10 ms·
Banks and hospitals are cashing in when patients can't pay for health care
- midislack 4y ago
- jleyank 4y agoHealthcare feels like something that should be a regulated monopoly if not provided by the government. Profiting off the misfortune of others seems a bit dirty.
- dan_quixote 4y agoI'd say it's cruel. Paying interest on some medical procedure because you (and likely almost everyone else) cannot afford the eye-watering cost? What else do we need to convince people that this is not sustainable? Maybe a collapse in this medical loan market? One has to assume the major players (hospitals, insurance, etc) have firewalled themselves from this system.
- deleted 4y ago[deleted]
- conductr 4y ago> Maybe a collapse in this medical loan market? That won't properly highlight the issue. It's just a financial shell game of bailouts and buying and selling of paper. It doesn't impact the patients. It's not ideal but the only solution is for the patient to be rejected for insufficient funds/inability to pay. Then, when people finally realize they can't get a doctor appointment because they literally can not afford healthcare in our current system, they will expect the government to provide it. What's funny/ironic to me is that people that are against single payor in the US always like to point to other non-US countries and say how care is restricted or people with cancer/needing surgery are on a long waiting list, etc. I don't know if that's even true but we've all heard it somewhere by now and it becomes a part of their truth (not unlike like politics). And it's what they're most afraid of, being cut out... when not being able to afford something is the very definition of being cut out.
- mgkimsal 4y agoThe US seems to have invented (or at least normalized) medi-begging - the process of posting to gofundme-type sites to help pay medical debt. The very existence of 'medial fundraising' as a thing should be the damning indicator that we need some form of single-payer across the board. Hundreds of thousands of people publicly begging for help with medical bills should be a national embarrassment.
- conductr 4y agoWe do a good job ignoring the economic issues of our neighbors, until it impacts our house. Overall, people are pretty vocal about wanting a living wage, affordable healthcare, affordable education, housing, etc. yet we seem to constantly move in the opposite direction. IMO - our political machine has become too dysfunctional and no longer serves the people, or even make meaningful incremental progress. It's quite a damning time for our country and seems like some large correction would be in order at some point.
- mrguyorama 4y agoThe big problem is that one "team" utterly refuses any help that may benefit people they don't like. We have data to support that they find solutions that benefit undesirables as a bad thing, even if it will help them. So yes, they say they want a living wage, but get really really really upset if you suggest that means the guy scanning your groceries makes as much as they do.
- Consultant32452 4y agoIn the US healthcare is regulated to be a monopoly. For example, a children's hospital chain wanted to expand to my city. They had to get permission from their local competition to open the hospital. As part of their terms, they had to limit their provided services for 5 years (no level 1 trauma care). Then you have organizations like the AMA who have a monopoly control over how many doctors can be created. There were lawsuits in the past because they would not let medical schools open. This reduced supply and kept wages sky high.
- rojobuffalo 4y agoI hope this isn't off-topic but I really like this text-only version of npr.org. I use Brave Browser and it has "reader mode" which does something similar, but it looks better when a site is designed with text-only in mind.
- biftek 4y agoNYTimes used to have a similar mobile subdomain you could browse on desktop too, it was great. It wasn't strictly text only but made reading the content a much nicer experience.
- i_am_proteus 4y agoIf you are an enjoyer of CNN's content, there is also https://lite.cnn.com/ https://lite.cnn.com/
- lob_it 4y agoThey do indicate that upwards of 70% of the population are on prescription meds. https://newsnetwork.mayoclinic.org/discussion/nearly-7-in-10-americans-take-prescription-drugs-mayo-clinic-olmsted-medical-center-find/ https://newsnetwork.mayoclinic.org/discussion/nearly-7-in-10... You don't go there for health Wealth breeds health :)
- advisedwang 4y agoThe USA is #54-41 in the world for life expectancy [1] depending on whose data you use. [1] https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/List_of_countries_by_life_expectancy https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/List_of_countries_by_life_expe...
- lob_it 4y agoLife expectancy is a personal goal and akin to the DNA lottery. You can't win if you don't play :) "Just because all of the other kids do it" is more relevant today than ever :p https://www.toledoblade.com/a-e/food/2015/06/23/70-of-Americans-overweight-or-obese-study-finds/stories/20150622306 https://www.toledoblade.com/a-e/food/2015/06/23/70-of-Americ... Edit: I didn't make the stats :)
- svnt 4y agoIf you are bragging about your margins while the alternative for your customers is death or a major chronic health issue, it no longer matters if it is malice or incompetence. It is structurally and functionally evil.
