6 ms·
Americans to Provide Biometrics and Pay Fee Traveling to the U.K. From 2023
- noobermin 4y agoThe first time I saw london was a few years ago on a long, multi-hour layover. I left the airport and walked around the city, then headed back to the airport to catch my flight. Looks like mini visits like this will become a thing of the past.
- allanrbo 4y agoSort of like how UK and EU citizens have to pay $21 for an ESTA when traveling to USA? Surprising that the article doesn't mention that.
- iudqnolq 4y agoThe sentences are a bit long and convoluted, but it does. > Electronic Travel Authorization schemes are becoming increasingly popular among developed nations looking to improve security and keep tabs on all who cross into their national territories. ... Since then, numerous other destinations followed suit, including Canada and the U.S., which have facilitated visa-free travel agreements, but expect all non-Canadian and non-U.S. travelers to apply for electronic authorization, or a visa, ahead of flying. Now it's Britain's turn to reciprocate
- thiscatis 4y agoAnd still be assumed a Syrian terrorist selling weapons to North Korea with proceeds that were laundered from a Mexican drug lord by default by the “friendly” folks at the border.
- kevin_thibedeau 4y agoUS citizens also get hostile treatment from the border guards. It's part of their scheme to pressure liars into breaking.
- deleted 4y ago[deleted]
- jakevn 4y agoOne time when returning from an overseas country, I was in one of two lines: One for foreigners, and one for US citizens. It was quite the line. After a few minutes, I was pulled aside and whisked through customs. As I was nearing the exit, a staff member said "welcome home". It hadn't hit me until later that I was likely skipped ahead due to having a military surplus duffel bag. No particular point here aside from how silly the whole thing is.
- midoridensha 4y agoI thought it was because people in American law enforcement are just generally assholes.
- dymk 4y agoIt follows that if you wanted a purposefully hostile "customer experience", you'd specifically hire the assholes ;)
- midoridensha 4y agoYeah, but it's not just border patrol, customs, etc., it's everyone I've ever seen or interacted with in American law enforcement: they're almost all assholes. It's nothing at all like, for instance, dealing with police or customs officers here in Japan. There's no way in hell I'd ever ask an American cop for directions, and I look mostly like they do. But here in Japan, I'd never have any fear asking police for directions or help; it's what they're there for. Just interacting with security in airports between the two countries couldn't be more different. Japanese airport security is helpful and courteous. TSA is.... not.
- notch656a 4y agoOur border patrol was placed under DHS sometime around 15 years ago, and DHS itself was created as the 'anti-terrorist' security umbrella post 9/11. CBP (customs and border protection) became a catch all gestapo to create the largest federal police force outside of the FBI, and of course one of their biggest subjects to 'inspection' in their anti-terror goals (be sure to read this in a George Bush accent) were none other than citizen John Q Public. Another group you may remember in DHS as every air traveler's favorite is none other than the TSA. The CBP is ostensibly primarily interested in the border where the "constitution doesn't (fully) apply." IMO this has caused them to become known a jackboot-thug like entities who terrifyingly are now deployed even within the interior of the US, often with poor discipline to their constitutional restraints. Their special response teams were deployed to Portland during the riots, during which some may remember unmarked vans were grabbing citizens off the street (I have no idea if the vans were DHS). Another favorite of theirs is setting up 'immigration checkpoints' which of course conveniently feature local police (milling in the background) who take advantage of using the stop to catch criminal violations without needing to obtain PC/RAS (silly constitutional stuff) to initiate a stop. The gestapo like roots of CBP has made it the most terrifying, and unrestrained, and poorly monitored of all the federal polices in America. It deserves even more scrutiny that it is already getting. In the words of CBP, last time I invoked the few rights I had at the border, "now I'm going to show you my (CBPs) rights." And oh, they did.... [0] [0] https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=33617350#33618162 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=33617350#33618162
- barbazoo 4y agoPlus 10 bucks or so every 90 days for the visa waiver program if applicable.
