12 ms·
FTX's collapse strands scientists
- Tyrek 4y agoI suspect there's a simpler takeaway than what most comments are suggesting: Don't spend substantial amounts of money (based on nominally promised funding) before the checks have cleared.
- jefftk 4y agoEven in cases where the checks have cleared it is possible that the money will have to be returned. Here's a post by the managing counsel of Open Philanthropy, the other large funder in this space, describing some of the risks: https://forum.effectivealtruism.org/posts/o8B9kCkwteSqZg9zc/thoughts-on-legal-concerns-surrounding-the-ftx-situation https://forum.effectivealtruism.org/posts/o8B9kCkwteSqZg9zc/...
- HWR_14 4y agoIf the checks cleared since August 11th, the money is almost certainly going back.
- abruzzi 4y agothe article mentioned possible clawbacks, so that one thing. However I don't know if clawbacks will be limited to unspent funds or have the possibility to demand back funds that were already spent. Another possibility--and I have no idea if this might be the case here--most of the grants here where I work use "drawdowns." Specifically the granting agency awards a grant of $X for whatever you said you were going to do with it in the grant application, but they don't actually give you any money. So you start spending money on the project, and carefully accounting it, and usually every month you sum up everything spent, and issue a drawdown request for the funds spent. The granting agency then cuts you a check and you mark those expenses as reimbursed. This means that if the grnating agency goes belly up, there is a possibility you could be out real funds that you spent and are expecting a reimbursal.
- hkgjjgjfjfjfjf 4y ago
- leppr 4y agoThis whole episode should hopefully bring donation recipients to do more due diligence on where the money comes from, before spending it. The US president, those researchers, and many, many startups are holding what is pretty directly the money of FTX's unsuspecting users. The recovery will be a long and painful process.
- bibanez 4y agoI don't really understand the logic here. If you've received a donation, you can't be forced to return any money, specially if you didn't know it had dubious origins
- leppr 4y agoIf the money is stolen (as is the case in the articles' story), then yes, you can be legally compelled to return the money to its original owner.
- bibanez 4y agoYes that is reasonable. What I know is from an account by a relative here in Spain, and it depends on the lawyer. Of cours, infinitessimal amounts compared to the money being talked about here
- YetAnotherNick 4y agoSource will be appreciated. What if the money has already been spent? Do they track it all the way through or just one level?
- deleted 4y ago[deleted]
- deleted 4y ago[deleted]
- RcouF1uZ4gsC 4y agoMaybe it’s a good lesson for non-profits and foundations to vet their major donors better. Before that Epstein was a major donor and the cachet of having donated to so many high profile charities likely allowed him to be a predator longer. In the case with FTX, it was likely committing fraud, and the money the foundations received was the equivalent of stolen goods.
- criddell 4y ago> FTX’s collapse was unthinkable just days earlier. I was shocked -- SHOCKED! -- to find out there was gambling going on in there.
- cscurmudgeon 4y agoThis wasn't pure gambling. This was plain fraud. Let us not sugarcoat it by saying it was "plain" gambling. It was gambling BUT with stolen funds.
- throwawaysleep 4y agoCrypto is just one big grift.
- lanstin 4y agoAnd when the crypto prices were going up, it was a safe bet with customer funds. Fraud, sure, but safe fraud, call it removal of unneeded regulations. Now, tho, looks like all that stuff between 2020 and now in crypto was, like the tech stocks, a bubble, and the longer term prices are more likely to be around where they are and stabler than previously, making a safe fraud a busted fraud.
- halfmatthalfcat 4y agoUnthinkable to the most naive and gullible people on Earth maybe.
- dragontamer 4y agoThe line above was a movie-quote, I believe Cassablanca? Where the inspector/regulator comes out of the Casino saying that he's shocked to hear of gambling in the facility, flanked by two call girls. ------ EDIT: That being said, the level of shock here is warranted. > “It’s definitely a mess,” says Josh Morrison, who heads 1Day Sooner, a pandemic preparedness research and advocacy organization that received $375,000 from the Future Fund and the FTX Foundation. During the pandemic, 1DaySooner became known for advocating so-called human challenge trials, which deliberately infected volunteers with SARS-CoV-2 to test vaccines. So FTX allegedly donates a lot of money to various causes. Those scientists begin the trials (expecting the money to pay them back eventually), but... FTX goes bankrupt before it hands those scientists money. That's... bad. I'm not in the scientific field, but it seems like these groups had reasonable expectation that some money was coming for them... and that money wasn't related to cryptocoins or whatever.
