3 ms·
Great communication is a skill. Being good at mathematics is a skill. The fraction of people who have both skills is tiny. If you have to pick one, then it is b
by roenxi 4y ago
Great communication is a skill. Being good at mathematics is a skill. The fraction of people who have both skills is tiny. If you have to pick one, then it is better to spend time being taught by a great mathematician over a great communicator.
Then add to that the effort required to learn the subtleties of maths and compare that to the time it takes to get exposure in the real world, and it quickly becomes clear why mathematics education is unsatisfying.
- marcosdumay 4y ago> it is better to spend time being taught by a great mathematician over a great communicator. At university levels, maybe. It's certainly not overwhelming better, so you want at least a basic capacity of communication. But for most teaching, a merely good understanding of math, with heavy knowledge of communication is clearly better. For a start, young students do not learn any advanced math.
- fn-mote 4y ago1. Learning mathematics is a skill. If you teach/learn this skill, the effect of other barriers will be reduced. 2. Learning to communicate is a skill. Instead of saying "the fraction of people who have both skills" you could say "the fraction of people willing to learn both skills"... then it becomes more clear that if someone is teaching poorly it is because they are not putting in the time to acquire the skill of communicating/teaching. I don't think people are talking about problems with great communicators in this thread. The complaints are usually about below average communication. Anyway, I am grateful to have been taught by both great communicators and great mathematicians. The great communicators have a huge impact, don't underestimate it. The issue is that you might not even understand the impact of what the great mathematician is telling you, unless it is communicated in a clear way. All I remember from one geometry class is the pictures... and they make the fundamental idea crystal clear.