10 ms·
Sabine Hossenfelder: There are areas where physics blurs into religion
- emsign 4y agoI've noticed she gets some more attention outside her blog and YT channel recently.
- cratermoon 4y agoShe's refreshingly keen on evidence and testability for physics advances. The entire niche of taking the equations and treating the results they give when pushed to the limits as reality is very dodgy. This is true even though black holes we predicted by plugging extreme values into general relativity. While black holes do exist, we don't know yet how well their real physical properties match those predicted by GR. String theory in particular has had a testability problem from the very beginning. https://www.math.columbia.edu/~woit/wordpress/?p=533 https://www.math.columbia.edu/~woit/wordpress/?p=533
- ars 4y agoActually the event horizon of a black hole has never been observed. All current observations are also consistent with quark stars. We don't know what the quark degeneracy pressure is, so there's no current way to differentiate.
- bmitc 4y agoWhat does it mean to observe the event horizon? LIGO has been able to confirm theoretical properties of the event horizon. The EHT has imaged a black hole, which effectively images the event horizon. > All current observations are also consistent with quark stars. Is there a reference for that?
- thethirdone 4y ago> LIGO has been able to confirm theoretical properties of the event horizon. What specific properties has LIGO confirmed about the event horizon? It is not quite clear to me how the gravitational waves of two merging bodies would be different between a merger of normal stellar objects and black holes. > The EHT has imaged a black hole, which effectively images the event horizon. The EHT image is mostly an accretion disk. I think accretion disks can also form around things that are not black holes. If something were of the sufficient density, I believe it could make the same image without having an event horizon. I am no astrophysicist though so maybe that image would force the density to be sufficiently high to make a black hole.
- pdonis 4y ago> It is not quite clear to me how the gravitational waves of two merging bodies would be different between a merger of normal stellar objects and black holes. No "normal stellar object" can be more compact than 9/8 of the Schwarzschild radius for its mass. (This is a result known as Buchdahl's Theorem, first discovered in the 1930s.) Gravitational wave emission when objects of that size or larger merge is much less energetic compared to the total mass involved than the merger of black holes, which merge at the Schwarzschild radius; also the predicted waveforms are different, because there is actual matter (nonzero stress-energy) present when normal stellar objects merge, whereas black holes are vacuum (zero stress-energy).
- bmitc 4y ago> What specific properties has LIGO confirmed about the event horizon? Hawking's area theorem is one: https://news.cornell.edu/stories/2021/07/hawkings-black-hole-theorem-observationally-confirmed https://news.cornell.edu/stories/2021/07/hawkings-black-hole... > It is not quite clear to me how the gravitational waves of two merging bodies would be different between a merger of normal stellar objects and black holes. I'm not sure one can be so loose here. LIGO uses detailed models of black hole and neutron star mergers to match the signals against. What are "normal stellar objects" that would yield the same magnitude of gravitational waves emitted during a merge as black holes and neutron stars? > The EHT image is mostly an accretion disk. I think accretion disks can also form around things that are not black holes. There's also a huge hole in the middle of the accretion disk. What other object, other than a black hole, has such a large accretion disk but yet no emitted radiation?
- naasking 4y ago> All current observations are also consistent with quark stars. Gravitational waves are a prediction of GR but not of quark stars, so GR explains more of the available evidence than quark stars alone.
- ars 4y agoThat is not true. General relativity concerns itself with mass, and gravitational waves are function of mass. Quark stars have plenty of mass, why would you think they would not generate gravitational waves? I don't understand what you could be thinking of. In fact a black hole would make things more complicated because of the infinite time dilation. If anything gravitational waves are evidence for extraordinarily massive objects, but against black hole singularities with their problematic infinite time dilation.