- skycatcher 4y agoThe comments saying the lesson here is that recipients of donations like non-profits and foundations should be vetting their donors better seem unreasonable to me. If FTX investors, customers, and watchers of the crypto space did not catch what FTX and SBF were doing until the shit hit the fan, what kind of due diligence can we reasonably expect of these recipients that would’ve alerted them to something being wrong here? And consider that the number of donors for most institutions would be much larger than the number of companies FTX investors would’ve had to keep an eye on.
- leppr 4y ago
- mbaum9 4y ago
- HDThoreaun 4y agoThe dem party probably figured Sequoia did a better vetting job than they'd be able to, and they probably weren't wrong.
- halpmeh 4y agoAnyone in their right might would also assume that depositors would vet the financial institutions holding their (billions of dollars of) capital, but alas here we are. Also, I think you underestimate the amount of effort it takes to uncover something like this. There was a YouTube video posted to HN a few days ago where Marc Cohodes went over why he believed FTX was a scam a few weeks prior to the news breaking. It provided an interesting glimpse into what's required to do DD on this type of operation. It starts with good intuition, which most people don't have, and then evolves into things like hiring private investigators, or running comprehensive background checks on the officers of the company, or calling people with intimate knowledge of the inner workings, or finding ex-employees, etc. etc. etc. Now you could say, well a presidential candidate should do all that stuff. And in an ideal world, they would. But Marc Cohodes does this as a full time job and likely makes large sums of money from his vocation. It's unrealistic to expect most people, presidential candidate or otherwise, to be capable of performing that kind of DD.
- wanderingmind 4y ago"We don’t think it is right that anyone should lose their jobs over a financial calamity totally unrelated to the excellent work they are doing,” Yet we are totally OK with exploiting young people aspirations by making them slaves and destroying their careers and mental health. The last thing we need to worry about is the academic cabal crying wolf.
- hobom 4y agoThe just-world fallacy is strongly in play with many comments here. Because those foundations and charities are massively affected by this scandal, there MUST be something they did wrong, right? Surely they should have vetted their donors better? And when making these arguments, we totally forget that people specialising in vetting people, like investment funds, journalists and so on, completely fell for the guy. If you want charities to implement a standard that would have prevented them from taking money from SBF, congratulations, you now have a process that prevents them from taking money from basically any billionaire.
- dahdum 4y agoThese foundations and charities were willing participants of SBF's PR campaign, but they're constantly being used for such purposes. Expecting them to unravel his complex, opaque, international fraud before accepting grants is a hard ask. Hell, Gensler's team was meeting with FTX to write regulations while freezing out other crypto companies. SBF had been anointed. Still, while victims of his fraud, they are certainly lower in standing than almost everyone else.
- rglover 4y ago> we totally forget that people specialising in vetting people, like investment funds, journalists and so on, completely fell for the guy. This is not an excuse for assuaging due diligence. And to be frank, the guy looked shifty. Even worse, a cursory look at his company would have told you he was shuffling billions of dollars in investments and user deposits without a board of directors. If it quacks like a duck... It would do a lot of people well to assume that anybody portrayed as a wünderkind or super genius in the media is anything but and cautiously invest their time, money, and attention in them accordingly.
- alistairSH 4y agoThe only mistake these foundations made was committing to spend money they hadn’t yet received. And relying on a single source of funding. Something about eggs and baskets. Should they have known FTX was about to fail? Maybe, but so should a lot of other people who should have definitely known better. So, it’s hard to fault them for that.
- mrcode007 4y agoI tend to be skeptical of grants that don’t fork cash up front. A lot of “pledged” or “committed” grants, giveaways are often tax dodges. I may be wrong, I’m not a tax expert, but it seems that tax deductions on pledges are accounted for immediately while the cash flow out is actually delayed. If my understanding is correct, it would make sense to pledge as much as one can in an “up” year.
- HWR_14 4y ago> it seems that tax deductions on pledges are accounted for immediately while the cash flow out is actually delayed I have no idea where you would get that idea. There have been some interesting arrangements for sure, but there is no way to get a tax deduction for a pledge that hasn't been given.
- mrcode007 4y agoI got the idea by learning about donor advised funds https://www.nytimes.com/2018/08/03/business/donor-advised-funds-tech-tax.html https://www.nytimes.com/2018/08/03/business/donor-advised-fu...
