7 ms·
This caused me read up on Estonia on Wikipedia, and this struck me: “ Estonia has pursued the development of the e-government, with 99 percent of the public se
by andsoitis 4y ago
This caused me read up on Estonia on Wikipedia, and this struck me:
“ Estonia has pursued the development of the e-government, with 99 percent of the public services being available on the web 24 hours a day.[198] In 2005 Estonia became the first country in the world to introduce nationwide binding Internet voting in local elections of 2005.[199] In 2019 parliamentary elections 44% of the total votes were cast over the internet.”
- fsh 4y agoI find it extremely concerning that they mix e-government and electronic voting. The former is obviously a good idea, while the latter is an existential threat to democracy. Estonian citizens can now no longer audit the validity of their elections in the way that paper ballots have allowed.
- SuoDuanDao 4y agoTo the Cryptoskeptics of HN, does this seem like a legitimate use case of Blockchain to you?
- francislavoie 4y agoNo. https://www.usvotefoundation.org/blockchain-voting-is-not-a-security-strategy https://www.usvotefoundation.org/blockchain-voting-is-not-a-...
- rpigab 4y agoIt's a typical case of a problem that we really think could be fixed by technology, but you're only adding or changing technology layers and the end result doesn't change, because it's not a technological problem, but a human one. People can be confident in paper votes because they can understand how to audit the result, and who does it. The best e-voting software in the world can provide that level of trust only to some engineers who know the code, and only if they can audit all the systems where the software is deployed. It's like passwords, it can't work if part of the population has no clue why it's needed or how it works. It's even worse with blockchain, because you can't put everything on the blockchain, it needs to interact with the real world, and that's where you can cheat the system (like stealing the keys of people in retirement homes because they don't know what they are for - sure it happens with paper but it's harder to do and easier to catch them in the act).
- andsoitis 4y agoCorrectness of system, especially w.r.t. things like voting, commerce, etc., are important to get right and to be able to verify. Wikipedia has a whole article about it in the Estonian case: https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Electronic_voting_in_Estonia https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Electronic_voting_in_Estonia
- rocket_surgeron 4y agoNorth Korea and Russia use paper ballots exclusively, and the recent referendum in Ukraine was conducted using paper ballots. Stuffing ballot boxes is much easier than an attack on an electronic voting system.
- fsh 4y agoAttacking an electronic voting system requires changing a few integers. Surely this is much easier than stuffing ballot boxes all over the country. In functioning democracies, the polls have observers from multiple parties which makes ballot stuffing infeasible.
- qwytw 4y ago> Stuffing ballot boxes is much easier than an attack on an electronic voting system. If you have free and independent observers it most definitely is not. If you don't have them it doesn't matter (with an electronic system you would have had exactly the same results both in Ukraine and Korea just at a much lower cost..). You'd need much resources and political power to compromise a normal election. With internet voting you'd need just a few people in the right spot (i.e. developing/maintaining the system) and some security vulnerability/backdoor to do it. Also it's virtually impossible to guarantee both security and anonymity with internet voting.
- manv1 4y agoElection integrity is more about the people running the election, not the method in which the votes are tallied. That's both a strength and weakness of the system. The less people in the process, the easier it is for someone to manipulate the process. That's irrespective of limiting the choices, obviously.
- qwytw 4y agoIn all/most democratic countries anyone can observe the counting of paper ballots and the process itself is relatively simple and easy to understand for almost anyone (even if not very efficiency). With internet voting we lose that. There is no way for most people to audit the system. Even if it's supposedly open source and transparent it's tricky to guarantee that the actual system is not tampered with and has no backdoors. > Election integrity is more about the people running the election True. But but fraud involving paper ballots is both difficult to execute at a large scale and hard to hide from other which is a huge deterrence.
- Strom 4y agoEstonia already has experience with faked election results with paper voting, due to Russian occupation. So that argument doesn't work as well in Estonia. Yes the electronic system can have flaws, but the old system didn't prevent the issues either. So might as well go with convenience.
- incomingpain 4y agoRead more about Estonia. They have so many good things going for it when it comes to their government. When communism died worldwide in 1989, estonia was left with nothing and had to figure it out from scratch. They chose computers and obviously this was a smart move. Due to this, they don't have hundreds of years of bureaucratic creep and big government problems. I very much love what estonia is doing, they have 1 obvious problem. They have a crazy neighbour.