- lotsofpulp 4y agoHow about people opting to choose non healthcare careers due to better pay to quality of life at work ratios?
- Arrath 4y agoAll the more power to individuals opting not to work within a cruel framework and take their labor elsewhere?
- MSFT_Edging 4y agoIf you look for stories of those leaving, predominantly nursing, the issues that cause them to leave are primarily the result of privatization of hospitals, striving for larger profit margins by taking advantage of the nursing staff. We're sabotaging critical infrastructure in order to insert more middle men to pay.
- pessimizer 4y agoQuiz: Does raising margins for a hospital raise or lower the pay and quality of life for the people who work in it? Hint: the people who work in a hospital are an expense.
- elzbardico 4y agoWhat is incredibly amazing is how much health care costs in the US. Government expenditures Per Capita are over twice of the nations like Canada, UK, Australia, and Japan. And most of this for medicare, for which only a fraction of the population is eligible. And yet, this is not enough, and people need private health insurance. Then you look at the prices of common medications, and most of them (mind you, a lot of them made in India or China) are sometimes ten times more expensive than the SAME medications in any other developed country and even more expensive for the same medications in Under Developed countries. It looks like the invisible hand of markets is not working here. But at the same, the political process is also blind to the real issues.
- starkd 4y agoIn no way is this a free market. Not even close. There are so many market distortions that prevent a healthy market place from operating. If you recall, the ACA act was supposed to help solve many of these problems by making it more affordable. It appears to have exacerbated it.
- theGnuMe 4y agoACA increases the subscriber pool. The main issue now is the high deductibles which causes folks to ration care. Otherwise your premiums are scaled based on income. You also do get some primary care visits included and a few other things. That's so you catch things earlier before they get expensive. What the ACA really does though, is reduce the financial impact of a catastrophic event. So you are covered and out of pocket say a max of $10k vs $100k+. So let's say you get diagnosed with cancer, well the $10k is manageable (excluding the insurance games).
- mgkimsal 4y agoAssuming that 10 or 100k of services is 'in network'. The only plan I can remotely afford now offers no functionality in any 'out of network' facility. The columns are all just 'n/a'.
- unbalancedevh 4y agoThis "cashing in" isn't really anything new or different from what we expect elsewhere. If it costs money to get healthcare, and there's value in being able to delay paying for it, then it makes sense that there will be interest. It also makes sense that the amount of interest scales with the risk. If a hospital did all of their own bookkeeping and debt collection, I would expect it to converge to the same kinds of policies and costs that a separate debt collection agency has. The unfortunate result is that the people with less ability to pay (i.e., higher risk) end up paying more, as with anything else. That's the real problem. But as long as it costs money, and there's a time/risk value to money, I don't see it getting fixed.
- cvccvroomvroom 4y agoAnecdotal example: I was in a coffee shop in Redding CA. There was a lady with a nasal infusion pump tube in her nose. I struck up a conversation with her. It turns out she had Stage IV cancer and was about to go before a bankruptcy magistrate to fight to keep her clothes, housing, and vehicle. Her creditors were the doctors and hospitals who were going after her while she was still alive.
- DavidPeiffer 4y ago> It turns out she had Stage IV cancer and was about to go before a bankruptcy magistrate to fight to keep her clothes, housing, and vehicle. There are protections that vary significantly by state, and it's interesting to look through the variations in policy. Some states exempt a single firearm (regardless of value). If memory serves right, 401k's are protected by ERISA rules, but many states have IRA protections as well. Iowa exempts the entire homestead up to 1/4 acre in a city, regardless of its value. Having to deal with all of those items while battling a terrible disease puts someone in a disadvantaged position, but if you're ever in a position to help someone, it is good to be aware what exemptions exist. If your house is exempted, don't do a HELOC to pay medical bills. https://www.nolo.com/legal-encyclopedia/california-bankruptcy-exemptions-property-assets.html https://www.nolo.com/legal-encyclopedia/california-bankruptc...
- ars 4y agoWhy didn't she qualify for all the free (subsidized) insurance options offered by the ACA?
