7 ms·
U.S. FBI director says TikTok poses national security concerns
- deleted 4y ago[deleted]
- MR4D 4y agoIronic: https://www.bbc.com/news/technology-57413227 https://www.bbc.com/news/technology-57413227
- _8j50 4y agoI hope it is more common for politicians to change their minds when they realize they are wrong despite "gotcha" sentiments like this.
- postalrat 4y agoHas Biden admitted he was wrong?
- _8j50 4y agoOf course not, has any politician ever unless it benefited them? Have you seen trump? He literally made fun of disabled people and he refused to even slightly suggest that was a bit too much. I am not saying biden is better, to the contrary trump succeeded because he was great at the politics game - never show weakness, always look out for yourself and damned be anyone else you harm!
- MR4D 4y agoThis isn’t a gotcha sentiment - I don’t do that. Specifically, Biden’s team didn’t do the analysis when they removed the restriction. That’s the dumb move that caused the situation. Had they followed their own advice and looked at it first before withdrawing the order, then they wouldn’t be in this position.
- listless 4y agoWhy is this downvoted? It’s inherently a political issue and the history here is relevant.
- libraryatnight 4y agoBecause of the added and unnecessary color comment if I had to guess. It's also not at all ironic if you read the article.
- MR4D 4y agoIf you read my link, you'd see the irony (which is why I included the link). From the article I linked to: ' It should use an "evidence-based approach" to see if they pose a risk to US national security, Mr Biden said. ' The Administration was sloppy in this, and they undid something that they had to redo because they didn't follow their own advice when the put out the original order (which is here by the way: https://www.whitehouse.gov/briefing-room/statements-releases/2021/06/09/fact-sheet-executive-order-protecting-americans-sensitive-data-from-foreign-adversaries/ https://www.whitehouse.gov/briefing-room/statements-releases... ). So yes, Irony is appropriate here. It's like a guy who puts down a banana peel and then slips on that same banana peel.
- Gortal278 4y agoIt obviously does. Still a great app though.
- Melting_Harps 4y ago> It obviously does. Still a great app though. What is so great about it? It's algo, infinite scrolling, monetization models? These are generally time sinks and engagement is what it's optimized for, but as a platform how is any different than what Vine or any other similar platform made before? People uploading hours of their skits/rants/dancing etc... and calling it content has never appealed to me, hence why I never bothered with Social Media. But I'm genuinely curious, what makes it a 'great app' amongst technologists?
- Gortal278 4y agoIt is extremely entertaining. The content and algorithm to get you content is better than anything i've ever seen. Definitely a threat though to US and west etc.
- avaldez_ 4y agoHow you can so nonchalantly say it's extremely entertaining and the best thing ever while considering it a threat to half of the world? One thing should completely negate the other right?
- birdyrooster 4y agoThe internet is still new in the grand scheme of society and people haven't adjusted. They haven't learned that these short videos are programming them to not think and taking advantage of them for marketing purposes. They still find them "extremely entertaining" because they haven't considered the second order effects. There are people with genetic predisposition to alcoholism for various reasons, this is kinda like that. I have ADHD and so I am very defensive of my focus and so I will not participate in TikTok or YouTube Shorts or any of that abusive stuff because for me it deprives me significantly of my agency. For some people (most?) dissociating into TikTok (and losing agency in the process) is the point.
- draw_down 4y ago
- rsj_hn 4y agoI wish someone would lay out the case -- or point me to a document that lays out the case -- of why it's a national security threat. The only arguments in the reuters piece is: * control devices -- if TikTok can take over devices, that's a sandbox problem, but I am suspicious about the accuracy of this claim * influence users -- here's the rub. The USG is worried about having social media that is owned by a rival power influencing public opinion? The assumption behind this is that all forms of media consumed by Americans must be under US government control or approval (say an allied nation). Moreover, if you accept that this is a national security threat, how are other countries supposed to treat US properties like Facebook? Or USG efforts like Voice of America, National Endowment for Democracy, etc? This is a recipe for total information control based on blocs, with Great Firewalls separating each bloc, and no citizen able to access any social media platform unless it's owned by a friendly government in your own bloc. Are the above two arguments the only ones? If there is a different reason why TikTok is a national security threat, I'd like to know, because all I see are short videos of old people dancing, young people yelling in their cars, and cat videos. None of that seems like a national security concern to me.