- pdonis 4y ago> General relativity concerns itself with mass, and gravitational waves are function of mass. This is way too simplistic. Gravitational waves are waves of propagating spacetime curvature. They can certainly be produced by "mass", i.e., by objects with nonzero stress-energy, as long as those objects (or mergers of such objects) have time-varying quadrupole moments. But they can also be produced by objects like black holes (or mergers of such objects), which have zero stress-energy and are made purely of spacetime curvature. > a black hole would make things more complicated because of the infinite time dilation There is no such thing. The effect you are talking about is an artifact of a particular choice of coordinates and has no physical meaning. It certainly does not prevent black hole mergers from emitting gravitational waves.
- ars 4y agoThe choice of coordinate is Earth. From the point of view of Earth black holes can never merge because it would take an infinite amount of time to do so. I do not care about the point of view of the black hole itself, or the point of view of an object falling into the black hole. And it most definitely has physical meaning, and while gravitational waves could be emitted, they can never actually get to the merger. The gravitational waves would essentially slow down and fade out if it was a black hole. And since that is not what we see, I do not find the data compelling for black holes, but rather for ultra massive objects.
- pdonis 4y ago> All current observations are also consistent with quark stars. We don't know what the quark degeneracy pressure is, so there's no current way to differentiate. This is not correct. There is a maximum mass limit for any object supported by quark degeneracy pressure, regardless of the equation of state. That is a fundamental fact about relativistic degeneracy that has the same general consequence for any kind of degeneracy pressure (it was originally discovered by Chandrasekhar when he discovered the maximum mass limit for white dwarfs that is now named after him). What the exact limit is depends on how stiff the equation of state is, but even the stiffest equation of state leads to a mass limit of about 3 solar masses. We know of plenty of compact objects that are far more massive than that.
- ars 4y agoHow do you know the object is compact? The idea is that quark degeneracy pressure is enough to keep the object from ever becoming dense enough to form a black hole. No one knows the actual quark degeneracy pressure, so no one knows if stars collapse to black holes or if they get stopped.
- pdonis 4y ago> How do you know the object is compact? Because we have these objects with huge masses but we can't see them, and such objects have to be compact. Objects with those masses that do not emit huge amounts of light that make them easily visible (i.e., that are not stars) can't not be compact. They either have to be held up by degeneracy pressure, which means they are either white dwarfs or neutron stars/quark stars, or they have undergone complete gravitational collapse and are black holes. All of those objects are compact, and there are no other possibilities. > No one knows the actual quark degeneracy pressure, so no one knows if stars collapse to black holes or if they get stopped. This is not correct. I have already explained why: the maximum mass limit. That limit applies regardless of what the actual quark degeneracy pressure turns out to be in an actual gravitational collapse. It is a fundamental fact about relativistic degeneracy.
- ars 4y ago
- oceanghost 4y agoShe's got someone doing good PR for her. I've been a subscriber for years and never seen her on HN except for the last few months. I'm probably an order of magnitude less intelligent than her, but her arguments seem extremely reasonable to me. She seem to me to be a bridge from the PBS, pop-science mentality to more serious considerations. Also, she's a fox. :-)
- deleted 4y ago[deleted]
- axiom92 4y agoShe has a dedicated channel for her music videos! https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=-eWOxKcpsXU https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=-eWOxKcpsXU
- Tozen 4y agoHere is the original version of the song, https://youtu.be/WmP3OJLJbB0 https://youtu.be/WmP3OJLJbB0, though not sure why there needed to be a remix. My goodness, strange on so many levels. Kind of looks like she is having fun, but hard to tell.
- tasty_freeze 4y agoI think the comparison is facile. I'm just a layman, but it is my strong impression that nearly all scientists working at the edge of astrophysics and quantum theory know what they have is a model, sometimes stunningly predictive and accurate but still a model. The vast majority of experimentalists (and theorists) would love to get some result that is inexplicable, far more than another experiment that takes years and doesn't turn up any surprises. Dark matter, dark energy -- as far as I know, everyone working on them see our current ideas as placeholders until someone comes up with a good explanation. Sure, there are many examples of scientists clinging on to old ideas too long, but eventually when enough evidence is marshaled by someone to overturn the old model, they are heralded and given honors. That is all to say: frontier physics is utterly unlike religion, where so may claim to KNOW the truth, where the most tenuous claims are literally gospel, where there is little desire admit counter-evidence.
