7 ms·
Perhaps a silly question, but can somebody describe how they might lose $10 billion on Alexa in one year? I don't understand the math. That's enough to pay 33,0
by somenameforme 4y ago
Perhaps a silly question, but can somebody describe how they might lose $10 billion on Alexa in one year? I don't understand the math. That's enough to pay 33,000 employees $330k a year, or some recombination of such. I don't think the real numbers come even remotely close to that.
So it presumably has to be hardware costs, but Alexa is software, and they have vertical integration of all servers which presumably would drive voice processing costs to negligible levels as well (and that's assuming 0 on-device caching/learning ability). And this is all assuming that the gross revenue generated by Alexa is $0, which also certainly isn't true. So I don't see where the numbers are coming from?
- nindalf 4y agoI think the Echo devices are included, so it means hardware sold. Not sure they were being sold at a profit. Also, you need to count the server costs, including machine learning training and inference.
- rabuse 4y agoAlso, people are expensive, and it takes them to design and program this stuff.
- OriginalPenguin 4y agoFor a while Amazon loved selling the smaller units for a little as a dollar (and often including several months of Amazon music for free or almost free as well). Sell enough of these 30 dollar gadgets for a dollar and it will add up quickly.
- laidoffamazon 4y agoThe Echo devices were sold for around BOM, but IIRC they were able to get some significant price reductions on that on a few popular devices, though I'm not sure if that ever got released. I think some of the newer devices might have turned a profit (not including R&D costs though).
- slaw 4y ago> This year, an employee familiar with the hardware team said, the company is on pace to lose about $10 billion on Alexa and other devices. Creative journalism or creative accounting.
- lsh123 4y agoOr both ;)
- behringer 4y agoCreative journalism of creative accounting is more apt.
- db1234 4y agoTo me this looks like a deliberate leak from Amazon. Why? I don't know. Perhaps a signal to wall street that more layoffs are coming to Alexa division?
- simplotek 4y ago> To me this looks like a deliberate leak from Amazon. That was what I thought as well. Whether to sugarcoat propr or upcoming layoffs, this niewspiece sounds like a justification in the public's eye of why everyone at Amazon is getting the axe.
- deleted 4y ago[deleted]
- thereisnospork 4y agoOver billed from AWS to make that part of the balance sheet look good? (entirely speculation)
- putlake 4y agoFrom what I've heard, AWS prices for large customers like Netflix are a lot lower than for Alexa or Amazon Retail. Netflix has the option to switch to GCP or Azure; Alexa doesn't so they don't get those discounts.
- AlexandrB 4y agoWhat does it mean for Alexa to "pay" for AWS though? Is it recorder as revenue somewhere or does it just get accounted for internally?
- HDThoreaun 4y agoProbably means Alexa loses $10 billion instead of $9.5 or whatever and has to fire some more people
- scott_w 4y agoMMAesawy gave the correct answer. It makes it clear what Alexa is really costing Amazon in an format that's easy to interpret. This is how most companies handle "internal purchases" from another business unit that also sells that product externally. Consider it this way: if Alexa doesn't buy that capacity, someone else could, so it's important to capture this opportunity cost. It's not perfect, however. I've seen examples where the repairs division of a company had to buy parts from its distribution branch at retail price. All well and good, so far. Except they then had to mark-up that part's price in the repair cost. Combine that with the fact distribution would give discounted rates to other repair companies to secure business and what you have is a repair division that's being outbid on price by competitors using the same parts!
- 4y ago
- adrr 4y agoHardware is very expensive. Alexa dot is $14 on Amazon.com right now, i bet they are selling it at a loss for that price.
- Hellion 4y agoI bet that’s at cost tbh. You’d be surprised how cheap things have gotten. However, r&d and every single Alexa request costs money. So from day one, it’s losing money.
- h4n1 4y agoHow much are two hundred million microphones in earshot of private conversations worth?
- RHSman2 4y agoThis
- deleted 4y ago[deleted]
- rapnie 4y agoOne Zuckerberg.
- ben_w 4y agoDemonstrably very little, at least with regard to $€¥.
- rchaud 4y agoMaybe right now it's value is $0. Think bigger picture. Imagine a panopticon spanning Ring.com camera networks and voice recordings telling you what's going on inside, with AI providing automated summaries of recent conversations. All delivered end-to-end by Amazon!
