15 ms·
Microsoft's ex-UI chief is shocked about the Windows 11 start menu
- petilon 4y agoThis article quotes Jensen Harris... the guy responsible for Windows 8 UI, which was a disaster.
- bigmattystyles 4y agoI still like the time they put the full screen win8 metro style start menu on their server OS. Pure genius!
- Haga 4y ago
- emodendroket 4y agoI'm still not sure I understand what made that so heretical other than being different. I can't really imagine any scenario where I'd be using the start menu and want to see something else at the same time.
- slavik81 4y agoThe reason why you need to open the start menu is often on screen, then you hit the Windows key and the context that should be driving your next action is hidden. All it takes is a brief moment of distraction and — if you're like me — you'll completely forget why you opened the menu in the first place. It's like walking into a room and forgetting why you had entered. At that point, maybe you return where you came from and see an unopened package. Then you remember: you were retrieving scissors. When the motivating context is in front of you, it's easier to remember what your goal is.
- emodendroket 4y agoWhat I thought was nice about it was that, if you're primarily a search user, you got a lot more real estate for the search results. I suppose they achieved some of that in the new design and the feedback has been pretty close to unanimous, though.
- kasabali 4y agoThey achieved more real estate with less results, for sure.
- jiggawatts 4y agoMore importantly, every method for opening the start menu was difficult on a server. Hitting a 2x2 pixel magic corner when not full screen and over a 100ms latency link is simply infuriating. The special “Windows key” would similarly not make it through KVMs, iLO/DRAC, and most cloud consoles. It was an exercise in frustration topped by only by this little pop up: “Swipe here to view this notification.” Okay, I’m swiping. Still swiping. It’s going to work any minute now…
- hulitu 4y agoYeah, they copied the idea in the new calculator.
- ChuckNorris89 4y agoEveryone on Twitter is a critic, thinking their opinion is the right one, and looking for their 5 minutes of fame by shitting on some low hanging fruit for clicks and likes hoping that will lift them out of their anonymity. I can't imagine a great designer like Jonny Ive (not that everything he did was perfect), sinking so low as to shit on Windows's start menu as he probably has bigger fish to fry. Great people don't need attention from shitting on other people's work because they get enough recognition from the quality of their own work. Only the has-beens with over inflated egos do that.
- Synaesthesia 4y agoThe Windows 8 start menu is fundamental, and it alienated a lot of people, something Apple have never done, they've kept their basic design consistent.
- aemreunal 4y agoHonestly, I think Jonny Ive makes good industrial design (minus the far too extreme "minimalism" push with the butterfly keyboard MacBooks; they really need an "editor" like Steve Jobs) but their UI/UX design has really not been good. Alan Dye is way worse. I find modern Apple software UI/UX design to be really devoid of functionality, information density, etc. I'm not the only one with this opinion (just listen to any Accidental Tech Podcast episode where they talk about it).
- sjcsjc 4y agoShitting on low hanging fruit is an unusual activity
- 8note 4y agoWhich was too bad, the zuneHD UI it was based on is still my favourite ever touch screen experience. It's however, really opinionated about being for listening to music and playing some games
- deleted 4y ago[deleted]
- amanzi 4y agoI think he also did the Office ribbon menu, which is far better than what was before it.
- MagnumOpus 4y agoIt is not, especially not for power users, and those who want to become power users - discoverability of keyboard shortcuts is absolutely shit now. And unlike even the Reddit devs, they made it worse and made it impossible to keep the old menu bar setup. The ribbon is part of the lamentable drift in Windows UI towards intentional dumbing down and not even allowing the power users to do what they could before -- see also the new Windows Settings menu...
- kasabali 4y agoRibbon was polarizing. Start screen was unanimously bad.
- hulitu 4y agoThe ribbon is not a menu. Is a mess. It can even show you keyboard shortcuts. Now if i could remember what Alt + 5 means. Earlier you had Alt + f for file menu and the first letter of the command. But i think that was too easy.
- notRobot 4y agoI would pay so much money to just be able to use Windows 7's UI with Windows 10's performance improvements. Try spinning Windows 7 up in a VM sometime. Using it is such a wonderous experience. It's almost perfect. I miss it so much. To me, Windows 8/8.1/10/11 have all been massive downgrades to different extents.
- mopsi 4y agoYou can have at least Win 7 start menu on Win 10: https://github.com/Open-Shell/Open-Shell-Menu https://github.com/Open-Shell/Open-Shell-Menu It's fast, reliable and highly configurable.