- deleted 4y ago[deleted]
- naasking 4y ago> but eventually when enough evidence is marshaled by someone to overturn the old model, they are heralded and given honors You mean when the old guard retires and dies, like Planck said.
- deleted 4y ago[deleted]
- lamontcg 4y agoIf there were as many PhDs working on stuff like twistors, loop quantum gravity, MOND, gravitational wave function collapse, etc as there are working on string theory and dark matter/energy I'd agree the argument was made up. But they're vastly outweighed by the PhDs working in String Theory which is going on 50 years now with nothing really to show for it experimentally. And they do claim that they know the truth, and they defend their PhDs, and their grants and grad students, with rationalizations that aren't testable and don't admit any evidence. It very much seems like a religion. Nobody has patched the holes in the theories that I mentioned, but almost nobody works on them, so the problems become self-fulfilling. And it just isn't that easy these days to have a single Einstein come along and upend the apple cart with a handful of rapid fire papers.
- shrubble 4y agoWerner Heisenberg: "In the history of science, ever since the famous trial of Galileo, it has repeatedly been claimed that scientific truth cannot be reconciled with the religious interpretation of the world. Although I am now convinced that scientific truth is unassailable in its own field, I have never found it possible to dismiss the content of religious thinking as simply part of an outmoded phase in the consciousness of mankind, a part we shall have to give up from now on. Thus in the course of my life I have repeatedly been compelled to ponder on the relationship of these two regions of thought, for I have never been able to doubt the reality of that to which they point.” From “Scientific and Religious Truth” (note that Heisenberg was a devout Lutheran from what I have read)
- locallost 4y agoAs she points out in this interview, she liked the church as a community, but was not a believer. I think most religious people fall in this category, their religion is more about everyday life than the divine. It gives them peace of mind and a set of rules to go by, which eliminates a lot of friction and doubt in life. So in that way it's not incompatible, but at the core they are the most incompatible things possible - one is about overcoming your limitations to understand the world better, the other to either accept things without questioning them or even try to find proof for something you already believe, ignoring all contradictions.
- zozbot234 4y ago> So in that way it's not incompatible, but at the core they are the most incompatible things possible ... There are many ways of understanding the world; rational thinking is only one of them. Note however, that the kind of theology that organized religion is usually known for is a kind of, perhaps misguided, rational thinking. The real core of religious thought is closer to direct theophany. (Note that a genuinely rational account of theophany and such is quite possible, but only at a meta level. The way you directly engage with such things is what leads to the distinction I'm referencing here.)
- locallost 4y ago
- jcampbell1 4y ago
- zabzonk 4y agoexcept we may be able to detect wormholes in this universe, but we have a few problems detecting other universes
- echelon 4y ago> The multiverse isn't ascientific The harder it is to test a given hypothesis, the closer to fantasy it becomes. It may be valuable if it simplifies the math or makes better predictions, but we've certainly seen a lot of careers spent on string theory and other conjecture.
- naasking 4y agoYou should entertain all predictions of a physical theory. That's how you test and possibly falsify them. Multiverses are an interesting intellectual exercise, but are they the only way to "solve" the specific problems we're encountering in physics? If not, then presumably there is at least one single universe theory with different properties that might yield different insights instead of sweeping the inconveniences into different universes. Those different properties might even be testable. It just doesn't seem like multiple unobservable universes actually gives you anything actionable where single universe theories might.
- jemmyw 4y agoI think she's willing to entertain multiverse conversations too but the point is if there's no way to test their existence then believing in them is not a scientific position.
