread, https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=32777875 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=32777875 And a few hundred comments in earlier threads, https://hn.algolia.com/?dateRange=all&page=0&prefix=true&query=central%20bank%20digital&sort=byPopularity&type=story https://hn.algolia.com/?dateRange=all&page=0&prefix=true&que...
- ridruejo 4y agoFirst time I heard the term Mokita… interesting in this context
- neilv 4y agoSome of the thinking about getting back to real startup dynamics sounds good, but this part didn't: > Labor market is in your favor: renegotiate compensations, starting with the B players. Whoever leaves will not be hard to replace. [...] Layoffs are disgusting for everybody. Multiple waves are not OK. Be courageous and sensible: any additional wave further depresses your team and worries your customers. And, at least a few thousands of the 175,000 laid off are surely better and cheaper than your bottom 20% performers. Probably more hungry too. > Founders who managed to be relatively less diluted thanks to recent sky-high valuations: carve-out a portion of your own equity to compensate your pivotal talents or new hires If you just listened to the savage management consultant type, and laid off everyone you possibly could, and then hope to take advantage of the misery of others, to hire more desperate replacement workers... Those "pivotal" people with experience are going to see there's no loyalty nor trust in the company. Which doesn't bode well for a startup. Uh, yeah, rather than more equity, cash is good. And, uh, let's switch to weekly payroll, given slippery slopes and the foot-dragging that the management consultant advised about payables to vendors.
- sneak 4y agoExpecting loyalty or trust from a purely transactional business relationship is a mistake to begin with. You should trust that your counterparty will abide by the written terms of the contract. Believing anything further is folly. It's just business.
- neilv 4y agoIf it's only about transactional business relationships, that's a high percentage of one's energetic waking hours to be spending on it.
- fakedang 4y agoI think it's justifiable for employees to feel some amount of loyalty to the concept of the startup when they join it, since they are inevitably taking a significant amount of risk when joining an early-stage company (growth stage startups will be fine). What I don't get is how not many founders believe that loyalty is a two-way street - you should expect to be as loyal to your employees as you expect them to be to your startup.
- vvanpo 4y ago> Hours worked is the #1 driver of any worker’s output: use your right to monitor. I don't think hours behind a screen have ever had much of a correlation with productivity for me. Autonomy, stress, being tasked with solutions that actually make long-term sense, etc. must have a much stronger correlation. The enormous erosion of trust that having my hours monitored would have would certainly impact my output.
- groestl 4y agoI've spent years doing stuff that I'd better not done at all. So yeah, hours worked is not a good metric by any means.
- pavlov 4y agoYes, it’s terrible advice if applied to engineering teams at least. The number of hours that an individual spent staring at the IDE or punching commands into the CLI have no meaningful correlation with the organization’s long-term goals. A manager who spends their time monitoring engineers’ screens is like a web developer who writes a CRUD back-end in x86 assembly. It’s the wrong level of abstraction for performing the job.
- cyrilgrislain 4y agoPeople join forces in a Business, rather than working alone for ex, because they believe the collective sum of resources = inputs will produce greater collective sum of outputs. Responsible businesses are those who maximise the outputs. Otherwise, it is a waste of resources that are extracted from collectivity ($, labor, natural resources, infrastructure, etc). Inversely, that is also why the standard business forms are not best suited for artists to thrive. So, as business is about maximizing output: no matter how much is your productivity, which is a ratio, if you apply it to one more hour of work, then you will produce more output. So there are 2 ways to go here for high-productivity workers: a) you are paid equal for same output, and allowed to work less. b) you work as much as others, then produce more, then are paid more. There is plenty of science that proves that choosing option a) is a shot in own's foot on the long run. Note: 80% of harvard professors thing their students would rate them in the Upper half best professors. which is of course statistically impossible. Same for how anybody = we, self evaluate ourselves in anything: how good a driver, a parent, ... a worker we are. How much hours one puts in is a fundamental parameter of how much one produces. Stays true even with diminishing returns, as long as productivity is >0. There is this say, pardon my french: an idiot who walks will still gets further than a sitting genius.
- tianqi 4y agoAlthough I didn't learn anything new, I must say that not a single word of this article is incorrect.
