2 ms·
> Mastodon doesn't fix that, because Alice@instance1.com doesn't necessarily mean you're talking to Alice. It could be a malicious Alice. Interestingly, email
by marcosdumay 4y ago
> Mastodon doesn't fix that, because Alice@instance1.com doesn't necessarily mean you're talking to Alice. It could be a malicious Alice.
Interestingly, email seems to not have that problem at all.
- dragontamer 4y agoPeople don't do large-scale public chats with celebrities over email. Think Reddit AMAs, or media interviews and the like. When someone says "This is reporter X talking with Alice (picture of Alice + voice + etc. etc.)", it establishes identity that people trust. I guess people could fake this these days, but building up these networks of trust for worthwhile interaction has grown more and more important recently. Twitter's blue checkmark kinda-sorta served this purpose, at least before it died last week. ----- If there was a widespread "Ask me anything" email discussion organized over emails, this identity verification problem would also need to be solved. Since Twitter is an "always ongoing" discussion with various celebrities, the blue checkmark was kinda-sorta the verification you needed.
- tsimionescu 4y agoOf course it does, email from stuff lime suppport@google.com is often used for phishing. Not to mention, email is mostly 1:1, so it has completely different discovery/identity validation properties than a social network that's normally n:n. Even for things like newsletters, you subscribe to a newsletter. It's true that mailing lists exist, but they don't scale and require curation precisely to establish the identity of each participant.
- apozem 4y agoEmail has this problem all the time! [1] Real estate companies have to give customers cybersecurity advice [2] because phishers pretend to be the agent and send incorrect addresses for wire transfers. [1]: https://www.proofpoint.com/us/threat-reference/email-spoofing https://www.proofpoint.com/us/threat-reference/email-spoofin... [2]: https://www.rate.com/resources/how-to-avoid-phishing-scams-and-other-attempts-at-fraud https://www.rate.com/resources/how-to-avoid-phishing-scams-a...