- notRobot 4y agoI know and I do use it! Unfortunately there's lots more to the OS than the start menu, that can't be changed :(
- nulld3v 4y agoDo you know if there's something similar but for the task bar? I really really hate the stock Windows taskbar. The design? Whatever, I can live with that. But it constantly refuses to unhide, it drives me crazy.
- stevesimmons 4y ago> I really really hate the stock Windows taskbar. Plus in Win 11, we lost the ability to put the taskbar vertically on the left or right side of the screen. When coding on a laptop, I want the max vertical screen space. Taskbar at the bottom means I see 10% less source code. Boo Win11!
- iflp 4y agoStartAllBack
- emeril 4y agoI use open shell and 7+ Taskbar Tweaker (https://ramensoftware.com/7-taskbar-tweaker https://ramensoftware.com/7-taskbar-tweaker) + also disable all pinned apps and reenable quick launch - this makes it look like win7/XP pretty closely (though I also disable windows updates so it doesn't get reverted randomly)
- svnpenn 4y agoI work in IT. The Windows 10/11 "settings" are a hole pile of shit. It seems like Microsoft almost purposefully took the 10 things you would most often use, and nested them so deep that you cant even memorize how to find them anymore. So you get forced into using the god awful search, which returns results FROM THE GOD DAMN INTERNET. If I am in Windows setting, or hell even on just the normal Start Menu, I DON'T WANT any Windows search returning anything from the internet. Ever. If I want to search the internet, I will open a god damn web browser. FFS Microsoft, stop trying to turn yourself into some Frankenstein of iOS/Chromebook. No one wants that.
- encryptluks2 4y agoWindows button and start typing what you're looking for. I don't understand users that still point and click at everything.
- super256 4y agoThe search sometimes just straight up does not work for me. Like 1-2 Minutes after a cold boot (I have fast startup turned off) it's completely unusable.
- svnpenn 4y agoever tried to test microphone volume levels? every fucking time I have to search three different things before I can find it. I try "microphone", "audio", "volume", and its always the last one I try, and I can never remember for the next time. Search is not a good UI, because you never get muscle memory with a search.
- xnyan 4y ago> I have to search three different things before I can find it I've had the same problem; Microsoft has been changing the keyword that triggers the audio input/output control panel, but the official and unchanging (so far) name of the panel is "Change system sounds" and "sys" in start menu search returns that as the 1st or second result.
- 4y ago
- locusofself 4y agoI work at Microsoft, it's a great company to work for. But I was bummed when I.T. upgraded my dev machine from Win10 to Win11. I really hope whatever comes next is better.
- drewcoo 4y agoWell . . . forever ago, devs there managed their own installs. And maybe they had boxes that weren't up to snuff for joining ntdev and maybe they had something so old it was basically a network infection, so MSIT would deal with them. But anyplace that forces machine config on devs? They don't really want devs. Even Ballmer valued developers (developers . . . developers). And he was a tragically engineering-impaired human being.
- pastrami_panda 4y agoHonestly Windows 11 is getting better all the time. It's much cleaner and less cluttered compared to 10 as well. It's not perfect of course, but it's the best one so far imo, and it keeps getting better. I really like the new way to connect and manage Bluetooth devices from the taskbar that was recently added. But then again, it's Windows, so when you look underneath the shiny new surface and realize e.g there's no way to add seconds to the watch display due to performance issues - the facade starts to slowly peel away.
- imperialdrive 4y agoGetting better all the time? Yes, so do wounds. Microsoft wounded technology for so many with Windows 11. It's gotten to the point it auto installs even without elevation, so many of us are home with family for Thanksgiving only to spend hours with confused parents trying to navigate the mess of broken 'features'.
- simfree 4y agoForced OS upgrades should be regulated. Microsoft, Google and other operating system vendors should not be using dark patterns to "encourage" upgrades when users aren't paying attention.
- hulitu 4y agoBut sir, it is for your security. That's why we don't fix bugs , but introduce new features.
- fomine3 4y agoOmitting Bluetooth flyout on Win11 21H2 was really weird decision. It's happy that it came back on 22H2, but I don't praise MS for it.
- orthoxerox 4y agoCan you uncombine taskbar buttons in Win 11 yet?
- 4y ago
- withinrafael 4y agoHarris was chief of the Windows User Experience for Windows 8. He created Windows 8. He created Metro UI. He created the Windows 8 Start screen, charms, allowed ads in its inbox apps (e.g. Weather), etc. Keep that in mind when Harris says things like "the Start menu is Microsoft's flagship user experience. It should represent the very best UI design the company is capable of."