- Kretinsky 4y agoThe e-id system has horrible UI. Also, their enterprise website hasn't been updated since the 2000', and any expat there can tell you that most services are done as if you still were in the USSR. 0 care for quality, nor customer service.
- yasinaydin 4y agoWhen I look at your messages in this thread, to me it sounds like you're doing deliberate anti-Estonia propaganda?
- Kretinsky 4y agoConsidering criticism as "anti-Estonia propaganda" is something very Estonian. I guess that when people criticize North Korea, it's just propaganda? No? How about facing the facts? - The E-id has a lot of tech debt. - Estonia is very far from being a "high tech country". Bus stops don't tell you the expected wait time, very few businesses are online, it's often complex to interact with the ones that are if you don't use a local bank, as apparently it's too hard to use Stripe. My internet provider doesn't support recurring payments and I can't pay with a credit card. - Estonian data collection is creepy. For instance, they collected around 10% of the country's inhabitants' dna to make "medecine of the future". In a country where you have to wait > 1 month to get an appointment for a general doctor and where you pay 20% VAT on pharmaceuticals, right. - Corruption is widespread in some layers of the society. Bribing public servant for school/kindergarten is common (I know many people who did it...). Tallinn's chronic mismanagement is probably due to the fact that town hall officials go work to the companies that deal with the city - Bolt being one of the first that comes to mind. Also, the massive money laundering scheme that got Danske Bank caught was known by every bank in the country, and all took part to it. The country being so small, it's very very easy to corrupt the right people, and it's quite cheap. - Can we talk about the fact that several government and city officials drive Bolt cabs to make ends meet? - Estonian tax system is crazy regressive. 20% vat on food! 20% flat income tax! Wtf is wrong with you guys? Instead of doing ads like this article, the government should maybe work on reducing the sky high preventable disease rates, mental issues in the population, find actual solution for the estonian language problem (as not telling people, "lol just learn Estonian by yourself dude"), stop reducing the spending in education, fund Estonian culture, which is now either a thing for tourists or an source of extractable public funding for the affluent Estonians. By the way, take care of your monuments - I've seen so many old manors (Mois) falling in ruins, it's a real shame. Maybe that's a better long term investment that another german SUV bought on leasing.
- argulane 4y agoThe Estonian ID-Card[1] that allows all of this is also pretty neat. Basically it is usually* a smart card that has your x502 government signed certificates stored on it. And because its a normal x502 certificate you can use Mutual TLS to authenticate every ID-Card holder / Estonian citizen by just adding those 3 lines to your nginx server config block[2] ssl_client_certificate /etc/ssl/certs/EID_Bundle.pem; ssl_verify_client on; ssl_verify_depth 2 (Adding a OCSP check is also highly recommended) Due to the ease of integration, the same ID-Card is also used to implement login for a lot of online websites and is also used as an Loyalty card in stores. It is also possible to use the ID-Card for SSH login[3] because it's just a standard smart card. * There is also an Mobile-ID that stores the x502 cert on you phone SIM card and a Smart-ID iPhone/Android app that require custom API-s and paying for the access. [1]: https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Estonian_identity_card https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Estonian_identity_card [2]: https://www.id.ee/wp-content/uploads/2021/05/2104-ubuntu-nginx-web-services-ssl-configuration.pdf https://www.id.ee/wp-content/uploads/2021/05/2104-ubuntu-ngi... [3]: https://ubuntu.com/server/docs/security-smart-cards-ssh https://ubuntu.com/server/docs/security-smart-cards-ssh
- aliqot 4y agoI want that
- Workaccount2 4y agoI can't decide if I love or hate the idea of using a national ID card for everything.
- jll29 4y agoIt's making life easier until the day comes that the card is taken from you and abused (or it is politely suggested you insert it on the requestor's behalf at gun point).
