7 ms·
If you wanted to implement something like this, regardless of merit, then DNS blocking is by far the worst way to go about doing it. Anyone with an interest in
by astrodust 15y ago
If you wanted to implement something like this, regardless of merit, then DNS blocking is by far the worst way to go about doing it.
Anyone with an interest in using pirate sites will simply switch to alternate DNS providers, there will always be a way, and legitimate users will be subject to rampant and arbitrary censorship in the name of "stopping piracy".
You can't stop piracy. It's a supply and demand problem. It's a perception problem.
How can you convince someone that the TV show that is broadcast for free over the air is legal, but downloading exactly the same show at a later time is illegal?
Companies have all the tools they need to reduce piracy but they refuse to use them, instead trying to extort money from people through more conventional means. They'd rather have ten sales at $20 than thousands at $1.
- pyre 15y agoCutting off the advertising revenues will definitely slow down piracy sites. SOPA isn't just about DNS.
- astrodust 15y agoIt'll put a dent in their revenue, but it'll also open up a massive market for underground advertisers.
- samstave 15y ago>You can't stop piracy. It's a supply and demand problem. It's a perception problem. I would go further; it is a greed/exploitative problem. You have every type of good in the world manufactured/produced/farmed/coded/filmed/etc. for far less than what the retail cost is. (the initial arguement is supply and demand) -- but that is simply false. Look at profits and margins. Apple and every oil company in the world is the perfect example of why this is true. Their supply is NOT in concordance with demand. Their profits and margins show this. Other business models have proven this out; make things cost less - and more people will buy. Actually, to Apples credit - this is an area where they are showing this; Apps that cost ~.99 are seen to be a value to the user at that cost thus paid apps make tons. (However, if you look at margins, again Apple fails. Their margin on paid apps is between 100% and ~5% (if you try to figure in the cost of the overall infrastructure to supply the apps (i*Device development etc. though the mobile market has a lot of outlying factors which refudiate the margin cost to apple, whereas the iPad is a device wholly dependent on the app market)
- onemoreact 15y agoOil companies have far worse profit margins than say Apple or Microsoft. They have good years and bad years but Exon regularly trades below 10 P/E where tech companies often trade above 20 because tech companies are far more capable of long term growth and far at the whim of classic inelastic supply demand curves. (In other words if oil when back to 30dollars a barrel people would buy more oil, but they would not do so quickly.) As to iPad's many people buy tablets and never load a single app on them. Unlike consoles where the device is subsidized by the software sold apple treats it's app store as revenue neutral. They have income but they poor it back into iOS development, because long term the OS with the best software wins and they can still make fat margins on the devices themselves.
- deleted 15y ago[deleted]
- dextorious 15y ago"""You can't stop piracy. It's a supply and demand problem. It's a perception problem. How can you convince someone that the TV show that is broadcast for free over the air is legal, but downloading exactly the same show at a later time is illegal?""" Actually, the thinking seems to be, you don't have to convince them, you just throw them to jail or fine them.
- billpatrianakos 15y agoI don't think it's a supply and demand problem. It's an ignorance problem and a financial problem. Media companies perceive piracy to be the cause of lost revenue above all others. Step 1: Media companies need to understand the Internet. I honestly don't think they're actively trying to take freedoms from us. I think they just still don't "get" the web and haven't come up with a business model that takes advantage of it yet. Step 2: once they "get it" they could use the tools they already have more effectively and attempt to use the web to their advantage without SOPA. Put yourself in the shoes of the people at the media companies who are behind this for a minute. You're an old, probably conservative, wealthy person who is most likely hyper aware of anything going on that's entertainment related. To you it seems like theres far more of your company's content online than there should be and because you're in the media business you perceive the web to be an entertainment medium and nothing more. It dawns on you that since you're in control of content distributed through TV, the movies, and other conventional platforms (like DVD and BluRay) you should also be able to have control over this new entertainment medium too! It doesn't occur to you that the web is of, for, and by the people because the media has really never worked that way. As hackers we're easily able to see the big picture and understand that the web isn't just one big On-Demand entertainment network. To us it's about entertainment as much as it is about communicating, working, sharing knowledge, education, art, and so on. But these people are viewing it from an outdated perspective. I think that if we really want to make a change here we need to quit assuming that this is only about power and control for the sake of power and control. This isn't good vs. evil here, it's just two competing world views. If we understood why they believe they should be able to implement SOPA-like initiatives then we'd be better equipped to stop the problem at its root.
- ghshephard 15y agoAs much as I despise SOPA, and realize this is little more than an wealth transfer to the entertainment industry from the internet industry, I will acknowledge that DNS blocking is actually a pretty efficient way to stop your average person from accessing web sites. Remember - SOPA is not designed to stop piracy - there are hundreds (thousands) of mechanisms for file sharing that your average government policy will have no impact on. What it will do, is make it burdensome for 99% of the non-nerd population. As long as the 99% are impacted, the entertainment industry really don't care about that final 1% trading files to their hearts galore. This isn't about principal - it's pure economics.
- Fluxx 15y agoI disagree. The younger population is far more technical than the current older population. Granted I live in a tech-y city (Seattle), and a lot of my friends are "internet savvy," but everyone I know that is under 35 torrents stuff. Simply making it harder to get to web sites will not stop "non-techy people" from pirating. Napster seemed to do really well and it didn't NEED DNS.
- ghshephard 15y agoTorrents are not what I would consider a nerdy way of sharing files - and have some pretty straightforward DNS vulnerabilities. The first target of SOPA will be every worthwhile Torrent Search engine. Those sites will be taken down overnight. Moving to static IP addresses puts the owner of that RIR block in jeopardy. Napster was sued out of existence, went bankrupt, and shut down. If SOPA passes, it will be a multi-billion dollar wealth transfer from the Internet Industry, and our personal freedoms, to the Entertainment industry. It will be effective in at at least two (Negatively impacting our freedoms, and the Internet Industry) - remains to be seen if it will benefit the Entertainment Industry.
- Fluxx 15y agoOh I agree on all accounts. My point was that if SOPA passes I don't think it will stop the "99%."
- rat87 15y agoIt's not broadcast for free it has commercials. Plus for cable/hbo/ect. you pay extra for the service.
- pbhjpbhj 15y ago>"How can you convince someone that the TV show that is broadcast for free over the air is legal, but downloading exactly the same show at a later time is illegal?" People know that copyright infringement is not lawful though, don't they. Generally, they just don't care. Like speed limits on roads. People don't care enough to strictly abide by the law, or moralise their non-compliance in some other way - late at night, good conditions, law is silly, nobody around, etc..
- pbhjpbhj 15y ago>"How can you convince someone that the TV show that is broadcast for free over the air is legal, but downloading exactly the same show at a later time is illegal?" People know that copyright infringement is not lawful though, don't they. They just don't care. Same way people know the speed limit but don't care to abide by it