- HWR_14 4y agoHe gave the money to a charity he controls. That's different from keeping the money until later. He can do a lot of things with it, but not buy a house. It's not his money anymore.
- mrcode007 4y agoI understand you can’t buy a house. You could for example donate to build a building at a college and get your kid into college instead ;) Some donors give with tax benefits in mind and dual intent giving , while some give just to give. In general, you can always ask yourself if a person giving is increasing their net asset value while giving or declining asset value while giving. The mathematics are fairly elementary even when you account for compounding rates
- BrainVirus 4y agoDoes it strand legitimate scientists or does it indicate that there is corruption in science? From what I'm hearing, this whole FTX thing reeks of clever, politically connected fraud and money laundering: https://odysee.com/@Chris_Martenson:2/the-deeply-troubling-ftx-facts-and:1 https://odysee.com/@Chris_Martenson:2/the-deeply-troubling-f...
- expazl 4y ago> SecureBio’s co-founder, Kevin Esvelt, a biologist at MIT, says the nonprofit is avoiding use of its Future Fund grant money for now, except to pay the salaries of the three newly hired people. “We don’t think it is right that anyone should lose their jobs over a financial calamity totally unrelated to the excellent work they are doing,” Esvelt says. All this discussion about weather the scientists should vet or not is irrelevant when they have 100% certain proof that the donated money they are spending is stolen, and they are keeping on using it... If you don't want people to lose their jobs, take a loan and find alternative funding, don't keep on using stolen funds for for goodness sake.
- oldgradstudent 4y ago> says the nonprofit is avoiding use of its Future Fund grant money for now, except to pay the salaries of the three newly hired people. “We don’t think it is right that anyone should lose their jobs over a financial calamity totally unrelated to the excellent work they are doing,” Esvelt says. They may be talented, but these are stolen funds that may be clawed back.
- nemo44x 4y agoYeah seriously. It’s not their decision to decide “what’s fair”. Every foundation he has given to needs to immediately stop using the funds he gave them as they are possibly (very likely) in possession of stolen money.
- whycome 4y agoI won't get over the fact that the principal's name is bankman-fried. Who's writing this story?
- ummonk 4y agoNormally nonprofits accept donations from oil monarchies, shady characters like Epstein, etc. in the exchange for providing good PR and increased connections with other influential people. In comparison, SBF and FTX must have seemed rather good, despite being in the crypto space.
- skinnymuch 4y agoEpstein the guy friends with every other powerful person was shady? Is every powerful person shady then?
- TechBro8615 4y agoI'm going to be really upset if the government uses stories like these as an excuse to bail out FTX, SBF walks free having "raised investment" to cover the $8b loss, and the government is left openly controlling a major crypto exchange.
- bArray 4y agoIt doesn't matter how 'noble' the research seems, these funds were clearly raised through criminal activity. It really sucks for the researchers, but the people who earned that money have a fundamental right to decide how it is spent. Stealing your money and pledging it to goals you may not agree with is a right strictly reserved for governments.
- jefftk 4y ago> SecureBio’s co-founder, Kevin Esvelt, a biologist at MIT, says the nonprofit is avoiding use of its Future Fund grant money for now, except to pay the salaries of the three newly hired people. I think it's actually two people. When FTX imploded I asked not to be paid if this would mean taking FTX money. (I'm fortunate that I'm able to do this, and I don't fault my coworkers who can't.)
- stephen_g 4y agoThe author of this article comes off as incredibly credulous... Apparently FTX was "brought to its knees by an old-style run on the bank" - what about the massive fraud Bankman-Fried and his management were committing?
- rdxm 4y ago
- Metacelsus 4y agoCount me in – I was pledged $300K for research on oogenesis and meiosis which I'll never get.