- Kretinsky 4y agoSorry to break the carefully chiseled communication of the Estonian government, but e-services in Estonia aren't so great. Source: I leave here. The Estonian e-id is a good idea, but very badly implemented, and quite creepy: - You need to install some government software on your computer to use basic services. They ask you to install a browser extension. huh... - The software UI is really crap. You get error messages in Russian, you have 3 apps for different purposes. You need to dump your cookies before using the e-id online, and it's nowhere said. Using e-id is usually a real pain, as it doesn't work out of the box most of the time. - It's not needed most of the time. Why do I need to find my e-id, the adapter, my code, just to check my internet provider account? A simple mail/password would have been fine. - If you're on your phone, you can use a "mobil-id" and use it like this, and pay using your id. Ok, but then, well...there's a disturbing centralization of data. A friend got a tax inspection because his supermarket card was linked to his e-id and he was seemingly spending more than what he was getting paid for his job. Are you OK with the government spying on your spending? - Estonia has almost no public services. Healthcare is a joke here - you need to wait often more than 3 months to see a specialist, even in Tallinn. Kindergartens are very difficult to access without bribing the administration (you don't need an e-id for this). There's a very opaque "elite school" system, which is geared around gatekeeping the good schools for the elite, while the rest of the population gets sub-par education. So yeah, being able to book a doctor online is interesting only if there are doctors available. Also, in the rest of the economy, one is forced to admit that web services are really underdeveloped - most shops don't have an online presence. Estonia's very good at PR, but most foreigners there (and some of the local population that lived abroad) will tell you it's mainly bs.
- Strom 4y agoNone of this matches my experience. > You need to install some government software It's open source and on github. Check out any of the ~50 repos https://github.com/orgs/open-eid/repositories https://github.com/orgs/open-eid/repositories --- not sure why this would be less trusted than any other open source software. > The software UI is really crap. I won't argue about the subjective taste of design, but at least the UI is Qt and not Electron. > You get error messages in Russian When you have it configured in English? Maybe. I can say that when configured to Estonian I've never seen any other language. > You need to dump your cookies Never heard of anyone having to do this. Sounds like a website specific issue anyway. > Why do I need [my e-id] just to check my internet provider account? Because you can sign binding legal agreements without leaving your home. It's convenient. > A friend got a tax inspection because his supermarket card was linked to his e-id and he was seemingly spending more than what he was getting paid for his job. This sounds like some grade A conspiracy. There is no government agency whose job is to collect supermarket purchase data. Are you claiming there is some sort of shadow organization hidden somewhere that goes through this data? I would bet that the tax inspection happened for other reasons and this conspiracy theory is made up. > Estonia has almost no public services Is this hyperbole? Do you have an example of a public service that is missing? > Healthcare is a joke here - you need to wait often more than 3 months to see a specialist, even in Tallinn. Not if your case has a medical reason to be prioritized. You can also always pay and go to a private clinic. > Kindergartens are very difficult to access without bribing the administration I'll assume you mean getting your kid into one by access. Some districts do indeed have long waiting lists. However if you register as soon as your kid is born the problem goes away. The problem usually surfaces when young parents are unaware of the registration waiting list and then later expect to be immediately admitted. That is only possible with 3+ year olds. The waiting lists are real for younger ones. The part about bribing is laughably false. Kindergarten administration doesn't have digital authorization to reorder the database, which is ran by different organizations. I guess maybe some kindergarten could take your kid "extra on the side" unofficially, but that's more like a special favor. There is no way to influence the actual registration list. > There's a very opaque "elite school" system Elite schools are like that in every country. Do you think an elite school would remain elite if it had general admission? > most shops don't have an online presence Are you talking about mom & pop stores? Because the biggest stores like Selver, Prisma, Rimi, Coop, Stockmann not only have an online presence but even do delivery. I think only Maxima doesn't do delivery, but still has an online listing of items. -- To summarize, you listed so many things that to me feel clearly false that its rather weird. You're either one of the unluckiest people in Estonia or have an axe to grind. Either way I hope you'll do better in the future, because me and everyone else I know has a much happier life in Estonia than what you described. Cheers!
- tapland 4y agoIIRC they also have e-embassies in certain countries so that services wouldn't be affected by a local military conflict.
- AdamN 4y agoThat's their whole disaster recovery plan and why they're so aggressive about digitization. If Russia overruns the physical country, the nation (it's state and it's people) can continue operating.
- fulafel 4y agoThere was also a government-in-exile spanning the USSR period: https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Estonian_government-in-exile https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Estonian_government-in-exile
- booleandilemma 4y agoThat's really interesting...a decentralized country...
- yasinaydin 4y agoBtw AFAIK there's only 1 e-embassy (called a Data Embassy) atm. https://e-estonia.com/solutions/e-governance/data-embassy/ https://e-estonia.com/solutions/e-governance/data-embassy/
- andsoitis 4y agoPerhaps it will be countries (as opposed to companies) that effectively build the “meta verse”. The internet itself was begat by government and public money, so this wouldn’t surprise me.