- pavlov 4y agoI know it’s getting boring to talk about Musk, but the ongoing Twitter experiment is just so fascinating because it’s the first time in history that someone has tried to autocratically reboot a $40 billion tech company with massive regulatory liabilities. So I’m wondering about this part: > Elon is currently applying the playbook to Twitter: > Scale back drastically, ideally the closest to your Series A size and cost base; > Protect your core: engineering and science What exactly is he doing to protect the core? It seems like it’s been all stick, no carrot. What are the incentives for Twitter’s best to stay, other than second-hand exposure to the Musk aura?
- texasbigdata 4y agoSpeculation: option pools (at least pre-ipo) are generally a fixed %age and therefore relative size. With fewer engineers the ones left get a higher piece of the pie? Just a guess.
- pavlov 4y agoBut will that compensate for the almost inevitable outcome that the next liquidity event will be a massive downround compared to the $44B valuation of the acquisition? Maybe there’s only 25% of employees left to share the pie, but the pie itself is now only worth $10B. That’s not a great incentive when asked to work nights and weekends on capricious initiatives that come and go.
- 411111111111111 4y agoIt is if stopping to work is equivalent with getting deported though. Great system the US created with h-1b
- ghaff 4y agoThe problem is that the following is what is was intended for: "The H-1B program allows companies and other employers in the United States to temporarily employ foreign workers in occupations that require the theoretical and practical application of a body of highly specialized knowledge and a bachelor’s degree or higher in the specific specialty, or its equivalent." Note, among other things, the word "temporarily" and the phrase :highly specialized knowledge." The real problem is that H-1Bs are often used by companies in very different ways than their stated purpose.
- alzaeem 4y ago> The past two years created a new type of hype: PMs. Until the Tech Giants (eg: Google, Meta, etc) made PMs the ‘new normal’ of how to get any product functionally built and delivered, down to the tiniest button, startups used to do just fine with no PMs. Chances are very high you could do with less (no?) PMs. Also an excellent forcing device to kill some of your internal bureaucracy. I think the PM fad has been around much longer, to the point one almost forgets how to build products without PMs. But from my experience, I find that the prevalence and empowerment of PMs is largely turning Devs into highly-paid code monkeys, as opposed to the highly-paid and empowered value builders that they should be. Much of the busy work that many PMs are doing can be replaced with a bit of Agile/Scrum training of a few devs per team. At the same time, I would say that having a product owner who develops a deep understanding of the domain, actively talks to customers, and steers the vision and direction is immensely valuable. But I hardly see any of my PMs doing it. Anyway, I am seeing a lot of negative sentiment towards the prevalence of PMs these days, which I mostly share. Would love to hear any counter-thoughts or corroborations of this. Are PMs necessary? How should they be utilized?
- intelVISA 4y agoNot an expert on PMs (is anyone?) but my understanding is the value to the business is, as you mentioned, abstracting the need to manage SWEs as value builders and instead as cogs within the Abstract Agile Machine, in this Sick Reality the PM is Programmer Remade and we are reduced to function calls. Software makes a lot of money and plenty of smarter people out there have invented roles to extract some of that (your) wealth without having to touch Vim. Due to the relative novelty of CS I think we're still going through the early motions of trying to mesh together a web of programmers from bootcamps to MIT into one cohesive corporate apparatus... eventually we'll land on something similar to medicine or other engineering areas where accreditation is prerequisite and individual cogs have a bit more agency due to licensing etc. Hopefully. My personal, unsubstantiated, take is that we'll come to look back on this odd time, with the glacial pace and grift hierarchy of enterprise software, as quaint. Some startups are coming around to the idea that you don't need 6 person multidisciplinary teams for generic CRUD, pay one competent engineer those 6 people's salaries and you'll get it built unless it's something special - in which case you pay that engineer 60x and their name is Bellard.
- hef19898 4y agoAs other already pointed out, myself included, yhere are some risky things, eg. stopping payments without legal analysis and talking to vendors and suppliers, which I am sure the author knows need additional steps to do properly (well, I assume he does given his background). This one advoce here: >> Founders must go back in the trenches and own back the direct leadership on: product development, engineering, monetization and hiring I more or less strongly disagree with. Because it highly depends on the founders, whether or not they have the necessary background to lead the restructuring. Because we shouldn't forget, it was most likely the founders that got the company in question (the article is about start-ups of sorts after all) into trouble in the first place.