- malkia 4y ago
- deleted 4y ago[deleted]
- chaosbolt 4y agoIt amazes me the length to which some people will go in their mental gymnastics instead of seeing the obvious explanation in from of thel: SBF is a crook, easy, there are bad people, there are evil people, if all evidence points to someone being such a person then... But noooo you can't think that because well you know. Meh doesn't even matter anymore, seeing the narrative about most things get more convoluted makes me doubt everything we even know about history, like how can I trust something happened 1000 years ago if I can't trust things that are happening right now it's crazy
- bmitc 4y agoIt’s a bit mind blowing that anyone who met Sam Bankman-Fried didn’t quickly come to the conclusion that he was a drug-addled kid who thought he was smarter than everyone else. He basically comes across like that on camera and in interviews, so I can’t imagine what it’s like to meet him in person or over a direct video call. The information coming out that he was hopped up on amphetamines, Parkinson’s disease drugs (!), sleeping pills, and various other drugs basically 24/7 is alarming, and it’s crazy that no-one was sounding the bells on this alone, much less the fraud and trading boondoggles. It’s hilarious to think of all these powerful people speaking with a drug addict, much less as if he was a crypto messiah. Maybe these organizations, the government, politicians, and corporations should be less focused on raising money at all costs. How many SBF, Madoff, Epstein, etc. do we need for these people to learn this?
- JumpCrisscross 4y ago> a drug-addled kid who thought he was smarter than everyone else This describes a lot of people who changed the world. This one, unfortunately, was simply a fraudster.
- jasonlotito 4y agoDid you meet him?
- bmitc 4y agoWhat is your point?
- d_graeme 4y agoI'm calling bs on this. I despise the guy (even before his crash, the way he was literally worshipped even here on hn, as though he was some kind of crypo-saint, was embarassing), but let's try and keep the rumor-mongering to a minimum. I've been junkreading all about ftx and it's silly founder the past couple of days, and nowhere have I read that he shot himself up with drugs. Let's not take tweets or posts by randos with an axe to grind as facts.
- 4y ago
- Ptchd 4y agoThe US Gov. hates crypto so don't wait for bailouts....
- Animats 4y agoWell, at least they're only losing their grants. That's future income. When Madoff went down, many Jewish institutions lost their endowments, because they'd been investing with him.[1] [1] https://www.investmentnews.com/a-year-later-jewish-charities-still-hurting-from-madoff-blow-25888 https://www.investmentnews.com/a-year-later-jewish-charities...
- whitej125 4y agoLast spring a neighbor of mine (researcher/professor) was talking about how one of his students stumbled upon one of these SBF foundations and that prompted them to apply. The application process was a Google Form and within a few days they got a $1M grant. No questions or interactions outside the Google Form. The only restriction was something to the effect that the it had to be spent 100% on the research project and the university couldn’t take any of the money to cover its own expenses (or something to that effect). He was amazed at how swift and low-detail it was as he’s generally spending most of the year flying to conferences, visiting/speaking to foundations etc to pull the funding together.
- savanaly 4y agoThis style of grant giving has caught on in the last few years (three other examples I can think of off the top of my head are Tyler Cowen's Fast Grants [0] and Emergent Ventures [1] and Scott Alexander's ACX Grants [2], inspired by the former). Despite the fact that SBF's foundations used the same style and collapsed, I don't think the style will go away. It's just so much more efficient than the normal grant application process, for small-scale interventions. [0] https://fastgrants.org/ https://fastgrants.org/ [1] https://www.mercatus.org/emergent-ventures https://www.mercatus.org/emergent-ventures [2] https://astralcodexten.substack.com/p/acx-grants-results https://astralcodexten.substack.com/p/acx-grants-results
- mlindner 4y agoI've been hearing a lot recently about FTX after it's collapse and I'd honestly never heard of it before it's collapse. I've read that they were a prominent donor to far-left organizations. Is there any truth to that? If there is, what kinds of "science" donations have they done that are far-left?
- jasonlotito 4y agohttps://www.opensecrets.org/orgs/ftx-us/summary?id=D000073694&topnumcycle=2022 https://www.opensecrets.org/orgs/ftx-us/summary?id=D00007369... They donated substantially to both left and right leaning organizations. https://www.opensecrets.org/orgs/ftx-us/recipients?toprecipscycle=2022&id=D000073694&candscycle=2022 https://www.opensecrets.org/orgs/ftx-us/recipients?toprecips... You can see the breakup of the congressional candidates there, almost a 50/50 split. Anyone suggesting they are only donating to far-left organizations or the like is lying and has an agenda that is opposed to the truth.
- StopHammoTime 4y agoJust remember, SBF wasn’t donating money to these causes: he was donating his customers assets. These organisations are lucky the assets don’t get clawed back because this money should be considered stolen or proceeds of crime.
- pcdoodle 4y agoGood. They were probably the ones doing the unreproducible science anyways...
- CodeWriter23 4y agoShow me a cryptocurrency backed by a standing army and then I’ll believe it is more than just numbers on one or more computers.
- deleted 4y ago[deleted]