- zaptrem 4y agoThe video targeting algorithm is a view into individual's psyches on a level that was previously impossible at this scale.
- kelseyfrog 4y agoLet's play it out. What happens after that?
- gnu8 4y agoTiktok's algorithms should be easily jammed by clicking on the wrong things, but at that point why bother using it at all? I've never tried it.
- mint2 4y agoUS govt:Facebook != CCP:TikTok
- robswc 4y agoYou don't have to look any further than the content curation for the US vs China. They feed US users absolute nonsense while restricting that for their own people. It absolutely is a weapon that people need to take seriously.
- newbYhrly 4y agoI see a free market of ideas at work. Why is the US government as-is a rational actor to get behind? More of its citizens in prison than China, it’s citizens vote against supporting each other through universal healthcare, and education, it’s opioid peddling execs, scandal plagued business leadership makes Mad Men look like Leave it to Beaver. China did not set the US on this path. It’s all homegrown. Let such exceptional and gritty people be. Get some popcorn. Front row seats to the end of society are waiting.
- trentgreene 4y agoCalling TikTok a market of free ideas is almost like an oxymoron when it’s beholden to a party that jails dissenting journalists.
- newbYhrly 4y agoI was referring to users choice of TikTok, not the “content of” TikTok. Why should the US government decide which apps free people download? Free people ostensibly have no obligation to government security concerns. Assange, Snowden, Swartz. Migrant children in cages. Along with the list in my original post, and recent history I was alive for that includes numerous other examples; US citizens and its politicians are bullies who ignore their own bullying. Not saying “China good.” I’m saying “US bad.”
- andrei_says_ 4y agoHow is “someone else bad” an argument to not “make thing less bad”? Isn’t this the very definition of whataboutism? What would be a constructive approach to improving the situation?
- quantum_state 4y agoBy claiming something is a national security concern, the government gains unchallenged power … is this what we want in the US?
- akomtu 4y agoIn some cases, yes. Nice try, btw.
- dsfyu404ed 4y agoIf you say "it's good because it will be used to marginalize people I don't like" in fancy enough words and dress it up in some plausible deniability people who like to think they're against jackbooted thuggery will readily agree with you.
- pyuser583 4y agoThe biggest threat to US security is cyberattacks by ransomware gangs. Focus on that please.
- thekyle 4y agoI would argue ransomware is improving U.S. security by providing a direct financial incentive for institutions to improve their cybersecurity.
- daniel-cussen 4y ago
- bmitc 4y agoIn my opinion, the four or so biggest existential and ideological threats to the U.S. are: 1. Unabashed and unhinged capitalism (growth at all costs) 2. Nearly every social media platform 3. The mainstream media 4. Billionaires and more generally the ultrawealthy As far as I can tell, basically no one in power cares about any of these (likely because they benefit from all of them), and they're tearing the U.S. apart from the inside.
- ralusek 4y agoThe biggest existential threat to any civilization is its own state, surprisingly absent from your list. A further and more generalized abstraction is that the biggest threat to any civilization are self-interested power centers of any kind. Those can take the form of states, corporations, unions, billionaires, etc. Any entity that begins to operate in its own interest and has vastly disproportionate power when compared to the individuals of which the civilization is made.
- bmitc 4y ago> The biggest existential threat to any civilization is its own state, surprisingly absent from your list. No it’s not absent. The state is controlled by (1)-(4).
- gfdsgfdsgfsd 4y agoThe USA is very wealthy because of 1 and 4
- dopidop 4y agoThe USA being wealthy seems like a weird idea from a lot of the USA territory. See : MS, LA, AL and consort. At some point you can’t ignore the division between the map and the territory. At best the USA is a country, with rich people in it. As opposed to say, Switzerland, a rich country.
- rcarr 4y agoAnd number 2 and 3: don’t underestimate the power of exported American culture via the media. There’s a clear trend (in English speaking countries at least) that the culture is becoming more and more Americanised, especially among youth. Non English speaking countries tend to resist it more but the influence is still there.
- poisonarena 4y agoI live in Israel, and all it takes is a few swipes to switch to palestine tiktok, its pretty wild, I have 'switched side' several times already to see whats up.
- theknocker 4y ago