- themodelplumber 4y agoCan you still use win+r for the important stuff? That right there is a classic of Windows UI
- anaisbetts 4y agoDid you read the article and see what he was complaining about? He typed the word "Chrome" and the top hit was a web search with a bunch of ads on the right-hand sidebar. His complaints were 100% justified and imho correct, and the immediate jump to ad-hominem attacks rather than debating the content of the article seems uncalled for.
- svnpenn 4y agosorry, but this is one of the few cases where its justified. Anyone whos developed on Windows since 7 or before (raises hand) knows how awful Window UI has been since 8. You wouldn't want Richard Nixon (if he was alive) commenting on Obama's term would you? Even if Harris is 100% right, its just tone deaf and in bad taste. No one want to hear his opinion on Microsoft products. Hes done enough already.
- pveierland 4y agoTested out the screen recording feature in Windows 11 yesterday. Thought it was nice to have this built into the OS - it can be activated using Win+Alt+R. It worked fine until I minimized the current window - this made it stop without giving any hint. Turns out "Gaming features aren't available for the Windows Desktop or File Explorer" - but it works fine for recording Chrome. Experiences like this just feels user hostile and plentiful when using Windows. The newer Start Menus causes stress any time I use them, as I have no idea how much data it will end up leaking, and because it is more likely to yield a random internet search than showing me a locally installed program.
- npteljes 4y agoWin+Alt+R recording is sporadically available in Win10 too. It worked well for general desktop recording for the colleagues who tried it, but it produced huge video files.
- ggm 4y agoIt's a large enterprise. Big enough there will be a range of views about any change. I would be amazed if an EX- ui chief in any enterprise would always align to design decisions his successors enact. It's stunningly unlikely because it suggests innovation is stultified by the dead hand of prior staff. That said, I think its not the best UI either. But the POLA here is "don't be surprised if people who replace you try to put their mark on things they control"
- roca 4y agoThis isn't a good example to use to critique the Start Menu because it's a special case --- downloading Chrome is an action that Microsoft does not want you to complete, so making it a good experience is a Microsoft non-goal.
- svnpenn 4y agowhy does Microsoft get to have any say in that? Most people using Windows purchased it, either directly or hidden inside the computer cost. Microsoft decision making power should begin and end with designing the product. They have no business making some tools harder or easier to install than others, the same as a hammer has no business favoring some nails over others.
- Jorengarenar 4y agoYou're right - it's not a good example, it's a great example! An example which once in the past got them into court!
- aatd86 4y agoDoes W11 still force auto reboots? W10 was a scourge with this... Rebooting overnight even though I tried everything to disable auto reboots.
- TowerTall 4y agoFor the waste majority of everything Windows 11 and Windows 10 is pretty much the same.
- ChuckNorris89 4y agoIt's not though. It has some great improvements on some fronts (no auto-reboot, built-in terminal, WSL already setup, better multi-monitor and dock-undock behavior) and worse on other fronts like the start menu.
- ChuckNorris89 4y agoNo, it doesn't auto-reboot. You get prompted for updates and you can keep delaying them forever if that's what you wish.
- aatd86 4y agoI does for me with the default edition. There is no way to delay it indefinitely. I tried editing the registry, the parameters, everything... Literally everything I could find online. The other non Home edition may allow to disable them.
- ChuckNorris89 4y agoIt allows me on the Pro edition without any hacks.
- jiggawatts 4y agoWhich is notably not the Home edition.
- hooby 4y agoI only updated my gaming machine to Windows 11 about two weeks ago (running Mint on my work device) - and it immediately felt rather incomplete/unfinished to me. For example, I am using 7zip for compression. In file explorer I right click a file/directory I want to compress, but the option to compress with 7zip is missing from the context menu. So I choose "more options" at the bottom of the menu, and what I get is the Win10 context menu in the old layout (different background, different font+size, etc.) - which has everything the Win11 menu has + some more stuff (including "compress with 7zip"). facepalm
- wilg 4y agoSometimes I have to just right click again which sometimes shows the old context menu instead of the new one? I think? What a wild OS. (Also, it's wild how much better macOS's .zip file handling is.)
- IlGrigiore 4y agoThe trick is to use shift+right click to access the old context menu. Incidentally, shift+right click also enables to copy the full path to any file in file explorer.
