3 ms·
> Mastodon doesn't fix that, because Alice@instance1.com doesn't necessarily mean you're talking to Alice. It could be a malicious Alice. Maybe the "real" Alice
by yjftsjthsd-h 4y ago
> Mastodon doesn't fix that, because Alice@instance1.com doesn't necessarily mean you're talking to Alice. It could be a malicious Alice. Maybe the "real" Alice is Alice@instanceAlpha.com.
Okay, I'll bite; how do you know that the Tumblr user actualice12345 is the real Alice?
- dragontamer 4y agoEDIT: I probably should note that I don't use Tumblr and I don't know the full context of this image https://pbs.twimg.com/media/DXC71NFX4AAUPX3?format=jpg&name=large https://pbs.twimg.com/media/DXC71NFX4AAUPX3?format=jpg&name=... I'm not a Tumblr or Twitter user. But it seems like Tumblr has a degree of identity verification going on with its users. ----- Even Reddit has these kinds of simple checks to make "Ask me Anything" a more legitimate-feeling experience. When a famous reporter posts a picture of Reddit-account name + face for people to see and do on an AMA, it helps verify the identity. (And if that's too much for the AMA user, having a trusted moderator do that kind of check can serve as a good substitute)
- idlewords 4y agoThe way it's always worked; she can publicly post the link to her Tumblr on her Alice.com homepage, or you confirm with her in private outside of Tumblr.
- zksmk 4y agoSo it's not any different than Mastodon then.
- catach 4y agoIs there any reason why doing that with Mastodon is worse?
- idlewords 4y agoI'm not familiar with Mastodon, but this is the generic mechanism for linking identity since the earliest web days; as long as names are hard to spoof it's independent of any specific service.
- isodev 4y agoAnd if you enjoy reading and interacting with content from Alice@instance1.com, does it matter if their name is really Alice irl?
- skybrian 4y agoFor fiction and chatting, no. For eyewitness accounts or providing evidence, yes, provenance matters. Also, a famous name (or at least, one well-known to you) has a lot of embedded trust associated with it that was earned elsewhere, which is why impersonation matters.