- drstewart 4y agoNo, sort of like how the EU is implementing a travel authorization for a fee for Americans traveling to the EU. Surprising you didn't mention that.
- johaugum 4y agoJust like how the US requires the same for EU travelers visiting the US? Seems reasonable to require the same going the other way. IIRC, it was the US that first introduced these requirements.
- timack 4y agoI'm from NZ and had to pay $21 for an ESTA just to transit in LA on the way to UK.
- rodgerd 4y ago> Surprising that the article doesn't mention that To paraphrase someone more famous, "an American is never a foreigner, he belongs everywhere that he goes."
- cmrdporcupine 4y agoFunny quote. Except I think it's also the case that Americans on the whole don't seem to leave their country as much as other citizens of the "western world." So they're not enjoying these privileges. Travel into the United States is so terrible and authoritarian, especially after 9/11 -- but I don't think Americans on the whole get it. Because their own country is such a centre of gravity that they don't experience it as much as others, or know the contrast on how things happen elsewhere. As a Canadian, living next door in a "friendly" country, we used to (before 9/11) be able to cross over with just a driver's license. Now, if I travel by myself without my wife and kids, I'm lucky if I can make it over for a quick ski trip or whatever without being detained and aggressively questioned for an hour and having my car searched. It now happens to me the majority of times.
- iudqnolq 4y agoI found the bit about looking for a technical way to have users upload a fingerprint with their own device interesting. The only thing I could think of would be taking a picture of an old-fashion ink on paper fingerprint. But that's far from ideal.
- noobermin 4y agoWhat if you have fingerprint auth on your phone, couldn't you just upload that?
- rPlayer6554 4y agoI don't think it works that way. I'm not an Android or iPhone developer but I'm pretty sure the OS does not give the app access to the actual biometric data. Apple made a big deal about fingerprints and facial data being in their secure enclave I think.
- jeeeb 4y agoThe title (and much of the article) sounds like the law singles out Americans, but the actual law apparently doesn’t. Calling the UK insular was also rather ironic given that the US has required ETAs for travel and fingerprints on arrival for many years.
- idlewords 4y agoI think they used insular in the literal sense—pertaining to an island. It's like how your uncle is avuncular even if he's a bitter jerk.
- jfengel 4y agoThough not quite apt. The UK is one island and part of another. That other part has a border with an EU country. It's only 300 miles of border, but it makes a huge difference. Especially since by law it's an unguarded border. Even English people seem to forget about it from time to time, despite everyone else being acutely aware of it.
- bb123 4y agoSeems like this only aligns the immigration policies to be reciprocal. UK citizens entering the US must pay a fee (ESTA or Visa if ineligible) and provide biometrics at the border (picture, fingerprints).
- jrochkind1 4y agoIndeed. I think it's all so awful. I remember as a child in the USA in the 80s the general feeling that travel would become free-er and free-er as time went on; and that we could take pride in being a democracy who could let citizens of other democracies travel freely back and forth (whether that was really true or not -- and it surely wasn't as much as we thought it was, and how rich or poor the person and country mattered -- the point was that our self-image was that it was and that this was good and something to be proud of -- that democracies could allow free travel between each other. No doubt this was in large part due to the context of the cold war, with the desire to distinguish ourselves from those behind the "iron curtain") It is so sad to me that we're all moving in the opposite direction, to my mind for no good reasons, and not even regretting it. We -- for some inclusion of "we" -- didn't even used to have to show any paperwork to travel from the USA to Canada. Young people now can probably barely believe that is the truth.
- JumpCrisscross 4y ago> we're all moving in the opposite direction I flew to Britain in 2020 of all times, and got in with a swipe of my passport. That’s easier than it has been for most across history to travel a fraction of that distance.
- jrochkind1 4y agoThe flying is easier, in the sense that it takes you long distances quickly and easily and relatively inexpensively, compared to what it took to travel such distances in most of human history. The border controls, I think you are simply incorrect. For most of human history in most places, if someone had the material means to go somewhere, nobody would keep them out, there were no documents, fingerprints, or fees. For most humans across most of human history there weren't even such things as borders. At any rate, the OP is saying that it will soon require more than a swipe of the passport for Americans to get into the UK; and the comment I was responding to that it already does for British to get into USA.