- Schroedingersat 4y agoMultiverse is just the null hypothesis. Whatever you want to call them, the pieces of reality we call the wave function and entanglement exist. If you want to assert extra mechanisms in order to claim measurement isn't just the lab getting entangled then that's fine, but the positive assertion requires positive evidence. Whether or not the multiverse is ontologically real or just the simplest abstraction that works is irrelevant. Dogmatically holding on to collapse as a concept without evidence is the position that is ascientific.
- akomtu 4y agoIt occurred to me that modern science and major religions study the same thing. The central axiom of religions is the consciousness-matter duality. The one uber consciousness (aka the god, the one without the other) brings everything into existence and splits itself into many pieces to inhabit this world. Compare this to the QM-GR duality: GR tells us what the matter really is, while QM tells the story of one uber wave-function that brings everything into existence and splits itself into many "particles" that evolve more or less independently. There is one important difference, though. Religions say that all this has a purpose: the one great consciousness wants to understand itself. Science, on the other hand, believes in chaos.
- jemmyw 4y agoUltimately any purpose is circular because there's always another why. And science doesn't necessarily describe chaos. There are some questions science just doesn't answer and doesn't need to. We might never get the tools to peer past the boundaries of space and time, so speculation made by scientists in those areas is still kind of religious or at least not science. Religion can simply say God created everything last Thursday as if it had always been, and science has no refutation for that and doesn't need one. Therefore I disagree with your analysis just because currently you can make that analogous comparison. There's probably always something like that because social discourse will spread current science to religion and vice versa, but they do not really need to compete. Also science has a chance of solving it's split but religion and philosophy will bang on about consciousness forever.
- deleted 4y ago[deleted]
- terminal_d 4y ago"Who watches the watchmen?" We need more Sabine Hossenfelders. Too bad natural hierarchies seek to excommunicate such people.
- colechristensen 4y agoShe’s a bit of a charlatan who leans too heavily on criticism of mainstream or even criticism and exaggeration of the Selena of developing theories. There is an attraction to having “real” knowledge that everybody else is full of manure, i know some people whose small children have found conspiracy youtube and are struggling at dinner conversation over every “well actually”.
- matthewmacleod 4y agoThere’s a certain attraction to counter-mainstream views of course—the idea of being part of a secret smart club—but it’s a massive red flag when someone starts to define themselves and their views substantially in terms of that opposition. Interesting counter-mainstream ideas are important and valuable - but I don’t hear about any of them from Hossenfelder’s writing, and it’s all about how broken “the system” is. Everything I watch or read from her leaves me deeply suspicious.
- terminal_d 4y ago> but it’s a massive red flag when someone starts to define themselves and their views substantially in terms of that opposition. Anyone from the other side could make the same argument (and they often do). If you're trying to name a "us versus them" then there's just one big mainstream entity, the rest is fragmented. So it's not really a "red flag" because opposition is by definition not a coherent group.
- terminal_d 4y agoI wouldn't call her a charlatan, but I would call many people on the "other side" that. Wading through BS is practically a full-time job and she's very good at it. If "low morale" is really the bottleneck then we aren't getting any science done anyway. And as an aside, I don't believe in group / peer based "science". There's a few geniuses (often not credited) that define the entire thing while everyone else seems to practically be in marketing by comparison. Science can be a group institution, but educational institutes are far from it. Criticism and disbelief are the bedrock of Science, and calling people that don't flock to still-unproven claims "science deniers" is very dystopian. There's also entire groups of phenomena that "hard" / popular science conveniently ignores. They all fall under Science by definition, but not under science-the-religion.
