10 ms·
US Supreme Court asked if cops can plant spy cams around homes
- ghoward 4y agoI really hope SCOTUS smacks down the cops; "right of the people to be secure in their persons, houses, papers, and effects, against unreasonable searches and seizures" is pretty clear, and it doesn't matter that the Fourth Amendment was written in a time without electronics. Also, this should apply to manual police surveillance of homes as well: there should be a warrant.
- pstuart 4y agoThis case was about somebody selling illegal drugs (and firearms but only skimmed). The War on Drugs has legitimized excessive policing to an insane degree (only eclipsed by the War on Terror). People continue to support this because "drugs are bad, m'kay?", which can be true, but doesn't warrant this madness. The US should have learned its lesson with alcohol prohibition but apparently too many people profit off the current scheme for it to meaningfully change. We could collectively remedy this promptly if enough of the population recognized and demanded that the better path is education, regulation, and taxation.
- modriano 4y agoImagine you have a largish property (say 5 acres) and you had a greenhouse that was not visible from any adjacent public land, and police suspect you're growing some marijuana in that greenhouse. Would it be unreasonable for cops to get a helicopter, fly high enough to see over the things hiding the greenhouse, claim they saw marijuana from a distance of over 400 feet with just their eyes, and used that as probable cause to then get a search warrant for the property? In Florida v Riley, "The Court held that Riley had no reasonable expectation of privacy in this case because anyone could view Riley’s property from a helicopter flying in navigable airspace and figure out what was inside. The police officer did not enter Riley’s land or interfere with it in any way. Furthermore, the manner in which he was flying the helicopter was well within the law; therefore, the police officer was within his rights to view Riley’s property from the air. The Court determined that the police action in this case did not violate Riley’s Fourth Amendment rights." [0] That case was in 1988, and it is not out of line with the 4th Amendment decisions over the ~50+ years since the Warren court that made good 4A decisions (like Katz vs US [1]). So expect this case to fly through 6 to 3. [0] https://www.oyez.org/cases/1988/87-764 https://www.oyez.org/cases/1988/87-764 [1] https://www.oyez.org/cases/1967/35 https://www.oyez.org/cases/1967/35
- scarface74 4y ago>… you're growing some marijuana in that greenhouse Your entire argument is based on the flawed premise that government should have any right to stop you from growing, selling or consuming marijuana.
- ghoward 4y agoI think you're right about the end result, and I do not like it. I also disagree with the Riley case: unless you have REALLY good binoculars, there isn't any way someone could tell what kind of plants are in a greenhouse at 400 feet.
- mkl95 4y agoIt's a known fact that cops struggle to distinguish hemp from marijuana. If they can't do it when it's in front of their faces, there's no way they will at 400 feet.
- aerostable_slug 4y agoEven better: outdoor grows have been located via their heat signature at night (I have a relative who was a national guard pilot and did this). There's no way to know what's there, just that it's a different temp than the native greenery. Generally this is done on public / state land, but I imagine more than one raid on private land was cued by this technique.
- dehrmann 4y agoThey're literally the same species. You might still need a license to produce hemp, so they could plausibly consult the license list, notice your cannabis, see you're not on the list, and get a warrant either way.
- Melting_Harps 4y ago> You might still need a license to produce hemp, so they could plausibly consult the license list, notice your cannabis, see you're not on the list, and get a warrant either way. You;ll only appear on that list if you do so for commercial purposes and are required to get a license, furthermore you can legally grow MJ or Hemp without one provided you live in a legal state: where you are allowed up to 6 plants per Adult resident of your home above the age of 21. So you can legally have a large compliant grow if you live in a CO-OP as is common in several legalized States. And this very thing was disputed in CO in the early phases of Amendment 64 (legalizing recreational MJ and Industrial hemp in 2012), and then was made law of the land after the Farm bill of 2018 wherein hemp could be grown in all 50 stares as it was codified as a matter that was to be handled by their respective Department of Ag in their state/city. In short, their is nothing stopping anyone growing Industrial hemp as a crop for their own usage in a legal state if it is not used for commercial purposes, it is however, not wise to do so because the DEA can get a warrant and sill do a search and seizure and continue to use things like asset forfeiture to ruin your life in the process so it's best to limit such grows not because the Law doesn't allow it, but for the sheer fear of having an agency that is growing in irrelevance to come inot your Life when a rather easy to get license/permit will do--some States even distinguish between commercial and R/D for this very purpose and to skirt around Laws where Federal funding can be threatened as was the case with CU Boulder/Denver. > They're getting a warrant, not a conviction. While true, you can still have your Life ruined in the process of said search warrant and be subject to asset forfeiture. Personally speaking, i think that is a direct violation of one's 4th Amendment Right, but that doesn't mean it doesn't happen and it's best to be avoided. Source: My startup was providing financial services and payment processing to the Legal Hemp Industry (2015-2018), and my co-founder was one of the first to legally do so under the seed/breeding program in CO.