- cyrilgrislain 4y agoTrue, some Founders just won't succeed at that, for lack of profile or mindset or experience. But ultimately, especially in VC-backed startups, everything starts and stops with the Founders at least until Series B. Handling well hardships is part of the role, and contributes to the making of the most successful Founders. Now, Founders don't have to do this on their own and can get help. Especially for bigger companies. Knowing how to acknowledge your own limitations, reach for help and delegate is a core CEO attribute. I have seen over and over again Founders doing that very successfullY.
- rexreed 4y ago> For the 20% of your customers generating 200% of your cash I don't get this math.
- thiscatis 4y agoThis stood out for me as well, I guess it's just meant as hyperbole.
- cyrilgrislain 4y agoSay you generate +$100 in cash. It is typically composed of customers generating +$200, and other destroying -$100. Typically you have an a) small fraction of cash-generating customers bringing in your +$200, and another b) small fraction of cash-losers explaining the -100$. The highest RoI actions are to focus on groups a) and b)
- rexreed 4y agoI responded to your comment in the thread above where you posted the same response.
- say_it_as_it_is 4y ago> I worked with Founders, CEOs and funds to save 7 companies from bankruptcy. In B2B, Consumer, and Infrastructure, from Series A to post-IPO. Saving tens of thousands of jobs, generating $2B+ in cash, and rising again, stronger than ever. Why bother reading the article with this level of self-aggrandizing absurdity? How much fiction will be presented as fact?
- zomglings 4y agoThis article is a worth a read from anyone who is currently operating a VC-funded technology business. Most people running such businesses in the last few years have been applying lessons and processes well-suited to a much rosier economic environment. Many companies have not yet transitioned their attitudes and processes to suit the current economic environment. You may feel that this article is absurd, but it legitimately tells you how deep a cut you can make to survive as a company. And the shapes this cut can take. Another piece I recommend is "Peacetime CEO/Wartime CEO" - https://a16z.com/2011/04/14/peacetime-ceo-wartime-ceo/ https://a16z.com/2011/04/14/peacetime-ceo-wartime-ceo/
- cyrilgrislain 4y agoThank you for sharing in this forum and starting this thread!
- iamflimflam1 4y agoAnyone working in a startup right now should be evaluating these hard truths from the article: We raised a ‘hot’ Series A, but have not proven PMF Our uniqueness is more in our narrative than in our product We are building a feature, not a product We have no clue how to get solid unit economics We have built a high-pay ‘9 to 5’ spoiled culture (btw, ‘Startups are hard’ is not meant to be true only for Founders) Our top performers will quit as soon as they find another job If you are one of the “top performers” then you should be thinking about how much you really believe the business can make it.
- rexreed 4y agoStartup companies in many ways are like funded high-risk research projects. They live and die by the support of their benefactors. In this case, the benefactors are investors who are interested only in one thing -- the growth value of an asset, their share of your company. If it's all inflating, then it's all good. If not, then the research project comes to an end. Whether or not they generate real revenue or provide customer value seems to be primarily an afterthought or side-effect of growing the asset value of the company. Startups are really financial products more than technology companies in many ways. Maybe we should call these startups investor-funded businesses (or perhaps more precisely, non-revenue generating pre-market fit investor-funded technology-centric companies). Then again, maybe that's what startup means these days. In which case I guess 20% of customers generating 200% of cash might make sense.
- morelish 4y agoThe author sounds absolutely horrible.
- codingdave 4y agoWhile much of the advice in here is good, some of it is really off, including a huge miss in the very first sentence. While bankruptcy has its problems, declaring bankruptcy is not the same thing as shutting down. Bankruptcy is a tool used to do exactly what this article is talking about -- restructure the business. It isn't the right answer all the time, and I have my own personal philosophical problems with bankruptcy, but when an article doesn't even point out that it can be a part of this process, there is a big gap in the perspective presented.
- cyrilgrislain 4y agoyou may sometimes prefer to, in other occasions need to, but certainly do not always HAVE to declare bankruptcy to do a restructuring :) As you can read, I chose to share a selection of quick-to-implement actions Founders can do. Declaring bankruptcy certainly doesn't fit those criteria.
- simonswords82 4y agoAnecdotal data but.. Was at a party with an acquaintance a week ago who said they need more money by February or they’re dead. Series A but still not profitable. From the outside looking in they have nearly 100 employees, PMF, great marketing and appear to be crushing it. So it was sobering to hear the reality. I asked what the plan B is if money is not forthcoming and he looked at me like I was asking a stupid question. I think the guy running it has been in this situation previously and do or die mentality is there. However as many people are saying this downturn feels different, deeper and more prolonged. I will be watching their progress with great interest from February and use their ability to weather this storm as a yardstick albeit acknowledging it’s just one data point. Bootstrapped companies that are profitable and sustainable will be rejoicing at the moment for sure.
