5 ms·
I was once part of a department that was so well-managed and functional that I couldn't quite believe it. Then when time came choose a new department head, some
by stncls 4y ago
I was once part of a department that was so well-managed and functional that I couldn't quite believe it. Then when time came choose a new department head, someone told me that they had always specifically avoided people who wanted to lead the department for the job.
- yesbut 4y agoGood policy. In worker owned enterprises that are run democratically the owner/employees elect their managers from the ranks. They act as manager for a term and then go back to their original position after the next election. Keeps everyone based in reality.
- bsenftner 4y agoDecades ago, the Boston University Free Press (the alternative views newspaper) was managed in this manner. My buddy ended up running the paper for a year because he was the least political, most liked guy working at the place. He just wanted people to be happy. After a year, he was no longer happy and was glad to give up the job.
- yesbut 4y agoManagers, like politicians, should have term limits. The temptation for abuse and favoritism is too strong.
- beardyw 4y agoA perfect model for democracy I would say.
- Jenk 4y agoThe flaw is that it forces someone into a role they do not want to fulfil, that could see the occupant become resentful of those around them and act out of spite. The short answer is there is no perfect model, people will always be people.
- soco 4y agoI somehow expect that person wouldn't have become spiteful _just_ because of the election, so wouldn't get elected in the first place... but yeah, we only have bad or worse solutions.
- dasv 4y agoAn idea that goes back to Plato's republic.
- Eddy_Viscosity2 4y ago“Anyone who is capable of getting themselves made President should on no account be allowed to do the job.” - Douglas Adams
- victor106 4y agoMy simple mind thinks:- Why would you want someone who does not want to do a job do that job? If you are interviewing someone and that person said “I don’t want to do this job” would you hire that person?
- salawat 4y agoThere's a difference between "I don't want to do this job", and "I don't want to do this job, but it needs to be done, and apparently everyone else thinks I'm the best fit for it. As much as I now hate you all, I'll do it, and may God have mercy on your souls." I've been told several times that I become scarily competent at anything I hate, far in excess of those things that make me happy or bring me joy. I guess what I'm trying to say is, don't discount disgust or aversion to something or it's lack as a disqualification to manage that thing. Quite to the contrary, they may be just the person aware enough of the thing in question to reliably manage it. I'll take a candidate who can explain at length why they hate that job over the most eager "this'll be great" candidate ever. I'll just be realistic about my assessment of their tenure, and the compensation offered, and try really hard to figure out what they actually want before pulling the trigger on the hire.