7 ms·
Always interesting to see how certain kinds of political speech were never really protected by the First Amendment. And to remember that WW1 was ended, in part
by pjc50 4y ago
Always interesting to see how certain kinds of political speech were never really protected by the First Amendment.
And to remember that WW1 was ended, in part, by labour action: the October Revolution in Russia, and the Kiel Mutiny in Germany.
The full speech is here: https://genius.com/Eugene-v-debs-anti-war-speech-annotated https://genius.com/Eugene-v-debs-anti-war-speech-annotated
- anon291 4y agoUsing examples of terrible decisions in order to justify continuing to make bad decisions is a terrible way to govern.
- Spooky23 4y agoThere’s always a reactionary push to silence people for their own good. John Adams kicked it off, and Woodrow Wilson’s craven politics represented a moment where the country could have moved in an awful direction. It’s unfortunate that we live in an era where many people have mastered the art of mass manipulation. We’re in an era where we’re vulnerable to the same sort of grinding warfare that WW1 became, and the information landscape is a barren one full of propaganda and junk.
- vkou 4y agoNo, we don't silence people for their own good, we silence people for our own good.
- Spooky23 4y agoSure. The problem is, who is “us” and who is “them”. Unfortunately the 20th century shows what people are capable of in pursuit of protecting “our” stuff, whatever that may be.
- MisterMower 4y agoWoodrow Wilson was the worst president in US history. If I had a time machine, I would go back in time to kill Wilson, not Hitler. Hitler would be a no name artist if it weren’t for Wilson completely fucking up WWI and the peace thereafter. Fun fact: Wilson resegregated the entire federal government and even went so far as to show a KKK propaganda film at the White House. The guy was a rabid racist. Additionally, Wilson had a stroke that left him blind and paralyzed in 1919 and for the remainder of his presidency his second wife and doctor manipulated him so heavily that there is serious debate as to who actually was in control of the White House during those years. Some historians call Edith Wilson, his second wife, America’s first female president the manipulation was so effective.
- MarkMarine 4y agoI find his speech to the court, knowing full well he was headed to jail for the crime of speaking out against the war, more powerful. He left half the members of the court, the people who later convicted him, in tears. Full speech here: http://www.emersonkent.com/speeches/address_to_the_court.htm http://www.emersonkent.com/speeches/address_to_the_court.htm
- cdmckay 4y agoAnd yet they still sent him to die in prison
- MarkMarine 4y ago“While there is a lower class, I am in it. While there is a criminal element, I am of it. While there is a soul in prison, I am not free.” I think to hear him tell it, he was already in prison.
- nopenopenopeno 4y agoThis is absolutely the meaninh of these epic lines.
- simfree 4y agoThey could have done a jury nullification.
- pooper 4y agoIt isn't that easy. The judges are all crooks and liars and will make you pay because you didn't "respect my authority" (read in the voice of the petulant child, Eric Cartman from the cartoon show South Park). In fact, I feel like I am doing something illegal just by typing this. We cannot win in a court of law. They will simply replace us if we show them any brain activity. You must reach a unanimous not guilty verdict, not because of jury nullification but because you genuinely believe the defendant is not guilty. > For the most part, the answer is no. You should NOT discuss jury nullification with your fellow jurors. > It is well-established that it is perfectly legal for a juror to vote not guilty for any reason they believe is just. However, courts have also decided that they can remove jurors for considering their option to conscientiously acquit. > This applies anytime until the verdict is officially rendered. Even as late as deliberations, if a disgruntled fellow juror decides to tattle on you to the judge, you could be replaced with an alternate juror. We recommend not openly discussing jury nullification during deliberations. > https://fija.org/library-and-resources/library/jury-nullification-faq/should-i-discuss-jury-nullification-with-my-fellow-jurors.html https://fija.org/library-and-resources/library/jury-nullific... All normal disclaimer applies. I am not a lawyer. I anal. Yada yada.
- IIAOPSW 4y ago[flagged]
- throckmortra 4y agoWhere was he arguing for Communism? Do you believe pro-labor == Communism? Your post reads as knee-jerk and paranoid
- dsfyu404ed 4y agoIt's beyond dishonest to frame him as paranoid for making the connection when the person he's replying made that connection for him. He might just be pro-labor but not pro-communist.