- jjulius 4y agoThis is mostly tongue-in-cheek, but: >... to be secure in their... houses... The cameras are outside, so teeeeeechnically...
- ghoward 4y agoI presume you are being tongue-in-cheek, and I agree, so it will probably be ruled for the cops. But why would police treat a peeping tom differently when they do the same thing? It's so hypocritical.
- krapp 4y ago> But why would police treat a peeping tom differently when they do the same thing? It's so hypocritical. For the same reason that, when the police restrain you against your will and lock you in a cage, it's an arrest, but if you do it, it's assault and kidnapping.
- cnelsenmilt 4y agoIt can still be assault and kidnapping when the police do it, if they don't have a good reason and follow the rules. Same applies to surveillance. The question is not cops vs. non-cops: it's what the valid reasons and rules for the cops are.
- pdntspa 4y agoIt is still assault and kidnapping, just legally sanctioned, and for some reason we feel compelled to call it an "arrest". Just because its LEO performing the assault doesn't make it any less of an assault.
- paulryanrogers 4y agoPolice have a monopoly on violence. Which requires holding them to a higher standard. The 4th amendment means the courts should err on the side of privacy, not surveillance.
- rychco 4y agoThe current SCOTUS? Respecting your rights? I wouldn’t count on it, friend.
- koolba 4y agoThey did a great job respecting the right to bear arms.
- pessimizer 4y agoSCOTUS will definitely approve of this. After Scalia died, any shared concept of an individual right to privacy died with him. That's why we should be thankful that prior restraint on speech was banned in the Bill of Rights, so only enforcement of that restriction hinges on current nationalist fashion, rather than the entire concept as in the case of the "right to privacy." Scalia's corruption, and his desire to deny the public the tools to prove it, was the thread keeping us all safe.
- pmoriarty 4y agoThose of us who value privacy and want to protect it have to find ways of convincingly demonstrating its value to others. Merely calling it a "right" is just too hand-wavy, and doesn't convince anyone who doesn't already agree with you.
- pessimizer 4y agoCalling privacy a right isn't an argument. Calling for privacy to be a right is what one makes an argument for. So I don't know who you're arguing with. edit: I mean, I deliberately put scare quotes around it.
- kelseyfrog 4y agoCalling privacy a right isn't an argument but it's a perfectly legitimate strategy for social legitimization. Repetition legitimizes, repetition legitimizes, repetition legitimizes and is a completely valid way of constructing a social reality in a way one wishes it to be. Besides, no one asked for a right and got it granted. These are socio-rhetorical problems, not logic problems.
- mdp2021 4y agoYou want a theorem. No problem. Privacy is a natural right. "I know what I am doing, and you don't." (It has to be interpreted as I did not write it in a literal form, but it will do at least for now.) Plus: one has the right not to be unnerved by peeking intruders. I have a viz for it, let me search for it and I will update the post. Edit: found: https://i.ibb.co/JCrzmbJ/clarkson-children-that-stare.jpg https://i.ibb.co/JCrzmbJ/clarkson-children-that-stare.jpg
- theknocker 4y ago
- RcouF1uZ4gsC 4y agoI think the Supreme Court strikes this down. I think this is similar to Kyllo which rules against thermal imaging of homes. The majority opinion was written by Scalia, joined by Souter, Thomas, Ginsburg, Breyer. With Dissent by Stevens, joined by Rehnquist, O'Connor, Kennedy Thomas is still on the court. I think Gorsuch is even more protective of due process than Scalia. I think the 3 liberals would vote to strike it down. That is 5. Robert’s, Kavanaugh, and Barret could go either way.
- siliconc0w 4y agoAny spying that has the intention of determining the contents of a home/property should be illegal under the fourth. Watching everything that goes in and out of a property is equivalent to searching the property.
- moralestapia 4y agoIt always comes down to "reasonable expectation of privacy" in the eyes of that particular judge. I don't think nosy neighbors should be illegal, for instance, but if they choose to plant something inside your property, then they should be in big trouble.
- User23 4y agoI would like this to require a warrant, but it’s hard to see why it should with the law as written. Placing a camera in a public place just isn’t a search or seizure.
- saxonww 4y agoDoes it matter if the camera is for a nonspecific security purpose and incidentally captures your activity, vs. a camera installed for the specific express purpose of recording your activity?
- 0xcde4c3db 4y agoI can hear the officer's testimony already... "We received a tip that a drug deal was going down in this area; it's just a coincidence that one of the cameras happened to be able to see inside that house."
- sokoloff 4y agoI think a camera placed by the police and targeted at your house for more than an incidental amount of time is a type of search. I’m somewhat struggling to see the counter-argument about how it’s not in any way a search such as the 4th would require a warrant for.
