3 ms·
An absolutely amazing city. And fascinating in that in this more collectivist society you have actual individualism whereas most American towns are heavily conf
by renewiltord 4y ago
An absolutely amazing city. And fascinating in that in this more collectivist society you have actual individualism whereas most American towns are heavily conformist and enforce this through law.
A curious glimpse into the fact that societies are not simply collectivist or individualist but so or not so across multiple axes.
One thing that I find interesting is how much laws influence these things and how a society moves from growth to preservation.
It seems that societies grow greatly and then settle into a period of stagnation, constantly talking about golden years while actively stifling them in the present - moribund European economies, the erstwhile innovation cities of America.
Curious. You can only create greatness while your populace is weak because once it is strong it seeks the status quo and slow decline - loss aversion trumping exploration.
Ultimately, in some way, cities and states suffer the Innovator's Dilemma too!
- throwaway821909 4y agoI guess you've heard it before but “Hard times create strong men. Strong men create good times. Good times create weak men. And, weak men create hard times.” I don't know whether it's true or not... hard to prove there's causation and not just random cycles of improvement and decline due to luck or external factors - the higher you climb, the easier it is to fall.
- rat87 4y agoIt does sound a bit like fascist nonsense. On the other hand I do have to admit to people often become stronger to when they need to in order to survive. Look at the Ukrainians. Still I'd rather they were living calm and peaceful lives maybe with a better economy instead of having to be brave and strong to survive.
- rocknor 4y agoAnd how exactly is that "fascist", can you explain? The word has no meaning now.
- Aeolun 4y agoI think it’s easier to say those things in hindsight. Obviously, if someone created good times, they must’ve been strong men. If the times are getting worse, it must be because whoever is in power is weak. I’m more inclined to say that when times are harder, it becomes easier for fortunes to shift, and a lot of the regulations that would otherwise stifle growth are lifted (either because nobody cares, or because the law makes it so).
- astrange 4y agoJapanese people are significantly more individualist than Americans. You can have any weird hobby you want and they’ll ignore you. They produce more cultural exports per capita than the US does too. The stereotypical collectivist society is a better description of Korea. A better way to explain Japan is it’s like England but Asian.
- TapWaterBandit 4y agoI find this implausible after just having visited Japan. The Japanese and Japanese culture are a lot of great things but I would never ever describe it as individualistic.
- astrange 4y agoThey’re not showing it to you. They keep it private but it’s still there. (that’s called “honne and tatemae”) You’re welcome to look through used fashion/music stores in Tokyo if you want to see how good their soft power is. Meanwhile the stereotypical suburban American thinks every nearby city is a hub of crime and won’t let their children walk anywhere until they’re 25. Vs: https://twitter.com/patio11/status/1596322167222063104 https://twitter.com/patio11/status/1596322167222063104
- quantumwannabe 4y agoYou should read the replies to that tweet: https://twitter.com/keccers/status/1596324554095595521 https://twitter.com/keccers/status/1596324554095595521 https://twitter.com/robinkunde/status/1596325433653559298 https://twitter.com/robinkunde/status/1596325433653559298 It is very common for American schools to have student art shows. I don't know where you get your perception of the US from, but it sure isn't reality. Your other two "observations" are similarly divorced from the real world.
- astrange 4y agoI read them. I think the point being missed there isn’t that it happens at all, but that US schools would be expecting that out of much older children. (My critique here would be, if you ask elementary schoolers to do a project, you might just get what their parents can do for them.)
- ilyt 4y agoI think the axis here to look at is not individualism vs collectivism but empathy and willingness to cooperate. > It seems that societies grow greatly and then settle into a period of stagnation, constantly talking about golden years while actively stifling them in the present - moribund European economies, the erstwhile innovation cities of America. I feel like more often it's not "it was great but now it is worse" but the fact people forget the bad stuff and remember the good times. Sure, buying a home is more expensive than ever but in general standards of living in most places are steadily growing and we're not getting poisoned by lead in petrol or have lead &asbestos in walls.