2 ms·
Doesn't this likely sound like an unintentional Goodhart's Law? Our heroes are those who have never erred, and anyone who ever errs can never be great. Given th
by renewiltord 4y ago
Doesn't this likely sound like an unintentional Goodhart's Law? Our heroes are those who have never erred, and anyone who ever errs can never be great. Given that we have created this ideal, it is unsurprising that no one ever wants to set that "have erred" bit. And given that, it is unsurprising that anyone would want someone they like or respect to have the "have erred" bit set on them. And given that, it is best to avoid any discussion of error at all.
Perhaps, and I speculate, it is our culture of dunking on targets. My personal favourite is that I disregard anything regarding Colin Powell. Someone might say "Well, he was quite the X" or "he would have made a good Y" and I cannot resist but say "But the mindless clown will just repeat nonsense if you give him nonsense". Others might decide that errors I consider insignificant in others are the equivalent of Colin Powell's.
Consequently, it is important to never state that another has erred.
- periheli0n 4y agoFamous example: Ragnar Granit studied color vision in the cat for 10 years. It turned out cats are colorblind. He carried on and later was awarded the Nobel Prize for related research.
- dekhn 4y agoCats aren't really colorblind, they just have reduced color perception compared to humans, but still are sensitive to many hues. In fact that's exactly what his paper in 1943 on cat vision said: https://onlinelibrary.wiley.com/doi/abs/10.1111/j.1748-1716.1943.tb02050.x https://onlinelibrary.wiley.com/doi/abs/10.1111/j.1748-1716....