- 8293048883 4y ago> For example, I am using 7zip for compression Nanazip is a "7-Zip derivative intended for the modern Windows experience" available on store/winget with the right hooks in place for Win11 context menus. Old menu is also available with Shift+Rightclick, or reverted entirely via registry tweak
- jiggawatts 4y agoThe biggest travesty IMHO is the updated Notepad that was rewritten using the modern Win UI. It now takes 2 seconds to start on an 8-core computer with a PCIe 4 NVMe SSD. Oh, and a tab indent and four spaces are almost… but not identically aligned. They’re like… one or two pixels off. With a fixed width font! This is just sad: https://paste.pics/aacb91eda1bfb46f968bed2004ad2328 https://paste.pics/aacb91eda1bfb46f968bed2004ad2328 Notepad can also no longer open large text files in under a minute, whereas the Electron-based VS Code does it nearly instantly! Where is Raymond Chen when you need him? https://devblogs.microsoft.com/oldnewthing/20180521-00/?p=98795 https://devblogs.microsoft.com/oldnewthing/20180521-00/?p=98...
- tinco 4y ago4 spaces and tab not being perfectly aligned sounds like a feature, not a bug to me. In what scenario would you want them to be aligned? Surely any scenario would be improper use? 100% agree with the rest of course, it's always been a shock to me how little love the essential tooling gets in Windows. You'd think with all the budgets and the fat salaries they'd simply have a competent engineer or two on every (category of) tools. But then you hear about stuff like this or the Terminal debacle and it's like they're not even trying.
- unwind 4y agoI think that in when using a fixed-width font in a text-only editing program, the assumption is that a tab is "made" (visually) of a number of spaces. That number is a frequent ... debatable setting, in software development teams, but at least it's a number of spaces. Not being able to visually line up indents made out of spaces vs tabs (in any mix) breaks a very basic usability/interaction pattern, and is really rather bad. :(
- tinco 4y agoWhat usability/interaction pattern is that? The number of spaces in tabs is not a debate, that's just personal preference in your editor. The debate is if tabs should be used at all. That tabs are not a multiple of the character width in a fixed width font is insane of course. But if any character should have that property as a feature, it would be the tab.
- azinman2 4y agoThat he’s quoting fitts law to me shows how frozen in time he is. The start menu is something you seldom use; the milliseconds saved in mouse time is effectively irrelevant over time, and completely irrelevant in a touch based system. What’s more important is that people understand what’s happening, the system is simple and self explanatory, and feel happy using it (meaning the UI/UX is attractive and consistent). I’m not saying Windows 11 is any of those things, but Fitts Law is the furthest from their worries. Yet it’s the kind of thing that came out of HCI conferences for years with little lasting translation into the modern era.
- deleted 4y ago[deleted]
- OrderlyTiamat 4y ago> "the Start menu is Microsoft's flagship user experience. It should represent the very best UI design the company is capable of." That is a joke, right? I have for years and years had problems to get the start menu search to work properly. It doesn't know about new programs until the following day, it doesn't remember frequently used programs, it can't find basic settings which it used to find fine, and worst of all is that it is _incredibly_ precise with it's recommedation. Typing "tea<RET>" gets you teams, "team<RET>" gets you steam. The next day (or hour, or 15 min) it is the other way around. It doesn't auto clear expired shortcuts, instead opting to ask about it when searching. Windows store apps sometimes don't appear, and if they do, the right click menu doesn't let you see it's path ( sometimes, I believe I had that working once?) "Flagship user experience". And now the problem is that he can't find chrome in it? Seriously, that is a suprise? Never mind the fact that indexing takes an extremely long time perhaps he has chrome installed and forgot about it- windows has, too. Contrast this with the apple experience with spotlight, and its night and day. Ateast with powertoys you get a spotlight esque replacement, but that's the irony of it: to get basic shit to work in windows, you have to install third party programs anyway and sometimes even work with regedit.
- rrobukef 4y agoI press Start and type and the menu drops letters. After it has popped up. Most of the times only the first letters. Sometimes it gets the first one or two and drops the third and fourth. As Tom Lehrer said: 'Я иду туда, куда сам царь идёт пешком - It stinks.'
- npteljes 4y ago> "the Start menu is Microsoft's flagship user experience. It should represent the very best UI design the company is capable of." Naive take, at best. Why would a desktop OS monopoly like Microsoft look at user experience as a top priority? All they need to do is not make something that's so atrocious, that users leave in droves. And they got that position, so, other priorities have taken over, and I'm sure the start menu serves those purpuses well.
- hooby 4y agoI want to use an OS on my own terms, for my own ends. I want an OS that respects the boundaries I set for it. This includes respecting my time, my attention, my privacy and above all my consent. I should be the user, it should be the tool, not the other way around. Every new version of windows seems to provide less of this than the previous version. More ads, more being forced into things, more telemetry, more updates reverting settings I made, less respect for my express commands, less useful feedback on what the OS is actually doing and why.