3 ms·
A fun thought experiment - imagine a fantasy society with no credit. Everyone who can buys a house based on their wealth. Introduce a bank into the picture, ma
by roenxi 4y ago
A fun thought experiment - imagine a fantasy society with no credit. Everyone who can buys a house based on their wealth.
Introduce a bank into the picture, making loans. How does that change the situation? It might not cause more houses to be built, because the physical situation hasn't changed. but it does mean that everyone ends up having to spend a lot of time working for the bank because it ends up that people with access to credit end up in a bidding war to try and buy houses.
We've tried very low interest rates in the west for a long time now. There is a dire shortage of hard evidence that it has helped people to own houses. Credit unwinds are painful in the short term, but in the long term I don't think it will be a major problem. Profound sadness for the people who were caught out with debt in the near future though.
- sph 4y ago> We've tried very low interest rates in the west for a long time now. There is a dire shortage of hard evidence that it has helped people to own houses. It hasn't helped because it is more profitable to get money on a loan to pay back later — that is, enter a short position against the currency and pay back later when it is cheaper to do so. Loans are granted proportionally to entities based on their wealth, so companies and rich people are more likely granted bigger lump sums, which they use to invest in real estate among other things, than people on regular or minimum wage. So, during low interest rates, more loans are given out, wealthy entities buy real estate with the easy money, leaving everybody else to live on the scraps and/or creating an abusive rental market, unless there is strong housing laws enforced by the government. If there aren't, you have situations like London, where most of the city centre is empty flats bought by rich foreign investors, and actual citizens are driven further away into the suburbs, in an rental market that becoming more and more unaffordable. IMO there is no economical solution to the housing crisis, because loans always favour the wealthy, and they're always in look for investment products; real estate is one of the safest.
- skybrian 4y agoTiming is everything. Being able to buy a house and live in it before you can pay for it is a substantial benefit. This is what loans do. There's no reason why it wouldn't cause houses to be built earlier than they would otherwise. I thought this was interesting: > Bricks — actual bricks, not stacks of cash — are another common savings mechanism, especially for working-class Argentinians. The value of bricks is fairly stable, and they’re useful to a family building out their house. Argentina doesn’t have a mortgage industry, and thus buying a pallet of bricks each time you get a paycheck is an effective way to pay for your home in installments. > (Bricks aren’t fully monetized, in that I don’t think people buy bricks and then sell them later, so people only use this method of saving when they actually have something they want to use the bricks for.) > As you can imagine, there are challenges that come with saving in wads of $100 bills or stacks of bricks. For one thing, they take up a lot of space. Worse, your life savings are also at constant risk of theft, damage, and fire. If something does happen, the bills are not insured or protected by any institution; they’re just gone. https://www.freethink.com/hard-tech/crypto-argentina-black-market-cash https://www.freethink.com/hard-tech/crypto-argentina-black-m...
- roenxi 4y agoAlthough that is a desirable use case; the important question to me is whether that is actually what is happening. I'm from Australia and our housing case is much worse than in most of the world. I know a lot of people who have enormous mortgages, and I can swear to the fact that none of the money they borrowed went to construction. They were paying to queue-jump people more like me who refuse to deal in debt. Which I can respect. But I think debt avoidance strategies will win out in the long term, on average. Unless they cheat and use debt to get ahead, then get it discharged by some political trick.
- skybrian 4y agoWhy would you say that new housing isn't being built where you live? Seems like the demand is there?
- roenxi 4y agoI expect it has been made practically illegal to build new apartment blocks in desirable locations. There isn't a lot of construction relative to the amount of debt being handed out.
- alvah 4y ago“But I think debt avoidance strategies will win out in the long term, on average.” I agree with you, but you have to be prepared for the long term being longer than a human lifespan. For example, house prices in the Netherlands were arguably at bubble levels for almost the entire 18th century.
- ralph84 4y agoThe purpose of low interest rates was never to help people own houses. It was to enable governments and corporations to paper over bad decisions by kicking the can down the road.
- eddyfromtheblok 4y agoTricon, as mentioned in the article, is publicly traded, owns houses in the US south, some of which are newly constructed, and has $1B to buy more houses once interest rates drop. So there’s institutional investors standing to profit if interest rates drop and if rents continue to increase. Seems like investors think it’s a good idea for them
- CPLX 4y ago> It might not cause more houses to be built, because the physical situation hasn't changed. That’s an extraordinary leap. The entire purpose of pooled capital is to enable more productive investment. Sure, if the very premise of the system is negated in step one the results of your analysis of the system will be different. But your argument is sort of like saying what if water wasn’t wet.
- roenxi 4y agoIn a free market what you say would also be my position, but we've got a non-free market where the people who own the military are jamming credit into the system like a cook stuffing a chicken and distorting the risks. We've seen interest rates well below the levels where investment needs to be productive. We've seen that the risk for a highly correlated drop in asset prices is being assumed by taxpayers and/or people vulnerable to inflation (the most recent example is the madness of the stock market shrugging off the effect of COVID policies). There is an interesting question to consider about what happens when that sort of distortion hits a market. In Australia the cases of high debt I've seen haven't generally been linked to construction.
- CPLX 4y agoI mean it’s not like we haven’t tried this. Without loans normal people don’t buy houses. At least not early in careers. How exactly would a regular wage earner save enough to compensate people for the thousands of hours of embedded labor it takes to build a house in a reasonable time? Where do they live in the meantime? We have tried subsistence living models. It’s not better. The problem isn’t that access to capital exists it’s the combination of excess capital with drastically restricted supply due to anti building policies, as well as general unequal distribution of resources.
- jojobas 4y agoWithout loans, if you don't have money to buy the house upfront, the builders can't get paid for their work. You'd have to arrange something with the builders to pay in arrears, essentially getting a loan from them. Land value however is 100% propped up by loans.
- imtringued 4y ago>It might not cause more houses to be built, because the physical situation hasn't changed. but it does mean that everyone ends up having to spend a lot of time working for the bank You mean interest payments? The principal goes to the previous home owner, not the bank. >We've tried very low interest rates in the west for a long time now. There is a dire shortage of hard evidence that it has helped people to own houses. You are contradicting yourself. You just said introducing banks means paying fees to the banks instead of spending the money on housing. Now you say that lowering fees paid to the bank doesn't help? You have to pick one or the other. It is pretty obvious. Lower interest rates make building new houses cheaper. The monthly cost of housing went down with lower interest rates but houses also got bigger and zoning restrictions got worse. Since buildable land has a shrinking supply, its price went up!
- roenxi 4y ago> You just said introducing banks means paying fees to the banks instead of spending the money on housing. Now you say that lowering fees paid to the bank doesn't help? You have to pick one or the other. Those two statements can be consistent with each other. If we pick on the US because that is the default economic canary, you can see that very low interest rates [0] hasn't had a sustained impact on home ownership rates [1]. So, obviously, excessive amounts of credit hasn't helped with home ownership even as the rate of interest went low. It isn't much of a stretch from there to say that giving the banks all that extra help hasn't assisting matters. There is a market level of credit that would be extended, but the system has been purposefully pushed to provide much more than that. [0] https://www.aboutinflation.com/_/rsrc/1307805149788/interest-rate/interest-rate-united-states/Interest_Rate_US_Historical.png https://www.aboutinflation.com/_/rsrc/1307805149788/interest... [1] https://dukewarner.com/wp-content/uploads/2020/05/home-ownership-chart.jpg https://dukewarner.com/wp-content/uploads/2020/05/home-owner...