- deleted 4y ago[deleted]
- pclmulqdq 4y agoThe fact that a lot of startups end up on this kind of trajectory is a big part of why I haven't sought seed funding for my current company. However, this has meant learning how to do sales, and suffering from a comparative lack of connections (and credibility) that come from investors. Bootstrapping definitely has its upsides and downsides, but I assume that in ~12-24 months, if this recession (or whatever you want to call it) continues, a lot of venture funded companies may find the money drying up. VC firms are likely finding it harder to get money for new funds, and this will trickle down to a tightening in the startup ecosystem. Bootstrapped companies will likely be able to thrive by essentially feeding on their carcasses. There may be a third way for startups that is actually better in this environment - doing a few rounds (seed through maybe series B-C) and then making it to reasonable levels of profitability, giving up ambitions of "eating the world" - but I'm not sure that most startups can achieve this. It seems to be a lot harder than either bootstrapping or taking funding to grow until you IPO (while still unprofitable).
- rexreed 4y agoI completely agree with your sentiment. I'm a bootstrapper at heart. However, I've dearly learned in the past few years that as a bootstrapper, one of the biggest dangers is believing that markets seem real, when in fact, they are only being buoyed by investor money and hype. This causes a mistaken belief that there are real, paying customers and the market is indeed growing and significant for new entrants when what's actually happening is the rapidly growing startups and even supposed customer-growth are supported by investor money, not by paying customers. When a bootstrapper tries to come into the market and isn't playing the investor-led startup game, by trying to build a company through customer money vs. investor money, they see that there aren't nearly as many customers as they would need or expect, and when customers are paying, the hype-driven, investor-backed startups are eating up a significant portion of the customer base. This is because customers, far and few between in those rapidly growing, hypey markets, tend to be "lazy" buyers and will not spend the time to do any sort of real evaluation or analysis of competition and markets. Rather, if they have a real need for the product, they will buy either from who they are already buying from, or if they will select a new vendor, it will be someone they can get support internally to purchase (if it's an enterprise), with such support being a combination of a who their existing suppliers or consulting firms recommend, influence from content marketing or shilled analyst reports (buying influence), whatever companies are gaining the most attention and marketing at that moment, and/or who their colleagues and peers are recommending, all of which is subject again to startup influence, and besides a bit of a self-perpetuating cycle since the more they get recommended, the more they get recommended. In any case, it’s never about who has the better product or service or who offers the most value for the money. In addition, and ideally, if the product costs nothing or very little to acquire, that makes it even easier for those few customers to gain support for a new vendor and that perpetuates the cycle, or if the customers' existing suppliers include the product or features of that product for no additional cost in their existing or new offerings, that makes it harder for the vendor. In any case, the fact that others are giving away a product for free or low cost makes it near impossible to compete as a bootstrapper, since you can't afford to give a product away, even if the startup can. If you're selling directly to consumers (or to small businesses, which act like consumers) and not to enterprises, then it's even harder as a bootstrapper, since customer acquisition cost and complexity is very difficult and expensive, and those who have the most marketing dollars combined with products they give away or practically give away will win. Bootstrappers almost always lose in those market conditions. Yes, there are definitely exceptions to all the above, but I am finding the rule generally holds. All this makes bootstrapping particularly difficult in fast-growth, hypey markets, which is where startups tend to proliferate. Basically, bootstrapping in an investor-led startup's game is not a recipe for success, and probably a road to ruin. You might be able to bootstrap selling ancillary stuff on the sidelines of what's happening in the hype-driven market, mostly marketing content-driven stuff, events, webinars, selling traffic, training or education, but even that stuff will come and go, and we're not talking large exits either. You can also sell consulting or advisory services in those hype-driven markets, but you have to really enjoy the consulting or advisory game and you have to mostly have relationships and connections to sell that sort of thing. Ideally, as a bootstrapper, you can go from hype-cycle to hype-cycle and keep and grow your existing customers. You can also bootstrap real products (not services or marketing content) in more sedate markets, but you'll most definitely face entrenchment of incumbents who protect their customer base, and so making entry into the market as a bootstrapper just as difficult. The key is to know what game you're playing and the best way to win at it, if you want to succeed, especially without exhausting yourself in the process. I know someone who is actually following a different "third way". Rather than raising a few small rounds with aims of profitability (no investor will be satisfied with that since investors are looking for asset value increase, not profitability), it's about raising some early rounds, growing and getting attention fast, and quick exiting. He has been able to crack this code by building small, fast-growing, investor-led startups, but only up to a certain level (usually up to Series B), and then finding a quick acquisition exit, before the music stops. Somehow he has figured out not only how to do the quick fundraise, growth, and attention building, but also how to develop relationships on the acquisition end of the exit. While these aren't billion-dollar exits, this approach seems to work and he has a stable of investors who know how to play that game for everyone's benefit. I haven't figured that out myself.