- LarsDu88 4y agoShe's absolutely right. When I was a kid I watched and read a lot of Brian Greene's stuff about string theory. I even saw him give a talk in person about the multiverse in grad school (I studied biology). The truth is, Greene is brilliant but his idea of science veers into fantasy. There's an entire generation of physicists who grew up during an era where all the low hanging experimental fruit evaporated. A modern physics experiment costs millions if not billions of dollars. Some of these physicists in their 50s have no idea what experimental science looks like, and this mentality has bled into the popular consciousness of what scientists do. It's in biology where you still have ample low hanging fruit in terms of experiments. I feel if you're a brilliant physics grad in 2022, don't waste your time on string theory - apply some of that knowledge to chemistry and biology
- europeanguy 4y ago> She's absolutely right. I wonder how much contact you have with the world of research in theoretical physics that lead you to this conclusion. More to the point: do you have any, or is this person your only source of information? Do you know that phenomenon where you think you're learning good information from a source, until that source talks about a subject you're an expert in and you realize they have no idea what they're talking about? That's how I feel every time I see Sabine hossenfelder on HN. I have a PhD in theoretical physics in a string-adjacent field[1], and my view is that this person has had negative net contribution to physics. First by contributing zero from poor research, and second by detracting by spreading the impression amongst the general population that experts aren't really experts, they don't know what they're talking about, are stupid or corrupt etc etc. Seems to be the theme of the 2020s that the most incompetent of any field become financially the most successful by making a business out of writing about how their colleagues are ignorant. [1] my experience interacting with the kinds of muppets that are fans of Sabine is that at this point you'll have learned the argument that "well of course you think that way, that's because you're in the system and benefit from its rotting, being a PhD in X". If that's what you think about me, don't bother even responding. In reality I've left the academia for industry and am doing 10x better financially than any of my ex-colleagues - I benefit nothing from the effort I make in trying to communicate what is really going on here.
- flobosg 4y agoShe has (or had?) a consulting service for autodidact physicists: * http://backreaction.blogspot.com/p/talk-to-physicist_27.html http://backreaction.blogspot.com/p/talk-to-physicist_27.html * https://aeon.co/ideas/what-i-learned-as-a-hired-consultant-for-autodidact-physicists https://aeon.co/ideas/what-i-learned-as-a-hired-consultant-f...
- renewiltord 4y agoShe's quite popular for this "emperor wears no clothes" stuff but has she done any meaningful research? All my friends with Physics Ph.D.s are in industry so they aren't of much use.
- sampo 4y ago> but has she done any meaningful research? If you want someone with a stronger track record in research, but with essentially the same message, there is Lee Smolin and his book "The Trouble with Physics". (1) Google Scholar lists a person's publications in the order of the most cited first [1]. Hossenfelder's 2 most cited articles [2,3] try to figure out the implications of the idea of what if there is a minimum length scale in nature. (Like the speed of light is maximum possible speed. What is there is a minimum possible length, i.e. what if nature has a resolution, like computer graphics?) [1] https://scholar.google.com/citations?user=NaQZcyYAAAAJ https://scholar.google.com/citations?user=NaQZcyYAAAAJ [2] https://link.springer.com/article/10.12942/lrr-2013-2 https://link.springer.com/article/10.12942/lrr-2013-2 [3] https://www.sciencedirect.com/science/article/pii/S0370269303014217 https://www.sciencedirect.com/science/article/pii/S037026930...
- renewiltord 4y agoI see. I recall when I was young that I believed that the universe was on a Planck length grid and then was disabused of this notion but I don't remember why. Is her work significant? I will check out your book recommendation.
- gorgoiler 4y agoWhen you look up at the stars, do you see the constellations? When astronomers refer to V509 Cassiopeiae, they believe in the shape of the stars they call Cassiopeia. Do they believe the shape is a real thing? Of course — I can draw it for you, it’s there every night and looks like a W! Of course not — you cannot touch it, it’s just an artifact of how we try to understand the Universe and our place in it! The God of Christianity is a concept that is there if you believe in him, and is not there if you don’t. To prove his existence is meaningless. It provides the same struggle as trying to prove that Cassiopeia exists, or what it means at an atomic level to touch an object, or whether complex multicellular organisms are one single being or a colony of many beings.