- jnwatson 4y agoI just tried to arrange a visit to London for this Christmas just for tourism. After my girlfriend spent 3 hours trying to get a tourist visa (she's from Ukraine), she finally gave up. It seems the only way to go is pay $800 to the company that runs the UK visas in the US. She'd be without a passport for an undefined amount of time. The UK really, really doesn't want tourists.
- jahewson 4y agoI dunno that just sounds like a standard visitor visa that costs £100. U.K. government websites are excellent and you can apply for all this stuff yourself online.
- missedthecue 4y agoTo get a British visa you must pay a fee and physically mail your passport to VFS Services Inc. It is not possible to do it yourself online. Source: I have a British visa.
- gnu8 4y agoHow is it considered secure or appropriate to mail one's passport to unknown parties to do who-knows-what with it?
- renewiltord 4y agoIn SF, at least, you can do it by appointment. You go in and they'll take it from you and mail it back.
- nradov 4y agoThe USPS is considered secure. It's even legal to send classified secret documents by mail as long as certain procedures are followed. Many other countries also require you to mail in your passport to get a visa. If you need to travel during that period you can obtain a second passport book from the State Department. It is a bit of extra hassle and expense.
- monksy 4y agoThis really sucks for those of us that are trying to avoid covid while travelling. (This is a collecting point where they want you maskless) They want to do this so they can collect your biometrics and look secure.
- johaugum 4y ago> They want to do this so they can collect your biometrics and look secure. It likely has more to do with reciprocity, as the US places these same burdens on travelers (including those from UK) visiting the US.
- JetAlone 4y agoA time is coming where the upright man must decide where he would like to live, stay there, and abandon the hope of simply being allowed onto an airplane. He should cultivate inner virtues, and charitably leave his coming air travel "carbon credits" for another person, whose flexible spine can stomach the bio surveillance and bureaucracy.
- deleted 4y ago[deleted]
- ulfw 4y agoGlobalisation is slowly but steadily dying. These measures are ridiculous. Reciprocating on the steady slow down to the 1970s again. Simple everyday things like "my transit flight is cancelled and now I have to stay a night over in Europe" will become "I will now stay at the airport instead of being able to get a hotel steps outside the terminal" because you didn't apply for authorisation beforehand
- chatterhead 4y agoAgreed, they are ridiculous measures, but I'd say this is exactly what "globalization" has intended from the beginning. Internationalism was different; where Globalists seeks to tear down walls by building gates, Internationalists seek to overcome borders by building bridges.
- kapitanjakc 4y agoUS charges way more and demands finger print, social media links, property papers, employment papers, bank account statement going back 6 months and various other details from many countries' tourists.
- deleted 4y ago[deleted]
- libraryatnight 4y agoThat's awful. Doesn't make this right or good, though.
- Entinel 4y agoGuess I'm not going to the UK.
- lettergram 4y agoGuess I'll skip going to the UK. Bet you can go through Dublin and drive in.
- FpUser 4y agoWell congrats. Our so called "Free" part of the world becoming less and less so without any good reason but a fucking control freaks running amok.
- onetimeusename 4y agoWhat actually happens to the biometric data after your trip is over? I can understand keeping it for a length of time. But one scenario where this could be a problem is if you did not agree to share this biometric data with another country, but that country requests it from the UK who happily complies. Another scenario is the one where the data is leaked because of a security issue and it enables you to be tracked with facial recognition software because your identity was tied to it. Although it's still possible to track someone without an identity and it's possible to get an identity without needing leaked government data, I still would consider this data very sensitive.
- Grazester 4y agoI wonder if commonwealth countries are subjected to the eta also?
- joeman1000 4y agoAbout time. USA has been invading everyone’s privacy at airports for a long time.