- tiahura 4y ago
- achow 4y ago2020 - It took Amazon four years to populate the world with 100 million Alexa-powered devices. It took the company just one more year to more than double that number. The e-commerce titan announced Monday that there are now "hundreds of millions of Alexa-enabled devices" in customers' hands worldwide, a massive increase from the 100 million it announced last January. https://www.cnet.com/home/smart-home/amazon-sees-alexa-devices-more-than-double-in-just-one-year/ https://www.cnet.com/home/smart-home/amazon-sees-alexa-devic... Annual sales ~100 million device, then losing $50/device would lead to a figure of $5 billion loss in a year. Loss of $50/device would include cost for running R&D, running factories, giving minimum guarantee to factories, and all other associated cost - marketing, customer acquisition, support etc.. So $10B loss in a year sounds in the realm of possibility.
- piva00 4y agoAlexa-powered does not necessarily mean Alexa devices made by Amazon though. For example: I own a multiroom speaker setup not made by Amazon that is Alexa-enabled, all speakers could run Alexa if I had set them up for it (which I won't, ever), and they're very likely counted on this metric. I can remember a multitude of other speakers and devices with an Alexa-enabled badge on their packaging that aren't made by Amazon. It'd be good to have hardware figures for sales of Amazon's own devices.
- achow 4y agoGood point. However, supporting all the 'partner devices' comes with associated cost in terms of engg' development and support (somewhat like what Android must be dealing with. Android division in Google would not be a low cost division I'm sure).
- piva00 4y agoIt surely does, I work at a place where we also have to deal with multiple partner integrations across multiple vendors and types of devices for our products, there's some overhead for it but not nearly as much as one would expect.
- b112 4y agoPerhaps a silly question, but can somebody describe how they might lose $10 billion on Alexa in one year? Amazon seems to be a very poorly run company. So many issues with search, with spam, with listings, and here's another data point... Just bought a laptop. Waited until it was on sale, after doing Linux compatible research. It shows up. 3 days later, it is even more on sale. This is a product sold and shipped by amazon.com, in both cases. I contact support, and ask for a price drop refund, as there is a $150 price difference now. Nope, guy keeps linking me to "Price match" docs. I explain, I am not comparing vs another supplier, but amazon itself. I am told, just return the laptop and order it again. That there is no other option. For me, there is no return cost, other than a 5 minute detour to drop it off. Free return shipping. For them, they lose the original shipping cost, the return cost, the processing of the return, and will sell it via amazon warehouse, for a $250 price drop. I imagine that to sell a laptop via amazon warehouse, a check that it boots, a drive wipe is done, etc. This is indicative of a company incapable of handling scale correctly. Yet they blather on about loss on returns! And about return scams! And yet, I still get the laptop at the price I want. Only an insane person would act this way, and this insane act is a weird emegent behaviour at amazon. It's telling, to me. Amazon === borked
- Rebelgecko 4y agoAmazon used to be happy to price match themselves within a month or so of a purchase, or do things like let keep a cheap item you wanted to return. My guess is that they did some A/B testing and found that the "irrational" behavior actually saves them money. In your example, if 50% of people don't bother going through the return process they still come out ahead.
- kube-system 4y agoI bet this is actually it. I totally would ask for a price difference refund for a few bucks. But I’m not bothering with a return/repurchase for a couple dollars.
- wikfwikf 4y agoMy guess is that they also might do market segmentation analysis to understand what type of customer you are, and this affects the return policy. For example, you consistently buy small ticket household items and rarely return anything: when you do return something they will be helpful and generous to keep you happy. You buy large amounts of fairly expensive clothes and shoes but return around 50% after trying on. They will accept the returns without issues but won't let you keep anything. You're a bargain hunter who buys expensive laptops or hard drives whenever the discounts look really good. They will make returning stuff a little harder for you since they know you don't have loyalty, and they don't want to facilitate arbitrage. Doing this is computationally no more sophisticated than the work they are already doing to detect professional scammers. They aren't supposed to show different customers different prices, but they can freely use things like this to do stealth price differentiation, since many details of how the return policy is implemented are at their discretion.
- wikfwikf 4y agoI don't understand the point about vertical integration. Amazon use their own hardware and services internally and AWS makes a ton of money of course. But if you were accounting for the profit or loss of Alexa specifically, of course you would account for all the AWS services used at the price they are sold for externally.
- UltraViolence 4y agoAmazon is not a philanthropy. The company needs to make money and as much of it to satisfy shareholders (who, BTW, are never satisfied). Having spent tens of billions on something that doesn't add up to the bottom line doesn't go well with shareholders, especially when there's no prospect that it ever will.
- Tagbert 4y agoIt is a surprising number. I assume that it also includes the development and manufacturing of the devices that they sell that use Alexa. They clearly sell those devices at close to cost. Or below?