- beloch 4y ago"But from a scientific perspective, if you want to make progress in our understanding of natural law, I’d say it’s a waste of time exactly for that reason, because you can’t test it." Science is doing what works, and you can't tell what works if you rely on theories that aren't testable. (What does it even mean for an untestable theory to work?) But... What if some theories that aren't testable eventually lead to theories that are testable and useful? How do we know when to abandon a chain of inquiry? What about theories that are technically possible to test, but currently impractical? Do we stop developing them until the technology to test them exists, or might further work reveal easier tests? For a long time, physicists were fairly ruthless about abandoning work that didn't quickly lead to something that could be tested experimentally, but not always (e.g. Bohmian mechanics was pursued quite ardently even though it's predictions do not differ from standard quantum mechanics.) In the last few decades, as we've increasingly searched for things like grand unifying theories that might bridge the chasms between fields, we've begun to tolerate an increasing amount of work that is not founded in anything testable. The key developments that will tie a field back into reality often seem just around the corner but never appear. It boils down to a question of how we allocate resources. Work done on untestable theories that never become testable is wasted, so where do we draw the line?
- adastra22 4y ago> What if some theories that aren't testable eventually lead to theories that are testable and useful? The history of physics is such that this almost never happened. In fact I'm struggling to think of an example in which it did, though I'm sure there are some examples somewhere. The few things I can think of are stuff like antimatter, which popped out of the theory and weren't taken seriously until they were unexpectedly confirmed by experiment. On the other hand as you mention the history of physics is littered with theories and frameworks pushing beyond the experimental frontier, only to be discarded. String theory being only the most recent example.
- nl 4y agoShe points to both the big bang and the idea of a multiverse as things that cannot be tested.
- MomoXenosaga 4y agoWe live in a world were science and technology won. Religion is desperately trying to latch on in order to remain relevant.
- ogogmad 4y agoIt looks like steady progress is being made in Mathematical Physics (which I believe is physics done from rigorous mathematical definitions - so you can no longer bullshit the Dirac delta "function" for instance). Some of that stuff is apparently supersymmetry-inspired and strings-inspired, but doesn't technically rely on any of these theories being true.
- rajman187 4y agoI read her book Lost in Math [1] which I have to say was quite a laborious endeavour. It is essentially a long-winded argument that is better summarised in this article and her YouTube channel, though she got to visit many scholars across the globe. Some agreed with her to a certain extent while others simply didn't (Nima Arkani-Hamid, for example, had no interest in her point of view). What I found most lacking was a viable path forward, an alternative to all this nay-saying. She had a section in the end with bullet points on what to do and not do, but it was quite brief and generic. I had a short but interesting exchange on Twitter with Dr. Tony Padilla who has spoken about the case for string theory on Numberphile [2]. He stands at the opposite end of the spectrum of course, and it's worth listening to what he has to say as well. Being a non-expert with just a casual interest in the inner workings of the universe, I am eagerly awaiting whatever the next breakthrough brings for our understanding of the cosmos, but I have to say that string theory and susy have seemed to over-promise and under-deliver with little prospect in sight, and perhaps at the detriment of a more fundamental or foundational approach. Indeed, the question of what is time has always bothered me, so I'm picking up Carlo Rivelli's book on this next [3]. [1] https://www.basicbooks.com/titles/sabine-hossenfelder/lost-in-math/9781541646766/ https://www.basicbooks.com/titles/sabine-hossenfelder/lost-i... [2] https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=Q8ccXzM3x8A https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=Q8ccXzM3x8A [3] https://www.penguin.co.uk/books/301539/the-order-of-time-by-rovelli-carlo/9780141984964 https://www.penguin.co.uk/books/301539/the-order-of-time-by-...