- NikkiA 4y agoFunctionally it's no different from a stake-out, which doesn't require a warrant and is not a search. And that's what the supreme court is going to rule. There is, of course a difference in that you have a reasonable chance of noticing a stake-out taking place, but then you have a similar chance of noticing cameras being placed on utility poles near your home so...
- wnoise 4y agoI don't see how a stake-out isn't a search. It might presumptively be a reasonable search that doesn't require a warrant, as it's not a search that interferes or trespasses. But they are looking for evidence, right? I call looking for something a search.
- rasz 4y agoI fully expect it to end at: Yes, except congressmen and judges, because safety blabla hand in hand https://edition.cnn.com/2022/06/14/politics/house-vote-supreme-court-justice-security/index.html https://edition.cnn.com/2022/06/14/politics/house-vote-supre...
- deleted 4y ago[deleted]
- 0F5 4y agoTangential but literally moments ago I evaded a prostitution sting. I met someone on Grindr who was really cute and she asked for payment upfront. Then I said that makes me nervous and I’d like to get to know you first, just a regular date. She agreed and then when I arrived to pick her up she changed her tack and demanded payment to do anything at all. I said ok, meet me in the lobby so we can discuss further. Refusal. Ok video chat with me to discuss further. Refusal. All with bullshit excuses. I played every angle I could and the shape of her was that she accepted nothing except what could incriminate me. I understood it was a sting very quickly. It’s so disturbing that the cops would saddle me with a class D felony even though I never wanted to pay her. They tried to pressure me in the moment to create criminal behavior where there was none. And then I would go to prison and probably be killed, certainly changed and damaged mentally for the rest of my life. Years of my life gone, my career ruined and my dreams destroyed all for those bastard cops to have the thrill of making a bust. It fucking sickens me. Our society is deeply sick where this violence is not only tolerated but endorsed and lawful. The cops are bastards and we need to put them in their fucking place. Thank god for first amendment auditors…
- lisper 4y ago> I met someone on Grindr who was really cute and she There are women on grindr???
- SoftTalker 4y ago
- lisper 4y agoNeither does "woman". (But your point is well-taken.)
- bobthepanda 4y agoWith gay spaces one big issue is often critical mass. I would suspect that for MTF individuals that Grindr would be one of the few places with a critical mass of both people they are looking for and people looking for them, even if that's not really the intended or main target audience. From what I understand, trans individuals have a hard time on other dating apps because their profiles get reported a lot for being "misleading" (which is a whole debate that I'm not getting into)
- coding123 4y agoTitles like this suck. I keep reading it as if the court was asking someone if cops can do x.
- ianlevesque 4y agoYeah, though if that was the intended meaning the sentence would begin with 'The'.
- doodlebugging 4y agoIt's time to crowdfund some cheap cameras that can be connected to a mesh network and deployed to cover the area where our elected representatives live and hang out. Blanket their neighborhoods with cameras and microphones and live stream it 24/7 so every constituent can see in real time how hard our representatives work for us. Track them from point to point and use Mastodon or the pitiful shell of Twitter to keep everyone informed about who they hang out with and how long they spend together, what they talk about, which devices they use, their favorite brand of beer or tennis shoe. We can call it RepWatch, PoliWatch, or whatever. It could be the next great social network and all they have to do to join is to run for office and win so we can monitor their habits, bad and good, and judge them on flimsy evidence.
- sieabahlpark 4y ago
- partiallypro 4y agoThey'll just ban the practice against government officials, make it a federal crime and allow everything else. Then they'll go by stock options on a private prison they throw people in that do this to them.
- givemeethekeys 4y ago> They'll just ban the practice against government officials And it would be defeated quickly on first amendment grounds.
- TheDesolate0 4y ago
- roflyear 4y agoLol nice joke....
- doodlebugging 4y ago
- anonu 4y agoTo me, this is akin to capturing of cellphone meta data. It should not be admissible in court without a warrant at the time it was collected.
- jawns 4y agoAs many First Amendment auditors have demonstrated, filming in public is a constitutionally protected activity, and their popular slogan, "You can't trespass my eyes," means that if something is visible from a public place (e.g. a sidewalk) it is also legal to film it. That means a citizen (or police officer) can stand on a public sidewalk in front of someone's house and film all they want. So what makes this utility-pole surveillance different? The cameras are placed in public (outside, on utility poles which presumably involve a public easement). They are not equipped with extreme telephoto lenses or infrared cameras. It is hard, in the abstract, to see how that is any different than a First Amendment auditor doing the same thing. Where I think it's arguably different is in the sustained, targeted nature of the activity. If one or more private citizens decide to film outside a person's house for 15-30 minutes as part of an audit or similar activity, yes it's probably annoying, but annoying doesn't mean illegal. But if they station themselves outside the house night and day, recording the comings and goings of the residents, I think that arguably rises to the level of stalking. To be clear, I don't think the surveillance cameras meet the legal definition of stalking, but they arguably have similar impact.
- cheri9 4y ago[dead]