- asah 4y ago> The past two years created a new type of hype: PMs. um, no. In the 1990s, it was widely recognized that PMs "pay for themselves" at around 6-10 engineers. Obviously, the ratio depends on the kind of work, but PMs are generally much faster and better at human-human communication and decision-making, where engineers (generally) get bogged-down with minutiae and struggle to tell a business-relevant narrative, to the right people, at the right time and in a way to get better decisions made. The extreme example: https://lettersofnote.com/2009/10/27/the-result-would-be-a-catastrophe/ https://lettersofnote.com/2009/10/27/the-result-would-be-a-c... (this "should" have been enough, and it wasn't - which is why it's a good example)
- arcturus17 4y agoIt's not only the recession that will self-correct the startup explosion of the last few years, but perhaps more importantly the rise of interest rates. Billions or trillions of investment will be re-allocated back towards the other end of the spectrum (fixed-income assets).
- hn_throwaway_99 4y agoThanks for posting this, I think this is the most important point, and I also think it's a great thing. The downside of the business cycle is no fun, but it should be expected nearly as much as the sun rises and sets. What I believe is truly different, though, is that a generation of people have never known "reasonable" interest rates. People are acting like we're near end times when the effective fed funds rate was still only 3.08% in October [1]. Yet for decades before the start of ultra-low rates with the Greenspan years, rates were much, much higher. And there are fundamental structural changes that mean that ultra low rates will be dead probably for the rest of my lifetime: 1. The end of the Cold War brought a "peace dividend" and wildly increasing globalization. That trend has abruptly reversed. It will be a long, long time before countries outsource so much without considering the geopolitical consequences. 2. The ongoing retirement of the boomers, and a re-evaluation of many women in the workforce who have found that it doesn't make sense to make a relatively low wage just to spend it all on childcare, means that labor will be much tighter than in the past couple decades. Also, my hypothesis is that vastly increasing wealth inequality means that a lot of folks who would have previously focused on their careers now no longer see themselves as "temporarily embarrassed millionaires", as we've seen a resurgence in interest in unions. The good thing about a renormalization of rates is that companies will actually need to make money again to stay alive. 1. https://fred.stlouisfed.org/series/FEDFUNDS https://fred.stlouisfed.org/series/FEDFUNDS
- cyrilgrislain 4y agoyep. And VCs will need to deliver even higher returns to stay alive. In fact, the recent exuberance allowed VCs to get rid of the 'hurdle rate' = min return to deliver to LPs before making any carried. This will probably be corrected back, as it should be. If interest rates stay high, then hurdle rates will be very challenging for VCs.
- bgoldste 4y agoDid not realize 'tabus' was the plural of taboo. Anyone else?
- klysm 4y agoI don't think I've ever seen that word in text, and would not realize that was the definition because 'taboos' is acceptable.
- 331c8c71 4y agoHe also wrote "Assana" meaning "Asana" I suppose. > Double-down on tracking discipline and focus (don’t have an Assana yet?)
- neilv 4y agoWhen I had to use Asana, pronouncing it Ass Sauna seemed entirely appropriate. (Putting the miserable sauna behind an Instagantt wall helped.)
- rukuu001 4y ago“Dedicate a street smart colleague to collect outstanding receivables.” Could be taken the wrong way :) (We have a running joke about ‘sending the boys around’ to a customer who owes us a lot of money and no plan to pay)
- cyrilgrislain 4y agoThank you everybody for your time to read my publication and all these rich comments I hope your company's are not in such dire situation to have to apply these tools. But if you are, I am happy to entertain a Q&A in this forum to help navigate at best.