- deleted 4y ago[deleted]
- sdht0 4y agoRichard Feynman has a good talk on this tendency to do "cargo cult science" [0]: The first principle is that you must not fool yourself—and you are the easiest person to fool. So you have to be very careful about that. After you’ve not fooled yourself, it’s easy not to fool other scientists. You just have to be honest in a conventional way after that. The history of science is rife with examples where eventual well established theories had a hard time getting off the ground because mainstream thinking at the time actively refused to consider them (plate tectonics, inflation, etc). I remember reading quite a few example in Max Tegmark's book Our Mathematical Universe [1]. All this to say, both the current state of our attempts to reach the next frontier of human knowledge (string theory, say) and Sabine's criticisms follow age old traditions of back and forth in science. Both are needed, the former to make actual progress and the later to keep the bad ideas in check. Having said that, I personally detest the particular populist-with-lack-of-nuance approach Sabine (and others like her) take. I like Sean Carroll's books [2] and his Mindscape podcast [3] for a more nuanced view. For instance, his recent podcast with Raphael Bousso [4] is such a nice overview of the current state of the art Physics. On string theory: String theory, I think, has given us from my perspective, as far as I can tell, the only consistent candidates for theories of quantum gravity that are in any sense complete. In particular, it has led to the discovery of the AdS/CFT correspondence. That is a lot of letters. But what it means is that there’s a certain class of universes, unfortunately, not including the one that we seem to be living in, but still a very rich set of space times worlds that you can imagine, for which we have a complete quantum theory of gravity. Or at least it could be wrong. We haven’t tested it experimentally. But it’s a very significant statement that you have a theory which is complete in itself, it’s not missing anything. You could put it on a computer and run it, you can calculate things with it. And so that I would say is, from the physics perspective, the number one thing that has come out of String theory, there’s a lot of beautiful mathematical results, and many other applications that the theory has had. [0] https://calteches.library.caltech.edu/51/2/CargoCult.htm https://calteches.library.caltech.edu/51/2/CargoCult.htm [1] https://www.goodreads.com/book/show/19395553-our-mathematical-universe https://www.goodreads.com/book/show/19395553-our-mathematica... [2] https://www.preposterousuniverse.com/books-courses/ https://www.preposterousuniverse.com/books-courses/ [3] https://www.preposterousuniverse.com/podcast/ https://www.preposterousuniverse.com/podcast/ [4] https://www.preposterousuniverse.com/podcast/2022/11/21/218-raphael-bousso-on-black-holes-and-the-holographic-universe/ https://www.preposterousuniverse.com/podcast/2022/11/21/218-...
- dav_Oz 4y agoI think it isn’t inherently “bad” (until you begin to fight for “resources” i.e. academic careers - which in my mind is what this now long-standing “controversy” really boils down to) that physics/cosmology at the frontier bleeds into regions of (yet) untestable hypothesis. It is kind of a natural progression of abstraction by defining physical objects, in the end you arrive at some endpoint like the “universe”. So, you wonder: “Hmm, in order to study it properly I need more than one. Let me see if there is some viable way to propose it. Which new predictions am I getting? Does it a better job than … ” etc The same holds true for other frontiers like exobiology, consciousness etc. where one can easily wind up in woo-woo territory. Hossenfelder mentions Penrose. Another prominent figure who pops up frequently is Stephen Wolfram with the means of financing himself. They are making bold claims which are most likely - surprise, surprise - false. But because the chances are astronomically or cosmologically low it is seen as somehow this high-stake game in reputation. Since there is only a tiny fractions of scientists with a lot of chips (say Noble Prize), when they get on the table the crowd cheers on. So, unfortunately most play safe in the long term. One such strategy was/is to hide the “trouble” behind ever more sophisticated mathematical abstractions which at least undoubtedly require extraordinary and disciplined mind to be even able to grasp. Ever since Lee Smolin called bs on that I feel that string theorists, now, appear more humble, careful in their presentation and acknowledge the pitfalls. As an popular example Sean Carrol comes to my mind. To put it constructively: level the playing field and measure your position with the same standard as you evaluate others. The more powerful, diverse and precise shots in the dark in terms of viable theories we get to test the better the chances.
- pyinstallwoes 4y agoBig bang theory and archaeology are both founded by Jesuit priests.
- deleted 4y ago[deleted]