- antisthenes 4y agoIf you have obscene hospital bills, just don't pay them. Worst case scenario, you will get sued and have a lien put on your house.This still doesn't obligate you to pay. You can just let inflation eat away at the bill for years on end. People need to hit these profiteering practices right in the wallet. I'll take bad credit over actual bankruptcy any day.
- chasd00 4y agoI agree, never ever pay a medical bill as printed. They're just trolling for suckers. It's one of the shadiest things out there, they're just looking for people that will pay the full amount because that's what the bill says. Medical bills are always negotiable to such a degree that the printed bill is effectively meaningless.
- notch656a 4y agoLol I got some medical bills when police dragged me to the hospital against my will (not psych related, insane warrantless attempt to search me "internally" for drugs, never consented to anything, was not intoxicated and doctors documented I was completely asymptomatic and non-altered mental status) >People need to hit these profiteering practices right in the wallet. Here in Arizona there is a hospital system that appears to be using false smuggling accusations as a racket in connection with CBP officers. "Patients" are forcibly taken in, rack up huge medical bills, and then when nothing is found they're dumped back on the street with the debt. Keep getting the bills. Can't wait for them to actually sue so I can discovery them for any shred of evidence what they did was legal.
- potta_coffee 4y agoI remember reading a detailed story of a guy in Arizona who experienced this. He ended up suing the state (he was arrested by state police) and the doctor and won, but it was a long battle. I wish I had a link. Sounds like a horror story, I wouldn't wish that on my worst enemy.
- klyrs 4y ago> You can just let inflation eat away at the bill for years on end. Can we really? Wouldn't that require that our income tracks inflation? Because that's not true for perhaps most people in the US. Only executive-level income is beating inflation. I think the option most available is to die poor and have your pitiful assets distributed to your creditors.
- hungryforcodes 4y agoAnd yet everyone is complaining about FTX and crypto on HN and how such a scam that is. But this all OK huh?
- delecti 4y agoTwo things can be bad.
- hungryforcodes 4y agoThat's true -- but in this case there is an irrational bias. The people on HN who criticize crypto obviously don't invest in it and have no skin in the game. They just want to feel superior. But it doesn't affect them at all. But this really could -- and yet they are silent...
- delecti 4y agoThis is primarily a forum for nerdy stuff. The crypto space is much more on-topic for discussion here because of its technical origins, so it gets discussed more. If you want more discussions of other topics, post about them, and they'll get discussed if other people also want those dicussions.
- pessimizer 4y ago> yet they are silent... No they're not.
- watwut 4y agoI have yet to see a thread on HN where people do not complain about this.
- stevebmark 4y agoGreat article. It’s important to understand that hospitals are the enemy in American healthcare. (All of its layers are the enemy, but hospitals are often overlooked). Many hospitals are viscous for-profit machines that fraudulently maintain a non-profit status. They employ CFOs and business analysts to maximize profits unrelated to care quality. They hire “medical coders” whose entire job is to find the highest price way to legally bill you for services. (Is a surgery followed by stitches from a second doctor one procedure or two? Can we bill higher for medication if we can’t bill more for surgery? Can we charge a “room fee”?). And medical coder fees often show up on hospital bills sent to patients! The non profit mission of hospitals has long ago been lost to maximizing profits.
- mistrial9 4y ago> that hospitals are the enemy in American healthcare no, not every hospital is run this way. Many are, of course.. how can constructive engagement get past these shrill and urgent criticisms, and make positive change?
- BugsJustFindMe 4y agoMy perspective isn't universal, but it's true enough that your objection reads like an attempt to subversively derail to me. Just thought you should know how what you just said might come across.
- digdugdirk 4y agoIn this case, I think that having more people constructively engage with the fact that these "shrill and urgent criticisms" are the reality for the vast majority of Americans would make for a positive change. If the vast majority of bank tellers sucker punch you in the face after completing a transaction, the correct response is to implement a sweeping reform of bank tellers - not to do a deep dive root analysis on the positives and negatives that bank tellers add to the banking experience.
- mgkimsal 4y agoAny criticism of banking at all would be met with "we have the best banking system in the world!", ignoring the 40 million 'unbanked' people.
- secabeen 4y agoThe biggest challenge is just the entrenched interests. If we reduced US health care expenditures just to the median level of developed countries, we would spend ~$1 trillion/yr less than today. That's a lot of people laid off, who will fight tooth and nail to keep their jobs active.