- throckmortra 4y agoWhere did he make the connection?
- chefandy 4y agoYeah don't you hate it when people inject their obvious political bias into comments?
- compiskey 4y agoIf you read the Founders writings justifying the first amendment you’d read it’s origins were rooted in fear members of Congress would be shot during periods of open debate. It was not until the last 60-70 years the “zeitgeist” changed such that free speech was considered a freedom for all the government could not intrude upon.
- est31 4y ago> And to remember that WW1 was ended, in part, by labour action: the October Revolution in Russia, and the Kiel Mutiny in Germany. I don't know much about Russia, Germany certainly has given Lenin a train ticket so that he could participate in that revolution, because they thought that it would help their interests. But for Germany, the theory that Germany lost the war because of the revolution is the so called "Dolchstoßlegende", a right wing conspiracy theory. Germany has already lost the war before that revolution. https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Stab-in-the-back_myth https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Stab-in-the-back_myth
- arlcode 4y agoYes and the mutiny did happen in part because the German navy planned for a Last-Hurrah-Suicide mission to "die an honorful death" The sailors were not cool with that and decided to not be killed on the final stretch of a pointless war That was the final straw and was used to kick of the revolution. The monarchy already had lost most of its authority by that point.
- lostlogin 4y ago> Germany certainly has given Lenin a train ticket This was fascinating and amazingly conniving. The Churchill quote, saying Lenin was smuggled back into Russia "in a sealed truck like a plague bacillus" is quite the imagery. Lenin on the Train by Catherine Merridale covers it well.
- AlbertCory 4y ago> WW1 was ended, in part, by labour action: the October Revolution in Russia, and the Kiel Mutiny in Germany "in part" saves you there. Otherwise it's nonsense. WW1 was certainly not ended by the October Revolution. If anything, it made the war 10x worse, by freeing German troops for Ludendorff's 1918 offensive, which almost succeeded. The Kiel Mutiny? Maybe accelerated the end by a few days. The Germans were already seeking an Armistice. > certain kinds of political speech were never really protected Adams and Wilson were indeed villains here. Lincoln suspended *habeas corpus." Roosevelt sent Japanese-Americans to the internment camps.
- philistine 4y agoUsing in part is perfectly fine because for the Russians, the war was completely ended due to labour action. They owe their war's end to that. Was it the right decision, or did it end up losing more lives in the long term? Whole other discussion.
- AlbertCory 4y agoLeaving aside the toll of Communism over its 72 years: There was a Russian Civil War, which we don't hear much about. So the war hadn't really ended for them. There was also a war between Russia and Poland. I looked some for a total of "WW I casualties by year" table but didn't find one; only "casualties by country." The significance would be "giant German offensive; therefore giant casualties." In any case, I don't think there's much of a case for the hypothesis "Russian Revolution saved lives."
- thriftwy 4y agoFor Russians, the war has started in 1917. Whatever there was in 1914-1917 now barely registers compared to what has followed. It is also disingenous to call Russian revolution a "Labor action", since it was performed first by army generals and members of ruling class, then by political exiles-in-return.
- 4y ago
- enkid 4y agoYou're ignoring the Russian Civil War, which killed millions more. It's not like the October Revolution was a clean stop to the violence. And even after the end of the Civil War, the political violence didn't end.
- deleted 4y ago[deleted]
- smsm42 4y agoThe Constitution can work only if the society allows it to work. If the SCOTUS judges are willing to concoct arguments saying "this political speech is so bad we must ban it at all costs" and the society lets them - then there's no magic Constitution Man to jump out of shadows and stop them. > by labour action: the October Revolution in Russia Calling Russian revolution a "labour action" is like calling WWI "a brawl between some German and British lads". Technically, part of it fits this description, but one can't but notice it doesn't exactly paint the correct picture. Also, Russian revolution didn't really end the war - rather, Russia was losing badly, which in part led to the regime collapse, which made Russia sign the peace and get out of the war which it could no longer fight. The war didn't end by it though.